Socialist Outlook

Socialist Viewpoint, International, Socialist Outlook and their supplements, 1984–2009

TGWU elections

Socialist Outlook no. 6, April–March 1988 · pp 5-6 · 830 words

ELECTIONS for the national executive of the Transport and General Workers' Union (TGWU) have produced a shift to the left within the leadership of the union.

This has big implications for the whole labour movement. The effects of the TGWU block vote at TUC and Labour Party conferences are obvious. But the result should not be considered as a simple victory for the left.

The key left victories, which changed a slim right wing majority into a slim left wing majority, were in three trade groups: the power and engineering group, the textiles group and the agricultural group. The left also won in the south-east London territorial division, where Ford worker

Carlos Guarita/Reflex

TGWU general secretary Ron Todd: considered to be too left wing by Brian Nicholson

Steve Riley defeated right wing national president Brian Nicholson.

Ballot-rigging and the TGWU

IT IS STILL unclear whether the TGWU election results will be challenged on the basis of ballot-rigging allegations.

General Secretary Ron Todd has rejected all tales of ballot-rigging as the 'invention of the media' and there is little doubt that most of them were.

Todd knows, however, that the record of the TGWU in this respect is scandalous and it is this which makes it an easy target for such allegations.

During the national executive elections Todd was forced to intervene in two regions and that may not be the end of it.

Successive TGWU leaders have refused to discipline ballot-riggers even when they have been caught red-handed. They have also refused to tighten up the union's rule book in order to make ballot-rigging more difficult.

A political consequence of this is that the TGWU Record is now being openly used to promote and justify the next stage of Tory anti-union legislation which includes postal balloting •

This result, which puts ten new members on the national executive of 39, has produced a broad left majority of about 22-17. This is, however, a difficult calculation, given the extreme diversity of the 'broad left' in the union which ranges from supporters of the hard left to Communist Party members and Kinnock supporters.

The media caused confusion in the run up to the ballot by presenting it as a contest between the soft left and the hard left. In reality it was a contest between the broad left national executive minority and the right wing majority led by Nicholson.

The Nicholson grouping have been a major factor in the union for some time. They have been systematically using their majority on the executive to

SOCIALIST OUTLOOK noó March/April 1988

3

mount a right wing challenge to Ron Todd's position as general secretary.

Nicholson has used his position on the appointments committee to install hard right- wingers into key non-elected regional secretary positions as they have become vacant. This has led to bitter clashes with Todd in at least two regions: region two (London) and region five (Midlands). The regional. secretaries are extremely influential and they administer the elections and arrange the counting of votes.

Nicholson's objective was to

consolidate his right wing control of the executive and to marginalise Todd whom he considers too left wing.

The TGWU has in most respects been a part of the 'new realist' project. Todd intervened along with Bill Jordan to create the basis for the recent Ford sell-out, for example. However, it has not been consistent enough or right wing enough for Nicholson. Had he been successful he would have taken the union to a position alongside the AEU or even the EETPU on the extreme right of the TUC.

It is not yet clear how much

the union will move to the left in the wake of this result. But it is clear that Nicholson's attempts to move it further to the right have been roundly defeated. The result is also a victory for Toda who is now released from right wing pressure and free to exert his own direction on the union.

Kinnock has expressed confidence that the election result will not change the relationship between the TGWU and his project for the Labour Party. He is probably right. The TGWU under the new executive is likely to support Kinnock on most occasions.

The general secretary's position is very powerful if it is not under threat and the executive is limited in the influence it can exert. It does not, for example, control the TGWU block vote at Labour Party conferences. Here decisions are taken by the conference delegation which has often been well to the right of the national executive. The election result should therefore be understood much more as a defeat for the right than a victory for the left • ALAN THORNETT

ANGLO-IRISH relations have been under considerable strain over the past few months. The Irish government has felt it necessary to object to some of the more blatant imperialist injustices perpetrated by the British government and state.

But are recent events an obstacle to the process started by the

← No compromise with Alton · Tories cash in on Anglo-Irish accord →

Something wrong on this page?