Socialist Outlook

Socialist Viewpoint, International, Socialist Outlook and their supplements, 1984–2009

Fighting Alton's bill

· Socialist Outlook no. 5, January–February 1988 · pp 10-12 · 2,233 words

This article was cut at the top of the page the printed contents gives it, because its title was too short to locate in the text. Its opening may carry the end of the article before it.

Women Britain

ABORTION

DJES

What right

have 60

old

totell

old

what

todo?

have

year

Men

15

to

8

Young women march against the Gillick ruling 1985 - they will be

especailly hard-hit if Alton's bill succeeds

THE JAMES WHErE bill fell at the end of October 1975 following the ment of a select committee to look at the proposals. Among other things, White. a Tabour MP.

licensing for referral

several rcasons: it was very

committee

for James White on February 7, but, like an increasing number of other MP's with majorities of less than 5.000, he is un- likely to vote for him Wrigelesworth said, "the situation had changed since the hill was drafted"?

William Benyon, the ill fated Conser varive MP for Buckingham, was the nest to be tempted into a major challenge to women's rights. His bill, whach got is second and final reading on 25 February 1977, souplit to make it more diffiesh for doctors to recommend abortion. to give police access to modical files and to

establish agencies and

long anil

rliame

wanted to amend the social clause in the 1967 act, to introduce

reduce the upper time limit from 28 to 20 wecks. The White bill was deleated for

complicated and the overwhelming bulk of the evidence presented to the selece

wax against it. During its rather long passage through parliament the anti-abortionists scored an impor-

rant own goal with the publicaton of a book called Babies for Burning, a typical

piece of anti-abortion propaganda which

was exposed as a pack of lies and did

Of course finally the bill was defeated by mass action coordinated by the newly formed National Abortion Campaige

them a lot of damage

(NAC.) which organised a 20.000-strong demonstration in Jume 1975 and which forced the TUC and the national Tabur women's advisory committee to take a position against the hill. This in turn put massive pressure on Labour MPs as the following extract from Issue No 38 of the feminist journal Spare Kib demonstrates: Mr Tan Wrigglesworth, the Labour and Co-operative MP for Thornaby, voted

again. Mr

reduce the time limit to 20 weeks, As with the White ball, it never gor to a thund rading. largely through fibustering by pro-choice MPs. The anti-abortionists were also greatly divided over the Be- nyon hill. NAC. ALRA and a group of women within it (Feminists Agatist Be- non—FAB) organised various activities and were simultancously centering un fighting the cifocts of cuts in the healt service on abortion provision.

When in 1979 women again tank 102 the streets in delianre of abortion righes and against the latest bill being proposed by John Corrie MP. the situation seemed a lot less auspicious for an on and out victory. A Tory government was in

SOCIALIST OUTLOOK na5 lanuary February 198E

David Alton's bill currently going through parliament is the fourteenth attempt to amend the abortion act since it was passed in 1967. The attack, aimed at reducing the upper rime limit for abortions to 18

weeks, has touched a raw nerve for thousands and thousands of

madi

18 organised through the

we need to defeat Alton today.

through mass action, led by women and

labour move- ment. It is this self-same strategy which

The first thing we have to do in preparing ourscives to deleat Alton is to reject fashionable "new realist argu- ments within the labour movement which shy away from such mass action. There are those in the movement who are secking to make a compromise with David Alton for a 24-wceks limit, thos Iving in the face of positions within the

government. Abortion is fundamental to women's struggle for

Bur as we dust off the old placards and leaf through the old

differences and the similarities in the situation. JUDITH

Our bodies

our lives

our right

to decidn

= 19

A protest against the Powell bill

power winch madr it more difficult to esploit some of the contradictions which the government found itself in under Labour. Norman St Jot Steva, a cath- ole and anti-abortions, was the leader of the house and the bill was introduced at a different time which meant that the filibuster tactic wooki not be feasible.

In facr. Margaret Thatcher imposed a one-line whip for the second reading and this bill got the biggest vote vei: 212 to 98 This Time.

anti-abortionists plaved up the proposal to reduce the time limit to 200 weeks as the major Junction nf the bill. Behind this wer included other proposals to restrict the grounds for shortion and restrict the chariev clinies

SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 3 JeruaryiFebrvery 1098

liberation. If we do not control our own bodies then what control do pamphlets to prepare ourselves to send Alton packing as we sent White

and Benvon and Corric before him, it is important to bear in mind the

we have leftover our lives at all? ARKWRIGHT reports.

pamph

or for

JUDITH

labour movement to defend the 1967 act

abomon on request. This is because thry have lost any fath ibey ever had in the mass movement and seck instead to rely on parliamentarist strate- gies like winning over Tory weis or the

into Daval Non's hands. Ir appears sha fir has learnt more than them in the last thirten years and he has made in cicar char this bill is only one step in a campaign 1o dismanile the '67 act en- tireiv. He is presenting a one line bill herause he has learned from previous

since in previous

Lousc of Lords.

mistakes that this goal must be underta- ken step by step. In this he seras to have united the anti-abortionists behind him. This ix important, campaigns anti-abortionists like those organised in Life did not lavour such compromises. Wheiher die bill is for an 18 ur 24 week limut, if it is grassed it will still be a delcat for women and give

tremendeus contidence to the anti- aburtionists forgo lorward

Furthermore, in an article in Marione Today, Wendy Savage points out that

Poran/Reller alrough a fenus is siable at 24 weeks

only ten percent actually survive and even then only with tremendous medical back up and resuurces. She states that we should not be led down this road of of the hild ran he kept alive we should bring down the limit" need is cast acres in abortion facilities which would reduce most late abortions, but we have to have the facilities for sonur late ones because there are some hard cascs:

David Alton

were

Bur if che ano-aborcionists slightly better prepared for this arrack (although in fart this was not to last). those supporting a woman's choice were

What women

Ax with the campaign against Corne. mass action with labour movement sup

We have no

compromise is deleat and the bill is unlikely to run out of time because it is more simple and straight- forward than in the past. The anti abortionists, for the moment at any rate appear united. This is not to say that a mass mobilisation will be easy to gene- tate. The political climate under That- 9

be this tine extremely well-organised By this time the Labour Party and the TeC had policy on abortion. Instead of

NAC. the

The maximum pon is our only option

other chince

doing evervthing through Campaigo Against Corrie" was ser up

order to involve number of pcople arounil the limited aim of delearing the bill. This tactic

pread serful and am 28 Ciner

in

1979. TUl led a 60,000 song demonstration against the bill. Herc. no one could be in anv doubt that the detence of women's rights had been achieved outside parliament and

ABORTION

cher's thind term is not favourable and

supports a 21-weck

Thatcher herself compromise. With cuts in the health service, 50 per cent of abortions are now done privately and there are the cle- ments of a moral crusade. perhaps more confident than on previous occaxions, being built up by the popular press.

Notwithstanding all this, the response

to the campaign set up to fight Alton has been unprecedented in its breadth and

KEEP

ABORTION

LEGAL

scope. There are more FAB groups than there were CAC groups and the TUC has already agreed to co-sponsor the na-

national demonstration on 19 March.

pangr GMH.

NATHE, NUM and others. The NUM has taken a position for the first time and this is not a little to do with the women against pit chisures movement whin are also supporting the campaign.

Despite the divisions among the left and within the women's movement people are rallying to defend this the most basic of human rights.

But as well as the defeatists there arc also those within the campaign who arque thar we cannot defend the 1967 act because it does not guarantee women a real choice. Of course this is true and that is why the National Abortion Cam-

LEGAL

January and the Trade unions supporting the cam-

NALGO. NUPE,

sc tire time and

AND

SAFE

bodied or disabled. lighring tor abortion

rights roes not challenge that in any way

should be able to decide

It over Won..

Tacose way

because it challenges women's role as

merely a reproducer of the workforce. But it is also a women's issuc and those in the campaign who oppose women-

— it merely says that at a certain prim

the woman who is carrying that toetus.

Ar a broad-bascd campaign in detence if abortion rights AB must seck the involvement and participation of blark wotten and their organisations. Wrall have an interest, black and white: in defcating Alton and we all stand to lose it the bill is passes. But this is nor in deny that black women are dilferentially al fected because of racism. In her Marxism Today interview, Wendy Savage shows just how different women's esperithe

She explains that in Tower

paign is in favour of changes in the law to get rid of the stipulation of two doctors? signatures, to make a statutory require- ment on health authorities to provide abortion facilities — in other words for

But that does not mean we cannot and should not defend the gains of the 1967

acc as it stands. Before the act was passed

unly activities or the need for women to

lead the campaign. do not understand

one crucial ingredient in the success of previous campaigns — the laet that they

werr ler by women. For, when it comes to it. only women will have the energy and commitment to carry on this light

since they are the ones direrily aflerted

and with the direct experience of what

more than 3,000 women each year were being admitted to hospital with septic wombs and hundreds died from back-

street abortions. They would surely not

ns on their righr

Some in the campaign have argued

can be

that abortion is a class issue because in

inky affects working class women.

- lane

Hamlets where she works, there was al In ratio of abortions to births for the West

agree that we should not detend the 1967

act from attack. The act did not decrimi- nalise abortion fully bur gave a lor of women the possibility of a safe, legal and

By fighring to defend the 1967 act we can bund a successful movement to de feat Alton and begin to alter the balance of forces towards women fighting for what we really want. This brings us to a further vehate which has emerged inside the campaign. Abortion is not exclusively a

It is a class issuc and many within the pro-choice movemen have striven to point this out in the last twenty years.

teel ch.

Indian and West Alrican populariton ot

1:2: of white women of 1:9 aml lor

Pengali women of 1:28.

Within the campaign we must link up

In the meantime with black women's organisations and

lind out such information and draw up

demands around it. A black women

against Alton group is being eblished

within the campaign to look at precisely

women opposed to Alton will not fight consistently for women's rights — that is their participation in the campaign only

their contradiction our euenues.

serves to highlight the divisions among

The campaign against Alton is diffe rent from previous campaigns and the these issucs. stakes arc much higher on both sides.

In onder to delei Als we coed mo Bur the methods of building the cam- druw on the strengths of our past history paign must remain the same. Alose all and learn from its wcaknesses. To do

must avind divisions within the thar we are going to noodl all the res- movement Already the anti- ources ur can master. The fight cannot abortionists are trying to ram that they he starked or acoided if we are coer tor it raises arc speaking for disabled people. Not achiere real control over our bodies and true. Many disabled organisations sup our lies port the pro choice movement. Our de- Dar nose carr Sorialst Charlook pamphle manki must be for the right to life, lair toe. Fight die Alien Bill defact racer fo the right to a decem life, shetber able

SOCIALST QUTLOOK 5 Januaryifebruary 1988

It is i class issue berause

issues such as the right of the state to take

personal decision-making out of the

bands of individuals. To is a class issue 10 because of the was imperialism uses

← Letters · Women for socialism →

Something wrong on this page?