abused child must have the right to make all the bane decisions whether to go into care, and su on
This is surely utopian.
"prusecution
will gir
thr
44448-
SES 35%
There-
albeit tomurrow, few
.. chile. They
- whether to prosecute,
demand.
The 'rebellious laxpayer" (always presum od young and healthy) is as much a firtion as
the 'infinite demand". systems are more expensite than the NIls, and
Many abused are far too young to have any
Many children
alterni the NI'
them — let's remember that many abuse victus are under ten, and many much younger. The inevitable conclusion is that socicty as a whole has to provide agencies, Tike social workers, capable of intervening, defending children - and in some cases, together with other agencies. making decisions on their behalf.
we shots Shee
is, or what it will entail for
ntall to much
ir will organise and frad a real rebellion
311ent, ArTIs
« a GP appor
"hotel charge
reb.
PIECEREL
Indeed, despite all the media hype, private medicine, is still proluundly unpopular. Less
than nine per cent of the population are covered by private medical insurance mostly through company schemes which end at retirement - when health care is most
Though Thatcher's strategy to suf- focate the NHS may press-gang some patients
in chronic pain into an Edna Healey-style compromise, this does not mean the puhlic
lunc Dani Ahren's and Judith Paton's article avoids the errors of most of the lell press in thar ir confronts the problers of analysing the family in terms of both capitalism and
Unfortunately, it suffers from a degree of
therefore anti-materialist view of the family.
thate ther
patriarchy, which is a precondition of an
adequate marxist explanation economistn and functionalism on the onr hand aral a covert liberalsm on the other. Tr also tends to slide into an essentialist and and importantly, ul sexuality.
16
It is certainly the case that the lamily is Junctional" for capital in ways pointed by Dani and Judith. Such an analysis. however, ignores the complexities of power relations within families and the diversity of family forms within which male dominance
has lustorically been exerrised.
We are told child sexial abuse has cxisted as long as the family has existed What is mcant by this? It sounds as if the
family has been in existence in some essential form since the beginning of line.
Family forms, as well as the pusstion of
children within houscholds and within society at large, have heen subject to considerable bistorical change. Nonetheless historical evidence demonstrates that child sexual abuse did exist prior to the rise of modern bourgeois family forms and the
emergence of the modern institution of childhood. ( course, parriarchy in our society cannot be understood without reference to class (and zuce seria), but Dani and Judith's premise reduces patriarchy to a ride-cffect of class which fails to account wither for its pervasiveness and persistence.
is for the changes it has undergone.
It is ironic that Dani and Judith rake a ritual sideswipe at radical feminism when their perspective so clearly erries that of Shulamith Firestone in The Dicinetic of Sex! Firestone in effect argues for a formally
equal status for children, also implied in Dani and Judith's legalistic conception of "empowerment". But children, especially
" I vou teel moved in:
iximum ol 300 word
London SW2 SUN.
-83813115131 37
ne truth of the
de tamilv 1s going se? ant torm of the organisati
apitali-m nme Children are vouns to lit- 10 atnunes, ane= thee
ay lundament: it.
Phil Hearse
hem wr
change in existing social relations which would mean the destruction of the nuclear family. So, socialists have to support mechanisms for society to intervene and defend children who are rhe actual or potential victims of abuse. This means specialised agencics, there's no way mund
ahused chaldren, are singularly ill-equipped to step into the mole of sovoreign, individual citizens exerrising their legally guaranteed
dan
"human rights
Of course chilinen shoukd be encouragod
«and decisu
appreciate that a statutory right to do so
would fail to counter their deep-rooted powerlessness. How can a child who has been subject to adult authority all her life,
who has deferred to arals, had decisions
made for lier be expected to lake her life in
al del
her own hands at a moment of crisis? Survivors of all forms of child ahuse are
nill aria.
blame, especially in the cose of sexaul
abuse; where the perpetrator will often have
anal
quelling the child's resistance. Other fears engendered in survivors include those of breaking up the family and hurring the mother. All these feclings cannor be land ar
the dour of insensitive or hostile reactions to
"disclosure" by the state, nor can they be blown away hy a quick psychological repair
I1150
job. Tackling them is the work of years.
EnV Pislin es Thie
gattet. En renee i sncially constructed, bur this does tot
there is no annerent canetenc in the capacities of a five-ver flicen-vear-old to understanc
and a lilicon-ycar-old to understand the world and make decisions accordingly.
On a wider scale, Dam and Judith say
sa maki
cuipowering thikiren would destry the
power structure of the nuclear family in capitalist soriety". I only it were that simple. Are we to believe that, with the 'empowerment" of children the entire
material basis lor the family and the suhordination of women and children will crumble?
A turber problem with the article is that it tails to deal with the issue of masculinity and male sexuality. Recognition that sexua! abuse, like rape, is an expression of power docs not mean that it has nothing to do
with sexualty. Womend to ask wily sex in particular should he used us weapon of domination. Failure tu raise such questions implies that it is taken for granted that this is how men "naturally behase sexually given the power lo do so.
Ar another level, reactions to ched sexual
abuse are shaped hy a historically predic configuration of arrinades to dildhood and sexuality, so that the sexual abuse of
children is treated as qualitatively difterent from other loems of abasr. The disbelief surmunding it is greater because of such artimudes. Some of the guilt survivors feel. may be due to the belich that they have transgressed against the strong social capertation ofsexual innocence in chileren. The secrecy and shame surrounding sexuality as a whole help make possible dee nast of silence imposed on the virtim.
It is true that the state and the "caring professions have not on the whole helped the position of tie victims of sexual abuse But a different analysis leads to different demandi. In our view. it, in cases of suspected sexual abuse. perpetrators conld he removed from the lown as casly as chikiren can he now, it would be a muel me agnificant shilt of power towards. children than paring die burden al proof
wonhwhile in itself. The necessary therapy
graps of abused children — surely the lirat
onto the man af a prosorton results months later, althon this may be for victims should emphasise work with
sep many griwth of a consciousness of collectice oppression.
Finally: the power of men in families will not be broken hy granting children un empty autarhy, bus by the establishment be aults of democratic. collective responsihilis for the care and protection winch children requin, and by braking the asso iation in cuen between power and sex. and constructing new forms of male
Stevi Jackson & Julian Wilson
SOCIALIST OUTIOOK no 4 November/December 1987
somality