Socialist Outlook

Socialist Viewpoint, International, Socialist Outlook and their supplements, 1984–2009

Labour's witch-hunt escalates

· Socialist Outlook no. 27, October 1990 · pp 7-8 · 2,156 words

Labour Party Britain

FEATURES

WHY PAY TO

WHY PAY TO

SUBSIDISE

THE RICH?

ME PAY?

NO WAY!

John Harris (NUJ)

Labour's witch-hunt is attacking poll tax activists tions of the left (such as the leadership of the Campaign for Labour Party Democracy) to recognise that registration was being intro- duced as a device to attack Militant, and that therefore a united rejection was required by the left. The fact that CLPD decided to apply for registration left Militant exposed.

Militant supporters later chose to appeal to the courts (as their only course of action) to prevent them being expelled. This was futile in its results, and politically wrong (how can an organisation seriously oppose the interference of the courts into the affairs of the unions but encourage the same inter- ference into the Labour Party?). They dropped any attempt to campaign against the witch-hunt, which left those still willing to fight it doing so on their behalf, without their backing.

At the same time a response developed among sections of the left of distancing itself from defence of Militant by means of spurious political arguments, while defending other victims of the witch-hunt. it was claimed that Militant weren't really part of the Left because of their attitude to Black Sections, women's sections and their policy on Ireland, as if these weaknesses were the reason the bureaucracy was attacking them.

Thus much of the left moved away from a principled position of solidarity against attack by the bureaucracy to a selective approach of only defending those with whom they had more common ground - with the result that

by Pete Firmin (vice-chair, End the Ban)

Recent months have seen a new surge of attacks on the left in the Labour Party. The proscription of the All-Britain Anti- Poll Tax Federation, expulsion of coun cillors from Labour Groups for their refusal to support the Poll Tax and rent rises, further expulsions of Militant sup- porters, tacit support for the attacks on Arthur Scargill led by the Daily Mirror, and the proscription of Socialist Or- ganiser are the best-known examples.

There is a common strand to all aspects of the witch-hunt going beyond the arbitrariness of singling out particular "tendencies" (Socialist Organiser, Militant) and not others or the vindictiveness of local right-wingers, who feel they have been given the green light by the activities of the national bureaucracy.

In addition to wanting to prove to the ruling class and its mouthpiece, the media, that the Labour Party's policies are an asset, not a threat, Kinnock wants to show that he can deal with any opposition to those policies. Thus, we have action against those who stand in the way of promoting Labour's "responsible' image (in particular those prepared to fight the Poll Tax rather than simply say how nasty it is) and attempts to eliminate potential opponents of a Labour government's austerity programme.

In his speech to this year's TUC, Kin- nock made clear that a government led by him will not be one from which the working class can expect favours" (they will be reserved for the ruling class).

Far from favours, he knows (and the vote at the TUC to drop calls for the repeal of the anti-union laws is further evidence) that there will be conflict with the working class. Retaining the Tories' anti-union laws and abolishing the block vote at Labour Party conference are intended both to help a Labour government defeat the unions when such conflict comes, and to prevent any revolt reaching into the Labour Party itself.

Robert Maxwell doesn't need any direct encouragement from Kinnock to conduct his campaign against Scargill (in which the "charges" have changed several times as each has been disproved). Both Maxwell and Kin-

nock want to erase the memory of the miners' strike as one of the greatest anti-Tory battles: but they also want to see Scar- gill removed as a possible focus for the left of the trade union movement against a Labour government. Organisations on the left of the party are also seen as a possible future focus for that opposition, just as they were during the Wilson and Callaghan govemments of 1974-79 and afterwards.

This renewed escalation of the witch-hunt coincides with the run-up to the next general clection, with Kinnock trying to make the final adjustments to both policy and organisation. It runs alongside the proposals to do away with the automatic right to reselection of MPs, the introduction of one member, one vote (ie. the abolition of delegate democracy), and possibly postal ballots for virtually all decisions, as well as proposals to reduce the influence of Party conference on policy.

Only for a short period in Labour's his- tory, from the mid-70s to 1982, did a rela- tively relaxed internal regime exist without the threat of proscriptions and expulsions. This all changed with the expulsion of the editorial board of Militant in 1982. Since then there has been a steady stream of expul- sions, suspension of District and Constituen- cy Labour Parties etc, together with the destruction of the Young Socialists, the at- tacks on women's organisation and the refusal to recognise any kind of black self-or- ganisation. Throughout this period the left has been unable to provide a common defence against such attacks for several reasons.

The response to the first witch-hunt (of the Militant Editorial Board) was strong, but weakened in two crucial respects. Most im- portant was the unwillingness of Militant to build a common campaign with all of the left against the witch-hunt. Instead it chose to conduct its own campaign, solely as a Militant promotion exercise, with the result that it alienated many of those initially will- ing to defend it.

Another problem was the refusal of sec-

SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 27, October 1990

Page 5

FEATURES

the defence against any witch-hunt was A beacon of principled light in this has of the left to fight new realism. And, of

been the attitude of Phil Kelly, the editor of weakened.

course, it is a basic truism that the

The result of this weakness is a much Tribune, who has come out strongly against bureaucracy, once having tasted blood, moves greater confidence of the bureaucracy to go on this witch-hunt. Speaking at the 'End the Ban' on to attack other organisations. the attack, in the knowledge that there will be rally on September Ist, he made it clear that

"End the Ban" has managed to get the sup hardly any resistance. For several years the he sees no contradiction between defence of port of many in the labour movement, MPs, NEC report to Labour conference has con- | Socialist Organiser and opposition to many of trades unionists (including the Bakers' Union tained long lists of those expelled, with little its policies, such as non-payment of the Poll executive) and individuals. Socialist Or- or no opposition expressed. Tax. ganiser has refused, rightly, to take the issue

The proposal to proscribe Socialist Or-

The 'End the Ban' committee was set up to to the courts (although, given the lack of ganiser arose out of the Birkenhead selection organise a broad defence campaign and "natural justice", they would probably have a saga. When Frank Field, a right-wing | publicise the case against the proscription of good case) and is concentrating on a cam- maverick who has been a thorn in the flesh of

paign instead. the Merseyside labour movement for years,

At a meeting on 18th August the Socialist was deselected by Birkenhead CLP he lashed

Organiser Alliance reluctantly decided to dis- out with a scurrilous "dossier" and threatened

band in order to enable its members to retain to stand as an independent against Labour.

Labour Party membership. "End the Ban" is

The protection of sitting MPs being dear to

now focussing on a campaign for emergency the heart of Walworth Road, it took this

resolutions to Labour Party conference calling catalogue of gossip, innuendo and half-truths

for no further disciplinary action in the light seriously. Although not denying that selection

of this decision. had been run completely in accordance with

There is a good chance of getting many the rules, they decided to use the opportunity

such resolutions passed, and although the for a new purge of the Left and re-run the

chances of winning are slim, a sizable vote in selection, giving Field another chance.

support at conference could make the

Amongst other things, Field's "dossier"

bureaucracy think again about carrying this named Militant supporters in Birkenhead and

witch-hunt through. pointed to the influence of Socialist Organiser

Some on the left seem to think that in neighbouring Wallasey. Field had pre-

Socialist Organiser has conceded an issue of

principle by announcing the dissolution of it's viously excelled himself by calling on people not to vote Labour in Wallascy in the 1987

organisation. There is no such principle. What general election because the candidate was the

would be unprincipled, however, is to make

(then) Socialist Organiser supporter Lol Duffy.

The Militant supporters in Birkenhead are in the process of being expelled and Labour's organisation department took the opportunity to produce their own 'report on Socialist Or- ganiser.

Yet Socialisr Organiser itself was never once contacted to discuss this and letters and phone calls were never responded to. When an

'he ideas

innock

ants to

lence

The ideas

Kinnock

wants to

silence

Phil Kelly: speaking at the End the Ban rally

concessions on policy to avoid a witch-hunt.

Thus the argument by Socialist Organiser supporters that any kind of left campaign around the general election is out of the ques tion because of the witch-hunt seems to be an act of self-censorship, offering the bureaucracy precisely what it wants - the silencing of the left. The lack of serious cam- paigning by the left in the Labour Party (and Militant in particular) on the Poll Tax

issue of Socialist Organiser showed this report to be a fabrication, the report was dras- tically changed, and a new one submitted to the NEC

With virtually no discussion, the NEC in July then endorsed the proposal that Socialist Organiser be proscribed as a 'party within a party". The fact that the Walworth Road bureaucrats didn't feel it necessary to go through even a pretence of allowing Socialist Organiser to answer the allegations shows how confident they felt about the left's response.

Particularly sickening throughout the whole episode has been the response of the "soft left". David Blunkett said in advance of the NEC meeting that he would want to hear the evidence before reaching a conclusion; yet he and other members of the soft left on Labour's NEC left before the decision on Socialist Organiser. One of them, Clare Short, has since gone into print in Tribune, defending the proscription. In this, Short is continuing a dishonourable record of the soft left over many years and witch-hunts.

Page 6

Socialist Organiser. Labour Party Socialists, Women for Socialism, Labour Briefing and Socialist Outlook have supported it from the beginning. The attitude of others has been less encouraging.

Campaign for Labour Party Democracy (CLPD) essentially made conditions for its participation - the dissolution of the Socialist Organiser Alliance, the admitted organisation of SO supporters, and a policy of not talking to the bourgeois media. Most other organisa- tions of the left have yet to be seen to show any support.

Militant and Socialist Worker, for instance, have devoted many columns to the witch-hunt of councillors in Liverpool for opposing rent rises, but have not even mentioned the witch- hunt against SO.

Motivated by sectarianism - political dis- agreement with Socialist Organiser and a reluctance to admit the existence of any/other organisations on the left in the Labour Party. this attitude weakens all of the left. Any suc- cessful witch-hunt is a defeat for democracy in the labour movement, strengthening the hold of the bureaucracy and weakening the ability

weakens our ability to resist the proscription of the All Britain anti-Poll Tax Federation.

A further worrying aspect of Socialist Organiser's defence is the way in which it has denied that the organisation was a 'Leninist sect", as claimed by Walworth Road. It has at- tempted to show how different it is to Militant in this respect, as if the bureaucracy were in- terested in the differences in democratic functioning of left groups. As if the bureaucracy had some basic understanding of or affection for democracy anyway! The ef- fect of it appears to be saying "it was all right to witch-hunt Militant, they are a sect, but we aren't".

Fighting all aspects of the witch-hunt is an act of basic solidarity. Disagreements over policy should be taken up within this context. The immediate task is to maximise support against the witch-hunt of SO for Labour Party conference. Hopefully the left can go on from that to fight all witch-hunts, without selection.

'End the Ban' can be contacted do 12a Canonbury St, London NI 2TD.

SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 27, October 1990

← South Africa – the roots of violence · Off to market with the Tories: Labour goes shopping for solutions →

Something wrong on this page?