Socialist Outlook

Socialist Viewpoint, International, Socialist Outlook and their supplements, 1984–2009

Negative review

· Socialist Outlook no. 3, September–October 1987 · pp 36-38 · 1,480 words

Reviews

Latin America

review forced upon us has been negative. The EWAC leaders have busied themseives

and dealing with anyone prepared to talk to them. National and

labelled "dysfunctional" regional women's committees havr had

thwarted. We need

(LWAC) wheeling

their activity Labour Party con-

women's organisation that is powerful and representative. We will only achieve this through struggle and action. not

through constitutional games and deals with tic umon leaderships

knowleder; and nace tie case reaches court. the hurden isplaced on the child to prove that

Fola i native. to rcmoving the child from bom

Licy are itmocent of lying.

The practice of lamily therapy as an alter-

forces children into contart with their abuser. and therefore places them in danger of re-

sextel

peated abuse and punishment for their dis cinsure. Family therapy silences the child, because a lot of what the child wants lo say i about the rest of the family. It is univa feasible oprion to use family therapy if you believe leat the ahnsive family is a dysfunc: tional family which must he rebuilt

Although being taken into care removes the child tmom the power of the abuser, it replaces one poition of powerlessness by another: Thie administration of the homes is all powerful in deciding who the children can scc. where they can go. and how much money they can have, for example: Living in a crowded dormitory continues the lack of privacy which is experienced by victims of sexual abuse. The farr that the whole system is under-resourced compounds these biems. The common leature of all these things is that the child has no control over what happens Another exmple if this is Esther Ranizens Childline which reports cases to the social sences or the NSPCC without the child regursting that they do so.

The Increasing awareness of the scale of the probica. and the growing realisation of the terrible effect it has had on the lives of millions of prople, mean that socialists must do more than point our the shortcomings of the lamily. The fundamental demand that socialisis must make is for the right of chil dren to make choices at every stage.

abuse

what policy

for

ciali:

pru-

The choice of whether to go into care amust be made a mral and cmpowering option This means more remares must be pur into thr care isslem, to take it habitable for abused children. Any decision to prosecute must he

Dr Marietta Higgs on her way in to Middlesborough town hall In recent months there has been a storm of publicity surrounding

the response of doctors and social workers to the sexual abuse of

ing Lal a witch hunt against social workers who, despite all the limitations of

MP Smart Bell nas war

made by the cluki, and the procedure mus he made as painicss as possible, with the child being in cantrol of the legal docisions made. and with the burden of proof put on the

This would make it casicr to

remote the father-figure from the family, in

•mer-ne and disclose cases of

father-figure-

"nals ha developed dillerent approache DANI AHRENS and JUDITH PATON

order that the child could safeis go home.

These measures are aimod ar mostoring to children the power winch has been demed to

Child sexual abuse has existed as long as

Ir takes place in families of all social classes and in rimes of prosperity as well as depression.

me" that somalists must concentrate on theru.

nemands which enn-

family against the state or vice versa can only hic answered by answering the queszion of how to delend the child in cach case. Whar this really means is empowering children to

Winte wE delend thow, like Dr Maricus

Cleveland social

sexual abuse by adults and the arbitrary diktats of starutory agencies.

services

demands which empower children to defend them both against

demands which empower children to defend them both against The question of whether to defend the casten, It is by au means certain that bring

die family has existed. of statutorv agenı

poverty. taken into care means being removed from danger. One thing that is certain is that the

For the victims of sexual abusc. power is

experience is not an empowcring one.

It is not

the breakdown of tie family", or simply parriarchy wluch causes child sexual ahose, bar the fact that the family is used by the ruling class to fimir people's ability to fight. Empowering children wonld destroy

department. who cmpliasise the need to act quickly when sexual abuse of a chukt hashoen disclosed or discovered. it is important to

point out the many ways in which the car asten and the medical establishment fail SOCIALIST OUTLOOK na3 Saplamber/Odober 1997

distors, hospirals, incial workers.

the care system Because dealing with child sexual abuse is centred on convicting the abuser, examinations intended to provide evi. denice for prusecution, rather than to heal the

smelling which is always denied. by the Lamily. churitable agencies, die police, conni, and

the power strucnire of the nuclear family in capitalist society. Unlike radical feminists.

we believe that a challenge to the family is a challenge to capitalism, not only ta pa- triarchy, because of the dependence of the ruling class ou the nuclear family structure

We incite readers to contribule do this discussion. Please keep articles to 500 acorde and stubmit by 12

child, am carried cna unnecessarily; children are subjeeted to harsh interviews which are taped videu-recorded withir

their Ortcher for psiblication in ant next tosse.

35

Wall Street

Banquet,

1928 Ministry of

Education

ROGER SPENCER DIEGO RIVERA was the best

known of the artists who dominated the mura! movement which flourished in Mexico between the two world

wars.

That mural painting was to

become Mexico's peruliar contribution to the achievements of modern art was the result of the particular cultural, social and political bistory of Mexico. The cataclysmic events of the

Serrar

Mexican revalution hetween 1910 and 1920 were the

impetus tor the mural

mperus -

In many ways the Mexican

Our Bread, 1928, Ministry of Education

Cubism with an understanding of Mexican history, recent, colonial and pre Colombian together with the indigenous and popular

art lorms.

In the murals he painted Rivera conseruered powerfl and portic narratives at the everyday life of the mass of workers and peasants, their experiences of the revolution and his aspirations for a socialist future and, latterly. vivid panoramas of national

history

commissions in the United States, most famously on one trom Jobin D Rockeleller

In the thirries he worked on

ECVULLLIUL SAX BEEH two revolutions - one

cress one run the an hand ir res

averthrow or the ran oligarcar of lan. by Porlirio Chaz and its

115...

replacement by a modernizing

capitaust state ar class.

On the other hand, this

transition of poilt..il

on whar in one sents one wine of the Fi..... another. not ach. an esther Cat An

countries, without the eruption onto the political stage of the armed and

organisedl su of the Mexican population. predominantly the peasantry. in pursuit of its own

independent aspirations.

In the aftermath of the 36 revnturon the murm

Mexican murals

rement ol Kivera.

Orozco and othere The mural

provided the radical and revolutionary artists of the

en lhe UppurtuIv Ec mo cos of public art h anuent to articulate the

hencex and aspirations

wing the

sun larucl

revolution to a still largely

illiterate public. For the new

stare it gave the chance to show that its radicalism was still alive, if not in its policies

Is pollar

sponsored.

River

at least in the art that it

Rivera was the artistic and

political leading light of this

movement. in 1922 he was a

founding member of the Mexican Communist Parry

and in 1923 together with others formert an artist

1023 rogethe

union, whose manifesto proclaimed Art must no longer be the expression of individual sarisfaction. but

should has re

educatve art sos

In sacs. in the

al outtaul

an Conn contained a majority of

painters!

In a series of commissions from various institutions of the state throughout the

twenties and thirties, Rivera developed his mastery of

mural composition combining the lessons of his years of study of European painting.

from Renas

Man at the crossroads which

was destroyed when

Rockefeller discovered that it contamed a huge portrait of Lenin.

Rivera was expelled from

Me~

sky are sians

Trotsky was allowed to seck

refuge in Mexico in 1937.

ten Sunct owed to seex

Jiving for the first two yoars in Rivera's Blue House'. years later he broke from Trotsky,

FATS IR Two

Always a politically restless

and undisciplined militant, Rivera finally ended up back

in the Cl with his erstwhile

colleague and Trotsky's would-be assassin, Siqueiros.

prodigous. The commissions

he reccived comprised not just

onc or two murals, but often hundreds of paintings in a

Rivera's artistic work was

The commissions

Secretar/Odober 1987

← Child sexual abuse · Rivera's murals →

Something wrong on this page?