SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 20, Dec-Jan 1989-90
DEBATE On THE BILL
The two main
positions on the Embryology Bill spelled out 1)
57188
REVERSE THF
GILLICK RUV
Like Gillick, the wacky right cannot accept any form of women' sontrol over fertility or reproduction
The Human Fertilisation and Embryology Bill, introduced into parliament in November last year, is an attack on women's reproductive rights. While it's clear that the ruling class doesn't agree on some of the issues in the Bill, including the use of an amendment to restrict time limits for abortions, none- theless, the Bill as a whole represents a right wing attack on a woman's right to choice.
The ruling class are divided over a number of issues in the Bill. These divisions are part of the contradictions faced by the ruling class over the whole question of women and work, the family and sexuality. The changing demography of Britain means that it is neces- sary to draw more and more women into the workforce, albeit in low-paid, part-time jobs and with flexible work patterns. Providing workplace nurseries is only part of the social adjustment necessary to facilitate this. For while the family remains the place where the reproduction and servicing of the labour force takes place, the demand for more working women means that control over this process, including control over contraception and abor- tion are also highlighted.
The Bill itself is not centrally about abor- tion; indeed some members of the Govem- ment, notably Kenneth Clarke, are unhappy that it is to be amended in. Nevertheless stop- ping embryo research altogether or restricting it to 14 days, does have implications for abor- tion rights. It has always been the argument of the right-wing that the embryo/foetus has rights from the moment of conception. To restrict research to 14 days capitulates to that view.
But the right-wing is divided further on other questions in the Bill. For example on the question of Donor Insemination (DI). The Bill sets up a Statutary Licensing Authority (SLA) to license and oversee a code of practice at
clinics for donor insemination; all very vague and no doubt deliberately so. But Tory right winger Anne Winterton wants precision. Her amendment will ban DI for lesbians and single women.
Despite that fact that the number of les- bians seeking Di is very small (for the good reason that DIY is easy) the far right are not content with the vagueness of the Bill. They also suspect that uniting opposition to the Bill will be made more difficult if one of the groups targetted for attack is lesbian mothers. However the right-wing's obsession with "family values" means thay have also attacked single mothers, making the group much larger. While there is not a very strong tradition of defence of women's different needs and rights by all women, it doesn't mean it can't be achieved.
While there are some positive elements of the Bill, for example the section on surrogacy. (Clause 32) which states that such arrange- ments are unenforceable; and while we would obviously support 14 days as opposed to no embryo research at all, overall the Bill should be opposed as an attack on women's reproductive rights.
It narrows choice, gives the embryo rights which could lead to further attacks on aborion. The SLA will undoubtedly attempt to stop any DI to other than heterosexual couples, leading to the closure of clinics, restricting choice fur- ther. If the Bill passes the 'no embryo re- search" position, then the important work on genetically inherited diseases will be under- mined.
Jane Kelly
2) Socialists must