Socialist Outlook

Socialist Viewpoint, International, Socialist Outlook and their supplements, 1984–2009

Fatal Attraction

· Socialist Outlook no. 6, April–March 1988 · pp 42-44 · 1,735 words

United States Women Marxism

Fatal Attraction cleverly draw: you along the thread of its logic and into the fabric of its own morality, which is the main substance of the film, hung on a flimsy — basic at best ... frame of a story line. But there's plenty of drama, action and emotional pitch to compensate for any lack in complexity or subtlety - and the film doesn't leave you in any doubt about who's side you're supposed to be on.

Two New York professionals

have a brief designer affair, complete with stylish sex in fully co-ordinated sets. He's married and wants to leave it at that. Fair enough. She's single and doesn't — also fair enough (at first), even though she knew the score when she made her first move. Forrest is treated fairly, and fairly positively up to this point in the film.

Besides doing the pulling, she also gets to make a reasonable case against men's use and abuse of women in sexual relationships, describing with some accuracy some of the immature emotional devices many men employ. So lar so good.

But she isn't allowed too much rope before she's very quickly reined in with the character weaknesses usually ascribed to sexually assertive women: loneliness, insecurity, possessiveness, hysteria and neuroses. She's also pregnant, and wants to be.

There then follows pursuit by telephone, car, cassette, a suicide bid, a kidnapping, and other generally unwelcome intrusions.

And there's worse too. When Forrest finally catches up with Gallagher and his wife (by which time he's had to let her in on the reason why bunny, who as far as we know never hurt anybody, had to end up in a pot on the stove), she turns murderous.

The moral of the story - delivered in a crescendo of dramatic tension which

apparently had US audiences screaming 'kill the bitch' (and British audiences expressing the same sentiments only perhaps with a bit more reserve) — couldn't be more clear.

Gallagher strayed from the happy home, lived a bit dangerously — certainly didn't use a condom — and got well and truly punished (though interestingly not morally censured). He is saved in the end by his family.

The ultimate punishment, and condemnation is meted out to Forrest. Not only does she have to live in a warehouse in the middle of what looks like a mobile abbattoir (while the perfect couple get a clean house in the country, she is made into the ultimate threat — not just to Gallagher, or his family — but symbolically to the nuclear family.

In the end the threat is seen off by the re-assertion of family values — to the relief, I presume, of those US audiences and of those US women who, it is reported, take their husbands along for a lesson in what happens to men who fool around

Alex Forrest has been described as 'the AIDS virus with a carving knive'. There is a level at which the symbolism of the film invited such a reading - despite the fact that (or even because) the disease itself is never referred to. But there is a more direct - and even more reactionary message in the film.

Woven into the characterisation of Alex Forrest is what amounts to a final warning on feminism. By mixing a superficially plausible ferninism with an irrational, pathological violence, Fatal Attraction gives a 'cesspit of their own making' verdict on feminism, on modern women, and even on modest sexual licence.

It has to be said in fairness, that one of the most interesting and annoying things about the film is how enjoyable it is.

Some marxist critics argue that the form - horror, thriller - (in fact almost anything with a story and characters) is itself inherently and inevitably reactionary.

They argue for a more wholesome form of 'cultural production' where the reader is a more 'active' participant; constructing meaning, and even the story and the characters her/himself.

This activity, goes the theory, is supposed to be more 'pleasurable' than passive consumption.

Now that kind of DIy entertainment sounds a bit like hard work to me - and I'd defend the rights of even marxists to access to an armchair and a bit of escapist fiction.

It might be a bit basic and reductionist, but I'd just appreciate the chance to watch a film from time to time when the baddies weren't always mad women/black/low-life/ communists •

SOCIALIST OUTLOOK noó March/April 1988

Lontre!

Censor bras 2r434 nald muté race permaruilure class rumour contre Bentel Sian power history shirt

THE WALL STREET JOURNAL.

LART BEAUTY

no BErISÜRE TRUTH cheie Sețe MUxIMUM CULTURE iDECLOGY

exposure POETRy PROFIT

EONDMUS GENDER

VOL. IIi NO.95 CHIEFS OF STAFF

SATURDAY, JUNE I5, 1985.

MICHELANGELO QUESTIONS

IN DISCUSSIOND WITH UN. PRIORITIES ON FAMINE

ARTEMISIA GENTILLESCHI RELIEF AND CASH CROPPING IN!

NOTUNS OF STERFUTYPING IN QUESTION BY STATUESQUE BRUNETTE THIRD WORLD FROM ITALY

NANCYREAGAN AND

PICASSO LASHES

THATCHER PROPOSALS BERTHE MORISTY DISAGREE ON BASIC

FOR EDUCATION AND PRINCIPLES of COLOUR

UNEMPLOYMENT AND COMPOSTTION

Pentagon turns down strategic defence initiative

by Velasquez

REMBRANDT

ARY YTELDS in call for trade

MACeto sanctions against M Brvys South Africa.

Chuz

Sn in1*

Gorbarher in discushions

RAPID EXPANSION WOULD WORRY ME SAYS CEZANNE

F2329 185-9935*33

.. : .Ke..s. měrscogte:7928:22270

KANCES

L'.S. art Shipments

1160

unhi

is suitural SHIPMENTS fAl1 10 tweena bites iT. April, after SeAboRA? gusters for a revent 509438 han

Mart. Ike Commence Defamen:

The Politics of Gender

Braufi

Nudity

with the funtanenial con- 31599 we sing

with Materitch disagrers 11 cession: matt by implication ip his work "White saudie ca antite giours'

KINNOCK AND

RAPHAEL IN

BUST-UP ABOUT

THE MEANING

OF BEAUTY

High Lim

yukz

Reagan tax plan:

Divine Spirit alle

RAUSCHENBERG AND REAGAN CLASH OVER TRADE DEFICIT

Kierkegaarde lays down the law on proqmat ism and polities to Thatcher Cabinet

Commerabo

* 100.

-150

1117

40

3130

DO STEWT Baced stucks.

George Bush condemns the politics of culture as outlines by Titian

VERMEER TO ATTEND SALT TALKS.

Baselitz and Reagan find substantial areas of agrecment on fiscal policy, the meaninglessness of the construction of meaning, ull P. sionifiers are wild - both men Like MaDonald's Cheeseburgers

Grotto complains that Pentagon statement conflicts with contral data camellation of commercial crease sale - Artscribe magagine descritts Grotto's stance as 'simplistr!

Fra Angelico utterly

opposed to star wars defines the plan as unethical, unworkable, i ungodly.

ART OR CRAFT? -— Benin Forinary restleone and interdaise - Botha acts.

DA VINCI HUSTLES N.A.S.A. ON GENERAL PHILOSOPHICAL

PRINCIPLES-

MARKET STATISTICS

Dow Jones Industrial Average Petter

1240:

Liam

--13%i

Al'H

N.Y.S.E, culture (in millions)

.2K:

12:

46 %i 28 res 19 28 21 tE AL "Call me a sentimental aesthetic old formalist if you like but I like to see a nicely painted missile tender boneless chicken chief argues national heritage enhanced br beautiful missiles

Sistine chapch feiling project has azficit funding insplications in period of cut backs and high unempleyment

cruise missiles aesthetically

pleasing says head of art school

at odds with the

leges William Blake

MATTISSE SAYS THATCHERISM FAILS TO RECOGNISE PLEASURE PRINCIPAL

= 8983 19. 5:

AT&T aspects cultural pentatien

to rise in the secant haif of this Year fromthe fose son mantli perios

PRESERVATION ORDER PLACED ON CLASSICALLY PROPORTIOED POLARIS MISSILE - iNTELLECTUALS FAIL TO GIVE LEAT ON BEAUTY SAYS DEFENCE SECKETARY HESELTINE

Veronese argues that Brunelleschi desten for new pentagon is prime example of cultural appropriation

Pentagon Plans To Boost Beauty, Reduce Clearances

ANDY WARHOL PRICE

RISE CAUSES CHAOS AS

KOREA LIBERALIZES LAWS

Rodin to sculpt

missile silo

11* 2b

2993325388 .. •/./: ?

t6%= Wixxnei

GOYA to appear

before grand jury

weinbrrger meets (anrad Atkinsen in Vienna Telks. Seeks advice on disarmament

IBM and third world represantatives discuss the complexity et

meaning in the inverted

figures of Baselitz

Superpower Summit declares agfeement on cultural accora- art and policies do not pass andare in essence unaconnected -

Let's get personal

Dow Jones & Company, Inc.

invites you to a seminar on Dow Jones Art /Retrieval

A demonstration and

training session for our online cultural service 1

Conrad Atkinson, Wall Street Journal, hand-coloured screen print - reproduced from and, journal of art and art education, 10 Swanfield Street, London E2 7DS.

Two pamphlets from

SOCIALIST OUTLOOK

Questions and answers on the crash

Ernest Mandel

Socialist Outlook, 16pp. £0.50

Ernest Mandel answers some of the main questions that have arisen since the

"crash of '87'. What were the underlying causes of the crash? Will the crash be followed by the same type of recession that characterised the 1930s?

What answers do socialists have to the crisis? Answers to these questions

and others are explained in this clearly written and concise work.

The fight against Alton:

abortion and women's liberation

Leonora Lloyd, Gill Lee and Valerie Coultas

Socialist Outlook, 16pp, £0.50 Abortion rights in Britain have been under attack ever since the passing of the '67 act.

Now the Alton bill seeks to restrict the time limit up to which women can obtain

legal abortions. This short pamphlet, written by women active in the pro-choice movement, explains why the struggle of women to control their fertility is a focus for

women world-wide. It explains why abortion is a crucial issue for socialists

and the labour movement. It looks at why and how we should build

the Fight Alton's Bill campaign.

Both pamphlets are available from your local Socialist Outlook seller or send a cheque/postal order

for 0.50 plus 0.20 postage and packing (per pamphlet) to Socialist Outlook, PO Box 705

London, SW19 1HA. (Bulk rates available — write for details)

SPECIAL OFFER C3 00 OFF

Socialist Outlook offers all new subscribers a copy of Alan Thornett's new book From Militancy to Marxism for £3.00 off!

SUBSCRIBE!

Annual Subscription rate: (10 issues) * £8.50 for inland subscriptions * £17.00 for inland multi-reader subscriptions * €18.00 for overseas airmail subscr * £54.00 for overseas airmail mull

$75.00)

.O1 ipt

Name.. Address

Post Code..

Subscription to start from issue number ..

] Yes, I want a copy of From Militancy to Marxism at the specially discounted rate and enclose a cheque for £15.45 for the book and my one year subscription.* 7l enclose a cheque for f Socialist Outlook.

Make all cheques payable to Socialist Outlook.

Please return to Socialist Outlook, PO Box 705, London, SW19 1 HA • Book offer only applies to inland subscribers.

for a one year subscription to

← Inside British fascism · Seafarers' struggle escalates →

Something wrong on this page?