DEBATE
In the last issue, an in Depth article by Will McMahon summed up Socialist Outlook's analysis of the Nicaraguan election defeat. Here, GARETH MOSTYN challenges aspects of that analysis, and argues that the emphasis of the article leads to losing valuable lessons. Will McMahon's article can be sum- marised as saying that the main reasons for the defeat of the Sandinistas were:
1) The Sandinista National Liberation Fron (FSLN) were out of touch with the
people.
2) Lack of direct democracy (recallable delegates, workplace elections, a supreme council elected from mass organisations, and so on't
2) Too much of thEm. the nands of the bourgeuisie: less given to them wich sen a revolution.
surces were undermine the
For these sort of criticisms to be useful to the Nicaraguans or the British, they have to be put in the context of international solidarity. This means more than a position you adopt or a sentence that you tack on to the end of an article: it is something you feel. and that inspires you.
Inspiration is every bit as important as the correct politics; neither one is much good without the other. A movement like ours needs to be able to capture the feeling of hope and identification with the struggle in Nicaragus, and to express the despair that was felt at the clection defeat, while pointing the way forward. We have to be able to do all this and at the same time maintain a rigorous analysis and critique.
I found Will's article very dry, academic and uninspiring: so for those in Brilain who are moved by the Nicaraguan struggle I think its criticisms will have fallen on deaf ears.
Solidarity is not just about offering state- ments of principle about standing with the oppressed against the oppressor. We also believe in the self-organisation of the op-
believe in the self-organisation of the op- pressed: so who do we offer both solidarity and our criticisms to? Will Mc- Mahon aims his criticisms squarely at the FSLN, while the solidarity is aimed at the people. The result is ambiguous.
We do not want to see a bashful support for "Nicaraguan workers and peasants': we
BOUt suarelv
OUT Mc
it the
Page 28
want to see unconditional support for their organisations. proclaimed loud and clear. Criticism should be in that context. The failure to show this kind of solidarity to the San- dinistas makes the criticisms look like conditions, almost as if we were saying our support for the people would be support for the FSLN - if they adopted the follow ing policies. Yet solidarity for the people that by-passes the Sandinis- ta organisation is an illusion, un- less you can explain the nature of the solidarity; it represents no more than opposing the interven- tion of the USA into other countries.
This brings us to the content of the criticisms. Will is quite wrong to put so much emphasis on the FLN heing out of touch with the people. We should have an ideal of socialist democracy, and see how the Sandinistas example compared with it: but we must also learn how the Sandinistas maintained such a high level of mass par- ticipation in such difficult conditions.
Anyone who has IncU to bund democratic structures, whether in a union, a Labour Party, or a mass campaign will be familiar with the problems. Getting regular attendance of more than 30 percent even for shap foor issues, let alone national issues can be difficult. Will's article unfairly sug- gests that the FSLN deliberately held hack democracy.
It is true that there was a night level of criticism of the Sandinistas. This was a good sign. If you set profound goals and high standards for democracy with limited resour- ces, you will get genuine criticism. Many of us are familiar with this. The tough lesson for us is how can the rest of us win the kind of sustained participation of a significant proportion of people - in the way the San- dinistas did?
The key issue that affected the course of events in Nicaragua was the economy. The worst problems faced were caused by over S0 percent of the Gross National Product going to the war, and the effects of the US trade blockade. In the last few years the Nicaraguans suffered 36,000 percent infla- tion and massive austerity. No other govern- ment could have won 40 percent of the vote after presiding over such an economic dis- aster.
Would those people who voted UNO have voted FSLN if there had been a dif- ferent type of democratic structure? No, we
Out of touch? Sandinista leader Ortaga
must argue for socialist democracy without using it as a stick to beat the Sandinistas with.
The question of the economy is difficult We should not listen with a more favourable
ear to all criticisms of the mixed economy just bocause they fit in with our theories. As we know, a badly-planned state cconomy can easily produce worse results than the ef-
fects of a tracherous bourgeoisic. I beheve
that large-scale expropriations would have
had a long-term benefit, but brought short- term setbacks. Nationalisation was by no means an easy solution.
What is clear is the need to devclop an economy that runs in the interests of the majority of the people - the workers and peasants. This will never be achieved in the long run if the major economic decisions and investments are made with a view lo secur- ing the profits of a small minority.
What we need is an in-depth coonomic balance sheet of the last ten ycars. 1 believe that the Sandinistas will leam the following lesson: that the contradictions between a stable bourgeoisic and a government that serves the interests of the people become greater the longer that government remains in power. If the government does not develop a momentum in opposition to the bourgcoisie, it will become weaker.
The Sandinistas have many gains of the revolution to defend. They have the ability and the mass organisations necessary to do so. They also have an experience of the armed struggle unknown by any previous revolutionary opposition. Let's hope that they never give up their arms, and never have to use them. We want to see them back in office with the necessary backing to move forward once more:
SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 24, May 1990