Ecology:
Anyone familiar with the writ- inge of Edward Goldsmith, or who saw his Fragile Earth presentation, could not have failed in notice the energy and passion with which he presented us with his vision of paradise: Ec- topia
The inhabitants of Ectopia
live in a communal, pre-in- dustrial sexier. mony with nature (Gaia). Goldsmith claims to draw in- spiration from Gandhi and a whole host of traditional cultures.
With revolt
Goldsmith points the accusatory finger at "multinationals" "goverments" and the World Bunk as culprits and co-con- spirators in the catastrophic destruction of many of the world's ecosystems.
He claims thar 'development"
and 'industrialisation" have heen responsible for the horrendous consequences of debt and de- pendency of many Third World" countries. He rightly points to many of the massive problems facing humanity: global wam- ing. rapid deforestation, widespread famine, and increas ing desertification, that threaten our global future. He shows how ill-conceived and large scale development projects have often caused wide-spread and long- tem suffering for many millions of people, whilst the benefits of this development are directed towards the few.
The unswer according to Mr Goldsmith, is simple: we must de-industrialise society, and retum to stability and nature. This is the path to Ectopia. But. let us look a little deeper. What we are being offered is atempt- ing mixture of revolutionary
change and deep con- sorvatism. As an ideol- ogy, this has some interesting historical parallels.
According to Mr Goldsmith: Man (sics: when or- ganised into a vernacular society and when ohserving the tradition- al laws of hix society, as they
have been by untold generations of his ancestors, is an integral part of Gaia. Such societies have
co-evolved with the ecosystem
so as to fulfill their differentiated
functions within its hierarchy. They thereby contribute to her overall stability and are subject to all the laws governing life processes on this planet.
He also cover The most fun- dumental ecological knowledge is aquired through intuition, and that "Ecology is emotional". For him, 'Garan systems are or- ganised to form a hierarchy or homearhy", and therefore: "Man when organised into the institu- tions that are essential to the tech- nosphere is no longer a member of the vernacular society, nor in- deed of the Gain hierarchy"
Progress that is technological is intrinsically anti-volutionary. and an anathema to living within the "Gaian hierarchy". We have created a surrogate world that is usurping the natural wisdom of the cosmos, and obviously, we as human beings are paying the price.
Such ideas can be compared with another idcology that has, at times, captured the popular im- agination in vanour countrier. with disastrous consequences. It started with the European Komantic tradition. This tradi- tion looked to the 'natural, or- ganic community as described by Tonnics. This was taken up
enthusiastically by Fische and Hereder, who looked back to medieval times when everyone lived in a natural, stable and or- dered hierarchical society, where everyone "knows their place".
Increasingly, the irrational, in- tuitive component of 'human nature" was seen as the driving force of human behaviour. 'Community, was therefore a safe, traditional, humane and in- timate existence, where the ills of industrialisation had no place. It was a populist vision of heaven on carth.
The concept that held this together was that of the Volk. On a popular level, the Volk could simply mean "the people', but on the ahstract level it could mean a
'system of absolute values, im- mutahle metaphysical idea of peoplehood. Between theae two meanings there was much room for ambiguity, and even room for a mystical interpretation, giving (for those with the intuition) ac- cess to the "innermost will of nature'
The final (and most success ful) synthesis of these views and social Darwinism was made by Hackel. and represented whist has been referred to as "proto Nazi volkism". This new syn thesis prided itself on the modemity of its views and laid the foundations for the National Socialist doctrine.
The most extreme interpreta- tion was developed by Hitler. who took Social Darwinism to its logical extreme: the race war. Hitler's followers believed that industrialisation had nothing to
offer them, and they folosed the politics of mass despair, an or ganised tyranny of irrationality
against the mind. Ar Sauer pointed out: "Since the procees of industrialisation as a whole was irresistable, the existence of civilisation is inextricably bound to it. Facist revolt against in- dustrialisation muxi, therefore,
lum against civilisation too.
According to Hitler, there
was a 'natural hierarchy of races, and a 'natural hierarchy"
within the race as well, with the Fuhrer at its head. Coincidental ly, and conveniently for Hitler, he and the Fuhrer were one and
the same.
Throughout the whole of 67 Principles' concerning The
Way", not once does Goldsmith mention democracy. Indood in principle 6l he states:
" In a Homeolectic socicty, the units of political activity, like those of economic and tech- nological activities coincide with the natural social groupings, the family, the community, the soceity itself. There are no for- mal institions or governments.
The elders, and in some cakes the chiefs, are first and foremost
citizens - that is differentiated
macabers of tie social sys-
tem..their role being limited to enforcing the traditional Law that which ensures social homcol- ty, and that which thereby best helps maintain the critical order of the Cosmos.
This synthesis of what is es
sentially a "Volkish" philosophy with environmental determinism is essentially fascistic. Are we
Pane 32
SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 23, April 1990
REVIEWS
really to do withnut kidney machines, computers, telecom- munications..?
The middle ages were not spent in an advillic communion with nature, They were hard times; the mortality rate and the suffering that the common people endured were horren- Jous. Was that really Ectopia?
Do we really have to go back to the time when the forces of natural selection could work freely on humankind? And even if de-industrailisation was a valid proposal, how would it be acheived? There are huge economic and political interests that would ensure that it did not happen.
The Deep Fcologists remain remarkably silent on the issuc of their political programme They find coccion unpalatable. But while they complain bitterly about the presence of left wingers inside the green move- ment, they say nothing about ex- treme right wingers- despite the fact that the National Front has launched its own organisa- surface. tion Green Wave
Goldsmith's own rocond is instructive. He founded the
led thin
magazine The Ecologist- funded by his younger brother.
James Goldsmith, who happens to be one of the world's largest Financiers. The ECologist is printed uxing tried and tested in- dustrial processes. Mr E Goldsmith has a telephone and of course a low-tech, labour-in- tensive, anti-industrial fax machine.
When he made his Fragile Earth programme, did he usc recycled cameras and film? When globe trotting to Malaysia, Sni Lanka and India, are we to believe he travels by dug-out cance? Obviously not.
You could call it cynicism, but 1 am sure that Jumes Goldsmith has realised there could be a profitable (in terms of removing competitions sior to any attempt at de-in- dustrialisation.
The Deep Ecology sejection of industrialisation, its world view and its apocalyptic vision of where present trends are lead ing, make comparisons with fas
cism unavoidable.
Pulling those
I punches
politica
Born on the Fourth of July Film, directed by Oliver Stone, starring Tom Cruise
Kovik's words, it suggests that the Vietnamese NIF was a brave resistance force deserving of victory. This was the best political scene in the movie, cast- ing shame on all previous Vict- nam films, which tend to show, with implied outrage, the brutality of both sides in the war but firmly give the edge on cruel- ty to the Vietnamese.
Nevertheless, these scenes are minor events in comparison
dramatic effect without raining too many cynical cycbrows shows how heavily these films rely upon the collective am
nesiac idcology of American audiences: it is vitally important that political parties andin- dividual Presidents are scen to be at fault rather than the system
Reviewed by Adam Lent
Vietnam movies have a paradnsical effect on the film makers of Hollywood:
The horrific war is a subject so weighty in its moral and his inrical implications for the USA that it always seems to wrench brilliant artistic el- fors from directors, actors
and cinematographers.
And yet, as serious al- tempts to understand thie politics of the war, and the
system that caused it, the
films harely even scratch the
as a whole.
Born on the Fourth of July. like all previous Vietnam movies, draws its dramatic im-
pact from the
siege mentality
the USA has nur
tured since World
War Two. Despite
condemning the
"reds under the
heds syndrome of
the fifties, it is
only because of
the Langer ap-
proach that Hol-
lywood can still
chum out successful movies
about the occupiers of Vietnam. and never show the faces of the occupied. For the same reason Hollywood feels comfortable making endless films about the whites of South Africa.
Of course one cannot deny that a hefty dose of racism also plays its part in maintaining this weakness, but maybe with the collapse of the Cold War, Hol- lywood will tentatively begin to explore the issue of Vietnam in a more serious political fashion. Maybe the tiny hints of radicalism in Stone's latest film will become major thematic con cems in the Vietnam movies of the future? We can only hope.
m on the Fourth on
July is only a very minor ex-
ception to this rule. It has all
the qualities expected of an
Oliver Stone movie: actors giving their utmost, war scenes of great beauty that somchow maintain their traumatic impact,
consistent attention to detail in sound and scene, and the meliculous, uncompromising analysis of the lead character's thoughts and emotions.
Politically it is undoubtedly an advance on pictures like The Deer Hunter and Full Metal Jacket. Born on the Fourth of July only pulls its political punches: other Vietnam movies don'teven bother to throw them at all. In some ways this makes the film even more depressing to walch.
One is allowed a hint of a radical theme - only to see it buried under the safer, but ul- timately impotent, views of liberal America. A black hospi tal orderly tells the initially gung ho Kovik (Tom Crujse) to shove his Vietnam "up his ass", while another explains that he cares nothing for the conflict bocause it is a "white man's war".
The film also takes a surpris ing step foward when, through
Protestors burn draft cards - under Johnson in 1967
to the overall message of the film. This message, like Stone's Salvador, argues that if "we" (the American people) can find it in our hearts to fight the cor rupt governments which betray the grand ideals of the Founding Fathers and the Constitution, we can truly create a good America where Vietnams don't happen.
This is most evident in a real wimp of a scene at the end of the film. Kovik is about to ad- dress the 1976 Democrat Con- vention after a long crusade against the war. The welcome is warm, unlike the protest he makes carlier in the film at a Republican Convention. A reporter asks how he feels. Kovik replies - to accompany- ing shouts of "right on!" and "way to go!" - "At last, I feel like I've come home".
Maybe I'm too pedan- tic, but wasn't it the Democrats, Kennedy and Johnson, who actually sent the US tmops into Vietnam in the first place?
The fact that Stone feels this denoument will have the required
..um out suc.
We welcome letters on
any subject: but please
keep them brief! Letters over 400 words will be cut. Send to Socialist Outlook,
PO Box 1109, London N4
2UU
SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 23, April 1990
Page 33