A film with very little to say
DAVID GRANT
The Last Emperor, a film by Bernardo Bertolucci.
OK, SO IT IS a great film. I mean, nine oscars can't be wrong, can they? Mind you, when you consider the opposition consisted of films like Moonstruck, one clip of which was enough to convince me to save my four quid, it's not surprising that Bernardo Bertolucci's latest, but by no means greatest, film swept all before it in Hollywood.
Apart from 'best supporting actor, of course, which inexplicably went to Sean Connery for his role in The Untouchables (a slick, sick, slice of gratuitous violence if ever there was one, replete with its pastiche of Eisenstein's pram- down-the-steps trauma in Battleship Potemkin, only this time with exploding heads- gore-and-blood...) but I digress.
Vitorio Storaro's photography is the real mainstay of the film, as the action sweeps us back and forth across sixty years, and at least three different modes of
production (depending on where you stand on the 'asiatic mode' debate and 'post- capitalist transitional society' issue).
His command of colour, the warm greens and yellows; splashing reds and cold, cynical blues, combine to produce a feast of visual signifers that the 'decoders' will, no doubt, have hours of amusement interpreting
The rest of us will simply lap it all up, courtesy of producer Jeremy Thomas' insistence that the Last Emperor be booked into the best "big screens' around the country.
But it's not just all spectacular interiors of the forbidden city, beautiful costumes and sets. Excellent performances by all the main characters set this film apart from and above ninety-nine per cent of the films you are likely to see on general release.
Then there is also the psycho-drama of Pu Yi. The plenipotentiary without power, the lord of ten thousand years who is never allowed to control his own destiny. A victim of his circumstances whilst ostensibly a man who should
make history, Pu Yi is secluded from the world, successively by the imperial court, the Japanese imperialists and the Chinese communist party.
The film includes superbly observed vignettes: the surreal ancien regime in the imperial court; the decadence of life-as- Japanese stooge, surrounded by jazz music, opium riddled relatives and androgenous kitsch; and finally, life as the humble, re-educated gardener, who witnesses his former warder humiliated by the fanatical red guards of the cultural revolution.
So what's the problem? Why the ironic tone of this review, you might ask? Well, two things really. First, this is not Bertolucci at his best. The sheer scale of the film, and no doubt its budget (reputedly loadsamoney) seem to have overwhelmed any incisive marxist or freudian insight, the most challenging and inspiring aspects of Bertolucci's previous work.
The film has very little to say. We have, it seems, come a long way since Jean Luc Goddard's protege denounced
the corrupting influence of tinseltown, making films that were banned by Italian censors (Last Tango) and forcibly re- edited by irate producers (1900).
The second issue is the new image being projected from Beijing. Who better to create, in the cultural and artistic sphere, a film to parallel the new 'open' approach, wooing western interest and attention, than the marxist film maker with a human face, Bernardo Bertolucci?
After all, a regime that allows access to a western film maker to make a film which is honest and objective about many aspects of both pre-and post-revolutionary China must mark some sort of progress, mustn't it? And if we're ever going to really 'open up' (for this read Chinese markets to western capital, weapons and consumer goods), then we surely have to break down the barriers at a cultural and artistic level first, don't we?
Perhaps the latter point is unfair. But then life is, as Pu Yi would have no doubt concurred, sometimes like that •
advertisement
the 5th annual
INTERNATIONAL RED YOUTH CAMP
From 23rd - 31st July — discuss and share experiences with hundreds of young revolutionaries from organisations like the JCR (France), JGS (Belgium), Rivoluzione (Italy), Rebel (Holland), JSR (Switzerland) and many more.
In the Haute-Loire region of France — hear speakers from all over the world, including from Sinn Fein (Ireland),
the Juquin campaign (France), FSLN (Nicaragua), PLO (Palestine), ANC (South Africa) and PRT (Mexico). As
well as politics, there will be discos, a bar, swimming and other sports, videos, exhibitions, theatre, a rock concert
and plenty of time for sunbathing. Plus vegetarian food, a women-only space and a creche.
For more details contact Susan Williams, 75 Millers Road, Brighton, BN1 5NQ, before June 10th.
'68
88
TWENTY YEARS IN THE
STRUGGLE FOR SOCIALISM
• Rally Fri 27 May with: • • DANIEL BENSAID •
Ligue Communiste Revolutionnaire — a well-known leader of the 1968 student revolt in France.
• TARIQ ALI •
Leader of the 1968 student movement in Britain, author and broadcaster.
• TESSA VAN GELDEREN •
Eye-witness to the Soviet invasion of Czechoslovakia in 1968.
• MICHAEL FARRELL •
A leader of the civil rights movement in Northern Ireland.
7.30pm Caxton House
SOCIALIST
OUTLOOK
ADMISSION £2/£1 UNWAGED
129 St John's Way London N19 (Arch
SPECIAL OFFER £3.00 OFF!
Socialist Outlook offers all new subscribers a copy of Alan Thornett's new book From Militancy to Marxism for £3.00 off!
Name... Address..
Post Code...
Subscription to start from issue number
ube).
SUBSCRIBE!
Annual Subscription rate: (10 issues) * £8.50 for inland subscriptions * €17.00 for inland multi-reader subscriptions * £18.00 for overseas airmail subscriptions (US $25.00) * £54.00 for overseas airmail multi-reader
$75.00)
• Yes, I want a copy of From Militancy to Marxism at the specially
discounted rate and enclose a cheque for £15.45 for the book and my one year subscription. * •I enclose a cheque for £._..
_ for a one year subscription to Socialist Outlook.
Make all cheques payable to Socialist Outlook.
Please return to Socialist Outlook, PO Box 705, London, SW19 1HA • Book offer only applies to inland subscribers.