WOMEN
Melanie Friend/Repon
Women cutting the fence at Greenham
VALERIE COULTAS looks at some of
the political questions that have arisen in the
British women's movement in the ten years
since the last national women's liberation
British women
since the
last
al wo
1978 SAW THE last national women's liberation conference in
Britain. The dehate represented a central political clash over
orientation.
Were women oppressed primarily because of their social position in socicty or was women's oppression a product ofa male conspiracy to subordinate female sexuality? Socialist feminists saw social causes as the root of women's oppression perceived sexual subordination flowing from that.
Fighting for the four demands of equal pay, education, nursery provision and fertility control was seen as vital to ending women's oppression.
While supporting the fifth demand — an end to the
SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 8 1988
1817° 19994
UUM SEM J0
slee male
ax SEM
incir social iroductof. •- Socialist
ression
i thar
cation,
al to
dau tron
• det:
development of women's struggles in the trade unions in the same period will appear in a
Issue of Socia
discrimination against lesbians and a self-defined sexuality
Radical feminists took a different view. They wanted to
demoted in importance in campaigning activity.
exavle. se
they did not want the social demands
•aJment was f
prenti
force questions of lifestyle, sexuality and sexual violence by
men to the top of the agenda. The argument was fierce —and
agenda lanother
fierce
10 231
These polincar difference: lain beneath the surtac .. vidual men the primar ere capitalist state?
• not new. Thev sern feminism.
e indi-
21
22
WOMEN
tull.
Although this is a slight simplification of the debate,
amnlilication of the debare,
because all agreed that men should be challenged for sexist vecalsP*..
behaviour, it did inform women's attitude to campaigning behavIour, and making alliances with the labour movement.
savour movement.
Differences over political orientation had torn the suffra-
neutation had torn the suffra- gette movement apart earlier in the century, and so this open
clash was not so unexpected. But unity had been possible up to the end of the seventies becausc an energetic movement of primarily young women had been able to act around unified demands, despite differing over the nature of women's oppression.
The demands for equal pay and equal educational oppor- tunity were the initial spurs to action at the end of the sixtics.
» spurs to action at the end of the sixtics
- tremendousy successful Na- During In.
was established which tional Abor forced the Trades Union Congress and Labour Party to take
- Congres and Labour Partv to take
and mobus- trade umonics to oppose
attacks on abortion rights. Campaigns to improve childcare,
to provide centres for battered women, to win child custody
for lesbians, to challenge sexism in the media, to support
black women's struggles, and to organise solidarity around
nanadillas
a prenapar attacks nm to provide "- for irshians LL.
"1Oм 4..- seventies.
5s-y
... sexism in in= media, to :
orgamse widaritv
-ntinued throuchout ind
political counter-offensive of the ruling class. This jolted an already divided women's movement, as it did the labour movement as a whole, whose leadership was left recling and unable to respond. As sections of the working class fought
back, the women's movement began to take part in the new batties and recompose itself.
But today nearly ten years of Thatcherism have taken
But today their toll among feminists. The ground is shifting to the right among wümen as it has among the mass of the working class.
The British women's movement is no longer polarised The British -
between radical and socialist feminists. Bourgcois and belween radica reformist feminism have more sway today than they did a decade ago.
Tnatene- rovernment and the
of the ruling class. This jolted an
movement. as it did the labour
w/we leadership was left recling and as er-mon of the workine mass fought
• negan to take pa- in the new
THE POLICIES of Thatcher and the general economic crisis
have played no small part in this political evolution among women. The ruling class in Britain has not engaged in a frontal assault on the women's movement to date although a sustained ideological offensive has been mounted against the welfare state, feminist values and for the family. In a speech in 1982 to the Institution of Electrical Engincers she argued that 'the battle for women's rights has largely been won', insisting that there was no need for the strident tones of some 'women's libbers'. However, the economic and political poli- cies of Thatcher have had a very direct effect on the mass of women.
First, they have increased the social divisions between women of different classes and within the working class. Tax relief for those able to afford nannies, alongside the closure of council nurseries, reveals which women Thatcher thinks should aspire to equality with men.
Secondly, the policies of market capitalism aim to exploit low-paid semi-skilled and unskilled women workers to the
atus inc generas
-200 wom
• pontical evolution among
Britain has not engaged in a
× movement to date although a
ve..s been mounted against the malues and for the tamil. In a speech
al Engincers she argued omen s nights has largely been won i au need for the strident tones of some
e renomic and political poli
rv airect effect on the mass of
... Elecen
the social divisions between no within the working class. Tax nannies. alongside the closure of which women Thatcher thinks
the midustries an hat- openca state and the
full. Casualisation, part-time work, no union protection and
industries are the opportunities' Thatcher's business friends
some of the must repetitive jobs in the industries are the opportunities' Thatcher's business friends
• and new technology
ness friends
the welliar
i have put
imr burden
have opened for this layer of women. Cutbacks in the welfare
HÔN SU. T en domesti
state and the privatisation of many social services have put many women out of decent jobs and increased their burden
Finally, Thatcher has made no secret of her willingness to challenge the post-war consensus on social provision for the poor, the elderly, the sick, youth and the unemployed. In a speech to the British Jewish Community in 1983 she said 1 was asked whether I was trying to restore Victorian values. 1 said straight out I was. And l am'.
Despite these attacks on the mass of women, Thatcher herself is a not an unimportant role model for certain layers of women in Britain today, not has the Tory Party this century been indifferent to winning the women's vote. She has articulated an alternative image of womanhood that is conventional and pro-family in contrast to the unconven- tional image of feminism. Her personal success cducation and marriage as she sells it — stands as an emblem "go-for-it" message of personal social mobility marketed no pop pealed to the individualistic aspects of modern feminism and found an echo in the still small number of women in higher professional jobs who can afford nannies to ensure uninter- rupted carcers even when they decide (as Thatcher herself did to reproduce.
As voting patterns ar the last general election show, this influence is not confined to these very privileged layers of women, despite the fact that social mobility is ruled out for many working class women who voted for Thatcher. As she
da prov Ir unemplov
..... 1983 she said "1
INESS IN for the d. In
"go-for-it" message of personal social mobility
As VorIng - iflucncc-in.t
vemen. despir man- wotki told thee
told the BBC workd service in 1984, "Many women... are tou casily contented with the job they are doing and do not necessarily make the effort to climb the tree.. sometimes it's thought to be unfeminine. It isn't at all, you know'
Thatcher has also been prime minister as a new layer of women have entered British politics. Many of these women would claim the feminist mantle. Thatcher herself has rejected it. I don't notice that I'ma woman. I regard myself as the prime minister,, she told the Daily Mirror in 1980. But she has promoted a tiny layer of right wing women who share her general vicws,
Thatcher's political strategy has had an important impact on the feminist movement. Unity around gender oppression is clearly inadequate when a government led by a woman is attacking the weltare state as well as Labour councils who have promoted feminist campaigns, the rights of women as trade unionists, tenants and black people. The political fragmentation of the feminist movement becomes almost inevitable under this kind of assault given the loose struc- tures of that movement and the lack of political homogencity among women.
ATe-
that
woman.. regara myse
a nad an importan: impar
d gender oppression
• = woman is
.. as Labour councils whi muge» the ..ghts of women as
nia The politicar
vecomes almost
in the loose struc-
scar homogencity
N255alas tures of that movement and the lack of political homogencity
A VERY WIDE diversity of views claim the label "feminist' in Britain today and debates among feminists are no longer confined to exclusively "women's issues". Thus it is difficult to discuss the state of the women's movement as a single entity: there is a lack of unified forums and unific cam- paigns. Instead this article will try to assess a number of themes of debate and activity, highlighting where the politi- cal retreats scem to have occurred and where some steps forward have been made.
The defeat of John Corrie's abortion amendment bill (which tried to restrict the availability of NHS abortions) in
1979 was one of the few victories the British labour mover
lemmust In •no longer ex difficult
as a singie
rum- and united cam-
assess a number of highliging where the polin- wered and where some steps
WOMEN
member's bill was defeated after the TUC called a protest of over 60,000 people. It did not win the support of enough MPs, including Thatcher herself.
Ironically however, NAC split a few years later. The debate involved many questions but reflected the general crisis in the movement. Women supporting a change in name to 'Reproductive Rights Campaign' argued that to focus so exclusively on abortion on a defensive basis was wrong. NAC should campaign on all issucs of reproductive rights empha- sising women's right to a free sexuality. This campaign should be women-only because fertility control was a wo-
illeo a protest of tofenouch MPs.
men's issue not a 'class issue'
Other women, among them trotskyists, disagreed, point- ing out that winning the right to terminate a pregnancy was a key advance for women at this stage of the women's movement, and that the attacks on the 1967 act had to be fended off if women were to advance. While NAC had a 'women's right to choose' declaration which related to other issues around fertility rights, abortion was the central issue for NAC and they argued that the name should not be changed. These women also argued that NAC should be a mixed campaign because the mass of women were organised by the trade unions and previous activity had shown that trade unions would fight for abortion rights.
Reproductive Righters claimed the banner of anti-racism in the debate and said that NAc had ignored black women's experience of forced sterilisation, lack of rights to have children, and forced contraception through Depo Provera injections. The NAC loyalists refuted this charge citing the establishment of an international campaign by NAC as an example. But the accusation, although opportunist, was not without some basis. NAC had not involved black women in Britain to the degree that it possibly could have. The women's movement as a whole had failed to listen to the emerging black women's movement.
The test of time has shown the political cost of the split. The divide was really about whether to run a women's health information service or a political campaign on abor- tion. When Victoria Gillick launched her attack on young women's contraceptive rights, and the MP Enoch Powell put his embryo rights bill to parhament in 1985, it was NAC that ind the response. The response of the traditional feminist layers was weak. In contrast to the huge mobilisation six years earlier against Corrie, 5,000 people marched in pro- lest, with large numbers coming from the far left rather than independent feminist groups.
The so-called Yorkshire ripper's horrific murders of women in the carly eighties provided ample grounds for feminist campaigns around male violence. Women Against Violence Against Women (WAVAW), led by radical femin- ists, took the initiative to lead protests in many towns, seeing this as an issue that united all women against all men. When police urged women to stay indoors or ensure they were escorted home, WAVAW countered with the demand that men should be kept off the streets not women, and also that women are most likely to be attacked by men they know, often in their homes.
Radical feminists toured the country with films showing pornographic images of women to sell the message that "porn is the theory, rape is the practice and that all men benefit from the threat and fear women have of rapc. Political solutions offerered ranged from uncontentious proposals such as women's taxi services and self-defence provision to the banning of pornographiv and longer sentences for rapists. Many socialist feminists kept silent in this debate — identify- ing with the outrage women felt, but reluctant to support "law and order' solutions.
SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 8 July/September 1988
The mass mobilisations at the Greenham women's peace camp in Newbury, Berkshire in protest at the siting of cruise missiles turned out 30,000 women at their high point, denting the Tory government's confidence in its ability to defend their policy on nuclear arms.
The appeal of Greenham contained contradictory fea- tures. Greenhar became a very uscful focus for the building ofa women's peace movement. But while some women in the Campaign for Nuclear Disarmament (CND) and labour movement activists saw Greenham as a way of mobilising women to fight against cruise and to oppose the Tory government's warmongering, the radical feminists in Women Oppose the Nuclcar Threat were interested in a more specifically radical feminist' analysis of war and male violence generally. Yet another group of feminists opposed Greenham altogether, arguing that the mobilisations celebrated motherhood and this had nothing to do with feminism. Even Spare Rib was quite slow to devclop a campaign in support of the women's peace movement.
pcau
cir high point, in its abilitv to
us for the building
men in the
and labour
mobilising
the Torv
Women
IT WASAT this point that the influence of what has been called populist feminism began to grow in
Britain, A new kind of simplistic radical feminism emerged from writers like Andrea Dworkin, Dale Spender and Mary Daly, which said that women were good and men were bad. Women were caring and civilised, men were violent and aggressive. The social construction of femininity and masculinity was some-
it was some- times recognised only to be forgotten.
"Take the toys from the boys' was an amusing slogan, but behind the wit lay a faulty analysis of why peace was a women's issue. Some women at Greenham argued that wars were fought and nuclear missiles were being imposed becausc men liked to be macho and fight wars. Women, on the other hand were concerned with reproducing life not destroying it.
The essential point that wars are fought because the imperialist ruling classes nccd to dominate sections of the world to protect and expand markets and profits is lost in
and proti" this analysis. Wars have historically affected men and women differently, women sometimes predicting the social costs of war before men, although many soldiers get disillu- sioned with actual combat.
But just as men's masculinity has to be socially cons-
mesally cons- tructed, so soldiers (today, male and female) have to be constructed by the capitalist system. Some women active in the labour movement put forward this emphasis as they mobilised for mass actions at Greenham. But their ideolo- gical impact was weak and the academic inclinations and sectarianism of some socialist feminists prevented them from participating in the debate as it was unfolding at the gates of Greenham.
At the base of the labour movement a dillerent but related debate was unfolding. Many socialist feminists had begun to organise in the Labour Party and the trade unions as the Tories stepped up their attacks on working class women.
Women workers form 44 per cent of the workforce in Britain
anali- women's issue. Some women at Greenham argued that wars
amusine sagan, but
aCe Was a
THA WAT naiminated
Women on
- wugh: becaus. the no in dominate sections of the
send mark
Dur related
ests nad begun to
o as the
WOrKIng cass Women
« ine worktorce in Britain we rise Some predictions sug-
rand the trade un
aCKS Women workers form 44 per cent of the workforce in Britain
Marin Snokeshot/IFL
fore:
23
24
WOMEN
the ground is shifting to the women as it has amongst the
working class
ight mass
SuomE of the
gest that women workers will secure two thirds of all new jobs created in the next five years. Part-time work accounts for this. Women part-timers are expected to hold 22 per cent of all jobs in 1990 as compared with 17 pcr cent in 1985. This, alongside the campaigns of feminists, has increased the pressure on the unions; if they are to survive, they have to recruit women workers.
But the new realism that is now dominant in the British
ww dominant in the British labour movement, which accepts "popular capitalism" and
epts popular capitalism" and enters into no-strike deals with the bosses, has influenced the thinking of many feminists in the labour movement.
Posturing and the idcalism of the sixties is rejccted by a more practical approach which emphasises minimum and winnable demands. A shorter working day is pushed but never without loss of pay. Sharing of housework is advocated but collectivisation of houscwork is downplayed.
Eurocommunists like Bea Campbell advocate a feminist incomes policy which argues for a new kind of social contract where higher-paid male workers accept pay curbs to redis- tribute their wages to low-paid female workers.
Campaigns which challenge women's oppression within the family are harder to win support for in this climate. A detensive stance is almost inevitable given the defeats suf- tered over the last ten years in Britain but it is only class struggle methods that will defend any gains that women workers have won. This reformist layer attacks the class struggle methods of unions like the National Union of Mine- workers iNUM! Bea Campbell. for example. argued that mass picketing was 'macho" in the 84/85 miners' strikc, and defended the Kinnock leadership of the Labour Party, which she characterised as 'feminist' in the London weekly ma- gazine City Limits. She also publicly attacked the print unions at Wapping with similar arguments.
Where the ideas of the reformist feminists and the new populist feminists overlap is at the level of rhetoric in denouncing "maleness", in accepting that a fundamental change in society is impossible and that women have to concentrate on winning small victorics.
Thesc examples give a picture of the retreats that have taken place in the Thatcher years. On the other hand the class polarisation in British society has radicalised women who have born the brunt of the Tory offensive and fought back with mass mobilisations. We will look at three groups in particular:
WOMEN TRADE unionists have fought hack against Thatcher ever since she came to power. The largest groups of women workers that have moved into struggle are in the public sector — healthworkers, teachers, local government workers, school cleaners and dinner ladies — resisting low pay, cuts and privatisation. But in manufacturing and textiles women workers have also resisted attacks on their industries and in the miners" and printers' strikes we saw women's support groups set up to involve wives of strikers in the dispute.
The trade union movement has been forced to make many concessions to women, adopting a TUC women's charter, campaigning on sexual harassment and abortion, and now proposing to establish a women's department at the TUC. But while trade union leaders may be willing to make gestures to recruit women they are reluctant to support any
This is why the independent organisation of women in the labour movement and the pressure of feminist campaigning is so crucial. Women Against Pit Closures was a very impor-
sen In tue campaignins • very impor wae directly
tant development in this regard because it was directly
linked to a fight against the Tory government to defend jobs
and was also able to use the forms of organisation the
women's liberation movement had developed in the previous
years.
Women's support groups, with their own bank accounts, banners and network of communication mushroomed in cvery mining arca and were abic to mobilise quickly for demonstrations and picket lines to confront the police.
The identification with other women's campaigns such as Greenham, strip searching, and black women's groups was important for developing the political awareness of women in mining communitics.
The loss of the vote for affiliation to the NUM made it
the NUM made * harder to consolidate nese kaine But some of the most militant women's support groups and the memory of this form nf organisation continue to exist in preparation for the next battle. This movement of working class women shifted thie terrain of debate in the women's movement to the lef as the strike showed that sections of the labour movement could stand up to the Tories and these groups of workers were prepared to support the demands of women.
ank
». mushromnen in mobilic- quickis tor
intt
on the police. - vampaiens such as women's groups was awareness of women
BLACK WOMEN have been organising in Britain in the trade
g in Britam in the trade unions and black communit for the vast 20 vears. But lowards the end of the seventies a black women's movement
*women's movement emerged to challenge the oppression of black women in
blare women in society and racism in the women's movement.
cement.
This movement had a sharp political and ideological thrust around racism on all levels
reflecting the growing self-confidence of young black British women who had
‹ush women who had grown up in Britain and did not accept the sccond or third
epr me second or third class status imposed on them by white society. The Tories have fostered racism by tightening up on immigration laws and strengthening police powers, using overtly racist themes
wars in wartly racist themes in their recent election campaign.
National conferences of black women have taken place
sen place over several ycars and black women have campaigned against deportation orders, sparation of hiack families. racist harassment, discrimination in education, in the health service and at work and established battered women's con- tres for black women.
The political critique of the priorities of white feminists has influenced nearly every feminist campaign and journal over the last period. Campaigns around violence against
violence against women have been taken to task for holding demonstrations
ask .n. nolaine demonstrations in black arcas of the inner cities and raising demands for more police on the streets. The Spare Rib collective, the London Women's Liberation Newsletter and the women's peace
and the womens peace campat Greenham have all had clashes on the subject.
As the black women's movement has developed it has
- devenged i has become clear that political differences exist among black
xist amon. alack women too. But because of the special discrimination black
. uscrimination inack women face in socicty they have been able to challenge the
i un challenge the false 'unity of women' imposed by many radical and populist
an. radica, and populist feminists who prioritise gender oppression in an artificial
"son in an artificial way, ignoring or playing down class and racial discrimina- tion.
lowards the end of the seventies a black women's movement
mied
*black women forced anti-imperialist issues into the centre of feminist debates'
SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 8 July/Seplember 1988
WOMEN
cenire of feminist debates. Recognition of Britain's imperial-
ist role and the racism of the British state has been reflected in conferences and campaigns around Namibia, South Ain- ca, central and Latin America. A key area of this activity has
Black women also forced anti-imperialist issues into the
mpes
eiler
th Amn-
been making links with women in Ireland. A protest
demonstration on international women's day in 1979 outside
Armagh gaol in Northern Ireland united Trish and British
Armagh gaol in Northern Ireland united Trish and British women in a common protest against the strip searching of
Britain and Treland which has had an important impact on Irish republicanism and the British labour movement. Sinn Fein women have been organising throughout this period but the links with British women have helped boost their strugele. The campaign mounted in Britain provided the uncessary prewure to win first the Labour Party women's conference and, later, the Labour Party conference to oppose
rif
Since that time a national campaign has been mounted in
act on
•nent sinn
this period
d hemyst their
provided th
women
to oppin courts and to support
and the non-jury
self-determination for the Irish peopic.
A recent Tabour Party women's conference called for a Labour government to set a dair for withdrawal of the British army from Northern Freland. Feminist activity on Irish questions has been in advance of the rest of the British
e callen for
dl a
the
Sris
IN THE LABOUR Party, socialist feminists have thus been able to play a role in campaigns wider than what are traditionally viewed as women sissues. The women's section of the Labour Party has been transformed into a militant. campaigning and feminist forum demanding more power for women in the party as a whole. The left's power at this conference is a threat to Neil Kinnock's project ofshifting the party to the right. The labour bureaucracy has had to devise some complex tactics to dull the campaigning strength of the women's organisation.
What Kinnock offered women was a women's ministry if Labour came to power and a slight increase in the number of women MPs. But simultancously he has moved to undermine
indermine
the Labour women's confercoor. by suggesting that trade the Labour wo union women are under-represented. This is an attempt to
tempt to
shift the debate away from the demand that women should shitt the Jebate «w elect their own representatives on the NEC, into a compli- cated debate over restructuring women's conterence itscit.
With the aid of the trade union burcaucracy, Kinnock aums to silence the critical voice of women and line them up behind the leadership. Leaders ofthe Women's Action Com- mittee, a group fighting for more power for Labour Party
* or Labour Party: women, and which at first won a lot of support among women at the high point of the Bennite reforms in the party.
Been or relarms in the partv. have since become accessories to