Socialist Outlook

Socialist Viewpoint, International, Socialist Outlook and their supplements, 1984–2009

Thatcher's nightmare

· Socialist Outlook no. 23, April 1990 · pp 9-11 · 2,779 words

Britain Trade unions Scotland

nightmares. It is delighting to see the

Poll Tax dream, Thatcher's "flagship', create the deepest crisis yet for

a government that, throughout the last ten

years, always seemed one step ahead of

Even the mos dedicated Poll Tax cam- paigners are now hemused at the seeming in- competence of the govemment's introduction of the Tax Into England and Wales. We we working day and night to reap the benefits of the massive upswell of opposition that has

swept across the country, from Tory shire to

councillors stole the show from Labour councillors' generally

tintid: opposition to the Tax. Brighton's Tory ex-leader resigned. Sir Mar-

SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 23, April 1990

Enx; wce-chair of the back-benen

ommuttee, talked of Tory MPkneig. drans: from the Pall Tax levele set -

constituencies Tory MP, Anthony Marlow. Jeclared 'we risk being confronted by a mas-

sive and unchallengeable campaign of civil

dischedience!. Thatcher's lesdership is now

ve ana uncl

being widely and seriously discussed inside

top Tory Party circles. And so it goes on. If we didn't have to keep an eye our for our own ranks and Labour movement leaders it would

Tanta 2u

Tory Part

FE BITE

all he a joy to behold.

neliold

So what went wrong for the Tories? !! seems they forgot one of the most basic politi- cal rules for introducing a new tax: "start it with all generosity. They may have heen con- cerned at the public spending figures that the Chancellor announced in last year's Autumn

2111 т0 statement

mas

rads.

quar

They may have been frustrated that extra

money made availahle for the intanduction of

Pall Tax in Scotland war used not to bring

Poll Tax levels down but to keep service

levels higher than they wanted. The gover

ment were certainly blamed for the high levels

of Poll Tax anyway. Whatever the reason, the

Tories are trying hoth to introduce the tax and

In squeeze council spending at the same time.

While the govemment tried to relieve the pressure on individuals by giving slightly more "generous (7) rebates than originally

gevins slichtly "han originallv ‹ DreNsUTe Ci I10

councils, blithely confident that high Poll

Taxes would be immediately blamed on the

Taxes would be immediately blamed on the local, especially Labour, councils.

The Standand Spending Assument levels that wete announced implied a 4% increase in spending, enough in the government's mythol- ogy to maintain this year's spending pius in-

mcrease in

‹mythol-

plus in-

Page 7

FEATURES

flation. With hindsight this was enormously

Kinka ie wat énormously preposterous levels of Poll Tax. The same In- nayers. Al pre

payers. At present public meetings on estates

senendent survey showed that 50 percent of can attract hundreds of working class people. stupid. Wage costs for councils alone in- creased by twice that amount. Inflation is con- theme saked would support copping even if

all of whom are angry and defiant about Poll

Tar. But tuming this into permanent organisa siderably higher than 4%.

meant cuts in their services.

tien, and expanding the active base of the

But the problem is how to devise a capping

There are other factors too, but the result is

anti-poll tax movement is a much more dir that the average Poil Tax is E370, at least £100 stem that hits the Lahour councu

ficult job. over the predicted level, and that the political ravine the Tory councils largerv wtow complexion of the council has made little diE-

is difficult to see how this can be done, given Terence as to whether the target figures for the Torv In fact, while Anti-Poll Tax unions must

he built wherever possible, socialists should

not allow this vital work to subsitute for the

fight to commit the existing organisations of

the working class to a real struggle agains the

GETSDIE

Then

that the -

.art

Poll Tax have heen overshot. There are at least

S0 Tory councils that are above the target

Penalties.

'The cenalty svstem is const

whole by the

councils overshoot the government targets, the

whole cost of that "overspend"' will be borne

by the Poll Tax payer. A 'gearing' system ea

"argers. u

be bone

sures that for every 1 percent "overspend the

Poll Tax would rise by 4%. This is why the

Poll Tax levels are on average 30 percent higher than the targets, while average spend- ing has only gone up hy 7 percent. It is known

as making the Poll Tax 'sensitive" to spending as making the decisions. and was designed to make the provision of local services as costly and un- popular as possible

It hackfired. Tory as well as Labour coun cils - and most importantly the Poll Tax payers are overwhelmingly branung the government for the high Poll Tax levels. An opinion poll in the Independent March 17 showed that 48 percent of the population

blamed the government. for the

levels, while a further 36 percent blamed both

the govemment and the councils equally.

No way out

It is quite obvious that the Tories. do not

know how to get themselves out of this mess

With inflation running high, and the Poll tax

POLL •

sur this foe-mas Pon THe Wi.... Pull Tar leve:- ar

levels, the gov

With atlap nu

... Juads.

about to add a full percentage point to it, with mortgage rates crushingly high, the political atmosphere throughout the country is becom- ing noticeably more hostile to them. All the predictions are that the Mid-Staffordshire by- cloction will show a mass desertion of skilled workers and home-owners from the Tory voting runks. They are in big trouble!

If the Tories attempt to keep next year's Poll Tax at this year's levels it would cost them around f3 billion, with an additional El billion for each further 230 reduction. But this means taking from the Chancellor's shrinking financial surplus, and by 1991 the Tories are going to need a nice big tax cut to stand any

chance of winning the next election.

Of course, even if they did make this

money availahle there is no guarantee councils

will use it to bring the Poll Tax down rather

wilh political

7Te11-

monev avanan will use it to than use it on services. That is unless the Tories use their powers to cap the councils.

Capping is in the air at the present. It is uscful because all the government bas to do is say to a council "No, you can't spend that much money! You must spend this much less!!. Then it can sit back. It doesn't have to make the decision as to what services are cut,

-VEN sle there

ncile

hung u

.. That .......

ap the

un tpo au the e

• Then

make the um hut it migh protecting the local

• spend mat

tdreen t hava

servicee am rul

• some Cical or population from

'overspenders", and that anomalies exist such as the fact that while Haringey's Poll Tax at £572 is presently the highest in the land, it is actualiv El below the target! Anu of en

capping would represent a major political retreal from the "principle of the Poll Tax. that the electorate should judge and if neces

y vote out a profligate count

ahlems may prove insuperable

with.

Squeeze

The end goal of the Poll Tax is not simply to impoverish and financially crush thr population: this is only a means to the end. The idea of the Poll Tax is to squeere people en hard that they squeeze the councils, and that councils squeeze the jobs and services.

The purpose of the Poll Tax is to destroy the remaining elements of collective provision councils maintain. And along with other chan-

ges, such as ringlencing housing finances so as to raise rents, it represents a huge escuiation of the Tory's drive for a world in which "there is no such thing as society, there are only in- dividuals and their families'.

So what of the opposition to the Tax? March has seen a huge mushrooming of the campaign against the Tax, given focus by the Poll Tax setting meetinge in England and Wales, and the emerging facts ahout the levels of non-payment in Scotland. The latter are trucly impressive and give the lie in those who claimed that the initial levels were no more than could be expected under the old rates sys tcm.

Figures compiled for Strathclyde Regional Council show that summary warrants have al- ready been issued to 352,745 poll tax defaul- ters, and that a further i0,428 are lu be issued. Even then, a further 48,583 people are at least three months in arcars. These figures include 146,129 people in Glasgow who have heen is- sued a summary warrant, an incredible 30.2 percent of the population! When the number of people in serious arrears is added, a total of 205,140 or 42.5 percent of Glasgow's popula- tion is reached!

Non-payment

It ix likely that non-payment in England and Wales will reach similar levels, if not The tidal wave of opposition thrughout the country has noticeably in- creased the confidence of people passing the innumerable anti-poll tax stalls and defiantly declaring "Poll Tax! I'm not puying that!"

The question will be whether these people are organised, and whether the Anti-Poll Tax Finions can build solid support among non

aTE-

-ITIONS

der-

TONE SINEE

Tradi

unil

Poll Tax. The Labour Pruties and the unions hold the key to defeating the Poll Tax, even if the Anti-Poll Tax unions and campaigns are making the running at present. There are a number of reasous why this is so.

Tre

The final target of the Poll Tax is to cat

jobs and services. Unfortunately Thatcher has

one major ally as levels of non payment build

up. That ally is the councillors, both Tory and shamefully. Labour. Quite simpiy, Thatcher is

sp. 1L...

ametl.... Lah

Jas und

relying on Labour councillors not to fom a united front with the anti-poll tax campaigns

against the government, but to pass the cost of

through cuts in services, back onto the con

united Erro non-payment an to the

cas camp igns

rass the curt of workforce, and

aie se uis B00

for exampo gas "ut

500 jobs. By the end of the year, when non- collection rates reach 20-30-40 percent, coun

deficits. Will they balance their books through

Itm patH

shesr bocik

sener перок tes 10°

Front line

zovemment "ade

determin-

Tae want w

councils get away with this. At any rate they

will be on the frontline. It seems that the

NALGO bureaucracy has suddenly realised

something has to be done, having just decided 1o spend €250,000 from the political fun for a campaign against the Poll Tax in the run up to the local elections. But it is action that is necded, firstly in defence of jobs and condi- tions, and secondly in solidurity with the com- munity that faces the Poll Tax.

Those inside the National Federation who argue that first you hulld the non payment

councils get away with this. At any rate they will be on the frontline. It seems that the

campaign and then you have the basis for

going to the trade unions and demanding non- collection are wrong There will he

the no payment

have the .... lor

van There was he sme

run thor relundancy nolices

wir get their Poll Tax

ion against the Pou Tax has

THSs workere at the

waunst beane forced

• will Tax regIster.

on irone n

I STELAY

trike. In Tax workers themsel the aracinian candie

tions a panicking management have imposed.

But the Poll Tax is designed to put a

man' have

designed to put a

mons and the local

ne Tones will be

wedge between the trade unions and the local community. For example, the Tories will be

Page 8

SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 23, April 1990

FEATURES very quick to calculate the Poll Tax cost of any wage claim made by local government workers and attempt to whip up community oppostion to such claimus. To combat this the trade unions need to give ahsolate solidarity to the community as it faces the pressures of Poll Tax.

Community support

They need to be declaring real opposition to forcible registration and fining. Ultimately non collection of the Poll Tax must be posed. This is a strong basis for the trade unions to go to the community asking for support when their johs and conditions are attacked. What would he disastrous is if the local government unions started to argue for higher poll taxes in order to protect their jobs.

This mistake has also been made by some "lefts" in the Labour Party. Lambeth council's "left" leadership argued for a preposterous level of poll tax on the grounds that "services had to be defended'. The fact is that services cannot be defended without fighting the poll lax, that poll tax represents a savage 'cut" in the living standards of local people.

The Lambeth stance would also place Labour Parties well outside the radicalisation

that is occurring on the Poll Tax, and which that is occurne should and could revifalise a beleaguered left inside the Party, by fighting for non-payment

enghting for non-payment

and non collection, ingether with fighting cuts. We are at the heginning of a real mass

curx. We:ar

movement. possibily the largest campaign of civil disobedience involving the working class

vi dischenic

• ampaien " working clas

thee sec Latiour Paren

this side of the Second World War. If the

Labour Partien are to stand in front of this movement and argue for either cuts or high poll taxes they will get short shrift.

this

Of course the Labour Party leadership has other plans. They do not want the Poll Tax to fall through mass action; and their alternative is not credible.

This is the fundamental reason for their hostility to the modest proposals to hold a na- tional demonstration - lost hy one vote on the NFC, on the excuse that they couldn't afford it! But they also said that the Poll Tax coulda't be changed until two years after a Labour government was elected, and Peter Shore told us on television that a Labour government would fine those who did not pay.

They have concurred with the Tories in condemnation of the 'violence" that has ne- curred on some of the lobbies. Two things should be said on this subject. First, the media have deliherately exaggerated the level of trouble, and dowplayed the role of the police, to take the heat off the Tories. Second, given the abject fnilure of leadership by the Labour Party and TUC to lead a fight, it is hardly surprising that some people get frustrated

The people who should be blamed are the very people who are shouting the condemna- tions loudest, the Tories, whose Poll Tax it is, the Labour and TUC leadership, and of course the Labour councils who have met behind lines of police, doors, and security guards. The

SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 23, April 1990

POLL TAX

14*

POLL

Don 1 collect

Poll Tax. They have generally been small

minoritics, but we need to bring them

together.

The anti-Poll Tax movement shows no

signs of retreating, and it is difficult to see a

way out for the Tories, Suddenly people are

heginning to think that they can win this one!

That represents a huge step forward for all of

us who have been fighting the Tories for ten

years and known very little except defcats.

Socialids must ensure that millions of

working class people who are squcezed dry by

the Poll Tax find a labour movement willing

and mobilised to fight for them. The Tories

are in disarray: We should add to their

problems. Their nightmare will be our victory.

John Tuite

Page 9

POLL TAX

Don 1 collect

"dented shield" strategy now has new meaning as Lahour councillors vote for poll taxes be- hind riol squad formations!

Inside the Anti-Poll Tax campaign there are some healthy signs that the various cur- rents are beginning to work together. In par- ticular, inside the National Federation, and certainly on a London-level, supporters of Militant have at last begun to seck a unified movement taking in the various different strands that have so far been working around the demands "Don't Pay, Don't Collect"

Both a national trade union conference and a campaign inside the Party is rapidly re- quired. The left inside the Party is still half-as leep on this question. On another level, some councillors have taken a principled stand on

max now meanie or poll taxes be

They

but

have generally been small wenced to bring them

← THE POLL TAX · The men who sprang George Blake →

Something wrong on this page?