SUPPLEMENT
John Liebenberg/NCCT
Without coherent political leadership workers in Namibia have little to celebrate
Social crises in sub-Saharan Africa have never been so acute. Under the impact of war, famine, rampant despotism, collapse of health and other public services,
and falling unemployment production and trade, hundreds of thousands of people are being systematically killed.
As in the late 1920s, the most acute symptoms of deep economic depression have appeared first on the periphery of world capitalism. Yet, with the exception of South Africa, black Africa is perhaps the most neglected area of international socialist analysis. Apart from a lew small circles of marxists in African cities and in exile, serious political analysis and debate on Africa's crisis has been left to development experts*, aid agencies and bankers.
Capitalist decay
Africa is the only continent where per capita output has declined consis- tently throughout the last decade, ac- cording to the World Bank. Although
by Ben Campbell there are great variations and enor- mous inequalities within African states, average income for each African is now over 50 times lower than the average for people in the OECD countries. Over the same period, Africa's debt has been the fastest growing in the world.(See Table 1) Historical structures of primary commodity export depend- ence have combined with a slump in world commodity prices and Reagan's deficit finance mini-boom during the 1980s (See Table 2). Africa's total debt is now over 80 per cent of the continent's entire produc- tion, and averages 300 per cent of its annual export earnings.
Africa's debt does not directly threaten the international capitalist banking system to the same extent as that of Latin America. This is partly because it is much lower in absolute terms, but also because most of it is not owed to private banks but to states. Nevertheless, in 1988-9 the leading imperialist states, including Britain, made highly publicised
SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 25, June 1990
moves to alleviate Africa's debt after the reschedulings of 1986-7 made lit- tle difference. But the moves resulted in only 1.6 per cent of the debt being cancelled. More likely, the moves were a ploy designed to establish direct IMF/World Bank control of African state economic management.
So far, 30 African govemments have adopted IMF austerity Struc- tural Adjustment Programmes", driv- ing down living standards and privatising nationalised property. Contrary to World Bank assertions, these measures achieved no discer- nable rise in growth. To add insult to injury, for the last four years African countries have paid back more to the IMF than than they received in loans. Rates of capital investment have fal- len and public services have been slashed.
Some 10,000 children in Africa now die each day of causes linked to malnutrition and the non-availability of rudimentary healthcare, according to UNICEF. Each year 150,000 women in sub-Saharan Africa die
"Africa's total
debt is now
over 80 per
cent of the
continent's
entire
production, and averages 300 per cent of
its annual
export
earnings."
Paqe 13
SUPPLEMENT
"militaristic Soviet aid programmes to Africa were cut in line with the declining Soviet economy.
Only Angola and Ethiopia still receive substantial Soviet aid, and this is destined to end in 1991."
from causes related to pregnancy. Declining rural inputs, desertification and civil wars mean that today nearly eight million Africans are threatened with famine, mostly in Ethiopia (potentially worse than 1984-5), Sudan, Mozambique, Angola and Ruanda. Yet the FAO forecasts a global shortfall of food aid in 1990 and a drop in shipments to 17 African countries currently requesting emer- gency aid.
Spontaneous revolts
Falling living standards, corrup- tion and lack of democracy in Africa's one party states have led since late last year to mass revolts across the continent. Spurred on by radio news of events in Eastern Europe, and then by Nelson Mandela's release in South Africa and by the UN supervised elections in Namibia, sections of workers, intel- lectuals and students have been demanding multi-party democracy in Zaire, Ivory Coast, Gabon, Algeria, Benin, Mali, Niger and Chad. Skir- mishes have occurred in Somalia, Tanzania, the Central African Republic, Guinea and Cape Verde.
In most cases, dictatorial rulers at the head of neo-colonial states have tried to seek an accomodation with opposition leaders or groups, but their link to the masses is extremely tenuous. Only the absence of viable political party alternatives and the presence of troops on the streets and campuses has prevented leaders being overthrown. With client trade unions
Rising Debt Ratios
Percentage of GNP
1970
1975
Debt as a Percentage of GP Note: 1990 figures are based on World Bank projections. Source: World Bark (World Debt Tables 1988-89) Published by the UN Department of Public Informati
1980
oy Region clons.
September 1989
corrupted by state and foreign union aid, an average of 54% illiteracy amongst adults, and the loss of about 70,000 administrators and managers during the 1980s, the working class in Africa has few resources to draw on.
Soviet influence in Africa was waning long before Gorbachev's reforms. Disillusioned after support- ing 'friendly' tyrants like Idi Amin in Uganda and Bokassa of the Central African Republic, militaristic Soviet aid programmes to Africa were cut in line with the declining Soviet economy. Only Angola and Ethiopia still receive substantial Soviet aid, and this is destined to end in 1991. With an eye to Wester donors, 'Mar- xist-Leninist' rhetoric has been dropped by ruling parties in Benin, Mozambique, Ethiopia and Congo.
Imperialist troops re-establish a presence
With the 50,000 Cuban troops now leaving Angola, imperialist diplomacy in Africa is the only one backed up by the threat of military ac- tion. Apart from French troops in Senegal, Djibouti, Ivory Coast, Gabon and the Comoros, a crack unit of 1,300 troops from the US Special Forces Group, or Green Berets, is to be reactivated in June explicitly to counter insurgency in Africa. Already Green Beret training teams have served in Nigeria, Zaire, Burkino Faso, Kenya and Tanzania, and Zaire is targetted as the main US logistical base. In April, 700 US troops were reported to be holding manuouvres
1985
1990
Africa, South of The Sahara
North Africa & The Middle East
Latin America & The Caribbean
South Asia East Asia
near Zaire's border with Angolis, where the largest US contra programme in Africa is underway.
Such reinforcements are not yet needed in militarily and economically stronger states such as Nigeria, Kenya and Zimbabwe where dissent has been quicky repressed. southern Africa, despite the presence of the large South African army, with its acquisition of nuclear weaponry, a small presence of British army of ficers is now deployed in a belt across the continent from Namibia to Mozambique, including Zimbabwe, Botswana, Malawi, Lesotho and Swaziland.
Such manoeuvres throw into sharp relief the question of im- perialist plans for South Africa as a regional power. Using Zaire, the American CIA has had to take over from Pretoria prime responsibility for the Unita contras in Angola. Britain is anxious to moderate South Africa's devastating destabilisation of its front line states, especially Mozambique because its ports service most of the neighbouring states. A special role for South Africa as the regional policeman of south-central Africa is sought, but is not yet possible politi- cally.
No socialist response in
advanced capitalism
In the aftermath of the 1960s* flir- tation with African socialism, cynicism and doubt has set in. Labour Party members, West European socialists, independent marxists and stalinists are confused about what to do. The burgeoning charity industry, with its Victorian appeal, is setting the pace with fun runs and sympathy, playing on the fears and hopes of middle class layers and youth who see the global village' cracking. Workers are dis- trustful of the new philanthropists but uninformed of the issues. 'War on Want tried to base itself on the labour movement bureaucracy, and ended up bankrupt.
Undoubtedly.
European chauvinism and racism is a major cause of the disarray. It is common to find socialists in Britain (rather, *British' socialists) who never relate the defeat of modern racism to the so- cial liberation of Africa. For them, equal opportunities policies, original- ly the stuff of the US army in Korea, have become a bureaucratic end in themselves. The actual historical material causes of racism are either not addressed, or are clouded in a lit- tle England' mentality.
SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 25, June 1990
SUPPLEMENT
When international solidarity with Africa is ever discussed, socialists are usually deeply divided, but on a subject they know too little about. Who knows, for example, that a con- stellation of British military training teams now stretched across southern Africa from the Indian to the Atlantic Oceans? Or that the British trade unions, along with the German, US Canadian and Nordic unions, are the main funders of southern African trade unions? Such issues hardly ever come up on labour movement agen-
das. British unionists don't ask COSATU
their leaders to account for how their dues are spent abroad. The Labour Party's
"international' policy debate is a Eurocentric sham and its second Socialist International is a caricature of solidarity
The left have by and large replicated, rather than chal- lenged, the political bankruptcy Workers across Southern Africa must unite of the labour movement over
IDAF
was "too insufficiently ac quainted with the conditions in South Africa' to provide *a full conclusive opinion on
series of practical questions*. Certainly, his vision was couched in terms of some of the backward cul tural notions of the 1930s: *To help the negroes to catch up to the white race, in order to ascend hand in hand with them to new cultural heights, this [proletarian mutual co- operation between black and white in Africa] will be one of the grand and noble tasks of a victorious socialism.*
Clearly, much work remains to be done. In the absence of strong support
from the workers' movement
in the imperialist countries, the relatively small and im- poverished working class in Africa will have grave dif- ficulties in leading the mas- ses to socialist liberation. Faced with ruthless state
Africa. Look in vain through Mar- xism Today or other left publications for a vision which sees how socialist revolution in Africa is possible. At its last conference, leading lights in the Review of African Political Economy, showed a new despair over the simplistic, autarchic (Castroite) solutions that they them- selves advocated throughout the late 1970s and 80s. Although few now believe in Ujamaa villages, most are still wedded to varieties of the neo- marxist school of dependency theory. They have either posed the question of socialism in Africa as a simple country-specific task, usually in populist-reformist terms, or haven't posed it at all.
The marxist approach
One of the only theorists to write seriously about revolutionary prospects in southern Africa as a whole, namely Alex Callinicos of the British Socialist Workers Party, has now limited himself purely to the study of domestic processes in South Africa (see 'South Africa between Reform and Revolution', Bookmarks, 1990). At a time when it is possible that an ANC government in South Africa might soon sit at the head of vital purse strings for workers and peasants from the Cunene River, the Zairian/Zambian copperbelt and Lake Malawi in the north, to the Cape Pen-
ninsula in the South, this is irrespon- sible. In neglecting the regional
dimensions, Callinicos slips back into the thinking of a long line of white South African socialists, whose chauvinism has rubbed off on African nationalists.
When Trotsky received copies of the draft theses of South Africa's in- cipient Left Opposition in 1935, he concluded his written reply by stress- ing the importance of a Soviet South Africa' to *the whole black continent'. And, at the end of his meeting two years earlier with US Left Oppositionists concerning 'the Negro question', he pointed out that the central problem of real colonial liberation in Africa was the lack of support from workers in Europe.
Though much has changed, these general guidelines retain their urgent relevance for socialist revolutionaries TOMORS today; yet they are only the starting point for analysing material condi- tions and specifying con- crete tasks.
Trotsky ad- mitted that he
that
repression, African worker leaders and socialists require support of a special kind. This complex problem should be discussed urgently. Cam- paigns in the imperialist countries against racism, the IMF/World Bank debt regime, primary commodity price reductions, military collabora- tion and in favour of immediate can- cellation of all Africa's debt, democratic trade union inter- nationalism, repect for human rights, ecological renewal and international African representation must begin now. Most of all, support for a democratic socialist South Africa is essential.
Reversing Financial Flows
1983
1960
1961
1982
Flow from South to North
A net drain
Developing Nations: Net Transfer of Ri Sample of 98 nations - covers private drect investment, prate icans, ofcal fow Sevice Un won Econom surely The UN DAMe Pok Wern
Flow from North to South
A positive transfer
IS 196 I toas
SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 25, June 1990
"the left have
by and large
replicated,
rather than
challenged,
the political bankruptcy of
the labour movement over
Paqe 15