By Kathy Kirkham
The recent battle between a weal- thy theatre producer and the US actors" union, American Equity, over the staging on Broadway of the West End musical Miss Saigon", is still reverberating round the theatre establishment on both sides of the Atlantic.
For raising the issue of racism in the theatre, Equity was lam- basted by the media, by theatre critics and by many of its own members for interfering with ar- tistic freedom.
In London's West End, British actor Jonathan Pryce had been playing the lead character in "Miss Saigon", a Euro-Asian pimp, wearing prosthetics to give his eyes a slanted look. A reciprocal agreement between British and American Equity would have allowed him, as the star and a British Equity mem- ber, to transfer to the US produc- tion when it opened in New York next April.
However, the leaders of American Equity, apparently under pressure from the union's Race Equality Committee, told the show's producer Cameron Macintosh that Pryce's portrayal would offend the black com- munity in the States. They ob jected to Pryce transferring to the US production and asked Macin- tosh to seek an American-Asian performer for the role.
The fact that "Miss Saigon' I had already taken some $15 mil lion in advance bookings on Broadway gave the union some extra leverage. But multi-mil- lionaire Macintosh said he could afford to take the musical else- where. His threat to pull out put the much-needed jobs for 34 ac- tors and large stage crew in the balance.
A truce looked possible at one point. After 600 members petitioned their union to come to an agreement, Equity announced it would welcome Jonathan Pryce - minus the prosthetics. In
retum, it sought under- takings from Cameron Macintosh that he would look for qualified Asian actors as re- placements or understudies on Broadway, prioritise Asian actors for the lead role in future produc- tions and assist with the vocal training of those Asian actors who might be considered for such roles.
Macintosh, however, main- tained that Equity had still not ac- cepted his artistic freedom as the producer and cancelled the Broadway production altogether.
While the theatre estab- lishment and the right wing in- side both British and American Equity sigh that the union shot itself in the foot", the real issue - the dire situation of black per- formers - has been conveniently pushed to the background.
For every Eddie Murphy or Whoopie Goldberg there are thousands more black performers in the US and Britain who, as one union official put it, "celebrate if they even get an audition". American Equity's records indicate, for instance, that from April 1989 to May 1990, 33 out of a total of nearly 100 shows covered by union agreement - representing 504 roles - included no black actors at all. An additional 12 produc- tions included only a couple.
Black actors have the worst of all worlds. Casting directors still give the majority of non colour-specific parts to white performers. Even when the plots of plays or films call for charac- ters of a specific racial origin, the plum roles still go to white "stars'.
During the "Miss Saigon" af- fair American Equity was ac- cused of advocating that casting be drawn strictly along racial or ethnic lines. How could anyone suggest that Laurence Oliver should not have played Othello
or Ben Kingsley, Ghandi, shock- ed theatre critics asked.
Equity calls this a total distor- tion of the issue: Jews (for ex- ample) have always been able to play Italians, Italians have al- ways been able to play Jews, and both have always been able to play Asians. Asian actors, however, almost never have the opportunity to play either Jews or Italians and continue to strug gle even to play themselves.
The union also points out that the practice of white actors using make-up to darken their skins to play people of colour is likely to remain a highly sensitive issue as long as others are barred from roles solely because of the colour of their skin.
The question remains of how actors" unions can begin to ad- dress such widespread dis- crimination against their black members, especially in the now highly commercialised theatre world and in the film industry. The kind of positive demands which Equity belatedly began to make of Cameron Macintosh were a move in this direction i.e. towards "integrated casting'.
But unions have to formulate a concrete programme of action with their own black members and campaign for these throughout their organisations. Otherwise if they are resisted by producers, the unions will not have the support of their own members to back up these demands, as Equity found to its cost.
Only in the context of a programme of measures to win training, job opportunities and visibility for a growing number of black performers at all levels will it be possible to begin to break down the white star syndrome.
Page 30
SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 27, October 1990
REVIEWS
DRES
A Mars a
day..
will enable Quaid to play out a fantasy as an undercover agent on Mars with the aid of a 'sleazy, athletic, but demure brunette, chosen out of a mix and match catalogue.
Of course the whole thing goes terribly wrong (thus prov- ing that private medicine is not so great after all) and Quaid finds himself up against a ruthless bunch of killers - minus his memory. The story then follows his search for his missing mind.
The opening sequences of the film are promising, and when Quaid attempts to pass through Mars immigration dressed as a woman in a brilliant and grotesque scene, expectations are high. However the art director failed to exploit the visual poten- tial of a future world that is both familiar and 'sci-fi' strange. One can't help but compare this with the totally believable world depicted in Ridley Scott's Bladerunner, where a similar post-holocaust homegenous society inhabits a decaying. damp and discarded city. Scott's gahstly vision of the future struck a balance between reality and fiction: Total Recall on the other hand presents a world look- ing exactly like Mexico City.
Once the action shifts fo Mars, any hope of an imaginative movie totally disintegrates. It is reminiscent of 1950s science fic- tion without any of the laughs; lots of rock, red dust, domes and caves.
Mars is controlled by a crazed capitalist who is exploiting the workforce, many of whom have developed mutations due to the poor living conditions on the Red Planet. Quaid becomes involved with a revolutionary group, and with the aid of a dusky maiden (literally the woman of his dreams) battles with the oppres- sors.
It is here that plot-wise things become difficult to follow. Quaid knows that he has been someone else because a video recording of his mirror image tells him "You're not you. You're me". The crazed capitalist is constant- ly telling him that he is a smooth and be-suited ally. The revolutionaries hail him as a
Total Recall Starring Arnold Schwarzenegger
Reviewed by BEV BYRNE
NO GAUDY graphics, no spec- tacular stills, just the name of the movie and the name of the star, Amold Schwarzenegger: that is enough to guarantee another Hol- lywood blockbuster.
Schwarzenegger is of course big movie business, and it is he and his big biceps which put "bums on seats". The Schwar- zenegger fans are there to sec him do what he does best - kill. It doesn't really matter whether Schwarzenegger is a good guy or the bad guy, his audience just want to see him bulging, blazing and burning to the bitter end.
Total Recall is no exception. It does, however differ from pre- vious Schwarzenegger films: here Schwarzenegger talks! Previous Schwarzenegger scripts have tended to limit his verbal output: but here he is quipping and questioning like a couple of James Bonds who have been spliced together and made to wear futuristic casual gear.
To be fair, he's quite a jolly sort of chap. And it is quite nice to see him in the opening shots at home with his loving and las- civious young wife as she com- forts him after a nasty nightmare in which his face explodes on Mars.
The world in which Douglas Quaid (Schwarzenegger) lives, loves and works is reminiscent of our own dear planet, but with whizzier streamlined cars, lots of Corbusian concrete, and heavy security. It is the year 2084, and work appears to be the only thing which has not been transformed by technology.
Quaid, afraid to be late, rushes to his job as a construc- tion worker, complete with heavy duty Kango. His dreams about Mars haunt him, and he decides to go to a firm called Rekall Inc, who will, for a few hundred credits, implant a memory of a holiday in your head (cheaper than taking the shuttle greyhound to Saturn or Venus). This memory implant
Schwarzenegger's audiences are now much easier to find
mountainous Che Guevara. Will the real Quaid please stand up?
This is further complicated by the implication that all the action on Mars is merely a figment of Quaid's memory implant, and that therefore none of it exists. The audience is constantly in- vited to doubt which is reality. Quaid is the good guy and the bad guy; his earthly wife is a faithless fraud; the revolutionary leader Kuato tums out to be two people literally rolled into one. But does any of it matter, since the events may not be happening anyway?
This is the most fascinating element proposed in the film: but one scene undermines the ten- sion between dream, reality and duplicity. It becomes clear Quaid is living a reality - and from that point on the audience knows that Mars exists and Quaid/Schwar- zenegger can get on with saving the planet.
One might think that all the tampering with reality would drag Total Recall out of the genre of run-of-the-mill sci-fi with expensive special effects. The author of the original story, Philip K. Dick, loves to play around with cosmic quantum questions. But instead of using the world of film artifice to describe phenomena which are normally inaccessible, the direc- tor has chosen to make Rambo goes to Mars'.
Schwarzenegger lumbers round the unimaginative Martian film set, stirring up insurrection, panic, passion and lots of red dust and polystyrene. Each new scene contains a twist and a tum. But everyone knows that in the end Quaid will discover that he is a nice guy after all and will save the world - or at least Mars.
The expensive special effects only serve to beef up some very dull and repetitive battle scenes, and there are so many of them that you forget to put your fingers over your eyes in the end.
There is of course a grand *finale where everything ex- plodes, including a few more heads. As the extras stand around gazing at the new blue sky which Quaid has somehow manufactured out of thin air, one can't help but think that Mars is a pretty dull place, even with oxygen.
Why is it that Hollywood takes all the potential wonder and fascination out of the future? The chaps who made this movie chose to ignore all the interesting bits and just make a "blow 'em away movie.
However, to judge from the whooping and clapping which went on in the cinema every time Schwarzenegger blasted someon's face, perhaps Hol- lywood possesses more insight into our present society than it does of our future.