Socialist Outlook

Socialist Viewpoint, International, Socialist Outlook and their supplements, 1984–2009

Farewell to the working class?

· Socialist Outlook no. 25, June 1990 · pp 25-26 · 1,952 words

Labour Party Britain

FEATURES

Kinnock's 'final solution' for Andrew Wiard/Report

Jane Wells looks at

party members after the next election.

Despite some disappointments in last month's local elections, Labour Kinnock: on the way to a final solution is still far enough ahead in the polls to warrant serious attention by the powers that be. City businessmen take Shadow Chancellor John Smith to lunch; and a

television documentary examining television Kinnock's suitablity as a resident at Number 10 concludes that he's not a total write-off. Praise indeed.

That's the context for the next stages in restructuring the Labour Party. As the next general election approaches, the leadership's plans to rein in members' involvement - and more importantly deny them any control over policy - come sharply into focus.

This, make no mistake about it, is Labour preparing for govemment. To get elected, reckon the party managers, you have to get the ap- proval of those who count in opinion- forming: journalists, industry and the city. This you do by achieving 're- spectability and by responding (by giving in) to any criticisms they may have of your policies or party. Naturally, left-wing policies are out (unilateralism, economic planning and public ownership, trade union and minority rights). And, crucially, party structures have to be changed, to transform Labour from its working class roots into a full bourgeois, so- cial democratic party.

In many respects Kinnock is well on the way to achieving his aims.

Since he took over as leader he has over- seen the reversal of many key policies through the mechanism of the policy review. The crea- tion of the National Constitutional Committee has ensured the snag-free prosecution and ex- pulsion of scores of socialists from the party; and the previously independent womens' and youth organisations have simply been abolished and replaced with entirely leader- ship-friendly structures. Control is increasing-

working

class?

ly centralised: the national membership drive now means new members come through head office first; party officers and publications are loyal to the leadership or dispensed with; regional conferences stick to regional discus- sions only.

Party democracy has come under attack too. Kinnock has so far managed to get his way on replacing the selection of prospective parliamentary candidates by General Commit- tees with a local "electoral college'; and he has ensured that challenges to his leadership within the Parliamentary Party will be less ef- fective, with more MPs now required to re-

Tame Fleet Street reporters duly regur- gitate publicity supremo Peter Mandleson's double-speak under headlines like 'Labour members to have more say on policy-making - when of course the changes will result in just the opposite. A membership pacified by Thatcherism and New Realism, and increas- ingly excluded from any real say in policy making is expected to toe the line as it has done to a large extent over the last five years.

Kinnock can only get away with it as long as the membership let him. But whilst factors out there in the real world - the balance of class forces - have allowed Kinnock to put

the party into reverse on policy, he has

also used the opportunity to introduce

fundamental structural changes which

will protect his policy shifts when

members become more confident and

organised again. That is why the cur-

rent priority for Kinnock is organisa- tional changes - self protection - and why the fight for the left at this, and probably next year's conference, will centre on protecting party democracy

The working class has got to go, is the ad- men's main message. Even though the pollsters are now telling us that Labour is win- ning the C2 (skilled working class) vote, it looks better in the papers if Labour isn't too closely linked with the unions.

This means that moves are afoot to ex- clude unions from choosing parliamentary candidates, through the introduction of selec- tion by 'One Member One Vote' to replace the electoral college (similarly for the election of party leader); and to reduce their block- vote share at conference. More votes for con- stituency delegates at conference has long been a demand of the left: Kinnock's sudden conversion is more a sign of his willingness to move to a social democratic model than any

"The NEC has assumed an unprecedented political

and organisational weight in the party, allowing

the leadership to initiate policy, and giving the

NEC a wider range of executive powers"

quest a challenge, and with the introduction of "One Member One Vote' for the CLPs in any election.

The NEC has also gradually assumed an unprecedented political and organisational weight in the party, allowing the leadership to initiate policy, with the membership forced to respond, and giving the NEC a much wider range of executive powers - including the now routine practice of choosing or even imposing candidates in by-elections.

There is much more of the same - and worse - to come, though.

Next on the list and most dangerous are the fundamental - and perhaps irreversible - refors planned for discussion at this year's conference, with implementation to stretch over the next few years into the next parlia- ment. All are subject, in theory, to consult- ation - but Labour's leaders, through Wal- worth Road press briefings, have signalled their priority 'hidden agenda'.

SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 25, June 1990

Page 23

FEATURES

notorious pre-1981 days when a GC

vote of no confidence was the required

Labour

trigger-mechanism for reselections,

there hardly were any. When a vote did

go through, as in the case of Newham

North West MP Reg Prentice (later to

become a Tory Minister), it took years

of internal battles before he could be

ousted.

If the NEC gets its way on this

there will be no more reselections,

meaning no new women or black MPs

and the domination of the PLP by white

middle class men will be guaranted

well into the next century.

Andrew Wiard/Report to make things up as they go along:

Most importantly, Labour MPs in a

Labour Govemment would be at liberty

conference (whatever may be left of it)

policy commitments can be torn up.

No reselections, no party account-

ability. Members will be powerless to Pleased to have ditched the working class

insist that party policy is observed.

It is an almost inevitable consequence of Kinnock's "electioneering by proxy', with only opinion-formers (and not the working class) in his sights, that top-down reforms, in- troducing top-down democracy with little say for the rank and file, must follow.

Insofar as there is such a rationale, or grand plan behind Labour's lurch to the right, it is misguided - even if vote-catching is the only immediate and ultimate aim.

Protest voting

Labour's current lead in the polls is evidence surely of common sense (and Mar- xist) psephology: voting behaviour (and politi- cal belief) is determined more by experience than ideas. Interest rates and high poll tax bills have much more to do with current protest voting than any positive approval of the vague package of policies that constitute Kinnock's new realism (although tragically, he will un- doubtedly make political capital from the coin- cidence).

That evidence leads some on the left in the party to conclude that oppositions don't win elections, but govemments lose them. True enough, to a point. But it is a serious mistake to go on and argue (as some do) that the argu- ment over policy and democracy can be kept 'in the family' of Labour loyalists, and that you lay the groundwork for left-wing policies not by campaigning now for socialist politics, but by refining party procedures to make sure the structures for accountability are there ready for when the left is on the up again.

It's a tall order, but we need an approach that embraces and builds on the experiences of the struggles that working people face every day, and brings them into the party to join the fight for working class democracy. Labour Party Socialists, as part of the Socialist Move- ment, is an attempt to build such a campaign- ing approach.

concem to take note of the members.

Reducing the weight of the block vote has to be accompanied by an increase in a passive party membership, and a restriction in members' say over policy, if Kinnock is to continue to get his way. Press reports indicate that Walworth Road is looking to cut the trade union share of the vote at conference to, ini- tially, 70 percent, with further reductions as individual membership increases. Easier said than done; a miserable recruitment drive com- plete, with targetted mail shots and credit card incentives, has met with limited success. Nevertheless, changes to policy making procedures are coming in thick and fast.

Consensus not class politics

Speaking at a recent meeting of Tribune Group MPs, Kinnock loyalist Tom Sawyer was reported as claiming that the policy review had been by far the most successful format for policy-making to date. He went on to argue for a revised structure which would involve a more "sifted' gathering of delegates (from regions, unions, PLP, shadow cabinet etc) who would develop policy in commis- sions, reporting to conference on a two-year cycle. I see this as particularly important when Labour is in office' he said, in a rare mo- ment of straight-talking.

This proposal is at the heart of the NEC's 'Future of Labour Party Conference' consult- ation document, and success on this is key for Kinnock. What party managers want is con- sensus policy developed at the top, and delivered ready-packaged to the members and the media: no more rows, or embarrassing in- cidents when the members propose policy or try to make up their own minds.

The replacement of conference as we know it by a highly centralised, stage-managed talk- ing shop would effectively cut out members completely from policy making.

Short of such a complete overhaul though,

there is a 'Plan B'. This involves a series of measures, all of which will restrict democracy and carve members out.

Resolutions and even subjects to be debated will be sifted through regional con- ferences or specially created bureaucratic com- mittees. CLPs will no longer be able to submit amendments to resolutions; this would cut their participation by half (whilst at the same time, the NEC could be given new powers to amend CLP resolutions!). Rule change resolu- tions will not be allowed except at rules revision conferences every three or four years. And changes to NEC elections to prevent MPs standing in the constituency section will en- sure that left candidates have little chance of getting elected.

Many if not all of these changes, described by Party General Secretary Larry Whitty as mere "tinkering" amendments, will be put before this year's conference. As with the policy review, conference will have no right to amend the NECs proposals. Once passed, rule changes would then be put to the first con- ference after the general election. Only two NEC members voted against the package: Dennis Skinner and Tony Benn. All this

means that a Labour Party in Govemment will

have a free rein on policy (most importantly to impose an incomes policy): members and the unions will be powerless to object.

"Vlembers Only': An end to

accountability

It is in this context that the move to make reselection of sitting MPs more difficult, and to reduce accountability of MPs by the intro- duction of 'One Member One Vote', comes sharply into focus.

Yet another "consultation' document from the NEC proposes that in future, sitting Labour MPs will be subject to reselection only if a majority of members agree to a contest in a postal ballot. On past experience, from the

Page 24

SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 25, June 1990

← Equal pay for women – but not at men's expense · Caught between the army and Sendero →

Something wrong on this page?