Socialist Outlook

Socialist Viewpoint, International, Socialist Outlook and their supplements, 1984–2009

Gorbachev - a turn to the right

· Socialist Outlook no. 5, January–February 1988 · pp 36-38 · 1,492 words

Russia and the USSR Latin America

Gorbachev's popularity with the capitalist and with right-wing party arc positive developments for the world's working class.

The INF treat has been made possible by the Soviet Icadership offering concession after concessions under the now treary the Us must destros 300 warheads, the USSK 1500, The result is very much a partial de-nucicarisation: Margarct Thatcher and others are alrea dy talking of replacing the lost missiles with submarine launched ones. and Reagan i left free to gu ahead with the Us project of ensuring a first-strike capacity through Star Wars!

Nor does the Soviet leadership's new realism" seema, so far, to be having the propaganda climinaung weakening western fear of the USSR) that are often claimed for it: after all Thatcher had no difficuley in playing the "red threat card in the June 1987 gen eral election:

The INF trcaty can be presented as at victory lor the peace movement aglunst the irrationality of the arms race: but its effect scems as likely as not to be a partial demobilisacion of this movement and a return to thr belief that it is possible to Icave these questions to the politicians.

USS R

editors of Labour Focus on Eastern Europe, MacDonald asked

There is noching wrong in itself with a stue making partial diplomatic agreements with this or that bourgeois stato, or indeed with making military concessions where these serve some use ful purpose — all the more when, as with the INF tracy, the result will be a

• glasnost presents limited openings' substantial saving of resources and the weapons abandoned have no pracrical military use. The problem comes when illusions in these agrcements are pro: moted, and when the march for them leads to policies which demobilise and disorient the working class.

Fifty vears ago. in the 1930caffer the Nazi coup in Germany, Moscow pur: sued for some time a policy of seeking to get collective security agreements with the Polish referendum tells us something important the democrane? bourgeoisie in Europe. with a view co protection against Hitler. Both the Spanish revolution and ife mass movement of workers in France were sacrificed by Stalin in pursuit of this policy. When no such deal was forthcoming, Stalin turned to a deal with Hitler and sacrified the remainder of the Europcan working class for the illusory security of the Hitler-Staiin pant.

Gorbacher, like Brechner before him, follows this illusory mad in relations with the imperialist powers — seeking "good bourgcos" who will do deal and promoting illisons in che permanence a turn to the right

In the last issue of Soctalist Outlook we published an article on Gorbachev and the lett' by Oliver MacDonald, one of the

In this they are done. Paralocital as it may scem, this leads Moscow to prefer rightwing governments: they represent the bourgeoisic and so can make deals stick. while reformist governments only show that the bourgeoisie is weak, and threaten the possibilny of a crisis which would destabilse peaceful co-cxistence'- Thus Brezhner went a long way in supporting Giscard d'Estiny ax French president. and Gorbacles is happy to be used to boos! Thantier's poll ratings and to give Krayan i summit achievement whach will help the Republican candidate in the next presidential election,

As for the Furopcan CTs. the "Gorbachev turn' has strengthened the euro. communist right-wig and ground but from under those lefts who looked to Moscow for an alternative to the euros political collaper

Morcover. Moscow's policy towards the semi-colonial third world follows the stalinist tradition of sacrificing the working class for the sake of deals with this or thar bourgeois rigime. Moscow presenter the fall of Marcos as US inter: ference in Philippines internal affairs, and was onc of the last governments to withdraw recognition from the Marcos regime. On South Africa, the Moscow press has suggested a multiracial federa tion - an idea which, though it tits with the oider ideas of the South African Commenis Party on South African somely: comes close in present condecions to endorsement of Rotha's "reformi"

The Moscow-based exile leadership of the Chilean CP has taken a sharp rurn to the right, advocating negotiations with Pinochet. The USSR His reduced oil supplies to Nicaragun and (in a move possbie connected with the fact that

Cuba is due this year to start repaving its vast Soviet delt) # senior adviser to Gorbachev has made n sharp attack on Cuban comomic policy and manage

Moscow's hims that it may respond to us pressure for rapid withdrawal from Atghanistan show a complete lack of interest in any solution to this problem in the interests of the Alghan working class and poor pcasantry, or even in the detonce interests of the USSR: Alghanistan is purely an irritation and a diplo-

A counter-revolutionary internatonal policy has always been one of the most notable features of stalinist. The only distinguishing feature of Gorbachevise in this respect is the abandonment of the occasional left manoeusres, and limited support for colonial revolutions, which have been a feature of Moscow's forcien policy since the opening of the colil war in 1948. Gorbaches carries to new levels the stalinise tradition of substituting diplomatic arrangements for any attempt to usc the strengths of the workers" states in the interests of the the workers" international workime class.

S R

Trotsky remarked, in Thr Revolution Beneyed, that foreign policy is everywhere and always a continuation of domestic policy, for it is conducted by the same ruling class and pursues the

Gorbachev's torcign policy tells us something about his domestic policy, which on the surface links carher airactive to much of the

His pulicy towards the other workers! states tells us something very important, and that is that glewd is entirely subordinate and lunetionally related to peresGorbachev with Reagan — he seeks 'good bourgeois' who will do deals toila, to the economic reforms'. For all the talk of 'openness and carning from diverse experiences, a policy uf the perestroike type is being imposed from the top down on the castern Europcan bureaucracies, using cconomic pressure. polemnics like those levelled against the Cubans (anil also against the Bulgarian leadership) and all the bureaucratir the Sovier possesses. In places the results descend into farce, as in the claim by the Coch CP leadership that the Dubeek period was one of the cconomic retorms similar to Corbachev's which, however, were

*abused by revisionist and right-oriented groups" (Guardiar, 5 December) - and: more importantly. Jaruzelski's referendum on reforms" in Poland, where a majority of the population either abstained or cored against.

The Polish relerendum also tells us something important. The economic cri ses in Poland, Hungary and Yugoslavia are the direct result of the pursuit, over a substantial period, of the lype of policies now advocated by Gorbachev and his rr-thinkers. Although these policies resalied in a good deal of loosening up of the repression of the dissident intelligentsa, for the wurking class they did not mean greater fredom nf action or control over thr ceonomy. They meant, rather, econome dislocation, price rises. wage cuts and speed-up and legal and semi-legal repression of working cass Jaruzelski pur proposals for more of the same to the vole, the rosult was cicar rejection. Tr was resistance to this sort of treform whirt sparked the emergence of Solidarnose in Poland, even if the main Icaders of thr musement cvolved more and more jowards frec-market

Oliver MacDonald argued in the last issuc of Socialis Onlook chac the working class tronghont the world has shown itself over and over again to be prepared to pay an astonishingly high econome price for grcater political freedom'. Te would he mire arcurate. copecially in the light of the Polish referendum. to say that The Laderships of the working class are willing that the workers should pay an extronimarile high economic price for a political treedom' whose principal boncficiery will be the leaders. not the workers themseives.

Overall, Gorbachev represents a turn to the right in the policy of the Moscow bureaucracy, as much in its domestic as in its forcign policy. Gleen does prescor certain linuired openings for movements ofoppusition in the USSR. But the Ief will be lost and separated from the workers, or will mislead them, if it does not start from the firm understanding that the altacks on the working class which are central co the perestrika must be resisted; that the only feasibile socialism" is one which is based on democratic central planning under the control of the workers, not the Irer play of market mechanisms with limited "social protection: and that reliance on diplomatic deals with sechions of the bourgonsie is a snare and a delusion The only real security for the workers! states against imperialist attack lies in the exlension of the world revolution 35

Bomb

culture

← 400 at Outlook for Socialism · Landscapes of the bomb →

Something wrong on this page?