Socialist Outlook

Socialist Viewpoint, International, Socialist Outlook and their supplements, 1984–2009

Tories in turmoil

· Socialist Outlook no. 20, December–January 1990 · pp 12-14 · 2,543 words

Britain Economy Unemployment

Every week seems to bring more bad news for the Tories. JANE WELLS tries to catch up with the crises and find out what's up.

The anniversary of Thatcher's decade in power earlier this year marked what is starting to feel like the beginning of the end for Conservative rule. A month later in June, the Tories lost their first national election since 1979, winning only 34.7% of the vote against Labour's 40.1% in the European election and losing 13 of their 45 seats. It's been downhill for them ever since.

Now, 'old' ideas, long discounted by the right and happily discarded by even some of the fashionable 'left' in the labour movement as outmoded romantic notions, are coming back in favour again. Examples include strikes (the summer of discontent has led even the AEU to call out members), and now troops are on the streets running ambulances for the first time in 10 years. Another unfashionable item has also reappeared - the working class -

Page 10

plenty of them in the streets of eastern Europe; and even the possibility of a Labour government in Britain.

Clearly, Labour's new-look electability is in a large part due to the poor performance of the Tories. Problems have been piling up for Thatcher: not just the electoral defeats, resig nations, internal rows and public sniping. It goes deeper than that.

At the root of Tory troubles is the crisis in the economy. The Government's ability to buy off, sell off and mortgage bits of it, and to ride public opinion with a confident (if not coherent) ideology, determination and short- term bribes, has been key to their success. The Conservatives shaky cconomic strategy enabled them to build a sound political base: the most important element of which was the employed skilled workers who became (or felt) better off as a result of tax cuts and sales of council houses and shares, along with lower inflation.

The Tories are now very close to losing that base as the problems stored up by their own policies are unfolding. The options for the government are suddenly much narrower -

witness not only the sharp rise in interest rates as inflation and unemployment start creeping up and the balance of payments deficit wor- sens, but also the veiled hint made in John Major's first Autumn Statement that taxes will be held or raised next spring. With the realisa- tion that the money's run out and the game's up, panic is beginning to set in.

The crisis in confidence has already cost the government E5.5bn in extra public spend- ing for next year: the first real increase for 6 years in the share of national output taken by public expenditure. The alternative, of doing nothing and waiting for an uptum to bring the voters back, is much more risky. An upturn isn't likely to come before the next election. Even the government have admitted that at least for next year, the economy will get worse. Lawson clearly anticipated as much and got out before more of the blame came his way.

Significantly, Major's Autumn Statement proposals included a E2.4bn increase for the health service in 1990-91 (that is not enough to maintain existing levels of service, but just a bit less than the Labour Party called for and

SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 20, Dec-Jan 1989-90

FEATURES

Some Conservatives are

well-placed to do that. The

"succession" is already the ob

ject of much coded competition

and jockeying for position. As

we go to press Michael Hesel.

tine is openly revealing his am-

bition to step into Thatcher's

shoes, while the possibility of a

"stalking horse" challenge for

leader is still being debated - if

only a volunteer could be

found. With a leadership chal-

lenge will go a political chal-

lenge.

This is where it could really

begin to get interesting. Waiting

in the wings in the Tory Party

are the silent majority: the non-

Thatcherite, 'one nation". party

loyal Tories. A recent academic

study of the Conservative Party,

which for the first time ex-

amined and grouped the politi-

cal position of cach

Conservative MP.

found that less than

20% of them could be

described

Thatcherites. Around

the same number are

fully fledged wets,

whilst the biggest

grouping - over half of

all the Conservatives in

parliament - are just

party faithful.

Politically. what

kind of successor emer-

ges is at the moment up

for grabs, since among

the obvious contenders

there are candidates of

each category, and

Graeme Cookson popular

some of the wetter, like

Heseltine, are the more

electorally

(22% of voters who ex-

press preference:

favour Heseltine to take

over after Thatcher.) Whether or not Heseltine himself is the chosen sucessor, the outcome of the issue at the heart of his difference with Thatcher - ad- vocating a German/European economic and defence alliance for Britain in place of the cur- rent "special relationship" with the USA - will be key for the prospects of British big busi- ness.

Who is chosen will depend in a large part on what are the circumstances of Thatcher's departure, and who, ideologically and in- dividually, is best placed to take advantage of those circumstances.

All this makes the prospects for the Thatcher revolution after Thatcher shaky. Ul- timately the test of the project is in the perfor-

Make

Budger

Day

NHS OUR

DAY

I/Defe

Hithe N

Stog

the

Bitterly unpopular: the Tories' new NHS 'reform' Bill promised if elected). That price they're clearly prepared to pay to defuse opposition while they push through their NHS Bill - a fun- damental political attack on the NHS.

With such virulently unpopular measures as the NHS 'reforms", water and electricity privatisation and the poll tax still to push through, many Conservatives in parliament are depressed and worried about hanging on to their own seats, even if their party manages to retain an overall majority at the next elec- tion. It's in that context that the question of Thatcher's leadership takes centre stage.

The polls tell us many contradictory things about public opinion in Britain. We hear, for example, that concern about unemployment is still high (second on most people's lists), and that they have no confidence in the government's policies for reducing it - but 57% still think that most unemployed people could get jobs if they tried. Most people favour higher taxes over cuts in public spend. ing. whilst at the same time the polls tell us that a majority agree with Thatcher's diag nosis of the problems of the welfare "depend- ency culture'.

But one of the clearest conclusions to be drawn from recent polls is about attitudes to Mrs Thatcher herself. She is massively un popular - even more unpopular than her party. The Tories know that and seem reluctantly to be gearing up to do something about it.

Following Lawson's resignation, telephone poll found that only 24% of voters were satisfied with Mrs Thatcher's perfor- mance as PM. That gives her the lowest popularity rating of any prime minister since polling began in 1945. The only rival to her all-time low was Harold Wilson, who held the previous record: a mere 27% satisfaction with his performance in the heady days of May 1968. Increasingly, Thatcher is seen to be out of touch and contemptuous of ordinary people. That, of course, she always has been.

EALTH

ERVICE RE

Bidding for the leadership? Heseltine What's more important is that she is now seen to be "losing control' - a weak spot indeed for a leader whose strength and decisiveness has been her main, if not only, selling point.

In that context her "post-Lawson' promise to resign if elected for a fourth term is under- standable: it underwrites her fundamental un- popularity with a guarantee that she will be going soon (promise) in the hope of reaping the dividends of her three-times tested voter appeal just one more time. But it's a risky move. Not only are other problems in the economy overshadowing any advantage her leadership style once gave her, but ovemight she is now seen as a political has-been. Her Tory rivals, as well as Labour, are keen to step into the breach.

John Harris (IFL.)

SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 20, Dec-Jan 1989-90

Paqe 11

FEATURES

and centralise, so too does political opinion. At least, that is, "informed", "authoritative" - establishment - politi- cal opinion. They all say more or less the same thing. If they say it often enough, then other people say it too. It starts to sound like fact.

It's a handy thesis, and it serves Labour's leaders well. It gives them the justification for a series of revisions which gut the movement of its momen- tum and potential for power. It offers a self-fulfilling vision of a party whose es sence is a nondescript, calculated lowest

common denominator rhetoric, just a lot

of hot air to fill a vacuum with. Its im-

John Harris

mediate benefit for the likes of Kinnock

is that such a strategy serves to shore up

their own personal standing and security

in the party. The trouble is they also take

"Unaccustomed as l am'- Engineers' leader Jordan addresses a mass meeting, calling for strike action! themselves at face value and in fact

seem to buy the whole line that it will mance of the economy and the satisfaction of tal out of the Tories" bankrupt policies and

get them into Number 10, capital with that performance. More politicians.

Not so. Unfortunately they don't seem to monetarism, uncomfortably combined with

Although Labour now leads the Tories by public spending sops to the wets and the an average of 10 points in the polls, a closer have noticed that the Alliance, the last party to voters doesn't look too convincing if you're a examination reveals that this has been almost take hold in the centre (with 50.5% support in big business mogul worried about interest exclusively as a result of a drop in the vote for its heyday) sunk there and disappeared almost rates, wage demands and inflation, and getting the Democrats and lately the Greens - with without trace. That's not to argue, of course, frozen out of European markets because little inroad into the solid core of Conservative that Labour doesn't need to win over a Thatcher thinks there are more votes in bang- support. This remains around the 35% mark- majority to its policies. Clearly it does but the

poor enough for a party of goverment, but only way to do that, and to hold support for ing on about British sovereignty.

Unless the Conservatives find solutions to substantially better than in 1981 when they any length of time, is with a series of policies the current crises (and the even bigger ones were down around the 28-30% mark, and in which can deal with conomic problems con- looming over the horizon) and deal with those 1985 after the end of the miners' strike when vincingly, and which don't penalise the work-

ing class in the process. Those policies aren't problems - and deliver the votes - then capital they dropped to a low of 24%.

On the brighter side, Labour's lead has available off the peg from the centre. If will be forced to begin to look elsewhere. If Thatsher avan with her armice to on hae heen steadu since the summer - oivine it a Labour is to be more than a passive, short-

rendered the Tories as a whole unelectable, the net will have to be thrown further than the Tory wets for a safe bet.

During the 1980s, of course, the centre parties have been bolstered as a fall-back. But plans in politics don't always go like clock- work and other, unpredictable factors like per- sonalities and party members have stepped in to almost wipe the centre off the map.

Enter Labour. Whilst capital is a long way from seeing Labour as a potential partner, it is wary enough to look on it a little more kindly these days. At the very least Labour could serve if not as a fall-back, then as a fall-guy for the impending economic collapse stored up by the Tories and the recession that must inevitably follow. The political options are not so desperate as to drive the capitalists into the hands of our obligingly moderate Labour Party, but they could certainly live with watching Labour struggle with their crisis and watching it fail for five years - as it inevitably must - giving capital's forces time to regroup and recoup.

Sadly, although Labour might find itself as a hapless beneficiary of Conservative decline and capitalist crisis, it is not so well prepared in its own bid for power.

So far, it has made very little political capi-

longer-term advantage, a feature new to the pattern of its previous mid-term leads. But un- less the party manages to chip away at core Conservative support, especially in a time when interest rates are high, and inflation and unemployment rising, then its prospects don't look too good.

Labour's new package of policies makes it

less, not more, electable. It is simply not up to

the challenge of what is a real shift in the mood and political temper of the electorate - which is decisively away from the values and economics of Thatcherism, but not yet distinc- tively pro anything else identifiable.

Labour has saddled itself with policies which take on board the more "acceptable" abstracts of Thatcherism, propose little else by way of policy framework or specifics, and leave the rest well alone.

In the middle of all the turmoil that may yet bring more seventies revivals, one feature of the Thatcherite eighties - the art of selling - remains. How else does Labour, so easily written off not so long ago, suddenly become this week's best buy? It's the way you sell tem.

We do - and to some extent, think - what we're told. Sadly politics works a bit like that too. And just as capital tends to accumulate

term beneficiary of Thatcher's unpopularity. then it must have something more substantial to offer.

Even tired old Marxism Today is waking up to that fact. There is some satisfaction, even if petty, to seeing Eric Hobsbawm strug- gling through an article in its pages describing Labour as the alternative to the Tories now that his beloved friends in the centre are out of the race. "The Thatcher spell', he announces

pretentiously, "has been broken." Many, but unfortunately not most, in the labour move- ment were never under it. The likes of Mar- xism Today succumbed all too quickly and grabbed too desperately at the centre as a way out - and dragged too many along with them as well.

Hobsbawm announces that at least Labour will not now frighten the voters off with the likes of Benn and Scargill, but asks, plaintive- ly, if Labour can manage to inspire them enough to win their votes. Sadly, the answer is probably "no". Some of the responsibility for that lies with the likes of him, for acting as a block on attempts to do that very thing, and for peddling old compromises under the guise of "new times'.

Page 12

SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 20, Dec-Jan 1989-90

← Poll Tax: the case of the missing 300,000 · The future for the left in Europe →

Something wrong on this page?