FR
THE MINERS' strike marks a new srage in
the struggle ugainst the apartheid regime in
South Africa The black Isbour movement has conscionsly shoulder- ed the responsibiary of first place in the liberation 'struggle.!
The three: miners' strike came at the lead of the biggest strike wave in South African hirrory The strike itself more workers than the 240,000 membership
COSATU
Icading role.
were
retining
expons. stands the state.
The relative Africa's big business apartheid regine has proved much less than previously aimed. During the strike eleven miners were killed, ar Icast 300 were injured and more than 100 arrested. 36,000 are now on the line. Such is the record of cumpany busses who are normally strident in their public expressions of distaste for the excesses of the apartheid regime.
Since its founding congress, COSATU has insisted that the big corporations cannot survive witwut the state. Anglo-American's private army and the South African police attacked meetings. queurs and. meeting ar Klerksdorp, charged 78 strike committee murder. These lacts speak for themselves!
Suuth African week long South African
amhraced
100.000
(15-19 July) which
Angio-American, South
of the NUM. It was proceded by the second
congress represented more than 800,000 organised workers and in which the NUM played: a
On the other side of the mines dispute
ranged Africa's biggrs corpuration, together with
other smaller companies (mostly British- owned — like Consolidated Goidfields) in the Soutl African chamber of mines. These companies are responsible for the mining.
representing 40 per cent and 10 per cent respectively of the volume of South Alrica's:
Kritish and export of gold and coal Behind the chamber of mines
independence of South
sector Irom the
The jobs of
picket lines.
after breaking up a union
members with conspiracy ter
The recent upsurge in trade union activity makes the decisions of the recent COSAL congress extremely significant. There are mixed views about the conrent of some of thuse decisions: they were certainly a definite and deliberate sluft in policy direction. This was in large part managed by the NUM (obviousiv aware of its impending industrial
therefore requires
When COSATU assembled on 15 July, it was the only part of the liberation movement
undamaged,
The recent South African miners' strike demonstrated that the black working class is in first place in the liberation movement. A lew weeks before the strike began, the Confederation of South African Trade Unions (COSATU) held its second congress.
BRIAN HERON argues that the congress recognised the leading
doubled. role of the working class in the struggle against the apartheid
arrinn): it evalation
iis urgent
iten that thr
which remained substanrially
orking class is in firs
onfederation c
indeed more powerfil, than it was a year before. Ar the Wounding congress in 1985. barely hall a million workers (an unmense
part confederation By 1987 that number had
This inerrase membership was all the more remarkable because the rest of the organised liberation moretent had been hit hadly by repression in the intervening period.
COSATU itself had not escaped. COSATU
hail burned down
prominent trade union leaders had been
Charter should be understood within this context. But
contradictory currents in the trade unions have emerged in the
process.
regime, and that the adoption by COSATU of the Freedom
hause
of the
in
several
been
SOCIALISE OUTLOOK so 3 September/Ocrober 1987
7
goaled (the mose important being Moses Mayekisa, now general COSATU's second largest affiliate,
136,000 members).
sccrerary
NUMSA, Significantly.
with Mayekiso was arrested for his role in the Alexandra rownship committee. The United Deniocratic Front has bad 25 of its exerutive office bearers detained. important UDE electively paralysed
Many of the most
affiliates have been
and rent
health of the
main issues of the liberarion struggle. The answers given mark a new stage in the ideological manunty of the South African
Mor prominent in the press coverage of the congress's decisions" was the resolution
stikes continue ar a much lower level of co- ordination
In fact it is the trade unton movement that has had the only subsrantial break through against the state of emergency, SARHWU'S victory against the South African Transport Services in Junc, after a bitter strike, was a
remarkahle example of the movement even after I4 months of state
repression
THE TRADE union movemen's bedruck of organisation and relarive social homogenesty has foreed it into first place in the liheration movement. A general retrear hy the popular movement but a tougher care of the COSTU unions set the scene for the COSTU congress. It was from that point of view that the congress addressed all the
revolution
taken on sanctions. Concern was capressed
about sanctions taking a more prolonged character than initially envisaged and, in
serving to disguise the continued cumplicity of international big business with apartheid
workers' hand won employment rights.
Many had believed that the sanctions
was patt perspective for the overthrow of apartheid which was emhrared widely in 1984/5
Instead there appeared to be un increasing price to be paid by black workers throngh a long drawn our process of international
having a largely cosmetic rule,
the same time threatening black
a short term
agh
pressure, followed by disinvestment and sell-
nuts to South African capital. In thar regard COSATU avoided an uncritical approach.
ausroach. form nt international pressure
as currently
Gold mine, Roodepoort, n
Thereture COsT
..comprehensive and mandatory santions and all tir related demands contrel once investment, busiless visits and so on But a moron on commented: "Disinvesment as is currently carrie out be multi-national companics nothing more than corporate compulsi
allows these increase their support for the regime Therefore the resolution says COSTIL must
ear Johannesburg
calied for This satric splution also makes los where
cOsvIL's priorin lies for Innerational
regarding ation against apartheid
To easure (liat the social wealil of South disinvestmenr Africa senors the property of the poople t
South Africa for the benetir of all — and
further commit nunselves to the principle of aridents
international working class solidarity action
as the most powerful form of solidarity companies to action in stuc struggle for national
aberations. Our victory will h there
A major srep was taken also on Namibia.
adequate Fout thousand Namubian Ilibers anc
currently on strike, despite the hombings,
beatings and, must recently the wholesale,
alers of union and swan leaders The
SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 1 Septemben/Delober 1997
applied will nor he effective against capital or the state, they can cause scrious regional unemployment and they often serve
interests of the imperialist states rather than
the South African working class."
the
which otten bring about ensure that where disinvestment takes place
not
organised working class in South Africa have not had control of sanctions
companies must Southi notice of stir intention to pall our of South
Africa so that hona fide negotiations can take
pilare :
miners are fighting lor an increase in their 30p an hour wage rates Consolidated Goldfields are the employers."
Farly in the year Namibian trade Namibian mctalworkers union.
South African taking
1he amplicati... British based BP and
: sccond coners. to au
demneracy and workers control, is of para: ot the tree
mount importance in our struggle.
NUMSA wurked with unionists to establish
Today the
movement is
Charter, was a Mcp backwards In a separale article socians: Waren
gle for narional liberation, true liberarion can ony be achieved through an economic and social transformation of our socicty to serve the interests of the working class.
only striving for better conditions in the mines, factories, shops and farms bur also for a democratic socialist sociely controlled by
This view is reinforced later in the same
'There is no cunlict between the struggle for national libration and socialism. struggle against national oppression and the
struggle against capiralist exploitation and complimentary to each other and part of an
•Point 5. While we are involved in a strug •Point 6. Workers in our country are not
Accusitin the tendershi
the most democratic union in South Africa,
trade union
the lead on work for independence. COsTU declared its preparedness to take solidarity action if the National Union of Namibian Workers or any of its affiliates come under attack from rither the employers, the interim puppet administration or its South African masters,'
advanced organisation in South Africa on
with the
of being like their counter Nambian Britain ... ee concerned With Tr
the union itself than supporting the rank and
SARHWU
the working class."
uninterrupted struggle for total liberation.
In the same resolution it is stared. •1. COSATU adopts the Freedom Charter as a guiding document which reflects the views
This takes COSTL
the issuc of sondarity people.
Similariy. determineu
formally, the most COSTU appears to be
JoIn
Tran
in Nicaragua, Fl Salvador;
resolution.
Namibian
This sorry stare of affairs has come
about through the NUMSA's leadership hav-
ing illusions in legality" a difficul consen-
the
on to maintam given that the generas
secretary was elected while in goal faring
812511
The
file.
determined to give a lead more generally in Alrica has decided Organisation of African Trade Unions,
DATE, explaining it is part of the anti-imperialist struggles fought by the
Philippines, Angola and many orher parts of
Our struggle agains apartheid
exocution!
What should we make then of the udop rion of the Freedom Charter hy COSATU? Be followed acceptance of the charter by in- dividual altiliates, including the NUM and NUMSA, in the
run up to the congress
working class Phutopi A
and aspirations of the majority of the oppres
ed and exploited in our struggle against na-
Our struggle agains apartheid and exploitation is also a struggle against imperialism and neo-colonialism. Al the same time, COSATU reaffirmed its
internacional trade union federations which continuc to splir the world trade union
IP.
COSALL
mume explostati. develops and trengthens
unperians. opposition to joining
amongst all workers a cohereat working class
either of the
Moscow and the
A resolution on the
Unemployment Javid tune Refle»
Working in an asbestos factory - note the lack of safety precautions
have organised
undersranding of the demands of the
Freedom Charter and encourages the fullest
discussion on socialismu and democracy
amongst all progressive and democratic
forces.
Contrary: to the claims of Socialist Worker.
there was no sharp contrast with the talk of
fighring for socialism it the federation's
foundation in 1985'. In fact, the political
movement berween capitalist wext
On other questions, COSATU 100k a real programmatic lead.
organisation of domestic workers into a new COSATU alliate begins "women workers ex perience both exploitation as workers and oppression as women and that black women
ure firth.
of race. It concludes with the necessity tu encourage all focals and other COSATU structures to involve women workers. in general and domestic workers in particular to take an active involvement in the affairs
and direction of COSTU
Similarly, a major new step was taken regarding the unemploved. is now running at an estimated 25 per cent among blacks COSTU has helped set up an uncmployed workers umon. NUWCC. Until the union has been esrahlished "where groups unempinyed themselves, they (are to) be given observor status with full speaking rights in all CoATt: structures.
results
uutbnwu uoltaocit aur to aseter
Julet the Chian
niversary, 20 August this year." congress
UT announcing its support on its fourth an
niversary, 20 August this year."
Ir is an explicit part of the discussion that the Freedom Charter is not a socialis: docu-
ment." Nevertheless, different orgamsations
rth
WETETHIS RECORD it is perhaps surprising that joumals like the British Socialist Worker register such dismay? when they report the
COSATU's second Socialite Worker said that the left in COSATU had suffered a serious blow with the adop-
the Freedom Charter as the
on, the Freedom Charter saye nothing abour workore rights It is not a socialist document and its adoption stands in sharp contrast to the talk of fighting for socialism at
SOCIALIST OUTLOOK n0:3 Seglober/Orater 1987
place the charter into diflerent contex. The contest for COSATU was proviled pardy by the NEM resolution to congress within which
the proposal to adopt the charter appeared.
This resolution includes the following
ndl *211a»
lian of .. ideological busis for the federation'.
the federation's foundation in 1985.
It goes
against capitalist exploitation
Point 3. The struggle against national op- pression is inseparabic from the struggle
•Point 4. The unity of the working class. hased on the principles of non-racialism.
resulation of 1983 did not mention socialism The nearest it came was a relerence to the
"democratic Therefore at one level (and only at one level) the new resolution represents an immense politicisation of the trade union movement in the intervening period. There are, however other dimensions to the story which Socalist
society
9
Worker entirely misses:
The congress had guest speakers from the
SAYCO.
vouch affiliate.
its recently
These solutcly explicir in whar was cot required
from congress. Here are some remarks from the SAYCO representative.
*This dehare revolves around the question
IDE and
the sAV
organised speeches were ah-
whether or not the workers in COSATU must adope the political direction set our in the Freedom Charter or follow what is called the
While we find
Bur still people discuss whether or not to adopt it.
"2) The idea of the workers" charter has güt no origin in any known democratic stric- ture. All indications show that it is the result of i very secret caucus not accountable to any democratic structure both underground and above board.
WOrKINK this debate mpora
this debate important we also find it very
queer for the following reasons.
working class -*
cxist. Ir is still a myth as to what it contains.
I he socaker troin
USATy were laid nown tion that mer with the ANC last year, which through the CONALU general secretary com-
rade Jay Naiduo acknowledged the leader-
ship of the ANC in the present phase of our revulutionary development."
About hall of the SAYCO speakers's speech
The guidelines lor the political direction of cosATU were laid down firmly by the delega-
ship
.. Naser
was made up of praise for the South African
Par- breaking at times intu astonishing named attacks on some of its relatively obscure enemies on the lelt.
Communis Party.
8550 relauvel
movement tu discuss and prepare a workers
charter around which the workers goals in
NUMSA tried to uncover the need fur the
CERIS HE
the revolution could be focussed and which
would safeguard the workers movement from other social forces on the programmatic
and ideolugical level. Ir is perhaps not sur-
prising that given the barrage of opposition
and the
saicated. the sec MATU could not tu
negroest
tun in the congress The first consequence of the atmosphere
produced by these developments was ob-
*he congress mer For son adoption of the Freedom Charter gave an
idcological cdge to the basis for the trade union movement's alliances." •Thus linkages created do not take the lorm of the relationship between Unity Movement and COSATU or NIM for thar marrer, but they are linkages berwoon basic organs of mass activism which are indispensible for
our struggle as we move to an alternative socicty. Members of the Unity Movement or
AZARO or any other obscure organisation are
not hanned from participating in the strug
gles of our peuple." Earlier
the same Mataur Cyril anhosa. the head of the NUM wate
car a political level the Freedom Charter has
been adopted as a guiding document and if there is an organisation which is violendy
•here
bench
•he prinespice of the
members wond find
ward har as a prognessive union with
ficult to
that.
which they ront
alliance."
Some are tempred by these facts to claim that
organisation within the democratic struggle in South Africa at the present time. (This was the final clause of the resturion which
There are many reasons why the pressure of the SACP and the chartists should be pat-
downrum and the concomitant collapse of the "victory in the short term perspective has allowed conditions for the SAP to define
the debate in its own more traditional terms.
speaking
adopted the Freedom Charter.) ticularly felt ar this rime. BOTH ENGLISI
The general
afrikaaner sectors have fractured away from the National Party consensus and defend a negotiated settlement. Under Slabert, the afrikaaners met the ANd in Dacca in Tuly. (Such mectings are invitable in a prolonged struggle of the sort that the ANC is involved with and there was nothing published about
and. and Ccl
now.
nged ived
'The workers of South Africa do not need but du (already) have a political party of their own and that consistently and correctly sands for the national democratic rights and socialist rights of our people No prizes for guessing which!
of the SACP and its supporters. Ar this stage "uch a cuum would be ralse The actua mechanics of the decision making reveal no cour calthough the charusts were ob viously very well prepared and organised) There were no vasr layers of support for the SACP as such. Rather, a strong link was con- structed between the chartists and largest delegation at the congress, the NUM The aim of this alliance was -st the unrcalisable take-over of COSATU but rather the isolation of the "workers charter poss tion. This they effecrively achieved. NUMSA will now have to struggie hard for legitimacy in the wider movement for their position
Further evidence that the SACP did not ger everything its own way is not hard to find Most explicit is the rejection of the upen ap- peal made by a guest speaker for COSATU tu take its righrful place' in the UH.
has bee
›me dominared
"he line
a21
SACEU sent a telemessage to the congress,
congramularing COSATU on its role but mak-
ing it very plain that it would be a great error
rUle ...mak- re a vreat eiror
to adopt any sort of socialist programme There could be no doubt about the message.
Dr its source.
The 'problem" that had given immediate
that nad r strictures
the Bacca moting which would indicate that the AN hudged from its position for the remnlutinnary natunalist overthrow of the apartheid regime rather than a negonated
100 2
African Communist Party and its various allies was the resolution adopted at the foun- ding conference of NUMS on 23 May, Like the NUM, ir had suhmitted its resolution to the COSATU congress. This resohution/? also
adoption of the Frecdom called for the Charter: "the Freedom Charter is also a good foundation stone on which to start building
our working class programme. The dif
ference in approach to the NUM's resolution was in one important respect: the organised working class can only take the lead in the struggle if it has a clear pro
apartem sctricment. )
202)
Ma. ike
Inevitably, however. in the context of the downtum, chis meeting was invested with strategic significance, and not just by the
South African leaders tu delatch any socialist objectives Irom democratic unes and that such an approach opened the door to an
We urge that the workers as a sector should build together with other sectors such as youth, women, residents, etc.,
a strong
Democrate From which
wundine n
alliance with sectors of the white ruling class
in Sourh Africa. In this light it appeared
prevent tie Alrican trade union movement, now occupy
mist doubly impurtant to become the first phase of building national unity against apartheid and imperialism.
the
which class is to rule?
gramme and aims which clarify exactly what is wanted by the working class and what 1s
NUMSA decided that all union structures should discuss the proposed content of this workers political programme. Not content
meant by their demands.
SUNSA dec
should Miscis
worx-ce poli 10 with zeneral
guest should he ar • COSATD which must ensure that workers take their rightful leading position of the national poutics. rsic.
COSATU oviously felt it had already taken its
rightful position. "COSATU must remain in- about socialism, dependent and nue adfiliate on
South
cupy
ing centre stage in the liberation struggle: embracing openly a mansitional type pro-
including both democratic
and
socialist demands and raising the question:
Less important in the SACP offensive arc the various attempts (none of which has significant support) to establish a workers
SOCIALIST OUTLOOK so 3 Septombai/Ocrober 1987