The place of Marxism in
history must be understood at
two leveis: as the conscius
MICHAEL LOWY Ernest Mandel, The place of Marxism in history. for Study and Research, Namber 1. 1986.
LOWY
Notebooks
THIS NEW SERIES Of brochures published by the Amsterdam based International Instinte for Rescarch and Education is inaugurated by a remarkable
test from Ernest Mandel!
Rejecting thc abstract. academic and positivistic view of Marxism as a "pure science"
from E
unconnected to the social
movement, he sets our to
apply the materialist
interpretation of history to Marxism itself: in other words. to sinate it in its general
Justorical context and dialectical relation
at once
integration, critique and supercession - with the social sciences of his time, with
utopian sncialism and with the workers movencht
In 30 clear, precise and
coherent pages. Mandel
world
Le 40 HIS to
neatiei sunal itir
nd E
Igeis,
expression of the real
movement for seif emancipation of workers in the capitalist system. Marxism is a modern phenomenon; but it is also the heir and executor of
thousals of years of emancipatory efforts by toting
humanity, the continuation of an old tradition of dreams and fights by pour people, the exploited and the oppressed
One of the main contributions of this brochure
is its critique of the linear. economistic and mechanistic IDICEDEr to which it counterposes a
the o
truly dialectical conceprion of the contradictions of historical progress. Along with the spread of the capitalise mocke
of production — particularly in colonised countries
- came
embodied in bourgeois society. "The violent, disruptive. destructive and inhuman
impact of capiralism un pre
capitalist societies in the Americas, Asia and Africa was
the ambiguities of the social and economic progress
-Time
tha
ATTLETTE
far worse than its impact on western, southern, central and castern Europe. Marx and
Heath, learn of the tragedies that befell most of Marx and Jenny Von Westphalen's
the famous desk in the British
museum and the cemetary in
Highgate. Don't expect any
great political insights into his work or an in depth analysis of
Victorian Londonl After all,
1815 Rrisi
gar
-man Londo
this is a reprint of a BBC pamphlet thar was released tu mark the screening uf a short programme about Marx,
broadcast in 1982. As
Thatcher and Tebbit push ahead to eliminate socialism from our television screens and
Journeyman's credir that they are keeping this title book
Engels were 100 rignrous
• A 3 KK.
w wat feletsed
ming uf .in
Di -masa Thatch-r - bookshelves, it is to alive. Nice onc!
scientists and too pastonate humanists not to notice this, to be indignant about it and to revolt against these ahominable crimcs.!
It was preciscly a lincar riew of progress which was the main weakness of second interational Marxism. The supercession of capitalism by socialist was more or less inevitable, as a result of economic evalution, and these Marsise paid unly scant amention to the decisive importance of political initiative. Ofien this implied downplaying and even
disparaging of direct action by the masses, a theme which remamed confined to anarcho- syndicalist circles until 1905
(when the international current represented by Luxemhung, Lenin and Trotsky emerged).
This concise work of Mandel is not only an exceptionally valuable educational tool — as an initiation to Marxism from a committed and activist standpoint - hur alsu an original contribution that
enriches and renews the debate
on the place of Marxism in
2123 history
SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 3 Sepsember/October 1987
REVIEWS
Cleaner fish
DIANA PATON
book is whether women can succord in a man's world; and
if they can, at what cost?
Zoe
Fairbar: 45.
None of them trus
CLOSING follows four women from varying hackgrounds traditional working class, traditional hourgcois, one self- made career woman and a feminist, over several months.
While at the start of the novel they seem rather hand-picked (even including a Thatcher character, complete with shop-
keeping parents), by the end of the book Fairbairns has
created four real people, all of whom we are interested in and
care about
These women
women's saics trainins (START, selling... women!) all
alming at mater varous types * reasons. The question Fairbarns noses With.
success she wants. The feminist magazine: Teresa Beale 1e struggling to save from bankruptcy is taken over. It is transformed into the magazine for the woman who knows that the battle is over
and she has won'! "New
Atlanta tries to prove its singan by showing a host of
token women who have 'made
it' — within the existing
system Thatch
including, of course, - herself. However, shows the tallacy of thi
idea — even the bourgeois
"feminist/feminine" woman at whom the magazine is aimed faces great hostility at work She cannot proceed further than a certain point on the carcer ladder.
Fairbairns argues that women can anly succeed by becoming "cleaner-fish" The metaphor refers to a mythical
SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 3
280L DONOM
breed of fish which are allowed safely in and out of sharks" mouths, to clean the sharks" teeth. If women do not act like this towards men, but try and compete on equal tertus, they are crushed — as happens to Daphne Barrlay. A woman who 'sees only two kinds of peuple: customers and competitors
sten as the same.
where these struggles are likcly to occur. The questions of class action and solidarity are
nor really taken up.
Fairbairns believes that women are at a disadvantage because we live in a man's
world, rather than a male- duminated capitalist world Thus all women's interests are
The idea that femumist projects would br more successful if they learnt.
presented as acceptable, as
Zue Fairbairns' books have
39
Fairhairs' analysis is fine as far as it goes, but ir ignores the differences in the options open to women of dillerent classes. All the women in
bourgons terhniques is long as the techniques are
Closing achieve limited success caught by a woman in business. The problems facing them are very similar
hocome more expensive since
she moved from Virago to the
hostility and parronising
hostilits
attitudes from male colleagues. These problems are faced individually; there is little
recognition of thi
- colles-
mainstream Methun, and
110.95 will be probibitive to many. Still, 1 found Closing an enjoyable and very well
of the courrea
women over issues such as equal pay. That sort of question does not arise. because Fairba
not involve
nx cha
written book. 1 would
recommend it as holiday teading for socialists and Ieminists — such a shame the holidays scom such a dissant nientory now!