FEATURES/ REVIEW
rents, cheap transport and so on. Part and parcel of the working class resis-
tance to austerity must be
the defence of its social
gains, which are based on collectivised property. No wonder some socialists in eastern Europe can't see what the SWP is getting al.
The intemational im- plications of the crisis in the east are not referred to by Harman. But the deepening of the peaceful coexistence course im- plied by perestroika has had deeply reactionary ef- ainst privatisation farte intamationaller
Nationa
must be defended agai
solve the basic problem of the inefficient and wasteful use of resources, which is a product of bureaucratic rule itself. Less investment could, while bureaucratic rule survives, chronically worsen the crisis. The political conclusions of the SWP's theories are dis- astrous. Harman is explicit:
*.. before socialists in the Eastern states can take advantage of the factors in the situa- tion which favour them, they have to be clear about certain important points. First, they have to grasp that the transition from state capitalism to multinational capitalism is neither a step backwards nor a step forwards but a step sideways... Unfortunately there are still socialists in the Easter states who have not fully grasped this' (1).
Apparently the conclusion from this bizarre approach is that we should support workers struggles in Eastem Europe, but not defend nationalised property against privatisa- tion!
Of course, the restoration of capitalism in the castern states is not yet a certainty. If it happens, it will be the result of defeats im- posed on the working class. The SWP, by in- sisting that it is already in place, logically. fails to grasp that capitalism can only be res- tored through a massive attack on the working class, including removing its social gains, which are based on nationalised property.
A concrete example. The IMF has told Hungary that it will make loans - provided these go to private enterprises and housing rents are charged at 'market prices'. Rents haven't changed in Hungary for forty years. This implies a huge attack on the Hungarian working class. But where exactly did these cheap rents, a basic factor in working class living standards, come from? Wasn't it some- thing to do with the absence of capitalism?
The workers in the GDR, where capitalism is being established, will soon discover what the capitalist order has in store for them - mass unemployment with perhaps a third of the workforce unemployed, the destruction of social services like free childcare, subsidised
intemationally,
strengthening the hand of imperialism. The US invasion of Panama was given the green light by Gorbachev. Only Soviet complicity allowed the US intervention in the Gulf. Since such developments don't fit in with state capitalist theory they are simply ignored.
More generally, Chris Harman attempts to insinuate that those failing to hold the theory of state capitalism, were in some way or other soft on Stalinism. Thus we leam that in 1956 "part of Pablo's supporters supported the sup pression of the Hungarian revolution by Soviet tanks*. Michel Pablo of course in 1956 was a central leader of the Fourth Internation- al; but no part of the Fourth International whatever did anything but support the workers revolution. We lear the intriguing information that Tariq Ali, who is soft on Gorbachev, was most influenced by 'Isaac Deutscher, Leon Trotsky and Ernest Mandel" (in that order). Logic: Deutscher, Mandel. Tarig Ali (and Trotsky!) are all basically the same in being soft on Stalinism. The left can do without this kind of silliness.
For decades many on the left have regarded the debate about the character of the Soviet Union and the other Stalinised states as a kind of esoteric theological exercise played by bizarre revolutionary groups. But the present crisis in the east, and the attempts of imperialism and intemal forces to bring about the restoration of capitalism show it is any- thing but. The restoration of capitalism in the Soviet Union, eastem Europe, China and
Cuba would have immense reactionary im- plications, and set back the struggle for
socialism. A theory which would describe it
as 'moving sideways' is a failure.
(1) The Storm Breaks: /S 46
(2) State Capitalism in Russia Tony Cliff, Bookmarks
(3) Sce E. Mandel: The mystifications of State Capitalism. International No. 2 1970
(4) IS 46: pp
SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 27, October 1990
Nice Idea; shame about the picture
Safe,
smug and depressing Dick Tracy Starring Madonna and Warren Beatty
Reviewed by DAVID GRANT
Is it a bird? Is it a plane? Is it a comic or is it a film? No! Its Warren Beatty in Dick Tracy! From the man who brought you Reds comes another over-long and under-edited Hol- lywood epic.
Dick Tracy, the movie, (as opposed to the T-shirt, poster, etc) takes the world of the comic book hero and animates it with big- name stars, hamming it up for all they're worth. With no real intention of trying to add another dimension to the two that the charac- ters posses on the original printed page, we find Dustin Hoffman, Al Pacino and Madonna tum in adequate, but immediately forgettable performances, in what is actually a rather pre- dictable and boring romp.
True, it looks very impressive, and in fact does look like a comic book. But then with one of the best camera operators in the world, Victorio Storare, guiding things along. you would hardly expect less.
It makes you wonder why he, and all the others for that matter, bothered. Can it really be just for the money? Perhaps the amounts in- volved are sufficient motivation. Quantity has a quality all of its own, as a certain famous film critic, VI Lenin, once remarked.
Or perhaps its that these films always seem to promise so much more, both to the actors and audiences? Certainly the hype attached to each succeeding blockbuster always manages
Page 29