FEATURES
The attempted imposition of the poll tax by the Thatcher government has resulted in the develop- ment of one of the most significant movements in British politics for a very long time. The govern- ment has been shaken more seriously than at any time in the last ten years and Thatcher's own
By Theresa Conway
ELB-
position within the Tory party has been jeopard- ised.
But while the movement against the tax has enormous potential, whether it is final- ly capable of defeating the Tories depends to a large ex- tent on the strategies it pur-
sues. There are a number of key questions that have to be Organisation Is needed to turn popular feeling into real power addressed, debated and resolved correctly. The movement must be or- ganised in a way that involves the greatest number of supporters possible.
Terrified of non-payment
Crucial to this are the issues and demands around which action is organised - and that participation at all levels is encouraged. The relationship between the anti-poll tax move- ment itself and the official labour movement must be developed and strengthened. The dead hand of new realism reduces opposition to the tax to a tokenistic level. The trade union bureaucracy, far from welcoming the develop- ment of mass action against the tax, is terrified that militancy on this issue will wreck Labour's electoral image. So both the Labour leadership and the TUC have put far more energy into denouncing non-payment than into mobilising people against the tax.
Opposition to the poll tax is extremely diverse. New forces coming into activity have been hungry for political ideas, and have lis- tened to those that seem to have a under- standing of the way to defeat the tax, and a commitment to doing so. Those involved range from dissident Tories to anarchists, from people who have never been involved in ac- tivity before to seasoned campaigners. But Page 6
within the organised anti-poll tax movement the forces of the far left are relatively strong. Supporters of Militant in particular have key positions of leadership at many levels of the movement, and as such have a particular responsibility for influencing the direction it takes - for better or worse.
Millions have taken action against the tax, in a myriad of different ways - but only a small proportion of these are involved in any ongoing way in anti-poll tax groups. A con- scious struggle is required to maximise par- ticipation and democracy throughout the movement conducting discussions in the most accesible and non-sectarian way possible.
Behind closed doors
The reality is that at various different levels, from small local groups to the Federation's founding conference, there has been a tendency for decisions to be made be- hind closed doors and inadequate opportunity for open debate. While a range of political for- ces have been involved in such manoeuvres it is the majority leadership of the Federation - supporters of Militant - must take particular responsibility for them. Without a conscious struggle against such practices the potential power of mass hostility to Thatcher's tax will
I not be fully realised.
Within the movement there are many dif- ferences about the way forward. Initially the key debate was over the significance of a policy of mass non-payment with forces on the right either seeing this as ultra-left or only of marginal importance. The scale of mass non-payment in Scotland and increasing sup port for such action in England and Wales has succeeded in convincing the vast majority of activists that this is indeed an absolutely cru- cial tool for the movement. Some of those who are unhappy about this direction have drifted out of the movement, either as in- dividuals or because the rival groups they set up have collapsed through lack of support. Others, to their credit, have been prepared to work for the goals agreed by the majority, while continuing to voice their dissent.
Non-collection
There have been sharp debates too about the issue of non-implementation by trade unions and non-collection by councils. Those forces who opposed non-payment as ultra-left- ist law breaking have even more emphatically condemned the idea that either trade unions or councils should take decisive action against the tax. They have pinned their hopes instead
SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 25, June 1990
John Harris (NI
FEATURES
John Harris/Report which has a substantial but not identical on a propaganda campaign against the evils of the tax, and being content to wait NO network of support in the unions, would
NALGO anothe NALO have been a major step forward in
for a Labour govemment.
But even amongst those committed to SaCK
developing a strategy for trade union ac- non-payment, there have been disagree- TORIES.
tion against the tax. Initially there seemed
SAVEOUR
ments. The forces of the soft left have ar- TENEMLES NALGO PUBUC NO to be a favourable response from key
CUTS people in the Federation leadership to
HARVICES
gued that it is incorrect to demand councils
should not collect the tax, and have also TALGO
such a suggestion. Within a couple of
opposed non-implementation by trade Chat MALG
weeks, 50 organisations and individuals
unionists, although they favour various Price Stand
such as Tony Benn and Alice Mahon forms of obstruction. A variety of argu- 4p supported the call for such a conference.
UPLITT Ou
All currents in the London federation, in- ments have been put forward ranging from
cluding Militant supporters had par- the idea that non-collection would result in
ticipated in a very successful local trade the devastation of local services, to the no- tion that it is incorrect to ask individual
union conference which was jointly or- councillors to face the risk of surcharge.
ganised with the Greater London As-
NALGO
sociation of Trades Councils. Such arguments are a repeat of the discus-
But in the end, the majority leadership sion around ratecapping; again the idea of
NOїOв)
the 'dented shield' rears its ugly head.
of the Federation decided to go it alone,
calling a conference in June, and refusing
Differences on the left
CUTS!
to allow the Socialist Movement to par
Within the left of the movement there
ticipate in the organising committee. In have also been differences. The position of
taking such a decision, Militant sup- the Socialist Workers Party (SWP) in par-
porters are throwing away a real oppor ticular has been erratic and opportunist. In-
tunity to build the anti-poll tax movement itially their attitude was typically syn-
in the unions. This sectarian attitude is dicalist; that only trade union action could
even more criminal given their pivotal defeat the tax and that non-payment was
position in the movement. either irrelevant or at best extremely
It is clear that it will be very difficult secondary because it was based in the
to build this initiative adequately in the community not the workplace. The SWP The fight against cuts Is key for the antl-poll tax campaign
unions given the short time scale in completely failed to understand that the
volved. The publicity so far issued for the best conditions for building trade union
I event concentrates solely on the question of action was the existence of a strong, confident,
wage arrestment; thus ignoring other issues - organisation of non-payers which can and will
in particular that of cuts - facing trade support such action. They ignore the fact that
unionists in relation to the tax. And there is a every trade unionist will be expected to pay
fear that the conference will be more of a rally the tax, and will need support not only in their
than a working event based on an exchange of workplace but on their estate or in their street
information and discussion of the next steps in order to resist.
forward. Because of the limitations of the
When it became clear that there was a
June event, the Socialist Movement is going strong mood for mass non-payment existed,
ahead with a trade union conference in Sep they changed their position and began to sup-
tember. port it. But in many areas they have
The conference the Federation is or
and in campaigned on
estates
ganising should of course be supported workplaces, outside the federations or at
by activists in the anti-poll tax move a tangent to them. They have used the
ment and the unions. Any other attitude support that exists for the anti-poll tax
would give the labour bureaucracy movement to build their own organisa-
another excuse to attack mass non-pay- tion not to involve people in the broader
ment and weaken the movement. At the movement. Such sectarianism is highly
same time, there is a need for the irresponsible - it puts the needs of the
Socialist Movement initiative and this should SWP as a group before that of the class as a
be vigorously built. whole. The practical result of activity such as
Unity in action by the whole of the anti- this will be that many people who oppose the
poll tax movement, together with left activists tax may not become involved in the move-
in the trade unions is the only way to defeat ment; others will rapidly become disillusioned
the new realist bureaucracy and force in- by this sort of behaviour.
dustrial action against the tax - a crucial com-
The All-Britain Federation has a formal
ponent in sinking Thatcher's flagship. position of support for non-collection and
So far, Militant supporters have shirked non-implementation, but the reality is that the
many of their responsiblities in leading the majority of the Federation leadership have
movement. The fight against sectarianism, for done little until recently to concretise work
democracy and for a correct understanding of around either. Despite the fact that Militant
the united front will be key in taking the have a significant number of supporters who
struggle forward. Socialist Outlook appeals to are councillors there has been no real push
all forces in the anti-poll tax movement to join either inside or outside the council chamber to
us in the battle for these principles. make this aspect of the campaign more
central. There has been no organisation of councillors opposed to the tax - although moves towards this have recently been made.
But it is on the question of organising in the unions that the greatest problems have arisen with Militant supporters. Over recent months there has been sporadic action by dif- ferent groups of workers against the poll tax, and the growth of mass non-payment in England and Wales begins to lay the basis for further action. Significant layers of trade
"Unity in action by the whole of the anti-poll tax
movement, together with left activists in the trade unions is the only way to defeat the union bureaucracy and force industrial action against
the tax"
union militants increasingly recognise that the
poll tax is a trade union issue and there is the
potential in a number of unions for mounting a I substantial challenge and possibly even
defeating the new realist leaderships on this
question.
Not only in the local government unions, I but more generally in the labour movement an
understanding is developing that the threat to
local government jobs and services posed by
the poll tax must be fought. In this context the
Socialist Movement trade union committee
approached the Federation to propose a joint
conference for trade unionists against the poll
tax.
Clearly a conference organised with the
resources of both organisations, each of
SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 25, June 1990
Page 7
FEATURES
New