collection ol poll tax registration forms is currently causing the au unt of difficulty. In a light-hearted trip through history CRAIG B "community charge officers, the worst is yet to come.
a poll tax res
Adam Smith as one of Scotland's greatest sons. It is casy to understand her admira- tion for the founder of capitalist economic theory. Smith's statement that the func tion of government is to secure wealth and to defend the rich from the poor' could have been made with the present adminis- tration in mind.
In her poll tax proposals, however,
«X B15 Thatcher leaves her mentor far behind: not only are the rich to be protected from the poor, it is the poor who are to pay for this service
Smith has important things to say about taxation. In his Wealth of Nations he lays down tour tiscal principles: equality, cer- tainty, convenience and economy.
That the community charge is neither convenient nor economical hardly needs to be argued. To make its collection "cer- tain" would involve the introduction of a police state, as I will show from pre- cedents in the sorry history of poll taxes.
But is it "equal? Its supporters say it is; after all, a millionaire and the woman who scrubs his floor will pay equal amounts. What could be fairer? However, this is not what Adam Smith (or any other sane person) understands by equality: *The subjects of every state ought to con- tribute
in proportion to the revenue which they respectively enjoy, he states.
During the Victorian era, which the prime minister wishes to recreate, Adam Smith's principles were seen as absolutely fundamental to the theory of taxation. They form the core of the relevant entry in the Encylopardia Britannica's 1888 cdition, which dismisses poll taxes with these brief and contemptuous words:
Capitation taxes are chiefly of interest historically, as illustrated by the poll taxes levied at various times".
A hundred years ago, then, poll taxes were dismissed as historical curiosities But, since the prime minister likes to rake through history's middens to find ideas on how to run a country, let us do likewise to see what we find.
The most famous of all poll taxes was the one which provoked the English pea- sants' revolt of 1381. It was not intended as a normal revenue-raising device, but as an emergency measure to pay for a war against France.
MARGARET Adam Smith
THAN HER
- gratest e nor admira-
tat the tunc traC wel
spusais, however
be Dn
tar betun: itected trom
One sal
131t11l reds
poll taxes _uriosities
In 1377 parliament agreed to an emer- gency levy of 4d per person over fourteen years old. The commons insisted that all the money so raised was to go direct to pay the starving English army in France. They even proposed the appointment of special commissioners to collect it, separate from the officials who collected other taxes, but this was finally agreed to be impractic- able.
In 1379, after further military setbacks, the government came back to parliament
wiking for moner and. as an obviousli astonished chronicler informs us: 'In this parliament there was granted a subsidy so wonderful i.e. amazing) that no one had ever seen or heard of the like.
*a hundred years ago poll
taxes were dismissed as
historical curiosities'
It was indecd wonderful and 1 com- mend it to the attention of the chancellor of the exchequer. Tt was a graduated poll tax, based on social class. Examples of
(rd lifesta
Irke
forces so the government decided to help them out with a decree fixing wages at
irated to heip ewing wages at
pre-plague leveis.
Roughly speaking, skilled workers were
not to receive more than about 4d or 5d a
day, and labourers 1ad. Iwe assume that these rates prevailed in 1380 (and the statute was not particularly successful in kceping wages down) we can casily cal- culate that a skilled worker was being
expected to contribute a single day's pay and a labourer about three days' pay. Not only was this tax fairer than the commun-
ity charge, it was a much lighter burden
Rougri: speaking. ... corone
ity charue... on the poor.
In 1380 the situation in France became
worse. The government begged ment for help. The army in France had not been paid for months. There was rebellion in Ireland and trouble on the Scottish border. A revolution in Flanders had dis- rupted the vital wool trade. French galleys were raiding English ports.
Apart from rebellion in Ireland, the present government can offer none of these excuses. On the contrary, we are told how sound and successful the economy is, and how peacefully we live under the nuclear umbrella.
The parhament of 1380 finally agreed after long and hcated debate to grant the subsidy at the very high rate of 1s per head. (Three days' pay for a skilled worker, cight days' for a labourer.) But the principic of fairness had not been abandoned, it being decided that, For the sum reckoned for cach township the suffi- cient shall (according to their means) aid the lesser, providing that the most wealthy do not pay more than 60 groats jone poundl for themseives and their wives and no one at all should pay less than one groat [four pence] for himself and his wife'.
A modern historian notes that this pro-
vision 'obviously penalised the inhabi- tants of poor townships", a feature not only reproduced in the community charge but actively desired by the government. In 1380 its injustice was recognised and deplored. The sufficient shall aid the lesser' indeed! What a gang of whingeing wets!
Voting poll taxes into cxistence is much casicr than collecting them. The king's
SOCAUST OUTLOOK no 8 July/September 1988
'Peter the Great had his son
flogged so severely that he
died'
rales include: Dukes. E6-13s-4d: Earls. E4: Barons, C2; Knights, El.
Merchants paid 2s, Is or 6d depending on the scale of their opcrations. Farmers paid 6s8d, 3sld, 2s or Is. Everybody not included in the list of ranks, over sixteen years of age, paid 4d, except beggars and those living solely by alms.
All this seems much fairer than the community charge. In any case it must be remembered that it was enacted by parlia- ment during what seems to have been one of the occasional bouts of foaming war- hysteria which afflict that assembly. Nor was it intended to be permanent.
What of the sums involved? How much did 4d represent to an unskilled labourer?
In 1351 the king decreed a statutc of labourers. Workers were in such short supply owing to the black death that
commissioners ran into trouble right
away. Faced with demands for the 1379
levy based on social status, people res-
ponded by reversing their normal habit of
pretending to be of higher rank than they
really werc, or of claiming distinguished
gretendine.to reallv weren ancestry
In the next year things were even worse. Who was "sufficient"? Who was 'lesser"? The collectors' difficulties were increased by the urgent and pre-emptory onders they received: 'You are to collect the required infortation by the means which seem best to you'. You are to seize all thosc who act in opposition or rebellion and you are to keep them safely in our prison."
The tax collectors obeyed their orders to the letter. The sufficient did not come to the aid of the lesser. Do they ever? Ha- rassed by officials, aroused by a sense of injustice, the lower classes rose in a bloody rebellion.
Poll taxes acquired a bad reputation in government circles as a result of this salutary experience. Only very reluc- tantly, in times of national emergency, were they resorted to thercafter.
Such an occasion arose in 164l when it occame necessarv in estr off a Scotrist army which was occupying the north of England. The 1641 poll tax was graduated like that of 1379. In 1688, a year not merely of national emergency but of revo- lution, a (graduated) poll tax was raised. After 1698 it was dropped and from that time on the idea of such taxes mouldered quietly in the archives until it was ex- humed by the present government.
Up to now we have considered poll
• of claim
insidered poll
taxes only as temporary measures, as in mediacval England, or as means of social
Cufford Harper them as permanent and major soures of
control. But a few examples of states using
revenue can be found. What are the social effects of such a fiscal policy?
By the end of the third century, political instability, inflation and civil and foreign wars had reduced the citizens of the Roman empire to such a state of despera- tion that they gave totai power to a bull- necked general, Diocletian.
This soldier saved the empire by runn- ing it like a military camp. He introduced a form of taxation based partly on proper- ty and partly on a poll tax or capitaltio plebeia which was levied on all those who had little or no property. But the only emperor who was daring cough to im- pose this on the urban poor was Galerius, Diocletian's successor.
This individual (another soldier) is cre- dited with persuading Diocletian that the christians would make a suitable scape- goat to bear the blame for the empire's ills. He is best remembered for his persecution and his taxes. In 311 AD, after a reign of three years, he fell ill and, attributing his
SOCIALST OUTLOOK no 8 July/Saptember 1988
un proper
no propertv was darine
•jose whe
is marils
1. 02 E IT was (o
HISTORY
affliction (probably cancer of the groin) to ur vengeance of the christian god.
reluctantly granted a measure of religious tolcration. To no avail. He died a few nonths later. unlamented by his subjects
The Roman empire's tax collectors
faced the same problems as were later. to
baffle those of medieaval England. People
concealed themselves, sold their property and moved from place to place. Diocletian was only a simple soldier so he produced a simple solution. Everybody must stay put. Peasants were bound for life to the farms they worked on. Artisans were bound to their trades, and their children after them In this way originated the scridom and caste system of European feudalism.
If peasant bondage began in the Roman empire, it enjoyed a late flowering in the
The peasants' revolt of 1381: the year of the last attempt to levy a poll tax
ous
Russian empire during the cighteenth and munetenth centuries. The cause of this bondage, and the means by which it was perpetuated, was a poll tax, introduced by Peter the Great in the 1720s. With typical Russian religiosity it was referred to as a 'soul tax", and Peter's contemporaries,
even those friendly to him, regarded it with dismay
*The soul is something intangible and incomprehensible and hasno price', one of them wrote, "Prices should be fixed only on tangible goods". It was this writer who invented the term "soul-destroying' to des- cribe the effects of the tax.
Assessment and collection of this impo- sition were accompanied by the violence and repression inseparable from capita- tion. Souls were 'salted away'. Even the holy synod was forced to threaten recalci-
«train taxpayers
with 'merciless corporal punishment to be
followed with forced labour, even in cases
We also learn of "severe
decrees, torture and confiscations, to get
the rusty administration machinery into
How did Peter's fiscal system work?
Before that time there were various legal
categorics of pcasants, some more free than others, who paid various taxes, and a minority class of slaves, who did not. Peter created a new unitary system of absolute bondage for all peasants.
peasants. Previousl employers or masters, landowners now became slave-owners. They were respon- sible for collecting the soul tax and to cnable them to do this, all right of move-
.. all nght ol move- ment was removed from the peasantry. They were bound to the land, and their owners were given total power over them. Peter introduced this system in order to pay for this wars against Sweden without having to borrow moncy
His popularity may be judged from the
fact that when his son confessed as a sin
cnable them to do this, all right of move-
ludged from the
- win confessed as a sin
"ather - «eath, the issuringly that evervbody rater had his son floreed
One of his biographers remarks that the damage done by his taxes would hardly
remarks that the
would hardlv
have been paid for even if he had con- quered five Swedens. Nonetheless, the slave-owning landlords acquired a vested
maint f unchanged
cu il hc had con.
Nonetheies
acquired a the poll tax, antil 1861
s. the vested and it
They
were later annihilated by a vengeful pea-
This sort of response to unjust taxation
is by no means peculiar to Russia. The French revolution was provoked by res-
French revolution was provoked by res- entment at the fact that the ruling classes were not paying their fair sharc of tax. It is not the level of taxation but its perceived
unfairness which causes the trouble.
The duty on tea which ignited the American revolution was, at 3d a pound,
an absolutely trivial imposition. But the Americans rebelled against it because they had not voted it on themselves. No
taxation without representation. The
witnew: representaton.
..llh entitled to adop. this
mun:, charge was
against the wishes of
ir representatives in
Now that the English Tories, who
imposed it upon Scotland without a mur-
mur, are being asked to inflict it on their
own constituents, they are much less en-
thuxiastic. It can be predicted with confi- dence that their enthusiasm will wane still further when attempts are made to collect it.
That, we learn from history, is when the real trouble always starts •
29