politics should reflect this reality"
Thus, the PDs have called for the repeal of Articles 2 and 3 of the Irish Constitution, which express the aspiration for and commit- ment to a united Ireland. They have also ex- pressed dismay at Supreme Court decisions on extradition made in recent months. Dermot Finucane and James Clarke, escapees from the Maze prison, won their appeals against ex- tradition to Northern Ireland. The judges decided they should not be returned to the Maze because they were probable targets for ill treatment by prison staff at that jail, if returned. A few weeks later, Owen Carron. former MP for Fermanagh/South Tyrone, also won his appeal against extradition.
The PDs' response to these events has been to call for a review of the Extradition Act, to i make it easier for extradition to occur. Not only is this diametrically opposed to the view of the Fianna Fail rank and file, it runs counter
to the very deep feeling held by the majority
of Irish people that they can not achieve jus- tice in a British court and at the hands of the British law and order establishment. The
release of the Guildford Fourand the Winchester Three have not allayed such fears. On the contrary, they provide tangible proof of the basis of such gut feelings, born of the historical experience of imperialist oppres- sion.
Fianna Fail and the crisis of
the state.
The problems within Fianna Fail are con- siderably deeper than disagreements between co-habiting partners.
The party's whole history has been tied up with the legitimation, construction and con- solidation of the institutions of the 26 County state. In the aftermath of the Treaty and the formation of the Southern Irish State, the pro- treaty government of Cumann na nGael was viewed with deep suspicion and mistrust by large sections of the population. This was not just the consequence of the repression un- leashed on republican sympathisers, but be- cause it relied for support almost exclusively on the most reactionary elements in the state - the cattle ranchers and big business. Dissent against the government was linked with demoralisation with the free state it spawned.
The decision of de Valera and Fianna Fail
Page 27
FEATURES
forced to form a coalition with the
Progressive Democrats. Thus,
having gone through a vitupera-
tive divorce, the erstwhile
partners co-habited again for the
"sake of the nation".
Significantly however, the
election marked a certain haemor-
rhage of working class support
from Fianna Fail, particularly in
Dublin. At the same time the out-
come created enormous confusion
and disillusionment within the
ranks of the party. The new
government has pursued its
policies of retrenchment with a
commitment to major
programme of privatisation of
state and semi-state companies.
Any apparent improvement in the
jobless figures is primarily as a
result of emigration.
The Labour Party and
the Workers Party.
The 1989 election saw a big
surge in support for both the
Labour Party and the Workers
Party. Labour won 9.5 per cent of
the vote and increased its repre-
sentation from 11 to 15 seats. The Workers
Party got 5 percent of the vote and saw its
number of TDs (Members of Parliament) rise
from 4 to 7. Together with a number of inde-
pendent socialists, the 24 seats gained by the
"left" in that election signified a historic high for left representation in terms of seats, al-
though in terms of first preferences Labour
and the Workers Party between them did less
well that Labour alone during its peak in the
1960s.
Labour's support has been steadily eroding over the last two decades. Particpation in dif ferent coalition govemments has chipped away at its base. The 1982-7 coalition with Fianna Gael saw its ministers preside over the most stringent cuts in public expenditure, lead- ing to a crisis in its relations with key trade unions. Three of its biggest affiliates - the IGTWU, AGTWU and the FWUl (the first and the last have now merged) threatened to break with Labour or cease operating the political fund to any prospective (Labour) candidate who supports coalition with Fianna Gael*. The 1987 election saw its share of the vote plummet to about 6 per cent and 12 seats.
It terms of its political physiognomy, the right wing dominates within the party: the leader - Dick Spring - took a leaf out of Neil Kinnock's book, and succeeded in ousting the Militant Tendency from the youth section and party branches. They, along with the rest of the left, under the leadership of Emmett Stagg (brother of hunger striker Frank Stagg) had grown with the disillusionment with the coali- I tion. Stagg is a leading campaigner in the fight against extradition, although the party as a
THE WOMEN
POLITICAL
INSTARA H BLOCK
IN ARMAGH
FOR
ACTION SADUP
IMPERICLIS
ACTORS HUNCER
STRIKERS
Eamonn O'Dwire/Report
Dublin solidarity with Republican struggle in the North, 1990
to enter the Dail, mobilising a wide base of
support - small farmers, labourers and urban
workers as well as the emerging national bour-
geoisie - was a significant factor in securing
popular support for the 26-county state. It has
successfully maintained this broad level of
support through the industrialisation
programme of the late 1960s and 1970s and
the promotion of welfare. It is only in recent
years that its role as an arbiter between dif-
ferent and competing interests has begun to be eroded.
Fianna Fail has always been identified with a particular brand of nationalism - equating national identity with social and economic conservatism, catholicism and acceptance of partition (save for holiday speechifying). However the fight against British imperialism involved a far richer and more radical com- bination of elements. It included the socialist tradition of Connolly and Larkin formed by the struggles of the emerging working class; those agricultural workers, small farmers and workers who took part in the land siezures and occupations in the tumultous period of 1919- 21; the women organised in Cummann na mBan who strove for independent participa- tion within the nationalist movement.
The defeat of these radical forces by the treaty, and their marginalisation in the sub- sequent history of the state by de Valera's con- servative nationalism, is not irreversible. Whilst it would be premature too much sig nificance to them at this stage, it is noteworthy that the schism within the Fianna Fail consen- sus and the impact of its Thatcherite policies has led to the development of local, com-
I munity-based movements around the health cuts, unemployment, extradition.
As alluded to earlier, the 1987-89 minority
Fianna Fail government marked an important
shift of direction. Faced with a National Debt
of Third World proportions, the Haughey
government pursued a policy of austerity, sig
nificantly slashing public expenditure. with
detrimental effects on the health service in par-
ticular. It was able to do this partly because it had taken over the austerity policies of Fianna
Gael, who could hardly oppose in opposition what they had proposed in government.
It was also aided by the particpation of the Irish Congress of Trade Unions in the *Programme of National Recovery" which dis- armed the working class and the poor. Whilst its two years in power saw a decrease of 8 per cent of the National Debt, unemployment and emigration soared.
In the political arena too, Haughey scored another volte face. Having fought against the Anglo-Irish agreement in opposition, he now adopted it as his own. The policy being pur- sued was one of direct participation with Britain in the policing of the six-county state. He committed himself to upholding the 1987 Extradition Act, brought in to make extradi- tion casier, at the same time as the appeal against the convictions of the Birmingham 6 was taking place, with the British judiciary making it clear that no other verdict than "guilty" would be tolerated.
The effects of Haughey's policies were revealed in the outcome of the 1989 election he called to achieve a majority govemment. Not only did he fail in his objective, he was
Page 28
SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 26, July-August 1990
FEATURES
THE WORKERS PARTY SAYS NO TO MASS UNEMPLOYMENT
Workers Party banner in Belfast; stressing 'class line' but igoring the border and the oppression of Catholics
whole is dominated by support for partition.
In recent years the Workers Party has been drawing on Labour's bedrock of support, par- ticularly in Dublin, although failing to make any significant inroads into Fianna Fail's working class base - until the 1989 elections. These proved to be a new element, and a cru- cial factor in Fianna Fail's crisis: Haughey's party failed to maintain its support amongst the Dublin working class who voted in large numbers for Labour, the Workers Party, and an independent, Tony Gregory, who repre- sents one of the most deprived inner city con- stituencies. His combination of radical populism - organised through local com- munity associations - and militant nationalism - has won him wide support amongst the un- skilled and unemployed especially the young people.
A deep-going debate has now opened up within the Workers Party. The Labour Party has proved rather more resilient in maintaining a base of support than the Workers Party leaders might have hoped. One plank of its policies has been vituperative opposition to nationalist aspirations, equating the struggle of Sinn Fein and the IRA with loyalist sec- tarianism. Indeed, the response of one of its TDs - Des O'Hagan to the Supreme Court decision on Owen Carron was to condemn it as a 'step backwards to a situation where acts of sectarian terror are whitewashed with the phrase "political offence"
The other strand of its politics has been its concentration on the failure of the Irish bour- geoisie, support for multi-nationals alongside state sponsored economic growth, and job creation and a more equitable system of taxa tion. Hardly the stuff of revolutionary rhetoric or action!
At the centre of the current Workers Party debate is disagreement over a perspective for the future. Recently, the party's leading theoretician, Eoghan Harris produced a docu- ment; "The Necessity of Social Democracy". which was published prior to its being dis- cussed in the party. It was this fact, not the content of the document which provoked a I furore and led to his resignation.
The text argues that the party has to put socialism behind it and dump socialist economics' which have become a break on progress. Instead, he proposes a retum to so- cial democracy, defined as 'the struggle for socialist values in a democratic society with a market economy*. What this means in practice is abandoning any notion of 'left unity' - namely any alliance with the Labour Party:
We have nothing in common with the Labour Party's nationalistic policies and green politics, with the collection of clapped out cliches carried around by the 'left'.... We should move up to midfield as a mass party of social democracy and take as much left, liberal left of centre space as possible, recognising that the Labour vote will come to us eventual- ly, and faster if it looks like we can take office. We should remind ourselves that coalition depends and is not a principle'.
So, the prospect of coalition again rears its head. In terms of its political outlook, it is dif- ficult to envisage any form of coalition be- tween elements of the Workers Party and Fian- na Fail. Rather, it is more a perspective directed at Fianna Gael and the Progressive Democrats. The Workers Party's virulent pro- partitionist policies have more in common with those of the main bourgeois parties. As Harris expressed it:
'Our party was not bom in a conflict about
SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 26, July-August 1990
socialism. Our party was bom in a conflict about democracy. About the right of Protes- tants to their Northem State. ... When we defend the separate Protestant identity we show respect for all identities. When we defend Unionist rights - so difficult to defend down here - we defend all other minority rights from women to the poor in society'.
Where do the rights of the oppressed and discriminated-against nationalist population of the Six Counties enter into the picture? They do not feature in Harris's schema. Perhaps this is part of their strategy to marginalise ter- rorism, as one of the leading members of the party, Proinsias de Rossa said in the Dail in November 1989:
*No one political party will marginalise terrorism by itself. It is up to each of us, in this House, to develop and promote means of strengthening the democratic culture. The demands for peace and democracy are are the primary demands of people in these is- lands...*
How such a perspective could have an ap peal among the working class is difficult to imagine.
The question remains. How to reforge the different radical and socialist nationalism in a way that challenges the conservatism and catholicism of the 26-county state, toward a united Ireland which in the words of the 1916 proclamation "will treat all its people equally. The breach within the Fianna Fail consensus opening up, provide a challenge and an oppor- tunity for those who would offer an alternative vision. Neither the Labour Party or the Workers Party as they stand can offer such a vision.
Page 29