LABOUR PARTY
Wayne Edgington
pleased with party policy. Benn is right to
warn that the new policy papers emerging
from the various working groups represent a further scrious shift to the right.
Maybe Benn and Heffer stand no
chance of winning against Kinnock: but an enthusiastic campaign in their support, taking up all the policy issues and reach- ing out to those in struggle can begin to forge links and organise a scrious chal- lenge to all the Kinnockites who are ditch- ing socialist policies in their grovelling to the press barons.
Local Benn-Heller campaigns have been set up in many areas, and Tony Bean has already addressed extremely large ral- lies in places including Liverpool and
Edinburgh. Vet organisational and politi- cal problems are limiting the impact of the campaign.
Despite the existence of democratic, non-exclusive local campaigns, regional organisers have simply been imposed, of- ten with no connection to them. Some of them, such as Socialist Action supporters, initially opposed any challenge for the lea- dership.
Nor is there any sign that the campaign has prioritised the crucial fight to win support and strengthen the left at rank and file level in the fight against 'new rcalism' in the trade unions. The National Union of Public Employecs (NUPE), for example, is balloting its membership on the Icadership issuc: but no Benn-Heffer coordinator has yet been appointed to make sure the left's argument is heard.
The Benn-Heffer fringe meeting ar NUPE conference was poorly organised and held at a lunch-time, meaning that it attracted only 120 from a conference of over 1,200 in a union holding one of the largest block votes. The National Union of Kailwaymen (NUR) is one of the few unions deciding its position on the leader- ship at conference: yet Benn and Heffer pulled out of a planned fringe meeting ar that conference in Swansea!
These episodes are symptomatic of some of the political problems of the cam- paign. They stem from an underestima- Lion of the crisis of leadership in the labour movement.
When Tony Benn ran for deputy leader against Denis Healey in 1981, there was a strong mood throughout the movement against any return to the right wing poli-
SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 8 July/Seplember 1988
bleaser
in Ku... 11T0
deal din.
smerging e renteset
ate of de
ampaiens regional
been imposed. of
in them, Some of
Arone supporterx. any challenee for the lea-
Eric Heffer at Chesterfield
cies that had brought disaster to the Wilson-Callaghan government. mood even influenced sections of the union burcaucracy, who supported Benn. Large rallies could be called at the drop of a leafler and there was little need to urge activists to campaign.
Now after eight vears of deteats at thie hands of Thatcher and rotreats by the union bureaucracy, and five vears of Kan-
That
Ware Fanta
be taken out into the union memberships,
... the union memperships: and those sections newly brought into ac- tivity such as the seafarers, abortion rights actvists and thuse lighting section 28. Links must be made - for instance be- iween the fight for abortion rights and the issuc of women's representation in the La- bour Parti. hetween opposition: 10 im- migration controls and the fight for black sections; and between all these issues and the need to build a new leadership in the labour movement.
Above all this requires a frontal chal- lenge to Kinnock's real power-base: the union bureaucracy. This means a fight to put forward class struggle policies around which the employers can be resisted, and showing how the union leaders have consi- stently retrated in the face of their attack. A real leadership challenge in the Labour Party has to align itself unashamedly with those left wing oppositional forces in the unions fighting for such policies and against the sell-outs and burcaucratic manoeuvres of the present leaderships.
Instead, a reluctance to go as far as is necessary in challenging the union bureaucracy — and indeed a conservative attachment to some middle layers of the 9
'Kinnock moved from
unilateralism to
"unimulteralism"
again'
and back
nock building on these defeats to push back the left wing policy gains of 1981, the mood is very different.
No union executive can be expected to declare its support for Benn and Helier (even the new 'left' executive of the TOWU will not push matters this far for fear of losing the support of the middle ground), and many activists have become demoralised.
All this means that the campaign has to
LABOUR PARTY
Benn-Heffer
This same ront the labour movement bureaucracy has marked the Campaign group since its formation. Breaking with the Tribune group in disgust at those who refused to
• refuseus to support Tony Benn in the deputy leader- ship campaign (like Kinnock, who. ab- stained), it was a positive break from be- ing simply a loyal opposition caucus wi- thin the parliamentary Labour Party. The Campaign group declared its intention to link with campaigns and activists outside parliament and decided on some basic issues of policy (such as, importantly, op- position to the witchhunt).
Yet this commitment was always more rcal from some than trom others. During the miners' strike, some like Denis Skinner and Tony Benn spoke at hundreds of meetings in support of the miners. But the Campaign group has always operated by consensus, which meant that it could be held back by its right wing some of whom were clearly only in it to keep their consti- tuency partics happy and some of whom were allied with anti-Scargill forces in the National Union of Mineworkers (NUM) and other unions.
This has meant that on occasions no
burcaucracy itself — is holding back the
Benn-Hetfer campaign.
This same reluctance sharply to conf-
This has meant that on occasions no
clear policy has been offered. The Cam-
paign group could hardly call for a three-
tor a thrce-
line whip against the Alton bill for
• thr Alton all for example when it accepted that some of its own members would not vote against
clear policy nat ace••
because of their "consciences as practising catholics/
The conflict over how far to go in oppos- ing Kinnock finally came to a head over the decision to mount a challenge for the leadership this year, with sections of the Campaign group deserting (several of whom clearly considered their own posi- tions as shadow spokespersons more im- portant than policy). Its aim to link up with forces in the unions has never hap- pened outside of a few individuals (like Scargill) because the Campaign MPs looked chicfly to those holding national exccutive positions — at a time when very
Sharpiy deans stores im prepared to
few in these positions are prepared to
The challenge this ycar is vital, and needs to be built as widely as possible, but the left also needs to look to the longer term and the lessons of the campaign. This means that the left itself must rec- ognise that a challenge will only be successful when it is across the board, taking on the policies not only of Kinnock but also of those who wield the block vote in his support.
To do this a united democratic left nceds to be built, campaigning around the policies and actions which can defeat Thatcher and throw aside those in the ranks of the labour movement who hold
back that fight. The linking of the Icader- ship challenge to the "Chesterfield current' can begin to create such organisation for the battles aheade
SOCIALIST CONFEIR
Two thousand people gathered
in Chesterfield in June for the second Socialist Conference, MANDY MUDD reports.
«scape hai changed .... the first conference iast we struggles in the NHS. Fords
-tory for the Icit in the
ras Workers Union.
-gainst clause 28
ad the leadership
- the Labour Parts. all
. mond os revitalisation
there is something to fight
insid Ad..
Tne progres:
was n
made between October ticcrea in the structure of rener The first attemp
.. call to the lett
d speaking 1o the
ana was on maruci- "o policy from the in ame nevoted to
policy workshops showed a serious com-
mitment to develop a detailed and cobe- rent alternative to Lahour's policy review: The regional workshops moved the organ-
The regional workshops moved the organ-
isation forward at grassroots level and
gave stering committee representation to the established regional conferences — a welcome democratisation of the conteren-
MAKING A START IN
POLITICS No 1
Take a plain piece of paper
Kinnock and Roy Hattersley
to stand by the following
socialist principles.
Unfortunately you will have
SEND (HOLIDAY) POSTCARDS
WITH A DIFFERENCE
Pack of 10 cards, E2
Ten or more packs, €150 per pack
All post free. Payment to Labour Bretting Orders to: B Griffiths. 11 Fremont Street, London E9 7NO 10
ment of the trade union Solidarity Net- work, Women for Socialism and the in- volvement of Black Sections in the Chesterfield nctwork was illustrated by the make up of the platforms in the plen- ary sessions and by the space afforded for
0210020000
idarıty Ner-
•1117
and the in- m: in the
in the plen- afforded for
those groups to meet and discuss sepa- rately during the conference
So what is the potential of the Socialist Conference and what can be achieved by
The forces involved show an important link between left intellectuals and activists
and an attempt by clements of the Cam-
paign group to orientate to all who sup- port a socialist programme — not only left
Labour Party members. This affords a real opportunity to develop socialist poli-
cies out of the experiences of those in struggle and at the same time lo use formulated policy to sustain and develop struggles and raise the horizons of those involved. Developing strong links between regional organisations, Wornen for Social-
in
le= USC
ism, the Solidarity Network and the policy groups is essential for this to develop in
a and the
/September: 1988