Socialist Outlook

Socialist Viewpoint, International, Socialist Outlook and their supplements, 1984–2009

Letters

Socialist Outlook no. 27, October 1990 · pp 35-36 · 1,314 words

Letters

Labour Party Trade unions War and peace

LETTERS

SOCIALIST

OUTLOOK

Ultra-left farewell to socialism?

The end of the sovereignty of Labour con- ference, the accountability of MPs and the rank and file individual and affiliated members's direct involvement in policy-making could be the outcome of this year's Labour Party Con- ference.

Jane Wells seems to share this view. In her article in the June issue of Socialist Outlook she stresses the threat the proposals to be put before this year's conference pose, and that thought they are described by the Party's General Secretary as "tinkering amendments", they are far from being so. She makes clear that they represent the first instalment of chan- ges to be completed at the conference follow- ing the next general election.

One might therefore have expected Jane

pat to the Labour voters, the working class and by "campaigning" the masses in general leads through the Labour by persistent Partv. annialise askin i

Harry Sloan Is on hollday: last seen somewhere in the vicinity of Baghdad

sath to the Labour voters, the working class and by "campaignin he masses in general leads through the Labour by persistent Party. socialists within

Yet, like supporters of "Economism" in Rus-

To whom is sia at the tum of the century, our present-day says: proponents of this doctrine shrink from the for-

"It is a serio nidable political task of winning the mass do that... you Labour movement for socialism.

wing policies n

In order to justifv what is effectivel a nolitics now hi

ing outside the Labour Party but 1 and systematic efforts of in it.

To whom is Jane Wells referring when she

BEES

"It is a serious mistake ... to argue (as some ou lay the groundwork for left- not by campaigning for socialist hat hu enfinina norte nanademn

Wells to urge all sections of the left within the withdrawal from politics, they have invented the

to make sure ti Party to unite behind demands which (if car-

"theory" that support of the mass political party are there ready ried at conference) would frustrate the NEC's for socialist policies can somehow be won out- agam".

plans.

side that party, or alternatively, by setting up a

It can only

Yet whilst the Campaign for Labour Party democracy (CLPD) and Labour Left Liaison halfway house on that party's periphery, by CLPD's positic

building, to quote Jane Wells again "on the ex- campaigning fo are mobilising the rank and file in favour of

periences working people face every day", (i.e. paigning for Pa resolutions to this year's conference countering the economic struggles of the working class).

Wells suggests, the NEC proposals (i.e. in the immediate

Organisations with imaginary high political I together and can present) Jane Wells (and presumably Socialist

potential are being set up - outside the real

This year on Outlook) argue that what is needed is an ap- political mass organisation of the working class. demands the rec

proach which "embraces and builds on the ex- Behind an elaborate structure of self-deception. • not exactly a

perience of struggles that working people face pseudo political activities - such as the con- dures.

every day, and brings them into the Party to centration on producing innumerable weeklies, The fact that

join the fight for working class democracy".

fortnightlies, monthlies, quarterlies or the hold /tional issues (as

With this approach. she effectively writes ing of innumerable meetings and conferences

penditure) is at off the struggle for socialism in the admittedly are being passed off as "campaigning, and results for the I

unfavourable circumstances of the political being substituted for involvement in the arena in succeeds in pusi present, and - in the best social-democratic which political class struggle is being forced lined above. Th

tradition - postpones the 'real struggle to out: the Labour Party.

leadership, and : some indefinite future.

Like their Russian predecessors the advo- be immune to rai

The underlying idea of "Economism" is the cates of the current version of "Economism"

It is a pity th prioritisation of the economic struggle of the leave politics to those intent on preserving are being dispe working class as against the political struggle. capitalist society.

time, when In the Labour Party today we have a mass

Jane Wells disregards 70 years of failed at- remains of the d political organisation arising out of its closer tempts to create an effective socialist force out- an absolute prior

ties with mass trade union organisations.

side the Labour Party. Mimiltant workers and

Vladimir Derer

Unlike the left-wing Russian Social

non-Labour socialists will not be convinced of London Democrats, the early British socialists proved the need to join the Labour Party by building

(This letter w incapable of striking deep roots in the mass

castles in the air - such as the "campaigning" of movement. Not surprisingly, the reformist the Socialist Movement - but only when the ideology of the Parliamentary labour Party Labour left is successful. This was demonstrated l

managed to firmly establish itself in the in- during the years of the Bevanite advance and evitably reformist minded trade union move-

more recently when significant gains were ment. achieved both on issues such as nuclear disar-

The Labour Party's close relationship with mament and public ownership, and during the

the trade union movement nevertheless means struggles for mandatory reselection and wider that Labour is the mass party of the British franchise for the lection of the Leader and

working class. For socialists, therefore, the Deputy Leader. These victories were not won

my song posey parces the structures for accountability y for when the Left is on the up

It can only be CLPD. Yet this is not ion. CLPD does not separate for socialist policies from cam- ty democracy in the way Jane s, for in its view the two go innot be separated.

This year one of CLPD's model resolutions eduction of defence expenditure a demand to refine party proco-

at CLPD is pronitising constitu- s well as the cuts in defence ex- above all because of the dire Party if the present leadership ishing through the changes out- hese changes would allow the la future labour govemment, to ank and file pressure.

It is a pity that the Left's limited resources ersed in all directions at this epelling the attack on what democratic gains of 1979-81 is ority.

Derer

was cut from 2,300 words: Ed.)

We welcome letters on

any subject: but please

keep them brief! Letters over 400 words will be cut. Send to Socialist Outlook, PO Box 1109, London N4

SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 27, October 1990

Page 33

Campaign Against

War in the Gulf

Campaign Against War in the Gulf is open to affiliation from all organisations and holds regular open meetings. The basis of the Campaign is No War in the Gulf! and US & British Troops Out of the Gulf!.

Affiliation form

Organisation

Address.

Contact Name/ Phone number.

(E50 National Organisations; local groups negotiable)

Affiliation fee enclosed

Our organisation would like to affiliate to/ would like more information about CAWG.

(Please delete as appropriate)

Return to: CAWG, 7e Cumberland Park, London W3 6SY

Sponsors: Bernie Grant MP; Alice Mahon MP; Eric Heffer MP; Tony Benn MP; Jeremy Corbyn MP: Women for Socialism; Campaign for Non-Alignment; Socialist Worker's Party: Socialist Society; London NUS; Labour Party Socialists; Labour Briefing; Socialist Organiser; Socialist Outlook; Jim Brann, Secretary, London Region CND; Isabelle McMillan, Chair, London Region CND; Jim Addington, CND National Council; Walter Wolfgang,

Chair Labour CND; Nicholas Russell, Secretary, London Labour CND; Narendra Makanji, International Officer, LP Black Sections; Emma Colyer, National Secretary NUS.

All individuals in a personal capacity

READ SOCIALIST OUTLOOK EVERY MONTH. 1 years subscription (ten issues) for £10 inland, € 12.50 Europe, £17.50 outside Europe (sur- face), €20 outside Europe (airmail) Multi-reader institutions £20 inland, €35 overseas. Name...

Address..

Subscription to start from Number......

Return to Socialist Outlook, PO Box 1109, London N4 2UU

← An outstanding intellectual for the Fourth International · Hands up for PR →

Something wrong on this page?