FEATURES
er sanctions, immigration c
and 1992
By Steve Cohen
Pother
HANG
HUNGE
STR
170IVC
One struggle: Turkish workers in Hackney on hunger strike in solidarity with Turkish struggle
"Equally important would be a check on the employment of over- stayers. A Department of Employ- ment witness told us that The TUC has expressed concern about illegal working by immigrants, especially in the hotel and catering industry, and the government has made it clear it shares that concern' and is keen to take some action to control illegal working.
"The Home Secretary has under- taken that there will be consultations with both sides of industry about what steps to take. The Department appears to have been dilatory, and accordingly we recommend that, as a matter of ur- gency, the government, after consult- ation with both sides of in dustry, should introduce measures, if necessary by legislation, to provide effective sanctions against employers who knowingly employ overstayers and illegal immigrants.
"But, as a Department of Employment wit- ness explained, 'a difficulty is that there is at present no comprehensive system of documentation in this country recording iden- tity and immigrant employment status, so there is no way in which employers can distin- guish applicants for employment who should not be legally employed".... We therefore ... recommend ithat the government should in- stitute an independent inquiry to consider the system of interal control of immigration."
The above are paragraphs 88 and 89 of the First report of the Parliamentary Select Com- mittee on Race Relations and Immigration, which was published in 1978 - under a Labour goverment. It supported and legitimised much of the tightening of im- migration restrictions that has been imple- mented by the Tories over the last decade.
For example, the Committee made the recommendation that 'the police, the Immigra- tion Service Intelligence Unit and other authorities should be afforded substantially more resources to trace overstayers and tackle all aspects of illegal immigration; that the department of Health and Social Security in- troduce without delay new procedures to tighten identity checks'; and that "the govern-
ment give priority to their consideration of British Nationality Law*: the Thatcher govern- ment has since obliged on all counts.
Employer sanctions
Paragraphs 88 and 89 relate to employer sanctions: under the 1971 Immigration Act it is a criminal offence for a person with leave to enter Britain to work in breach of any condi- tions restricting their employment. It is not a criminal offence as such for an illegal im- migrant to take employment - though the entry itself can attract criminal liability.
In a little-publicised section of the 1988 Immigration Act, people refused entry but given "temporary admission", and also those subject to notice of deportation, may have conditions against employment imposed upon them - and breach of these conditions can be a criminal offence. In practice, police and im- migration officers frequently conduct raids on factories and business premises in search of il- legal entrants, overstayers and those working without authorisation. In 1980 in London in just one month there were raids on the Be- staway Cash and Carry, the Hilton Hotel and the Main Gas Company. Two national union leaders, Moss Evans of the Transport Workers (TGWU) and David Basnett of the General and Municipal Workers (GMB) issued a joint stalement saying that black workers would now have to carry at all times their papers
proving their right to live and work here. This is a situation more reminiscent of the apart- heid system in South Africa than of Great Britain'.
The raids have intensified throughout the decade. On March 2 1989 police raided several sweat shops in Hackney and arrested 37 Turkish workers. However it is still not a criminal offence to hire undocumented" labour. Such criminalisation would be ex- tremely reactionary. It would have the effect of making employers the agents to enforce immigration controls - in just the same way as the 1987 Carriers" Liability Act, by imposing fines on airlines carrying "undocumented" passengers, has tumed carrying companies into a private arm of the immigration service.
Inasmuch as the use of unlawful labour in certain sectors of the economy, notably cater- ing and garment manufacture, depresses the wage of all workers, then the answer is not the criminalisation of employment but the
employment but the unionisation of all workers and a struggle for better conditions for all.
Now with the attempt to hannonise EC im- migration laws by 1992 there is a serious danger that these employer sanctions may be legislated in Britain. In fact in 1978 the European Commission produced Draft Direc- tives on immigration, of which Article 3 declared that:
Page 28
SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 20, Dec-Jan 1989-90
FEATURES
Mexico.
*For the purposes of preventing and detect- ing illegal migration and illegal employment,
The most frequent justification given for
employer sanctions was that they would save member states should organise adequate con- trol, especially of employers and persons and
jobs for Americans". Likewise in this country. undertakings supplying manpower to third
a common racist justification for immigration parties.
controls has always been that black people
"take our jobs. In fact the campaign for the
In its Explanatory Memorandum to the:
Draft Directives, the Commission
US Immigration reform and Control
Act was thoroughly racist. Restric- stated that:
* In particular, as regards the or-
tionist groups such as 'Americans for
Border Control worked closely with ganisation of controls, the Commis- sion is of the opinion that effective
key members of Congress.
Central Americans - and Asians - control at the internal frontiers of the Community is becoming more and
were linked in the media with drug
CAN BE LOS
smuggling and other crimes. They more impracticable. This will become
FOREVER
increasingly the case when the Com-
were characterised as people with munity establishes a Passport Union
high fertility rates and cultures strong-
ly incompatible with US ways. Head- and abolishes all internal control on
lines in the popular press in support of Community territory. It consequently underlines the necessity for providing
immigration control absolutely paral- checks on non-Community labour at
lel those found in the UK - for in-
stance "legal Aliens Swam the place of employment".
Mongrelises Our Strain', and *Flood
In its own expalantory statement on the Draft Directive the British
of Aliens Coming Our Way'. INS
Western Regional Organiser Harold Home Office declared that for the UK "Legislation would be required to
Ezell issued dire warnings that "those make it an offence for an employer to
who are invading this country by feet employ a person who may not take
are going to overthrow what we un-
derstand and enjoy as a culture. the employment in question. To make
Senator Alan K Simpson, the main such an offence effective it would probably be necessary to place upon
sponsor of the new Act, himself used the employer a duty take the language of war when he intro- reasonable steps to see that his
duced the slogan "To regain control of
our borders. employees had permission to work, and to provide machinery by which
In reality employer sanctions could he could do so
never - even if this were their true in-
tent - "save jobs for Americans". This
The US Immigration
is because the demand for immigrant
Reform and Control Act
labour in the USA is structural: cer-
Whole Industries depend upon cheap migrant labour
1986
tain sectors of the US economy,
This is the most extensive harden-
notably the so-called secondary labour market, ing of US immigration laws since the Mc-
are dependent on cheap undocumented labour. Carren-Walter Act of 1952. It is aimed against
These sectors include food processing and migrants and refugees from Central America,
packing, catering, light manufacturing, house and contains many repressive measures. It ex-
and office cleaning, parking and garage ser- tends the criminal law in relation to illegal
vices, building maintenance and sub-contract entry, particularly in respect of the transport of
garment manufacture - even baby-sitting. If alleged illegal entrants once inside the United
employer sanctions were consistently enfored States itself. It vastly increased the budget and
then these sectors would be decimated. personnel of the Immigration and Nationality
Enforcement of employer Service (INS) - including a 50 per cent in-
sanctions crease in the personnel of Border Control.
Sanctions are enforced - but in a selective
However the most significant feature of the
way. The main aim and effect of this is to un- new Act was the introduction of employer
dermine labour organisation through rendering sanctions - alongside a bogus "amnesty'
undocumented work even more vulnerable for scheme. As such it is a likely blueprint for im-
the employee. Certainly there have been many minent changes in UK immigration law.
cases of firms being fined for employing un- Employer sanctions in the US in fact consist of
authories workers: the Western Regional INS a complex cluster of provisions, of which the
office, which covers Califomia, Arizona, main ones are the following:
Nevada, Hawii and Guam, imposed S1 million
• Graduated civil penalties (up to $10,000
in fines in a 2-year period. However a more per violation) ad criminal penalties (higher
frequent practice is for the INS to use its fines and up to six months imprisonment per
powers to inspect 1-9 forms and then arrest violation) for those who knowingly hire an
workers for false documentation, whilst ex- *unauthorised alien' after November 6 1986
cusing employers on the grounds that they had (when the Act was passed);
acted in 'good faith'.
• Employers are required to verify the
documentation of identity and immigration work authorisation for cach newly-hired employee and to keep a record of verification - the Employment Eligibility Certificate, or so-called 1-9 form. The Act imposes penalties on employers who fail to fill out the 1-9 form and save it for possible inspection for a mini-
mum of three years after date of hire or one year after date of termination of employment, whichever is the later.
An employer would comply with the employment verification system and avoid all sanctions if the employee documentation reasonably appears to be genuine and is believed 'in good faith".
• The Act gives the power to the INS to inspect 1-9 forms at any time, without a war- rant.
• it also provides for fines and imprison- ment (up to two years) for employces who use fraudulent documents in respect of indentity or immigration work authorisation.
Racism and economics
US employer sanctions have sweeping im- plications. Since November 1986 every worker applying for a job has had to have, as a matter of law, his/her immigration status checked by management. Central Americans regard the new Act as a particular threat. A Houston school teacher described how One of my students came in and said My dad says we have to leave because of the war'. I said 'What war?" He said The war against
SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 21, February 1990
Page 29
This is what happened in Chicago in 1988
when a factory with 126 employees was
raided, with 122 being arrested. Moreover
management often uses the threat of employer
sanctions either to discipline or actually to
sack workers. Soon after the Act was passed
an official of the Interational Ladies Garment
Workers Union said "We've had several cases
of threatened firings'. Employers have
engaged in mass dismissals of workers and
replaced them with others brought in from
abroad on short-term government contracts. In
California, following a mass firing of Latino garment workers, thousands of Filipino women were imported, who would work for even lower wages than the undocumented.
This reveals the flip side of employer sanc- tions, namely the creation of a "guestworker" layer of imported labour that is totally under the control of the employer by being im- mediately returnable on termination
termination of employment. This is the same as the notorious "gastarbeiter" system prevalent today in West Germany, and which will be extended throughout Europe by 1992 with the har- monisation of controls.
In the USA such a guestworker class be- tween 1942 and 1964 undermined the farm workers' unions, with Mexican agicultural labourers imported under what became known as the "Bracero" programme. Indeed the 1986 Act allowed for the reintroduction of short- term contracts under the so-called H-2A agricultural workers" programme. Dolores Huerta, vice president of the United Farm Workers Union said of H-2A: "The INS has been working hand-in-glove with the growers since day one'.
The Amnesty
Integrally linked to the employer sanctions provisions of the 1986 Act was the granting of an amnesty to illegal entrants. This purported to give legal status to those who could es tablish that they had entered the US prior to January 1 1982, and had lived there con- tinuously since; or to those agricultural workers who could prove that they had worked for at least 90 days between Novem- ber 1986 and November 1987.
This "amnesty" was spurious. It gave protection to relatively few and created dangers for many more. The cut-offdate of January 1 1982 was itself quite cynical, since the majority of refugees from El Salvador ar- rived after that date; death squad activity in El Salvador only came to a peak in late 1982, and "counterinsurgency" bombings terrorising the region only began in 1984.
Also the US amnesty had all the legal and practical limitations of the temporary amnesty which applied in Britain in 1974. The US am- nesty did not apply to anyone who had entered the country lawfully but had then overstayed their leave. More important was the question of how to prove that an illegal entry had taken place prior to 1982. Entire undocumented
Page 30
FEATURES
Expelled as economic migrants: Boat people in Hong Kong
communities found themselves caught: as
found themselves caught: as most undocumented people are paid in cash, never fill in income tax returs and never make purchases on credit, they had to rely on employers and past employers for the papers they needed to legalise their status. The employers, fearing reprisals from the Internal revenue Service demanding back taxes, often refused to give the necessary documentation.
The amnesty split families, some of whose members arrived before 1982 and others after. This happened to the Herrera family from El Salvador: Carlos fled in 1981, but his wife, Celfa and children, only managed to get out in February 1982. The INS made a deportation order against Celfa and the children.
As with immigration laws generally the amnesty has generated a parasitic group of "immigration advisors' charging large fees for bad advice. Latinos in the USA call such people 'abogangsters" - coined from the Spanish word for lawyer (abogado) and the English gangster".
In two respects the US amnesty was even worse than the one in this country. Firstly, the government demanded a fee, $180 for adults, $50 for each child, and an additional $75 man- datory doctor's bill. Secondly, the INS regula- tions defining the terms of the amnesty ex- cluded anyone "likely to become a public charge" - and those who did receive amnsety were rendered incligible for most forms of government welfare for five years, This provision affected women in particular, espe- cially single mothers and those who wished to leave violent marriages. Even in the UK. where the "no rcourse to public funds' require- ment runs through most immigration law, such a criterion was not applied to the 1974 amnes- ty.
ty.
Most organisations in the USA which op- pose employer sanctions also opposed the am- nesty on the grounds that it as bogus, divided documented from undocumented workers, and
led to further govemment and employer con- trol of migrants. This control became obvious after May 4 1988 - the final date for amnesty applications.
Throughout May 1988 INS agents boarded Chicago Transit Authority buses and detained suspected undocumented passengers. EL Heraldo, a Spanish newspaper in Chicago, called these raids "gestapo-like". The INS had claimed that information obtained on legalisa- tion applications would not be used to deport anyone if the application failed: in practice ap plicants for amnesty, even successful ones, were at risk. In March 1988 the INS raided the Swift meat packing plant in Des Moines, ap- parently after first checking the 1-9 forms with the management. 17 workers were ar- rested for working with false documents - though the firm was not charged with any- thing, It was later revealed that many of the 17 had amnesty applications pending. Non- etheless they were charged with having previously used false Social Security cards. One INS agent is reported as saying "Just be- cause you are an applicant or have been given amnesty, it doesn't mean we aren going to forgive your past sins".
At the moment several other EC countries
- most notably France - operate employer sanctions. With the projected dismantling of intemal EC borders, such sanctions are anyhow the most obvious method for the capitalist class to control immigration and im- migrant labour.
The US experience shows what this will mean in practice, and how even a 'sweetener' such as an apparent amnesty scheme can also tighten the screw on immigrant workers. One measure which would make employer sanc- tions even more viable would be the introduc- tion of a system of national identity cards. Several organisations, not least the Police Federation, are already campaigning for this.
SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 20, Dec-Jan 1989-90
REVIEWS
DAVE PALMER assesses some of the last books published in the 1980s
An Injury To All - The Decline of American Unionism By Kim Moody Verso £9.95 Moody, from the staff of the Detroit-based Labor Notes, provides a comprehensive (and Trotskyist) history of the US labour movement from Truman to Reagan.
Against the Tide - Diaries 1973-76 By Tony Benn Hutchinson £20 Part Three of the Benn saga, and the best bit so far... Those well- known horrors of the last Wilson government (and why Benn ended up meeting people like us!).
New Times - The Changing Face of Politics in the 1990s By Stuart Hall and Martin Jacques Lawrence and Wishart, £9.95 A suitable gift for any preten- tious, shallow cynic in your life. A collection of crass writings from Marxism Today to make anyone choke on their Sunday lunch!
Intifada - Zionism, im- perialism and Pales tinian resistance By Phil Marshall Bookmarks, £5.95 The SWP takes on the Intifada in Palestine: *one solution revolution"?
Critique of Economic Reason By Andre Gorz Verso, £9.95 Leading post-industrial, post- marxist thinker Gorz on 'the ter- minal crisis of a system where every activity and aspiration has been subjected to the rule of the market. I'll buy that! "Gorz's greatest work, and a crucial book for our time, alleges Le Monde.
up the old decade
India's Struggle for In- dependence By Bipim Chandra Penguin, £5.99 Highly recommended history of the Indian independence move- ment, which makes extensive use of primary material.
Coming on Strong -
Gay politics and cul- ture Edited by Simon Shepherd and Mick Wallis Unwin £8.95 Collection of inter-disciplinary essays on the situation of gay men.
Preserving Disorder: Selected Essays 1968- 88 By David Widgery Pluto £8.95 As l am sure you all know, David Widgery writes for Socialist Worker: good reading for the less sophisticated ultra- left.
Cricket By C.L.R. James A&B, £5.95 Had to include this, given CLR's recent demise. For the sportier marxist who has not yet read it. Beyond the Casino Economy - Planning for the 1990s N. Costello, J. Michie, S. Milne Verso, £8.95 The first really serious attempt for a long while to draft a proposal for a democratically planned economy under a Labour goverment. I'm sure it's flawed: but then what isn't? Sacred Elephant Heathcote Williams Chatto, £9.95 "Nature's blasting, billowing Ar- changel- A land-manatee A land-siren A land-whale, For all you eco-softies... the fol-
low-up to the Whale opus. Red- Green alliance anyone?
FICTION:
Foucault's Pendulum By Umberto Eco Secker & Warburg, £14.95 Ideal companion volume to the Marxism Today collection. Sal- man Rushdie has alleged that it is unreadable twaddle: I couldn't understand enough to be able to disagree. It just happens to have topped the best-seller list. Libra By Ron de Lillo Penguin, £4.99 Now in paperback, De Lillo's book takes a trip through the inner lives of those involved in the event that obsesses the USA ... the Kennedy assassination. Alleged to be 'the novel the shaken American psyche has been awaiting for 25 years". How can you resist?
A frightening glimpse into
Labour's future
Has Conference a Fir ture?
Pamphlet available from CLPD/LLL, 10 Park Drive, London NW11 2SH. Single copies £2.50 incl postage, bulk orders E2 each plus postage.
Reviewed by JANE
WELLS
As the Labour leadership prepares to chop up the labour movement into little pieces so that it can never be put back together again, the Campaign for Labour Party Democracy and Labour Left Liaison have produced a new pamphlet defend- ing conference democracy.
•Much is at stake - not just the future of Conference but also I of the Party itself, says the pamphlet's introduction.
Exactly so. Even if Labour Party procedure and constitution is not your first love, it's worth
struggling through the dense and detailed analysis, argument and proposals contained in Has Con- ference a Future?. The pamphlet is CLPD's response to the proposal by the GMB's John Ede monds, agreed by the 1989 Con- ference to review conference structures, and the NEC's so- called 'consultation document" on the "Future of Conference'. It's truly frightening.
If the leadership get their way, we could be going along every two years to a set piece per- formance staged for the press, with subjects for debate deters mined and sifted by party managers, with plenty of time for NEC members and MPs to sound off, and with permanent, hand- picked 'policy review commissions" setting the real agenda. We will be electing an NEC guaranteed to be 100% leadership-friendly. Party mem- bers will be reduced to making tea at fundraising jumble sales in-
stead of policy.
CLPD have produced an ex- cellent document, with critiques and suggested responses to each * of the NEC's proposals, and they highlight the "hidden agenda". too. As such, the pamphlet is an invaluable tool in fighting the right in the Labour Party, and to give them credit, CLPD are probably the only organisation in the labour movement currently prepared to mount such al response at this level.
Unfortunately CLPD et al mistake the Labour Party for a proletarian and potentially revolu- tionary party, and therefore see this kind of exercise as the end (defending and improving its hest clements) and not the means (to superceding it with something infinitely helter and truly revolu- tionary in potential). This limits their horizons and ultimately the success of their short-lemm siralegy.