Socialist Outlook

Socialist Viewpoint, International, Socialist Outlook and their supplements, 1984–2009

Civic Forum searches for answers and allies

· Socialist Outlook no. 26, July–August 1990 · pp 34-35 · 1,611 words

Civic Forum searches for answers and allies

'Don't

mention

the econ

At first glance the Czechoslovak elections in June followed the pattern of other elections in Eastern Europe, with the ousting of the stalinist party from office and the emergence of a leadership more favourable to western "democracy'. But as COLIN MEADE shows, the results and the situation are more complex, and the position of the working class includes strengths as well as problems.

Civic Forum (OF and its Slovak equivalent.

Public

against Violence(VPN), led by personalities identified with the leadership of the "gentle revolution' in November last year, gained a crushing victory in the Czechoslovak elections on June 8-9, with 46 percent of the vote nationwide on a turnout of 96 per cent.

In second place came the Czechoslovak Communist Party (KSC) with 13.6 per cent, followed by the Christian Democrats (KDU/KDH) with 11.6 per cent. This last result was a bitter blow to a party that had seemed at one stage to be fast catching up on the OF/VPN and believed itself certain to push the KSC into third place.

The OF/VPN did better in the urban centres than in the countryside, and while in the Czech Lands the OF got 53 per cent of the vote, the VPN could only manage 29.3 per cent in Slovakia, although even here it was the largest party, beating the Christian Democrats into second place. The OF/VPN victory was due, of course, in the first place

side of OF/VPN is underlined by the fact that, as the votes for the Greens, and the So- cial Democratic and Socialist Parties declined, so the OF/VPN vote rose.

The KSC will have been pleased with its result, which makes it 'the party of construc- tive opposition in the new parliament. Its voting base is the still really existing bureaucracy, armed forces and police, plus pensioners from all these, and some support in rural areas, where the power structures have been less shaken than in the towns. Its best result was in Central Bohemia where it got 18 per cent.

The KSC will be hoping to pick up fur- ther support from sectors immediately threatened by imminent economic liberalisa- tions. It is also hoping to place itself at the centre of a left regroupment, as the only left party to have got above the 5 per cent of the votes needed to be represented in the federal parliament. The Social Democratic Party and the Czech Socialist Party both failed the 5 per cent test, as did the Greens.

Nonetheless the KSC's historic respon- sibility for the present crisis will mean that other left forces will remain profoundly and rightly suspicious of its motives and objec- lives.

People with a sense of history will know that much of the KSC's present rhetoric about respecting democratic rights and genuine collaboration with other forces can be matched almost word for word from the party's propaganda from the post-war period, before the takeover of monopoly power (the introduction of "socialism') in 1948.

The results in Slovakia were strikingly different from those in the Czech Lands, and of central importance for the future. Slovak national claims have traditionally been

Page 32

SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 26, July-August 1990

FEATURES

treated with dismissive condescension by the Czechs. Professor Masaryk, the first president of independent Czechoslovakia, considered Slovakia 'the natural area for Czech economic expansion' and under Masaryk's First Republic the existence of Slovakia as a separate nation was official- ly denied.

Things did not improve under the Stalinist regime, with a ferocious cam- paign against "Slovak bourgeois nationalism in the 1950s. Despite federalisation in 1969 - a belated result of the 1968 reforms - the Slovak sense of being treated as an appendage has led to a powerful upsurge of nationalism. In these elections the openly pro-independence Slovak Nationalist Party got 11 per cent of the vote, but all the parties, including the VPN ran on an overtly pro-Slovak ticket.

The Slovak question also entails a Hungarian question. Slovakia formed a part of the Hungarian kingdom until 1918 and some 300,000 Hungarians still live in Slovakia. Anxious about the possible consequences of a rise in Slovak nationalism, within which right wing and clerical currents have historically al- ways dominated, many Hungarians voted for a party of the minorities whose leading figure Miklos Duray is ideologically in tune with the OF/VPN.

The great unspoken issue in the election was the economy. The lack of discussion of this was a product of the unanimity of all the political parties on the need for reintegration of Czechoslovakia into the world market. In carly July major price rises will be introduced, with a compensatory rise in wages. State firms are being broken up into 'rational units" which, in the absence of other sources of supply will have to make arrangements with Western - and above all West German - firms: to survive.

Groups of workers will be hoping that such arrangements will lead to higher living standards and a secure future. Yet the first step towards making any deal with a Western firm will be significant productivity improve- ments in the new, smaller, "rational units". Often the workers will exercise their current strength in the enterprises to choose capable managers able to ensure the survival of their enterprise.

The goverment, learning from the ex- perience of surrounding countries, hopes to avoid a catastrophic transition, offering com- pensatory benefits for social rights that are to be scrapped. For example, women, instead of being legally entitled to a place for their children in (low quality) state nurseries, will be offered a financial benefit to use, either to pay for a nursery or stay at home. This will be a popular measure, at least as long as inflation doesn't catch hold, devastating the value of wages and benefits paid in Czechoslovak crowns.

FIX YOUR OWN DAMN COFFEE!

TRATE SEMEN CLECHOSLONAKIAN COMMUNIT PARTY

POLITBURO

The danger is that, in the process of providing a 'choice", the currently existing right will disappear in the framing of the new constitution that will be the first task of a new parliament. Those wishing to oppose the negative effects of the changes will have to negotiate a narrow course between the Scylla of the world market and the Charybdis of ap- pearing to call for the restoration of the dis- credited system of bureaucratic planning

There is also sure to be resistance - for ex- rample there are already reports of opposition amongst transport trade unions to planned fare rises.

An issue that the new government will not be able to escape is the problem of what to do about the secret police and their files. The Bartoncik affair shows that there is plenty of dynamite under the chairs of many in respon- sible positions; and it also shows how a revelation at the right moment can serve elec- toral ends. Only a firm decision either to destroy or open all the files can clear the air.

Other controversies are certain to explode if the OF/VPN decide to make a coalition or rely on parliamentary collaboration with the Christian Democrats. The KDU/KDH will al- most certainly push the idea of a restriction on abortion rights as a price for its collaboration. However Havel's move in reinstating Slovak ex-communist Marian Calfa as prime minister suggests that he continues to believe in an at- tempt to sustain an implicit "historic compromise with the pro-reform wing of the KSC.

The question of the right of 40,000 Viet- namese - already the object of racist attacks by skinheads - to stay in the country will show whether the leaders of the OF/VPN are really serious about humanist principles.

Here also all is not lost. On May 13 An- tonin Hrazdira, the Czech regional interior minister was fired for "passivity in the face of aggression against gypsies and Vietnamese*, an example of serious concem over racist at-

tacks which might be usefully studied by some of the Western goverments that are now lavishing advice on "democracy" to Easter Europe.

It seems certain that the line of divide on these and many other questions will cut directly through the Civic Forum and Public against Violence. Even before the elections there were controversies in the government over economic policy between the finance minister Vaclav Klaus, who wants an im- mediate transition to a market economy and Vladimir Komarck who shows some concern for the social costs.

This division will become much more profound as the economic changes get under way. In a round about way this controversy reflects the conflict belween the democratic potential of the mass mobilisations of Novem- ber and December, and the undemocratic plans and elitist instincts of the arch- marketisers who control many of the key positions in the OF/VPN movement and the government.

Controversy over the economy will also lead to a sharper questioning of the un- democratic structure of the OF/VPN move- ment, where ultimate power resides in the hands of an unelected coordinating committee in Prague. Petr Kuzvart from the Czechos- lovak Left Alternative - Movement for a Democratic and Self- Managing Socialism writes:

*When we look at the different forces within Civic Forum, it is probable that this imposing political force is going to be tom apart, or, at minimum, that it will be reduced by the split of left-wing elements, as well as by groups from the political centre of right' (International Viewpoint no 188, July 3 1990)

In any case these elections open a further stage, and in no way the end of, a profound turbulence in Czechoslovakia, a turbulence that will not fail to send waves through the whole of Europe.

← Don't mention the economy · Food for thought →

Something wrong on this page?