UPDATE
Only a week after the start of the Gulf war did it become possible to cut through the barrage of US propaganda and begin to make an assess- ment of the military course of the war and the possible political implica- tions. ALAN DA VIES weighs up the events so far.
It is clear that initial estimates by the US alliance - that the war would be over in a few weeks - were wildy off the mark. Estimates of the dura- tion of the air war ranged from one to five days for gaining air supremacy. One report even said three hours. These estimates were a cru- cial part of the US military strategy since for Bush a quick war (and a clear vic- tory) is both a political and a military necessity.
Not only has the air war not been won in the first week, but the damage inflicted on Irag, par- ticularly on military targets, has been much exaggerated. Some al- lied planes have been attacking cardboard cutouts of missile launchers, and it is now accepted that the destruction of all Tragi airfields is impossible because of their size, number, camouflage and 1.5 metres-thick concrete covers for the aircraft - which were build by the British. Even the alliance now claims to have destroyed only 30 of Iraq's 700 aircraft.
Damage has clearly been sus- tained in the infrastructure of the economy, (electricity, water and communications); but the extent of this seems well short of dis- aster level as we go to press. Water pressure is reduced in Baghdad but it is still flowing in the taps, electricity has been restricted but may still be avail- able. The telephone system is working in some areas and Bagh-
Page 2
dad radio continues to broadcast.
Iraqi reports of casual- ties are also low, still under 300 - 41 of these civilians, though for some tactical reason they appear to be deliberately mini- mising the civilian death toll, which according to refugees interviewed in Jordan must be much higher than the govem- ment admits. It is easy to see why military casual- ties should be concealed, but there is little reason for Saddam to withhold details of civilian casual- ties which have world- wide propaganda value, not least the reported bombing of schools and hospitals, If there were
ing in the open -is the worst pos very big civilian casualties, Trag sible option. It would involve the would surely want to use this to biggest tank battle in history. refute unsupported and doubtful with combined armies of over a US claims of "clinical" bombing million on the Kuwaiti front
US: worried about land war
the ruling class. But elsewhere opinion is already moving in the other direction - such as in Italy where opposition to the war is 80%.
accuracy and restriction to military targets.
If the reports of relatively low casualties are true, this points to a highly developed system of har-
alone. Alliance forces are clearly not prepared for such battles, as shown by reports that some British armour is already bogged
In Britain, although public support for the war is strong at the present time this could
evaporate quite quickly. The anti-
dened shelters available to the population and adequate wam- ings of attacks. These probably date from the Iran/Irag war and have been extended in the last six months.
The most important military reality which has now been recognised by the USA is that they failed quickly to destroy the
down and lost in the desert before the war has even started.
Massive casualties in tank engagements are absolutely in- evitable under those conditions, and there is no certainty that the US could win. Generally ac- cepted military strategy sees a three to one advantage as neces- sary for a ground attack against defensive positions. The US does
war movement is developing fast, and even the craven support for the war shown by the Labour leadership could soon be chal- lenged. 34 Labour MPs are op posing the war, and there have been four front bench resigna- tions on the issue.
There is no serious pos sibility, at this stage, that the hamhine camnaion will turn the
Iraqi air force, and that their air power is ineffective against deep- ly dug-in troops. These factors alter the course of the war, since
defensive positions. The US does not have this advantage. Ul- timately they could win, of course, in a military sense. But
bombing campaign will tum the Iraqi population against Saddam. At the present time support for him and the war effort is clearly
ine crucia quesuon as wacte creasing. do usually happcus the US strategy for a land assault they could win before political with air bombing. The population has been to ensure that it is un- opposition became unstoppable? is being rapidly politicised into a dertaken under conditions of air
And if they were to win after wider understanding of the im- supremacy, after the defending such mass slaughter, what would plications of the war for the forces have been seriously be the new shape of the Middle region. The attacks on Israeli damaged by air attack. In some East, and what would be the level cities are highly popular and seen ways they mean that the real war of opposition to a US presence?
as direct support for the Pales- has not yet begun.
The start of the war, and the tinians. These factors may
The prospect of a land assault claimed victories, has increased change if the US bombing caused against defensive positions which support for the war in the main a complete breakdown of Iragi are largely intact - and the pos combat countries - US, Britain society, but this is not the case at sibility of Iraqi air attacks against and to a lesser extent France, the present time. US and coalition forces advanc- where there are clear divisions in
The prospect of a protracted
SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 30, February 1991
UPDATE
US troops: massive casualities inevitable war holds other major problems million each. Already it is clear
sland alia will banana a maino immand
for the US alliance. They have picked the best climatic condi- tions for what they saw as a short war. From now on, conditions can only get worse, with rain at the moment, sand storms February and March and then the temperature rising to intolerable levels. A tank war in such condi- tions would be something of unimaginable brutality. The medical authorities are already predicting that they will be over- whelmed by casualties, and are preparing mass graves for the dead.
At the same time Iraqi trench defences are being recognised as more effective than previously
that this will have a major impact on the budget.
Iraq's medium-tech army is easier to maintain and supply. Iraq has its own huge arms in- dustry, built up during the war with Iran, which can supply most of its needs, and an engineering industry closely integrated into it.
The economic effects of the war are clearly massive. It could push the world into massive new recession: the US is already talk- ing about putting up taxes to pay for the war which is now costing them S1 billion a day. The cost of the hardware being expended is absolutely enormous. It costs £500,000 to launch a Patriot mis-
thought. They are very deep and sile, and 40 were launched in one some are hardened - particularly attack. A top US strike aircraft command posts, amunition costs S72 million and an Mi tank dumps and tank emplacements. $4.4 million.
US surveillance is less effective,
The Scud attacks on Israel and and possibilities of camouflage | Saudi Arabia are clearly of politi- are more effective. than pre- . cal more than military sig.
nificance. But the Scuds have viously thought.
Munitions are being expended taken the war outside of Iraq. in the Gulf at a level which may forced the deployment of expen- not be sustainable. With up to sive defences, and created a 3,000 sorties a day. likely to in- political problem though deploy- crease if cloud cover lifts, ing Patriot missiles in Israel shortages may arise quite quickly. which in a sense draws them into High-tech missiles in particular | the war. can only be produced at a fraction
Syria has already objected, of the rate they are being used up. saying that the deployment alters even with the factones on maxi- the military balance in the region, mum overtime (leaving aside the and that the Patriots will even- economic effects of their cost). tually be used against Arabs. At The first four days of the war cost the same time the US has Britain £100 million and Major is prevented Israel from striking now forced to admit that the £500 back with air power by denying million they put forward for the them the identification codes used war is totally inadequate. The five by alliance aircraft. Tomados lost to date cost £16
The alarm of Arab govern- SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 30, February 1991
ments which are a part of the al- liance has also been increased by the intervention of Turkey, through the use of its bases to at- tack northern Iraq. Iran and Syria have raised the possibility that 1 Turkey may attempt to take over part of Iraq in the event of its defeat. The Iranian Foreign Mini- ster has said that this could lead to an Iranian declaration of war against Turkey. They suspect that Turkey wants to take over Mosul and Kirkuk, two oil-rich provin- ces from Turkey which were in- corporated into Iraq by Britain in 1926.
The Iranian govemment, under pressure from fundamen- talists for its connivance in the war, has made proposals to try to end it via an Islamic solution, and has called for a conference of Is- lamic leaders.
Most governments of Islamic countries or countries with Is- lamic minorites, are now under pressure from their populations who are increasingly supporting Irag against the US. Egypt's Mubarak and Assad have hinted at a conference of Middle East governments to call for a cease fire.
The govemment of Pakistan, which has 10,000 troops in the Gulf, is under massive pressure from the population and faces im- minent collapse over the issue if the contingent is not withdrawn. There have been massive demonstrations and strikes - notably in Islamabad and Lahore - against the war, some organised by the youth wing of the ruling party. Tens of thousands have
volunteered to fight for Iraq, and are demanding to be allowed to go to the front.
There have also been demonstrations in Bangladesh, where 1,000 have signed up to go to the front. Anti-war demonstra- tions have broken out in India, which has a Muslim minority of 100 million. In Malaysia, where demonstrations are banned, thousands are signing up to fight for Iraq. In South Africa, Mus- lims are asking to be allowed to join the war.
Iraq's strategy is clearly to fight a protracted war of attrition. Saddam Hussein made it clear before the war started that Iraqi troops would be dug in deep, that there would be nothing above ground, that the air strikes would be ineffective and that when the land war started the Iraqi army would be intact and ready to fight. So far this is emerging as essentially correct.
All this says is that a US vic- tory is no longer guaranteed. In- deed, the possibility exists for a political and military catastrophe for the USA, where Bush hinged his whole appeal on the pledge the war would not become another Vietnam', Yet a land war with tens of thousands of casual ties now looks certain, and politi- cal support for this in the US may well be impossible to sustain.
Failure to defeat Iraq would put the US back where it was after Vietnam - facing a massive loss of credibility, and its im- perialist foreign policy crippled by a population not prepared to go to war.
Page 3