Socialist Outlook

Socialist Viewpoint, International, Socialist Outlook and their supplements, 1984–2009

Irish women: up against the church

· Socialist Outlook no. 22, March 1990 · pp 20-22 · 2,279 words

Ireland Women

SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 22, March 1990

Page 17

SUPPLEMENT

RAPE!

Beth Ridgel

Contraceptive Action Programme (CAP) protesters demonstrate aginst restrictive family planning

against the power of

"Irish women have suffered qualitively more setbacks than any other section of Irish society"

Page 18

Irish women have suffered quali- tively more setbacks than any other section of Irish society.

There has been a vicious attack on women's rights in the 26 Counties, while in the North the nationalist population has been confronted with attack after attack on their basic rights. Women's rights in Ireland are in any case quite limited in com- parison with the rights in mainland Europe.

The sustained attack against women has given rise to an uneven response. What I want to concentrate on is the question of abortion. In 1979 Family Planning was legalised. Ob- viously people were using contracep tives before then, but it was not actual legal. After the right wing had lost the battle to keep out contraception, they moved on to abortion. The Irish Preg- nancy Counselling Service and other centres were at that stage giving in- formation so that women could come

Ann Conway

(People's Democracy, Ireland) to England to get a safe and legal abortion.

What the Society for the Protec- tion of the Unborn Child (SPUC) at- tempted to do then was to bring in a constitutional prohibition which would allow them to legally challenge abortion in the courts. Abortion itself was already illegal in Ireland, but their fear was that this would be changed. They succeeded after one meeting with government ministers in getting a constitutional referendum. That was in 1981, and there was a period of political instability around that time since a number of hunger strike and H-Block candidates had taken seats in Dail, taking a substan- tial number of votes away from the main bourgeois parties.

The idea for the referendum ac- tually came from an international conference of doctors in Dublin where some American doctors met with some of our leading obstetricians

and decided they needed to take up the amendment campaign. They decided that rather than leave SPUC to front the campaign it should be headed by professionals and 'experts" - people who would appear removed from the issues of sexuality and morality involved.

So the campaign was run essen- tially by them - trying to give it some kind of human face, pretending that they were really interested in women's rights. The other side of the campaign was weak. The women's movement was involved, but it was mainly taken over by quite reformist sections who didn't want to raise any issues that could be regarded as too feminist or radical. So they never at- tempted to take on the Church who were backstage using the pulpits as a political platform and encouraging people to vote no.

They didn't have it all their own way. Only 45% of the people turmed

SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 22, March 1990

SUPPLEMENT

out to vote on what was a hotly

debated issue - which had school

children and youth talking about it. The question of abortion was actual- ly discussed widely, making their victory a rather shallow one since the matter would have had less attention if they had not gone on the offensive.

There was a 3 to 1 vote in favour

of the amendment, so we now have a constitutional amendment copper- fastened to the constitution, and we will have to remove that if there is ever to be new legislation to permit abortion. Now personally I don't believe that we shall ever see abor- tion in Ireland until partition has been removed: and it is possible that we will not see divorce in Ireland until the removal of British im- perialism and the partition settle- ment, because the partition is based on the power of the Catholic church. It's based on the political establish- ment, and the possibility of removing those things can only really arise in the situation where there's a real change to build from. That's not to say that it's not an issue on the agen- da for feminists. It certainly is.

During the Amendment Cam- paign, SPUC spokespeople said they weren't going to touch the women's clinics; they weren't interested in preventing women having abortion information; that they were really only interested in the rights of the unborn; that the situation as it presently existed would not be inter- fered with. They waited two years before they actually took a legal case against the women's clinics, and I think the fact that they had to wait so long showed that things weren't real- ly going all their way. The courts ruled in favour of SPUC - declaring that clinics were actually helping women to procure abortions in Britain.

Unfortunately, the court judge- ment was given against a background of defeat in the divorce referendum, and I mention that because, if it had actually been in an earlier stage, the result might have been quite dif ferent. Garret Fitzgerald had actually called for a referendum on the divorce issue. Before the referendum there was something like 70% of the Irish people who were actually in favour of divorce. The government that called the referendum refused to campaign on the issue, completely absented itself from any debate, and let the right wing take over.

The forces who were organising to demand the right to divorce were thoroughly divided, and were not

prepared to take on the power of the church. The argu- ment, the defence, was left, as it was in the anti-amendment campaign, to legal experts - to lawyers, doctors, to that par- ticular group.

Though it was a debate about women's rights in both instances, but it had very little relationship to the reality of our lives.

I think it's just worthwhile reading what was a pretty vi- cious judgement: page after page reiterated the right to life of the unbom.

Abortion was seen as wrong and evil in all circumstances. It was said to be contrary to national policy, con- trary to morality, contrary to common law, statute law and the constitution. It went on to state that consequently the right to life of the foetus, the unbor, is afforded statutory protection from the date of its concep- tion. I think Ireland is the only country in Europe in which we actually have that sort of situation.

Now that was a

real victory for SPUC. The women's

movement did respond immediately.

but it wasn't a sustained response,

principally because the clinics that

were involved, against whom the

judgement was made, didn't really

want any public protest campaign. In

fact they weren't too sure if they

even wanted to appeal immediately

after the judgement: it was a very weak response.

That really tended to take the

steam out of the women's movement

and create some sort of confusion as

to where we would go. And of

course there wasn't that much sup

port coming from the traditional or-

ganisations on the left. The trade

union movement were opposed to the

judgement from the point of view of

civil rights, and that was very good.

And so was the Irish Council for

SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 22, March 1990

Civil Liberties, the Workers Party, the Labour Party, and the Republican movement: but there wasn't any real concrete support coming through from any of those organisations. The political forces weren't there, in any sense other than much very paper support, so it was left up to the women's movement. With the refusal of the clinics to confront the issue themselves, they backed off.

So it was mainly a small group of feminists who consistently cam- paigned on the issue, both in Dublin and in Belfast. There were quite good relationships made between women in the North and South in relation to the issue. The students were the main force who actually took up the campaign. They started campaigning on the issue in the col- leges, at conferences and and meet- ings. What we've seen in the last

Soviet anti-abortion poster; Children are the flowers of our lives "the right to life of the foetus, the

unborn, is

afforded

statutory

protection from

the date of its

conception. I

think Ireland is

the only country

in Europe in

which we

actually have

that sort of

situation"

Page 19

*Obviously the

next few months are going to be hard. We hear that Cosmopolitan magazine, which publishes an Irish edition, will no longer carry information on abortion for sale in Ireland"

20

SUPPLEMENT

The judgement was a another setback for the cam- paign, and the fight goes on. But it is difficult to organise around court judgements be- cause the initiative can always be taken awy from you. I would be especially foolish for us to rely on the European Court because absolutely

Court because absolutely nothing positive has come from the European Court to Ireland. In terms of EEC directives, the only one that has actually been imple- mented in Ireland turned out to be negative: in changing its policy on social welfare pay- ments for married and cohabiting couples the Irish government reduced its pay ments downwards, rather than lavallino. unt

Roisin Conroy (front left) won a High Cou women were entitled to state benefit

couple of weeks is that the students' unions who have actually been giving out abortion information to women have been taken to court, and threatened with jail sentences. They actually stated that they were prepared to go to jail, and that they had lists of hundreds of people who were prepared to fill jails behind them.

The problem that we've been con- fronted with each time is that the fight has always been around court battles: this is the third battle we've had in relation to the courts. it confuses people to have to wait for a judge- ment before we can decide where to go next. A month ago the High Court decided not to convict the students. Previous to the court hearing they had been saying that people can't go around breaking the law, they can't be giving out information, the rights of the unborn must be protected - and then they saw the mobilisations - that a lot of people were actually coming out supporting the students.

Some Dail deputies, particularly from the Labour Party, some from Fine Gael in an individual capacity gave support; some union bodies passed resolutions and put out a state- ment. But it was the militancy of the students that pushed it all on. They decided that the judgement was basi- cally in their favour, and that they would continue to give out informa- tion until the matter went to the

European Court. SPUC were devas- tated, and appealed again. Last week it was debated in the Supreme Court, and the background to the hearing was not as positive as it had been six weeks before.

The students made the mistake of trying to deal with the matter simply inside the student movement, not call- ing on other political forces to give out the information. This is extremely important: I myself have been in- volved in the defend the clinics cam- paign, and I work at the Dublin Well Women centre, so I know the reality of what the law means in terms of women not being able to get proper information about abortion.

There was a short debate among the students on whether other or ganisations should give out the infor- mation, and ikt was said that if the Labour Party (or for that matter the Republican movement or the trade unions) wanted to give out the infor- mation it was up to them: the students would not urge them to do so. But it was not possible for the students alone to maintain their position: they began to become isolated. Some stu- dents in the colleges started calling for a referendum, so we now have a situation where in three of the main colleges the students have been voting against giving out abortion informa- tion, so the situation has slipped back and ths students are now on the defen- sive.

So we haven't gained so-

cial parity with any of the

- European countries. Progres-

& sive legislation that has been

implemented on the continent

has meant little to Ireland. But

for women there is a positive

influence from the European dimension, from our relationship with other countries, especially Britain where women have the right to abor- tion under the 1967 Act.

Irish people's attitudes are chang- ing: they are looking to the future, breaking with the church on many is- sues. Obviously the next few months are going to be hard. We hear that Cosmopolitan magazine, which publishes an Irish edition, will no longer carry information on abortion for sale in Ireland.

On the other hand there are posi- tive developments - the organisation of a fightback against cuts and attacks on public serfvices. It has been women who have been the backbone of this response, women working in the health service as nurses, radiog- raphers and domestics; women teachers defending education; and mothers in the community.

Community women have played a very big part in the demonstrations of up to 50,000 strong against the cuts. We need to make some kind of link between the right to abortion informa- tion - the right to women's reproduc- tive rights - and the fight on these other social and economic issues. If we can build this alliance there is the basis for us to win.

(Speech given at Socialist Out- look Rally, London, December 1989)

SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 22, March 1990

← Whose Social Charter? · USSR and E. Europe: Facing the Abyss →

Something wrong on this page?