Socialist Outlook

Socialist Viewpoint, International, Socialist Outlook and their supplements, 1984–2009

From women's rights to feminist politics

· Socialist Outlook no. 26, July–August 1990 · pp 17-26 · 7,933 words

Women

SUPPLEMENT

The developing struggle for women's liberation in

Poland

By Brenda S. Bishop

aspect of women's lives. Women within the trade union Solidamosc are beginning to draw attention to the special problems of working women and to develop structures that can ad- dress them.

But at the same time, women are facing a far-reaching assault on their legal rights and living standards that threatens to set them back decades. As the new government of Solidar- nosc-allied intellectuals and politicians rushes to privatise the ailing economy, women are becom- ing the majority of the new un- employed and have already lost their right to protected long term parental leave. Legislation to illegalise abor- tion has been introduced in the Sejm (the Polish Parliament) for the second year in a row. Women are even less represented in government

goverment than

These are times of great promise and great danger for women in Poland. For decades, the second class status of women - in public life, on the labour market, and at home - was an unchallengeable fact of life, firmly rooted in the hypocritical policies of the Com- munist bureaucracy and in the ideology of the powerful Catholic Church. Now the collapse of one-party rule and the nascent democratic process have created political space for women to begin struggling to change their situation.

A newly formed national feminist organisation is taking the lead in ad- vocating women's rights and chal- lenging the institutions of male dominance that circumscribe every

in

before, while Playboy-style calen dars are displayed in most stores and offices,

Never has it been more critical for women to unite to defend their rights. While the potential for such organisation exists, there are many obstacles which must first be over- come.

A twisted history of

subordination

The situation of women in Poland is complex and contradictory. Basic legal rights and social benefits, which in the West were won only after protracted struggle, were provided by the ruling Polish United Workers Party (PUWP) after World War IL

The Polish Constitution guaran- tees the equality of the sexes. Abor- tion was legalised in 1956, on certain

SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 26, July-Auqust 1990

"Women within the trade union Solidarnosc are

beginning to draw attention

to the special

problems of working women and to develop structures that

can address

them"

Page 15

SUPPLEMENT

"The Polish Constitution guarantees the equality of the sexes.

Abortion was legalised in 1956, on certain specified grounds, and has evolved to permit essentially abortion on demand. A system of childcare support was developed...

specified grounds, and has evolved to permit essentially abortion on demand. A system of childcare sup port was developed which included, for mothers, the right to three months paid maternity leave and leave to care for sick children (35 days per year per child) and, for either parent, the right to up to three years' parental leave, with an allowance of 40 percent of the former salary paid during the first 18 months. Pomography was legally banned. New opportunities were made available to women who wished to attend university and to study or work in traditionally male- dominated fields.

But in reality, little changed for most women. Male dominance was perpetuated in public life through the party bureaucracy and in private life through the weight of tradition rein- forced by the Catholic Church. The PUP's commitment to equality ex- isted only on paper. There were no women in top party posts and only a token few in government and management in industry. (Only a quota ensured that 20 percent of party members were women.)

Women entered the workforce in record numbers to help rebuild war- devastated Poland, and currently con-

stitute 46 percent of the workforce. (Between 70 and 80 percent of

women 20 to 30 and 45 to 50 years

old engage in paid labour.) But they have been kept segregated in the

lowest paying. and often most

monotonous and unsafe jobs, con-

centrated in the textile, food and pot- tery industries, the clothing trade, and education and health services. Thus, the average woman eams only 65 per- cent of the average man's wages.

At the same time, women have al- ways been expected to assume full responsibility for children and the home. Recent statistical surveys show that women (i.e. wives, mothers and mothers in-law) are exclusively responsible for cooking in 94 percent of all households, for washing and ironing in over 90 percent, for mend- ing clothes in 97 percent, and for dishwashing and other housework in 85 percent of all households.

Rather than challenging the sexual division of labour, party policies en- couraged it. For instance, rather than investing in daycare centres, the government urged mothers to take ex- tended parental leave, which rein- forced traditional sex roles and disad- vantaged women on the labour market. Poland's perennial economic

problems only increased women's

burdens, as many hours had to be

spent waiting in food shops lines, and cooking and cleaning had to be per- formed without the aid of adequate

supplies or time-saving consumer ap

pliances.

Despite the hardships of women's

lives, the conditions did not exist for

mass feminist consciousness to

develop. Entering the workforce did

not change most women's view of

themselves as first and foremost

wives and mothers. While work is a

source of self fulfilment for some, for many it is merely an economic neces- sity which they would happily aban- don if given the chance to retur home fulltime.

Because of the party's control over information, there was no vehicle for introducing feminist ideas into society. Only one feminist text, an anthology, has been translated into Polish. The one established women's organisation, the Women's League, has been little more than a project to occupy wives of party bosses, publishing a magazine Women's Life, and providing some individual services to women, such as help in finding part-time work of child care, to justify their vast array of offices and other privileges. It promoted the party line that equality between the sexes had been achieved, which only served to discredit such ideas in the eyes of most women.

Yet women have not been entirely passive. In 1980-81, they became ac- tive in (the trade union) Solidarosc in numbers equal to men, not- withstanding their noticeable absence from the history-making photos. In those days, women saw their interests as identical to men's in the fight for economic democracy and national liberation. But even as Solidamose

broadened into a mass movement of

opposition, its critique of the political

and social order never extended to

the subordination of women. With

the Church hierarchy as its strongest

ally, the leadership maintained its so- cial conservatism.

Although the social foment of

those years made room for the emer-

gence of a feminist group at the

University of Warsaw in 1980, it

found itself isolated and unable to

grow. Nevertheless, it stayed together

as a small discussion and support

group, while the women associated

with it, one by one, tried to raise the

special problems of women in their

work in Solidarosc underground and

in other emerging movements, such

as Freedom and Peace (an anti-

militarist, environmental movement).

One step forward, one

step back

As in the west, it was the attempt

to take away women's right to con-

trol their reproductive capability

which created the conditions for

women to begin openly struggling

around their own agenda. In

February 1989, a bill was introduced

in the Sejm (the Polish parliament) to

protect the rights of the "unborn

child" not simply by outlawing abor-

WHERE'S

MY

CLEAN

SOCKS!

Page

SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 26, July 1990

SUPPLEMENT

tion, but by subjecting

I THOUGHT ABOUT HAVING KIDS violators - women and

BUT CHANGED MY MIND doctors alike - to a three year prison term! (The draft was prepared by a group of experts on behalf of the Catholic Episcopate and was presented by the Polish Catholic Social Union, with the support of conservative

thinkers from within every party.)

Women all across the country were indignant.

In a country where safe reliable birth control is obtainable only by chance, and neglect of the issue constitutes the na- tional policy, many women are forced to resort to abortion as a birth control of last resort. (About 700,000 women have abortions each year, in a population of 19 women.)

Independent women's action groups sprang up in every major city, often around universities, and under- took petitioning. Parliamentary ap peals and even street actions in defence of the existing law, including an impressive demonstration in War- saw which drew a thousand. After being inundated with letters and phone calls, the Women's League was forced to take a stand against the proposed legislation, while Solidar- nosc managed to avoid publicly stat- ing its position. (Walesa vacillated, remarking first that people have to stop "killing each other" while later suggesting that the question is a moral one better decided by the in- dividual conscience, not the state.) The bill died last summer before coming to a vote, but the newly formed action groups did not.

Monumental developments at the national political level were unfold- ing around the same time that would entirely change the political landscape in Poland. At round-table discussions. Solidamos eventually agreed to a compromise with the ruling bureaucrats, leading to new elections in which 35 percent of the Sejm was freely chosen and a second house of Parliament, the Senate, was established in which all of the seats were freely elected. While Solidar- nosc, as a trade union, could not run its own candidates, it set up a Nation- al Civic Committee (NCC) through which candidates representing a spectrum of political perspectives and backgrounds were selected

THAT'S MURDER

million

MURDER?! ALL I DID WAS THINK ABOUT IT!

DID IT!

LIFE BEGINS

AT CONCEPTION!

380005090001 GNOSSPNILY THE SA

(creating an awkward relationship

awkward relationship between the workers" organisation and the politicians which continues to this day).

When the PUWP was soundly trounced and unable to rule (none of even its uncontested candidates won a plurality), Solidamosc finally agreed to a power-sharing arrange- ment, under which the PUWP retained control of the army and security forces, as well as the newly- established post of President (filled by General Jaruzelski, who had declared martial law in 1981).

Sweeping reforms

These concessions leave Poland behind most of its neighbours in terms of establishing political democracy. Long-time Solidarnose advisor and Catholic intellectual Tadeusz. Mazowiecki was chosen as Prime Minister, and put together a government in September, 1989, which immediately embarked on a program of sweeping reform. For the first time in years, freedom to or- ganise, to demonstrate, to publish and distribute information in the open without fear of repression or control, was possible in Poland.

These changes gave new impetus to feminists. As soon as the law on organisations was liberalised, the core of feminists moved to establish an official national organisation by registering with court as the Polish Feminist Association (PFA). (In Poland, this formality is an absolute prerequisite to securing recognition in the media and public life and con- crete benefits from the state.)

At the beginning of November, a

conference in Poznan brought together the activists from the abor- tion rights campaign (including PFA, independent local groups such as the Women's Club from Poznan, Women's Honor from Torun, Move- ment for Protecting Women's rights from Bydgoszcz, and the Polish Feminist Movement Club from Krakow, members of the Polish Socialist Party-Democratic Revolu- tion (PPS-RD) and Freedom and Peace, and even a progressive from the Women's League) to exchange views on how to continue women's struggle.

The following week, on Novem- ber 12th feminists organised a picket of the American Embassy in War- saw, in solidarity with the thousands demonstrating in Washington that day to demand safe, legal and funded abortion. And later that same month, the first national meeting of women in Solidarose was convened to lay the groundwork for developing a women's agenda for the union.

Ironically, the very openings that made it possible for women to begin organising to advance their rights also unleashed other forces which threaten to push women even further backward. Far from taking any in- itiatives to improve the position of women in society, the new govern- ment has been, at best, indifferent to women" concems and at worst, responsible for policies which sacrifice women's interests in pursuit of other aims.

Although the goverment has a "beautiful spokeswoman" (Malgor- zata Niebabitowska), as Prime mini-

"many women

are forced to

resort to

abortion as a birth control of

last resort. About 700,000

women have abortions each

year, in a

population of

19 million

women"

SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 26, July-August 1990

Page 17

"Some 80 percent of those already dismissed are women, who are

concentrated in the

"non-essential' office jobs which are being eliminated in

all sectors. Other women have been

forced to quit their jobs, as the cost of daycare soars to levels exceeding their take-home pay"

Page 18

SUPPLEMENT

ster Mazowiecki once referred to her, there is only one woman in the gover- ment - the Minister of Cul- ture. In the Parliament, women are only 6 percent of the representatives elected on the NCC slate, sig-

nificantly less than the 20 percent the PUWP made

room for. But lack of repre-

sentation is just the tip of the iceberg.

The thrust of the government's

sweeping economic reform jeopardises women's interests as workers. the government's

solution to the problems of the inefficient, debt-ridden Polish economy is nothing short of the reintroduction of capitalist economic relations

in all sectors. As of January 1, 1990, in accordance with the IMF austerity plan, inter- nal convertability of the zloty was in- troduced and a classical anti-inflation program was implemented which led to catastrophic overight prices in- creases.

The goal was to stabilise the economy in order to attract foreign capital and facilitate the return to the market! The effect was to reduce living standards by 40 percent (twice the anticipated drop) and to bring back unemployment, as enterprises go bankrupt, climinate layers of the bureaucracy, or halt production due to the drop in sales. The IMF estimates that 5 percent of the population will be unemployed by the years end.

It is no coincidence that women are the hardest hit. Some 80 percent of those already dismissed are women, who are concentrated in the "non-essential" office jobs which are being eliminated in all sectors. With less training and few transferable skills, these women will have great difficulty in finding new work. Other women have been forced to quit their jobs, as the cost of daycare soars to levels exceeding their take-home pay. Many more mothers will lose their jobs as a result of changes on the law which now permit employers to fire women during their three year paren- tal leave. The politicians are clearly counting on women's quiescence and

political passivity to help them carry through the most unpopular aspects of their economic reform.

These attacks dovetail with a cam-

paign to limit women to their role as

homemakers and mothers, spear- headed by an alliance of conservative

These eggs 'fell off the back of a lorry in Warsaw

politicians from the NCC and the newly activated right wing parties. In January, the Sejm quietly eliminated the state subsidy to the Family Development Society (formerly the Family Planning Society), a private association which was the only family planning body in the country. Less than one month later, the NCC dominated Senate sent to the Sejm proposed legislation to illegalise abortion, slightly altered from last year's failed bill. The leader of the so- called Liberal Party, Jerry Korwin- Mikke, has even gone so far as to suggest that the right to vote should be taken away from women, while the centre-right Union for Real Politics has urged that women's access to higher education be limited, on the theory that women are less likely to make use of their degrees!

Working women unite

While it is clear that women can only rely on themselves to defeat this array of attacks, there is little chance of building a mass independent women's movement in the near fu- ture. Women's advocates must find ways to maximise their impact, seek- ing to win support for pro-women policies and to mobilise women through existing institutions.

The most important institution in this period is the trade union Solidar- nose. Only a strong workers' or ganisation can lead the kind of fight in the workplace and in the political arena that will be necessary to defend

women's economic interests. But the union cannot be counted on to automatically play this role. Under Lech Walesa's iron hand, the top

leadership currently supports the government's pro-market policies, ac- cepting that mass layoffs, loss of so- cial benefits and the growth of social differentiation are the price that has to be paid to put the Polish economy back on its feet.

The internal opposition within the union lacks a strong base from which to to mount a successful challenge to this course, as the majority of Polish workers, who are expressing growing disaffection with the direction of government policy, are no longer or- ganised in the union. (Solidarnosc has only around a tenth of the 10 million members it had in 1980-81.)

Furthermore, there is little reason to hope that a more militant union leadership would be prepared to unite its members against attacks which threaten primarily women workers. The male-dominated union has no history of attention to women's spe- cial problems, and top union leaders (including the new head of the

Gdansk region and the union's female spokesperson, Barbara Malek) are on record as justifying the mass dismiss-

als of women first.

Nor do women have any decisive influence in the union. Activists es-

timate that women comprise about

20-50 percent of leadership at the

enterprise level, from 10-25 percent

at the regional level, and have only a

token representation on the National

Executive Committee. (No statistics

are readily available, itself an indica- tion of the problem.)

However, women are beginning to

emerge as a force to be reckoned with

in the union. Due to the efforts of a

SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 26, July 1990

SUPPLEMENT

handful of women activists and feminists, with a little help from the intera- tional trade union movement (ap- plied through the International Confederation of Free Trade Unions (ICFTU), with which Solidarose is af- filiated), a week- long seminar ad- dressed exclusively to women's issues was: held in Gdansk the last week of January. (lt was one of a series of 12 semi- nars so-sponsored by the union with the ICFTU.)

A few dozen Even basic chores like shopping are more exhausting with Polish queues unionists, most of whom were leaders in their enterprises, as well as many feminist academics and activists attended the conference, which was part educa tional and part working session. The full range of material and psychologi- cal problems facing working women in Poland was outlined.

Top on the list was the fact that all working women, regardless of age, education or type of work, are saddled with all the housework and childcare after they have put in their eight plus hours on the job. As a result, women are often chronically overtired, with little time or energy to pursue further education or training. which could lead to higher paying or more rewarding work opportunities, or to become active in the union, and they suffer from feelings of inade- quacy or failure. (In a survey of metal workers, 71 percent of husbands with working wives said they were satis fied with their domestic situation, while only 8 percent were satisfied.)

On the labour market, the top con- cem was the 35 percent pay gap separating male and female workers, which was attributed primarily to ex- treme job segregation and devalua- tion of women's work, and women's lack of advancement due to dis crimination in promotion or lack of skills improvement. Inequality in the job market resulting from discrimina- tion in education, hiring and promo- tion was also identified, though this point proved controversial, with

primarily university-educated women stressing the problem, while others insisted that there is equal oppor- tunity.

Hazards

In industry, where women con- stitute 13.2 percent of the workforce, women are exposed to an array of health and safety hazards: 63 percent work in a standing position without interruption, 50 percent are required to lift excessively heavy loads, 48 percent work with high levels of noise, 35 percent are exposed to ex- cess dust levels, 30 percent to exces- sive temperatures, and 15 percent to intense vibrations. One of the most severe problems is the three shift sys- tem, which forces or induces women to work at night, leaving them in a state of utter exhaustion.

The search for realistic and ap propriate solutions to these problems proved difficult. As the very first speaker put it, the only real answer lies in reversing the centuries old tradition, passed from grandmother to mother to each new generation, that a woman's place is in the kitchen while a man's is on the shop floor.

But working women of this generation, even those motivated to fight for their rights, are so shaped by those values that they either accept or are resigned to the constraints of that socially-defined role. Thus, in the quest for more immediate solutions, many women sought to carve out special protections for women which

would only perpetuate the sexual division of labour and fuel the forces of discrimination.

Many women favoured the es- tablishment of a maintenance al- lowance that would enable mothers to remain home to "educate" their children until the age of ten, express- ing concern that daycare deprived children of their "mothers" touch". Wide support was expressed for a ban on nightwork for women (which exists in many European countries) and for the right to retire with a full pension after 30 years of work. A prohibition on women working over- time or working with hazardous sub- stances and a homemaker's al- lowance were among the other suggestions raised.

All of these proposals were ul- timately dismissed on the grounds that they were financially unfeasible, would undermine the fight for equality, and were divisive, distin- guishing men from women rather than uniting all workers around the fight to improve the working en- vironment. But the fact that they were raised provides an important in- dication of the level of consciousness of many women that will have to be confronted in the effort to organise union women.

More appropriate policy recom- mendations were ultimately formu- laled. The conference insisted that flexible working hours and part time work should be made available to women at their option, and that more

SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 26, July-August 1990

*all working

women, regardless of age, education

or type of

work, are

saddled with

all the housework and childcare after they have put

in their eight

plus hours on

the job. As a result, women

are often

chronically overtired, with

little time or

energy to pursue further

education or

training"

Page 19

"in these days of economic crisis and austerity, advances seem unattainable. Participants expressed alarm over the potential loss of social benefits, decline in health and safety standards and weakening of the union that may result from foreign capitalist investment."

Page 20

SUPPLEMENT

daycare centres of higher quality (i.e. lower teacher-child ratio and more flexible opening hours) should be opened, especially for children under 3 years old. It was also stressed that men had an equal responsibility for home and childcare duties, and that medical leave to care for sick children should be extended to fathers as well.

The principle of equal pay for work of equal value was endorsed, and the union was urged to take an active role in the re-evaluations currently under-

made it next to impossible to feed a family even on two incomes, and women are not likely to passively ac- cept the loss of their income without a fight. Thus, women are a potentially powerful force of opposition to the policies of wholesale privatisation and mass layoffs within the union.

For women to succeed in im- plementing their agenda, they must become more active in the union and assume leadership roles. The women

rank and file women.

Women's development within the union will also be affected by women's struggles on larger social and political issues. A strong inde- pendent women's movement will generate social pressure that will in- directly aid unionists in campaigning for pro-women policies. Introduction of feminist ideas into public discourse will help develop the consciousness of working women, as evidenced by

the positive impact

feminists had at the

conference. This is

way street.

i fight for national Independence

working conditions for all workers.

These policy recommendations provide a framework for women's struggle to improve their lives. But, in these days of economic crisis and austerity, advances seem unattainable and the pervasive concer is to keep from losing ground. Participants ex- pressed alarm over the potential loss of social benefits (such as parental leave), decline in health and safety standards and weakening of the union that may result from the much sought after foreign capitalist investment.

But the conference stopped short of expressly prioritising the fight to defend women's jobs. On the con- trary, many women were prepared to accept on principle that, if workers must be fired for the sake of improv- ing the economy, less harm is done by dismissing women - on the as- sumption that women earn less money and that their income is sup- plementary.

Cold hard economics may trans- form this consciousness in the com- ing months. Women at the conference were adamant in their insistence that women who are in fact the primary breadwinners in their houschold, as a growing number of single and divorced women and even wives of alcoholics are, should be absolutely protected against dismissal. Inflation and the wages freeze have already

at the conference exhibited a disturb- ing tendency to blame themselves for the appalling lack of women in the union's leadership. Each of the five working groups reported that there were no barriers to women becoming union leaders, explaining that any woman with the interest and com- petence could serve. Yet problems unique to women such as lack of time and energy due to family respon- sibilities, lack of self-confidence, lack of experience and leadership skills and health problems were all acknow- ledged during the discussion. Surpris ingly. discrimination was never once identified as an obstacle, although it undeniably exists.

There was virtually unanimous agreement that a Women's Commis sion should be established to take responsibility for information gather- ing, education, support and advocacy on behalf of women.

Fortunately, National Executive Committee agreed and okayed a Women's Commission at the national level. This represents only a partial victory, as the commission was sought at the regional and eventually enterprise levels as well, but it proves that the leadership can be pushed to take women's demands seriously.

The real work now lies ahead. If the Commission is to avoid becoming merely a bureaucratic body or ghetto for women, it will have to activate

The union can be an invaluable ally. providing direct support the women's move- ment, both material- ly (as in Bydgoszez, where the new waninnal haid hau

to

18 made printing facilities available to the local women's group) and politically: the mobilisation of working women

will be critical to the defence of women's rights, particularly in the upcoming abortion rights battles.

Moving on to feminism

On the national political front, feminists have placed a high priority on securing a strong women's repre- sentative to the govemment and push- ing to make the position a meaningful one. The post was established by Poland several years ago in com- pliance with accords signed at the In- temational Women's Conference in Nairobi, Kenya. Soon after taking of- fice, the Mazowiecki government fired the PUWP-appointed repre- sentative, but did not replace her.

While recognising that the rep has no real power, feminists see the post as an important vehicle for the work of autonomous women's organisa- tions. They appealed directly to the Prime Minister to make the post truly independent, thus not accountable to any govemment ministry. Without even bothering to reply. Mazowiecki delayed some five months before finally appointing Helen Goralska, the vice-minister of the Ministry for Labour, to be the new representative, on top of her other duties.

At a 'get acquainted" session with women's advocates which she con- vened shortly after her appointment. Goralska confessed that she had no particular expertise in the area (she is

SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 26, July-August 1990

SUPPLEMENT

an economist by profession) and no particular initiatives in mind, but she expressed a willingness to help. Women intend to keep her to her word. In particular, they will insist that she take an active role in the legislative process, monitoring proposed legislation affecting women and, hopefully, provid- ing drafts to women's groups, who have learned about certain damaging bills only after they have already become law. (PFA is also hoping to win the right to have a repre- sentative present at all committee and floor debates on such bills.)

They also expect her to support research and statistical documentation of the status of women, which is now sorely lacking.

Toward that end, PFA has proposed that a Women's Roundtable be convened as a forum for publicising such in- formation and develop- ing policy recommen- dations.

Feminists are also concerned to address the lack of rep- resentation of women in government. The number of women selected by the National Civic Committee as can- didates for local self-government election in March was no better that in the national elections last summer. Some feminists were exploring the feasibility of running candidates as part of an alternative slate. Zuzanna Dabrowska, a leader of PPS-RD and member of the Polish Feminist As- sociation, was one such potential candidate.

To admit to being a feminist in Poland is tantamount admitting having the plague. Many of the few women prominent in public life, in- cluding writers and academics, go to great lengths to disassociate themsel ves from feminism. (Ironically, al- though the sociologist responsible for the one Polish feminist anthology did not consider herself a feminist, and was using the texts to illustrate a completely unrelated theory about human social behaviour, her reputa- tion was ruined by the project.) Such women, like the eye surgeon who is the mother of a leading feminist ac- tivist, regret the price they paid for their careers and urge their own daughters to follow a more tradition-

al, family-oriented path. the new women's groups want to tackle that taboo head on, embracing the term feminist and endeavouring to give it new meaning.

In this project, the personal must be made political by subjecting to re- examination all aspects of women's

Cerol* Simpseu

experience, from the sacred - mar- riage, motherhood, family - to the taboo - sexuality and lesbianism, rape and incest, violence against women. Ideologically, the cult of motherhood is being nurtured these days, while the sexual objectification of women is becoming more Pronounced.

Pornography, which is still offi- cially illegal, arrived several years ago with the market reforms and is now spreading like wildfire, a sym- bol of Poland's 'modemisation'. In the year that Miss Poland reign as Miss World, calendars of nude women in degrading poses are produced by state companies, prominently marketed in state-run department stores and bookshops, and found hanging on most office walls, even in tourist bureaus and police departments. Female strippers are becoming commonplace in regular discos and scantily clad women predominate in the new TV advertising.

The Church, which has done its best to suppress any discussion of sex, even forcing a lone school book on sexuality off shelves and out of print, has lost its tongue when it comes to the new pom. Women, in- cluding strict Catholics, who already

SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 26, July-August 1990

express dismay at the enforced ig- norance and guilt which surrounds sex, will be further alienated as the Madonna-whore duality is strengthened. The sexual violence and harrassment which women have always been subjected to, especially women out alone in the evening,is

Yes, this is a two

career household.

Unfortunately, I

have both

careers.

reportedly getting worse. But guilt and shame still inhibit most women from discussing such "private" mat- ters.

Despite the much hailed freedom of the press which now exists, many feel that a new form of self-censor- ship, an "inner moral control" shaped by Catholic ethics, makes the en- vironment even more hostile to dis- cussion in these matters. Though it is not yet feasible to think of producing their own feminist publication, they are using all other means at their dis Posal.

In March, in the university town of Krakow, academics and activists from across the country were invited to address the subject "Motherhood: duty or free choice?' at a public seminar organised by a lone graduate student (who is active in PFA). Other local groups hope to organise similar seminars in the future. PFA is trying to build up its collection of feminist texts and to develop a system of cir- culation that will provide greater ac- cess to the works.

Women occasionally make presentations on books they have read, in part because all are in foreign languages. In Poznan, the Women's Club has just negotiated the right to temporarily house their books in the

"Ideologically,

the cult of motherhood is being nurtured

these days,

while the

sexual

objectification

of women is

becoming

more

pronounced."

Page 21

SUPPLEMENT

SGPI

HiSTOR

(NE 1

GRAFIA

ZAWSKA

"Women who choose to remain single are often treated as social outcasts... the chronic shortage of housing forces many to remain in their parent's home for years"

Page 22

American Consulate library, which is open to the public, and has also managed to secure several radio inter- views.

Another important goal of the feminist movement is to create space where women can feel comfortable talking about their personal experien ces. Given a supportive environment, many women are eager to discuss aspects of their lives about which they have long been silent - whether it be disrespect and harassment on the job, their fear of men, psychologi- cal or physical abuse in their intimate relationships, the constraints of mar- ried life, or the alienation and frustra- tion experienced by all women who refuses to play by the rules. In the process, women emerge from their isolation and begin to see the com- monality in their situations, develop- ing the solidarity which will provide a foundation for united political action. They also begin to understand the ex- tent to which women psychologically adapt to and perpetuate patriarchal in- stitutions. In their own lives, it is often women (mothers, grandmothers and female teachers) who have been most directly responsible for restric- tions on their freedom - limiting them to "girl's" activities, forcing them to assume domestic duties (from which brothers were exempt), underrating their intelligence or dismissing their ambitions, pushing them to get mar- ried and preaching to them about con- duct appropriate for a wife. From

such exchange women also derive support which is hard to find in everyday life.

Other women have even more am- bitious ideas about developing women's culture. Women who choose to remain single have an espe- cially tough row to hoe. Not only are they often treated as social outcasts, suddenly finding themselves ex- cluded from social gatherings of their married friends, but the chronic shortage of housing and priority sys- tem which favours married couples with children forces many to remain uncomfortably in their parent's home for years. Por lesbians, the stigmatisa- tion is even more severe.

One women's community in Krakow provides an alternative for such women. More than 75 years ago, a group of single career women es- tablished a women's residence which provides living space in a communal environment for several dozen women. While in recent years it has increasingly been occupied by divorced women merely seeking an affordable place to live, a feminist ac- tivist, who will soon be moving in, hopes to revive its character as a sup- portive space for women who con- sciously embrace single life, and even possibly to develop it into a centre for women in the community.

Feminists are not lacking in crea- tive ideas for the future. Some are al- ready talking about the need to or- ganise self-defence classes for

women. The graduate student from Krakow dreams of seeing a regular seminar series established at the university at which participants could cam credit, as a first step to the development of women's studies in Poland. (A seminar on feminism of- fered over the past decade at the University of Warsaw by Renata Siemienska, a sociologist who has served at UNESCO as an expert on women in Poland, has helped to edu- cate and inspire many of those who are now becoming active in the women's movement.) A lawyer from Warsaw wants to concentrate on developing anti-racist discrimination laws and enforcement procedures, while a teacher has a particular inter- est in improving health care for women. Some hope eventually to begin a feminist publication, while several are interested in translating into Polish and publishing women's literature and feminist theory.

Success will depend in part on the ability of the young groups to strengthen themselves organisational- ly. At present, little more than a handful of activists is assuming responsibility for an overwhelming amount of work, and many are al- ready spread thin by other political activities in PPS-RD, Freedom and Peace or Solidamose. (All but a few of the feminists who came together in Warsaw in 1980 are now living abroad.) Local groups have largely been functioning independently.

SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 26, July-August 1990

SUPPLEMENT

taking their own initiatives. While this decentralisation may be ap propriate to the internal needs of the movement at this early stage, it makes it more difficult for feminists to make a name for themselves and win the media attention that other small par- ties and movements have begun to capture. It may also weaken their ability to coordinate efforts in order to lead the coming political struggles. In the abortion rights campaign last spring, they found themselves out- manoeuvered bv Pro-Femina. a new:

"movement started by a male student with strong links to the bureaucracy. which called and

operate, problems not casily solved. As soon as PFA was legally recog nised, it attempted to arrange a meet- ing with the cabinet minister respon- sible for assisting partisan organisations and for doling out pre- cious office space, which is otherwise unobtainable or unaffordable. when Minister Hall finally agreed to a meeting, after months of dodging their requests, he sent in his place a female official who was in her second week with the ministry and had neither the knowledge nor the power

took credit for the Warsaw demonstra- tion after leaming that feminists were discussing the idea

The independent faminius anuamant

faces its greatest challenge from the formerly "official" organisation, par- ticularly the Women's League. Having lost the backing of the bureaucrac the

A patronising premier: Mazowieckl League is trying to prove itself still to be the leading women's organisation in order to hang on to its extensive of- fices and privileges. Thus, it is at- tempting to play a more activist role and to force independent women's groups to follow its initiatives. At a day long conference co-sponsored by the League and the Women's Com- mission of the OPZZ. (the once offi cial trade union), which feminists at- tended but did not participate in, the organisers sought to present themsel ves as the Women's round table. The League has also approached PFA about working together on draft legis- lation. To date, PFA has refused any collaboration, not wanting to be used to legitimise the League or to risk being discredited by too close as- sociation with the old guard. But at the same time, feminists cannot simp ly stand aside and let the League use its established position to set the direction for or take all the credit for the women's movement. Nor can they afford to tum their backs on any who are allies in the fight to defend women's rights.

The new feminist groups are hand- icapped by their lack of resources and of an established base from which to

to assist them. If and when they aare given office space, they will have to confront the problem of how to pay the rent.

PFA's difficulties may be exacer- bated by its reluctance to formalise its organisational structures, not surpris- ing after years of living under the iron hand of a male-dominated, hierarchic bureaucracy. At present, there is no formal membership or affiliation procedure, no clear leadership, no regularly convened meetings or for- mal mechanism for decision making. and no system of dues or other regular source of funding.

The frenzy of activity of the past months has left little time to devote expressly to outreach, but it has laid an important foundation for incor- porating new women into the move- ment, particularly union activists and university students. Some groups are now tuming their attention more to public events, such as seminars, in order to attract such women. Other women may be drawn to discussion and support groups.

The struggles ahead

In the near future, the threat to abortion rights is certain to occupy centre stage in women's struggle. It is

SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 26, July 1990

not yet known if and when the anti-

abortion bill will be taken up by the

Sejm, and opinion is divided on whether it has any chance of passage. Ironically, the fact that the Sejm was not freely elected and is still dominated by members from the now dismantled PUWP (which split into two "social democratic" parties in February) makes it more likely that the anti-abortion measure will be defeated this time around. (Thei Speaker of the Sejm was formerly as- sociated with the Family Planning

Society.) In the long run, the posi-

tion adopted by

Solidamose and its allies in govem-

ment will be criti- cal. Its leaders are widely thought to be anti-abortion and it is feared that they may support

regressive Proposal in order to pay back their loyalty to the Church.

The Church is pulling out all the stops in its anti- abortion cam- paien. resorting tol

appeals from the

pulpit and propaganda displays set up in chapels. The prospect of Poland be- coming another Ireland is many women's greatest fear. But there are also indications that even loyal Catholics are not prepared to follow the Church on this issue. Many are becoming annoyed with the Church's ever more bold intrusions into secular affairs. (The introduction of a chaplain in Parliament and masses on television are but the most obvious examples.) Catholicism has never prevented most women from using birth control or having abortions, as evidenced by he predominance of two child households. Even among those with moral objections to abor tion, many believe the question must be resolved by the individual con- science not the political process.

Such sentiments will not

automatically translated into public

opposition to the proposed bill, as

guilt and social pressure often cause many to keep quiet about their dif- ferences with the Church. But such reticence may be overcome as the danger posed by the anti-abortion forces becomes more obvious. University women can be expected to

"The Church is pulling out all the stops in its anti-abortion

campaign,

resorting to

appeals from the pulpit and

propaganda displays set up

in chapels.

The prospect

of Poland

becoming

another

Ireland is many women's greatest fear"

Page 23

"The stakes are high; it is not simply a question of restrictions but of loss of one right which is more protected than in the West. The outcome will also show whether the new era in Poland will awaken women to defend their interests or will pacity them as never before"

Page 24

SUPPLEMENT

Walesa's

Christian democratic wing, which has the upper hand over the so- cial democratic and smaller radical wings of the move- ment, is not attempting to find a new middle road but is leading the country firmly down a Westem-oriented capitalist path. Rather than seeking to organise working people or actively involve them in their union or in grassroots politics, political leaders are preaching restraint and disciplined cooperation their economic program in an effort to at-

in the hands of the politicians and 'experts'.

he stalinist stereotype

tract foreign investors. Many are alarmed at the all- too familiar conservative at- mosphere in which criticism is discouraged as irrespon- sible and unpatriotic. The majority is currently accept- ing this state of affairs, despite considerable grum- bling, in part because of the chronic resignation which set in after martial law was declared a decade ago. In this environment, there is a

be a particularly militant source of opposition, as indicated by the lead- ing role they played in several street actions last spring. Working women may become more vocal as they come to see the connection between attacks on their economic interests and the anti-abortion legis lation. While it is unrealistic to think that the union might adopt a pro- choice stance, the pressure applied by union women will be critical in at least preventing the leadership from openly supporting the reactionary legislation. Other allies may be won from among those who are concerned to check the power of the nationalist right wing

The stakes are high; it is not simp- ly a question of restrictions but of loss of one right which is more protected than in the West. The outcome will also be an important indication of whether the new era in Poland will awaken women to the need to or

ganise to defend their interests or will

pacify them as never before.

The answer to that question will

be linked to the larger political

developments, In theory, the disin-

tegration of the old order presents his-

STAYSKAL

I SAW GORBACHEV IN THE

SUPERMARKET. THE BAO NEWS

IS HE TOOK THE LAST

36 CANS OF PORKE

toric opportunities for a social trans-

formation aimed at establishing a true

political and economic democracy.

But in marked contrast to the mass

mobilisation of 1980-81, when the

majority of working people par-

ticipated in constructing a new union

and workers' councils which were to

be the infrastructure of a future self-

managed republic, the process is now

real risk that women will feel defeated by the attacks against them and passively accept their fate. Mass resistance by women is only likely to develop if and when the growing dis

content of all working

people is translated into a

political struggle to

protect their interests.

A general radicalisa-

tion would only be the

first step for women.

Nothing short of

revolution in conscious

ness will have to occur

before the majority of

women will be ready to

take up the fight to

change their position in

society. This will not

happen ovemight. In the

meantime, the projects to

defend women's rights

and change women's

thinking being patiently

pursued by feminists and women's activists may achieve limited yet sig- nificant advances for women while paving the way for development of a broader women's movement. This is just the beginning of a new round in the long uphill struggle for liberation

which women in Poland share with women around the world.

SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 26, July-August 1990

← Rebuild the Berlin Wall? · The shape of 'post apartheid' South Africa →

Something wrong on this page?