LABOUR PARTY
anis Doran/Reflex
Tony Benn, the obvious candidate for a
left challenge to Kinnock
Denis Doran/Reflex
Kinnock -
delay
AT THE TIME of writing, it is still unclear whether anyone will oppose Kinnock and Hattersley for leader and deputy at this year's Labour Party conference.
The Campaign group of MPs has voted by a large majority that there should be a challenge, and most consti- tuencies with Campaign group MPs sup port such a challenge. But Tony Benn, the obvious candidate, is still undecided despite the sharpness of his attacks on Kinnock. The three women MPs mooted as candidates for the deputy leadership have withdrawn for one reason or another.
The longer the indecision, the less likely a challenge. The chances of launching a serious campaign diminish by the day. Yet the conditions for a leadership challenge are better than they have been for several years.
Kinnock has already said that such a 12 contest would be a 'diversion'. It is not
Roy Hattersley: speaking no evil? Unfortunately not!
clear whether he means a diversion from his obsession with witch-hunting Labour party members or from the fight against the Tories. It is because he refuses to lead any fightback (and indeed is closing his eyes to that which is going on) that a contest is necessary.
With Thatcher's programme for her third term more radical than ever, the Labour and trade union leaderships have sunk even further into ineptitude in response. Continuing down the path set in the Tories' previous two terms, they have whinged and moaned while oppos- ing any attempt to resist Tory attacks. Indeed they have gone half way to meet them on many issues.
Ironically, it is on the two issues on which the Tories are least popular, the NHS and poll tax, that it is most blatant. The best the Parliamentary Labour Par- ty can do on fighting the poll tax is to support the amendments of the Tory
il? sot!
Denis Doran/Reflex
John Prescott
"wets': Meanwhile, Kinnock tours the country telling the labour movem that the one thing which would ensure Thatcher's proposals went through unaltered would be to organise against the poll tax — either by local authorities refusing to implement it or by a 'won't pay' campaign!
On the NHS, NUPE bureaucrats bend over backwards to squash the developing militancy; Kinnock refuses to associate the Labour leadership with the strikes and merely asks the chancellor to 'find more cash' in the budget.
Thatcher can again appeal to the "better off' sections of the working class by saying that Labour is the party of higher taxes. Other strikers, such as the seafarers and Ford workers have not even been awarded the token 'sympa- thy' of the Labour leadership.
On many other issues, Kinnock's only difference with Thatcher has been La. Last ta imalamont hor aalirioo
the lent sure ugh : the ities on't
end sing iate ikes find
the class y of s the
not
only
on
Tn
SOCIALIST OUTLOOK noó March/April 1988
the Spycatcher case, Kinnock accepted the •Tory argument of the importance of national security. He has supported the refusal to prosecute anyone in the RUC associated with the 'shoot-to-kill' policy. Many Labour MPs voted disgracefully for Ken Livingstone's expulsion from the commons for pointing out that the attorney-general was 'an accomplice to murder'
The reaction of Labour's front bench to the notorious clause 29 attack on lesbian and gay rights was to welcome it before the tide of opposition forced them to change tack. A similar failure to pay the slightest attention to party policy has occurred on the Alton bill, with a refusal to apply a three line whip which could have defeated it at the second reading.
For those who refuse to accept that Kinnock is intent on a fundamental shift in Labour's policy and argue that the left should welcome the much-vaunted 'po- licy review' in which Labour listens to everyone but the organised labour movement, he and Hattersley spelt it out in their policy statement on 'democratic socialist aims and values'.
Here they codify the direction in which they have been taking party policy in the last few years. For them the allocation of goods by the market is 'generally satisfactory' and nationalisa- tion outside utilities is unnecessary. Gone is even a formal commitment to
LABOUR PARTY
clause four's 'common ownership of the means of production, distribution and exchange
This statement provoked criticism from wide sections of the bureaucracy. It was too much even for Bryan Gould, famous for his support for Thatcher's 'share-owning democracy'. David Blun- kett saw the way the wind was blowing and got in with his woolly counter- statement first.
Beyond the policy statement, dis- gruntlement with Kinnock's leadership is rife amongst sections of the bureau- cracy who have been his willing helpers in beating back the left. Murmurings about ignoring the unions were heard immediately after the general election and came to a head with GMB right- winger Warburton's open attack.
But a leadership challenge cannot be based on such a mixed bag of dissent. By their treatment of Prescott and Warbur- ton the Labour leadership and its trade union backers showed their reaction to any rocking of the boat. They may have disagreements with Kinnock's style and methods, but not his basic project and they are not prepared to open the floodgates which would allow the rank and file to raise more serious issues.
After all, these hiccups can be sorted out in time-honoured fashion in the corridors of congress house. Unlike 1981, little support will be found
amongst union executives for any chall- enge. Most of them have swallowed 'new realism' hook, line and sinker and are now more concerned with holding back their members than defending their jobs and conditions. The battle for union support will have to be fought out in the membership and on the conference floor.
Any real attempt to build an alterna- tive leadership to Kinnock and Hatters- ley must appeal to the rank and file of the movement, who — in stark contrast to the bureaucracy — are showing a re- newed willingness to fight back.
The support given by Campaign group MPs to this fightback shows that a leadership challenge could provide a focus for drawing together these issues, while putting forward policies which pose a real alternative to Thatcherism.
With the new upsurge in struggles, there has been no better time since the miners' strike to contest the leadership. If the challenge is ducked it will be a setback for the whole left and be seen as a victory for Kinnock.
While such a campaign will, real- istically, have little chance of booting out Kinnock and Hattersley, it could begin the job of building an organised left opposition. This is something many in the Campaign group have shied away from in the past o PETE FIRMIN
Who is Labour
A POLI, of Labour MPs found 40 per cent sceptical of the whole 'Labour listens' and policy review process.
According to the Independent, when 'Labour listens' is mentioned, many MPs 'snort, grunt, shake their heads or suck their teeth'. This is, of course, standard behaviour for the house of commons. But it is also a sign of cynicism about the party leadership's public relations efforts.
So what is behind Labour listens' when even our parliamentary representatives are wary?
Opening 'Labour listens' in Brighton, Roy Hattersley said the project was 'intended to provide an opportunity for individuals and groups outside the Labour Party to offer their advice... we cannot promise to accept your advice. But we do promise to listen to it with respect
Besides implying that Labour has never listened to anyone before, such an approach reduces still further the role of party members and constituency organisations in the development of policy. It is not the rank and file who are being listened to.
Those issued with tickets in Brighton included trade unions, community and pressure groups which Labour should, anyway, be in constant dialogue with.
Much more worryingly, equal weight was given, for instance, to the local trades council and Brighton and Hove chamber of commerce. Similarly, in Bournemouth, Labour was concerned to 'listen' to local bosses.
SOCIALIST OUTLOOK noó March/April 1988
'listening' to?
This brings us to the real point of the exercise. Hattersley insists: 'nobody should delude themselves into thinking that the basic beliefs of the Labour Party will be changed'. However, 'Labour listens' takes place simultaneously with a policy review in which, we are told, no policy is sacrosanct.
Don't imagine that the 'Labour listens' replies go straight in the bin. 'Experts' will analyse them. The "results' will be fed into the policy review. The whole process will be used to shift the party even further to the right.
Nobody is saying Labour should not listen. Labour leaders should be listening now... to the Ford workers, the nurses and other NHS workers, the seafarers and the local government workers struggling against Labour-imposed cuts in jobs and services.
But this would go against Hattersley's dictum that "a great national party must not speak for one group, one class, or one region'
Labour may be 'listening'. But it is being very selective in what it hears. And it's not listening to you or me.
With carefully selected audiences and carefully chosen questions, the leadership intends use what it hears to rule out any consideration of socialist policies o
DAN CARTER
13
OMEN D