Claimants wait at the Hackney Hous
The Tories' 1988 social security
act has attracted widespread
opposition across the political spectrum — IAIN GAULT asks how the outrage be
translated into victory.
FOR MANY PEOPLE, the social security changes introduced on 11 April have high- lighted the heartlessness and cynicism of the present administration. This is parti- cularly the case since their introduction took place just a few days after Chancellor Lawson had announced a package of tax 12 cuts amounting to some [2 billion.
Public discussion of the changes in social security and housing benefit has tended to focus on how many claimants will "lose out' as a result of the new regula- tions. Individual cases of extreme hard- ship have been used with some effect to expose the immediate consequences of the government's reforms". However, for the left it is cqually important to understand the long-term implications of the recent changes, and, in doing so, begin to deve- lop an alternative socialist response.
Since their clection in 1979, the Tories have made no secret of their hostility to certain aspects of the social scurity system inherited from their post-war pre- decessors. In a series of legislative:
legislati
1980 and culmınat- ie unsetliltieli arc
developed a specific agenda for social security based on the following princip-
agenda for soci followin: princip-
* Dires
ment. I
Le faren
utler Witn
ezine particular penctis
• them in line with prices
del. Increasing en
certain benctits Withdrawing a proportion of benefit from families
inde
eneht lever and enute. non of bencfits from avr
nette for exame • Deriods for
• Privatisation. Transferring central gov- ernment reponsibilities to private agencics
of one sort or another: insurance compar nies and financial institutions in the case
SOCIALIST OLMOOK
open tory sick pay- @Attacks on arcased mean non in seppe and tr mants. • A scoping: claimant: squads ano
• Attacks on 'universal benefits and in- creased means-testing. Overall a reduc- tion in scope of social security provision
sion
claimants. Increased staffing of fraud
• A stepping-up of attacks on individual
and specialist claims control
aud •antrol
entire post-war social security system, despite embodying some rcal gains, is pro- foundly flawed from the standpoint of the working class and the oppressed. In re- ality "Thatcher's social scurity "reforms' represent not only a discontinuity and a break with the post-war "welfarist" consen- sus, but also, in many essential respects, a continuation and exaggeration of the most divisive and incgalitarian aspects of the system it cstablished.
From the time of its introduction, the
'we should be wary of
falling back on an
uncritical defence of the
previous system'
post-war social security system has pres- ented an unstable compromise between working class demands for "welfare and capital's need to discipline the working class and maintain its 'incentive' to la- bour. Thatcher clearly recognises this. and is determined, within the framework of the present system, to alter the balance of forces even more decisively in favour of her class. Socialists must also recognise it and, with cqual determination, promote policies in the field of social security and income maintenance which consciously unify and strengthen the working class.
Four clements of such a socialist alter- native can be mentioned briefly. First is a rejection of means-testing and of the "insu- principle in relation to income
maintenance, and a recognition that these scrve to reproduce the existing divisions within the working class, particularly be-
maintenai SCave t6 1
within th. tween the
within the working class, particularly be-
employed We should be promoting an alternative
ing divisi rticularlv
and
DES be
the
unemployed
system based on a guaranteed income for
Secondly, a rejection of the family as a
unit of assessment and of the consequent reinforcement of the dependent status of
all.
n alterna dino
women.
The thi
of a somalst alterna-
v sustem demand-
a critique of the racism of the existing system both in terms of its day-to-day opcration and of its close connection with immigration control!
Finally, we need an analysis which is capable of illuminating the connections: between the opcration of the capitalist system and the social marginalisation of groups sach as the eiderly and the dis- abled. Support for the self-organisation of these groups and an acceptance of their demands, not least for a decent standard of living, is a priority for the left as a
for the eft as a
whole.
An alternative, and advancu and orkanna.
for radicar
lects. The ser Tone- .. "depenc weakest link
s this Kina, supported
the ..bour movement
the oppressed could
irds seizine the agenda
31 the social security um the Tories and into the When n most directly at- motent promotion by the
slogs opposed to the
ver their
units'. Introduction of the so-called non- prosecution intervicw, designed to inti- midate people into withdrawing claims. • Stripping claimants oflegal rights, under the guise of simplitving' ne system Replacement of legal entitlement to 'single' and 'urgent needs payments with a discretionary cash limited 'social fund".
Given the scope of the Tories' offensive, there is a clear and pressing need to mo- bilise the maximum possible number of individuals and organisations against par- ticular attacks and on specific issues. Coa- litions such as Action for Benefits" can — despite their limitations —play an impor- tant role in uniting claimants, voluntary organisations, and those trade unionists directly involved in administering the system, on a programme of opposition to cuts and restructuring.
However, in opposing the government's
plans for social security, we should be
wary of falling back on an uncritical
defence of the previous system; a position
which both the Labour Party and the
major civil service unions have tended to
withdraw...
mad
plans for socia wary of talling defens- of the p which
wary of falling back on an uncritical defence of the previous system; a position
mator civil servin adopt.
Such a stance socialists for the ximper reas
inalue one I0г
- inat the
Realignment in the CPSA
AT THIS year's Civil and Public Servants Association (CPSA) conference the right smashed the lelt electorally: Last year the left virtually wiped out the right. What may seem from the outside to be a random game of swings and roundabouts is more predictable from the inside. where a long process of realignment continues
The 1984 split in the broad left, when Kinnock loyalists and communist party members formed their own broad left 84, allowed CPSA's right wing in to run the union.
In just two years the broad left was back, electing Militant supporter John Macreadie as general secretary (although he was eventually ousted), and sweeping to power on the NEC in May 1987 with a majority
uf 18 to eight.
Militant supporters misunderstood this situation, arguing that the Kinnockites were decisively beaten and CPSA was hack to a straight left/right polarisation.
In fact the realignment was continuing. A soft left bloc, based primarily in the bureaucracy, was forming -
the type of force which characterises most of the major TUC unions.
The remnants of the old guard right wing are merging with the rightward-moving Kinnockite forces. The clectoral victory of this coalition is the significant result of this year's conference.
Its representation is, however, patchy: ruling the DHSS section executive since 1987, but less manifest at
Saner 19RR
national level - only three of the cight Kinnockites elected to the new NEC ran on a joint ticket with the right wing.
Basing itself solely on opposition to the broad left may be electorally popular. but is not a policy for running a union. Indeed, the broad left is seen as the body prepared to organise against the Tories: and conference continucd to support most of its policies.
The broad left's problem is how to mobilise the membership's will to fight (shown by the high incidence of industrial action). Last year's tactics failed, as the CPSA full time machinery outmanoeuvred a broad left more open to bureaucratic solutions than relating to activists.
The broad left, historically controlled by Militant supporters, must change to regain power. With the Socialist Workers Party (SWP) blaming the CPSA broad left for every defeat since
Tolpuddle, but otherwise not
participating, the main impetus for change comes from the rank and file-based socialist caucus.
A mainly independent hard Is groupine. including Labour Briefing and Socialist Organiser supporters, its strategy couples democratic reforms in CPSA with class struggle politics outside.
This is the way to halt the creeping soft left bloc and build a fightback against the Tories. The broad left must recognise this if it is to survive • FERGUS LEE
13