Socialist Organiser broke from the traditional marxist view of Ireland on the issue of the protestants, a view which, in the words of James Connolly, defined the 'orange working class' as "slaves in spirit because they have been reared up among a people whose conditions of servitude are more slavish than their own'. This, and the consequential analysis of the protestant working class as a labour aristocracy was increasingly questioned by Socialist Organiser and its ideological leader, Sean Matgamna. GEOFFREY BELL writes.
found in the SDLP in the north or Fianna
Fail in the south.
• The attempt to justify the presence of
British troops in the north of Ireland by
raising the spectre of the protestant
backlash is rather old hat these days. Let
us remember that the troops went onto
the streets in 1969 because the loyalist
security forces had been defeated. And
today the political unity which would be
necessary for the loyalists to be a real
threat to catholics in the event of British A loyalist band prepares to march in withdrawal is completely missing. The Portadown
failure of the loyalists to defeat the
Anglo-Irish agreement is just one
example of the limited capability of the
'protestant backlash'
the 'right' of the British parliament to rule them. Moreover, historically speak- ing, the protestants in Ireland as a whole have generally defined themselves as 'Irish' or some variant of that — 'Anglo- Irish', 'Scots-Irish', 'Northern Irish' or 'Ulstermen' (sic). Even today the major- ity of northern Irish protestants reject the view that the British parliament has the right to tell them what to do. They also toy with advocating an independent Ulster (the UDA) or Ulster as a British dominion in the way Canada is (Ulster Clubs). • The notion that contemporary Sinn Fein republicanism is different from that of Wolfe Tone is an historical illiteracy. Sad to say, but in fact the examples of anti-protestant sectarianism in Wolfe Tone's 1798 rising were much more commonplace than in the present IRA's campaign, although in both cases such sectarianism was no part of the politics of the vast majority of those involved. • To define Sinn Fein as 'Irish catholic nationalism' is a slander. Irish national- ism has often had a rather right wing and catholic side to it, but Sinn Fein in word and deed has resolutely opposed it. If there are present day catholic Irish nationalists they are most likely to be
In seeking to minimise British respon- sibility for the situation in Ireland, in suggesting that, for the good of the Irish, British troops must stay, in painting the "loyalists' more 'British' than they paint themselves, Socialist Organiser ends up calling for the extension of both loyalist 'rights' and the British presence.
The advocacy is for protestant self- rule — in other words, a statelet drawn up purely on a sectarian headcount. This man. el.- l - -
espon- nd, in : Irish, ng the / paint ds up oyalist
it self- drawn count.
This statelet would apparently be part of a federal Ireland. But then comes the biggest howler. There have to be 'ties of some confederal sort between that united Ireland and Britain'
In other words, Brits into the south of Ireland. Wave the union jack and pass the ammunition •
• All quotes in the text are from, 'Ireland: the lies the left tells itself' by Sean Matgamna, in: Workers' Liberty no. 9, January 1988 • Geoffrey Bell is the author of The Prote- stants of Ulster and Troublesome Busi- ness: the Labour Party and the Irish Question, both published by Pluto Press.
SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 6 March/April 1988