white election,
excluding the vast majority of
the people of South Africa - its
results and conser
be lightly dismissed, argues CHARLIE VAN GELDEREN.
In few other countries would a gover- ment with such a dismal economic mood voluntarily pur its popularity to the test ar the ballot box (elections were nor due con- stitutionally for another two vears). Bar this "election" was not being fought on sachi
Ile state of the cronomy scarcely figured on the hustings As the Financal Times pur it for many whites "security and the maintenance of white privilege is more important than prosperity
the one is the
What was at issue was the most effective
whire-dominated
thought. The
THE WHETE ELECTION was of course not so much an clection as a referendum. Even the rame Uncle Toms of the coloured" and in- dian legislative chambers were excluded The white voters were being asked if they would continue to place their future in the hands of Borha and the dominant National
bread-and-butter issues:
Parry (XP)
The cction Was launche»
te econonue and political cris
midst ol - state of emergen..
ser con inflation rate and'a
still growth. nemploymem has reached n
no whire as well
MONT NU
There
For many, of course.
guurantee of the other.
way of maintaining
* BEEN XIN 20°
imploved). The - afte- rax in 14%1
Increase
foreign less than a decade.
Africa's
which accounts for more than half South
curreney
nat IrT
bloated bureaucracy necessary to process the mass of apartheid legislature (pass laws, in- flux cuntrul, censorship and so on) hus led to a four-fold increase in personal taxation in
capitalist. Among the white elertorate there
three schools mainstream, represented by the ruling Na- tional Party: believed that severely limited "reforms" — the three chamber parliament: trade union rights for black workers (certain- ly the major reform): tinkering with some of the more irritating aspeets of Verwoerdian apartheid such as the mised marriages act and similar cosmetic measures, would coa- tain the situation
SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 2 July/August 1987
were
unassailable were captured by the NP and others transformed into marginals. In the
liquidate themselves as political force'
words of Basiness Day, a Johannesburg finan- cial daily, english voters sucrificing ar last the role of keepers of a liberal flame, chose to
an identifiable
By playing the racist card, Botha succeed-
Blacks registened their protest at their exclu-
ed in uniting the whites.
WHILE THE white electorate rallicd to the tattered blood-stained banner of apartheid Blacks registened their protest at their exclu- sion from the decision-making machinery in
the most effective way open to them. More than half-a-million stayed away from work
laning mataine
in in sher Mor
may from wor mari double tha
Jemonstrate what
position of th
Jeople in the
wurse this govern-
saty of students
colleges and
striking
on polling day and
vast majority of South Africa's people to the mad, repressive, racist course this govern- ment is bent on. Thousands of students
number the next day to demonstrate whar
COSATU described as "the opposition of the
ment is bent on. Thousands of students stayed away from schools, colleges and universities in solidarity with the striking
workers:
One immediate effect of the triumph of the sp and the emergence in strength of the
ultra right — who won more than 26 per cent of the overall popular white vote, almost double the PFP's share — is to diminish the
influence of big business on future govern- ment policy. Despite their domination of the
South African cconomy, Botha will now be even less inclined to listen to the blan-
JItna sh the - "uture wern
omination of the
ans will now h
Beer of Anglo-American or to bow pressure fron the multi-nationals, They pin-
dishments of enlightened' capitalists, like de
to
pressure fron the multi-nationals, They pin-
ned their post-clection hopes on the success
of Dr Worral and his fellow independents
" in the bian.
ike de
$ WHIT
IS A
WRONG THING
ENs
SKOLE
WIT
BY WIT
le white elections
To the 'left of the governing party were the "verligtes", those Narionalists like Wy- nand Malan, Esther Lategan and Denis Worral and the Progressive Reform Party (PRP) who aligned themselves with sections of big business and wanted the reforms" to go a little faster and a little further, None of "hese was in favour of a unitary state with one-person-one-vote They all campaigned for the continuance of what is euphemistically known as 'free enter- prise bur which in reality, means the con- tinued domination of the economy by the
monopolies, headed by American. To the right of the National Parry
Conservative Party (cI).
these progressives
thin edge of the wedge, opening the road to racial equality and. inevitablv. black rule
Botha perceived that the main threat to his
base came for the right' rather than the
'left" despire the media ballyhoo which sur
leit desnle •ne sneca allyni whi rounded the dramatic journey of Dr Worral from the South African embassy in London
to the hustings of Helderberg. The clection
result has more than vindicated his judge-
ment. The ruling National Party increased
its parliamentary representation from 116
sears to 123. Its gains were largely at the ex-
pense of the PFP. The rise of the ultra-right Anglo- force in Sor
the
tine giant
was the
Herstigre National Party (HNP) and in the hackground the openly fascist Afrikaner Weerstand Beweging (AWK). These want to turn the clock back to the days when Ver woerd was king and che "kaffir" knew his place, to a rigid apartheid in which blacks would exercise political rights" only in the so-called tribal homelands" and coloureds and indians only in racially demarcated areas. For them Rotha's "reforms" were the
han
the ex
resulted in a net gain by the Cl of four seats ar the expense of the NP and replacing the
PFP as the ollicial parliamentary opposition.
Had the CP and the HSt not split the right- wing vote, they would have won six more
A feature of the election result is that the
s who naun
liberal' ve
PFP. suppo
English-
were considered
kin
SDe3K1n virtually
SOCIALIST OUTLOOK. no 2
'even the quisling
Buthelezi is hesitant about participating in a national
council'
which, according to a statement de Beer made in London on 4 May would increase pressure on the government to make conces- sions. Pressure from that quarter is off the agenda for the time being
sme veing.
In the immediate future, Botha will have
to ward off the threat from the die-hards on ...diamentarv opposition benches bv
showing that his reformist" velvet glove con-
ceals the iron fist which he would not now
hesitate to use. He has received a mandate
which he dare not ignore if the NP is to main-
tain its hegemony over the Afrikaners.
was neatly summed up by UDF leader Allan
Bocsak: "white voters have made their posi-
tions of the security forces"
in the in:
rion clear. They support the state of
emergency; they suppor detention of
thousands of children; they support the ac-
Opening the newly-elected parliament, Botha made it clear that apartheid was here
de
to stay and warried of an impending crack- down against the extra-parliamentary op- position. If there were still any sections of South Africa's voteless blacks who thought that any real reform, let alone a change of
ISUP
cia was mete ading crack
vho thought
9
ed compound since they increased local rents in Seprember, 1984. This was the beginning of the nation-wide rent boycotts and the
unrest which unabated despite two states of emergency:
government could be brought abour through the white parliamentary process, these hopes
ed lox brake on the movement of revolt.
There is a danger, of course, thar without
organised political leadership this will take
has cuntinued the form of mindless violence and anarchy.
aware that he was
Botha has not wasted much time in ar- lempring to put his threats against the op-
wave of
Mayor Mahalatsi, the state president'x invitation:
the real opposition - into effect. One of his major targets would appear to be the trade unions. Even before the elections, the police laid siege to Cusatu House, the headquarters of the Confederation of South
African Trade Unions. This was followed by
positinn
While this will increase the ungovernability of the townships, it will not create die best conditions to give birth to an alternative government and social system. The problem of political leadership would still have to be
THIS 15 ONE variant of the years ahcad. Bur there is another aspect which was not present in the 1960s — the independent trade union movement. Undoubtedly, the government will try to curb the influence and militancy of
as it has shown by its vicious
action against the striking railway workers.
Even te
elected by a derisory microscopic vote and that he was not one of the real black leaders as described by Botha, gracefully declined
'we would have great reluctance in participating in the national council', he said. 'We seriously
urge you to ahandon the idea... the reform
Atre
solved
the unions — But they wont and this cas representatives of big business are aware of the power and strength of the organised
raids on other union offices and the harass.
Two days after the elections, the striking railworkers" six-person negotiating team was picked up in a Johannesburg raid. On the
Themba Nxumalo;
Municipal and Workers of South Africa, was stopped at u road block. This was followed by more raids
ment of trade union Icaders.
un? his an
picker same
= di day.
it does not (lead to) the ultimate participa-
tion of blacks in parliament on a par with
secretary
general
Allied
In anticipation of strong action against the
liheration forces, Botha is clearing the decks. His deportation of media representatives
from Britain, USA, Australia and other
countries is no simple art of revenge for past
whites"
BRAIN. ISA.
on union offices and arrests in Pietershurg in the Northern Transvaal and Germiston near
Johannesburg COSATI offices in East Lon- don were burnt down.
Botha has also made it clear that the group areas act and segregated education - twn of the corner stones of apartheid would be rigidly enforced. The so-called grey areas,
tV. theer reporters: With state - adio and ty in South Alrie and nr no enverely curtailes
the regune can conceal thi
trem peopre in Souch Atnh...
down the rurtain ber
Botha has as
trade unions: In the pre-clection interview in the Independent (5 May), the Anglo-American director. lung term the most effective anti-government
TCAR n the
urganisation in South Africa was the trade union movement. "Wherever you are now you are dealing with unions in South Africa What I have said many times to the govern- ment is that if you give people trade union power it is certain they will use it for political purposes. What is remarkable is the restraint the unions used in the first six years but this
Another prominent member of the big business establishment, the chair of the ma-
of taking on the unions Starc
where white and black have been living peacefully together these past few years,
ween South Africa and the rest of the world
For President Botha, no news from the dark
would no longer be tolerated. This was
i the townshin
signalled by a rud on a largely black- necupied flat in the central Johannesburg
suburb, Hillbrow and the alleged detention of a Hillbrow caretaker who has been promi- nent in the prolonged campaign against the
'the banning of the mass
is changing
organisations must be in
eriction of black residents in Hillbrow.
Verwoerd's policy of 'independent' black "homelands would also be pursued. Botha has given the go-ahead for impoverished KwaNdebele to become the fifth 'black na-
the mind of the regime'
jur multinational Sheil SA, John R Wilson has also warned the regime of the conse-
pressure on COSATU, be said. could only "bode ill for the luture'. The raiding of of fices, the banning of meetings and the in discriminate arrest of hundreds of workers is nor likely to crush the unions, he said. Rather it will strengthen their resistarice
and suppurt and will have adverse ramifica- tions for stable industrial relations, the ef- ferts of which will be felt thoughout in-
Unduubtedly, the increased authority which the clection result has given Botha will
quences and
lion', only nine months atter the territory's Jegislatives assembly voted against the in- dependence proposals. KwaNdebele is a
be uscd ruthlessly. While he will keep the trade unions within his sights, he will first train his guns on the political wings of the
wholly artificial cration with no traditinnal tribal ties. It consists of a few thousand acres of desolare farmland, 100 miles north-cast of Pretoria: The land was formerly owned by
liberation movement and, in the first in-
stance, on the UDF, the main mass extra-
parli movement, Preparing registalu to ban these orgas
and
19 white farmers who were, undouhmedly. handsomely compensated. Now ir is 'home' to 250.000 blacks, mossly of the Ndebele tribe who have heen forcibly removed there.
watch escape nullification m
Court ma roxe tim- A- mediare step.
dustr
Botha proposes to ... Ars of 1078 to stop thes
ne finsan....
such
present repressive conditions.
He went on to say: 'Sadly: though, as viuletice, high-handed and strong-arm lac- tics are employed in what is transparently an attempr to crush an increasingly powerful government opponent, one's helic in a negotiated future becames fragile. (Weekly Mail, 22-30 May).
Botha having been rebuffed oven by the quislings of KwaZulu and Tockna seems 10, have realised that he has to conl the situa- tion. After the attempted vicious repression of the rail strike, the employing authority suddenly caved in. All 10.000 sacked railway
There can be no dour that all sections of the liberation movement face a difficult furure in the immerhate period ahead during which the state of emergency will become a
-. This mavin
covernment appear liberation
organisations widespread support that it can get by
to nr...
enjoy
permanent franure. The single, bleak gesture
which Borha has made toward the majority. as the ofter of black participation in a na- tinnal council. Even the quisling Buthelezi is hesitant abour participating in this farce. He has stipulared the release of Nelson Mandela as: a condition for talks, but this is virtually impossible in the present climate
without overseas aid though, undoubredly.
this will increase their difficulties.
The banning of the mass organisations. however, must be very much in the mind of
cven more
th
the regime. It hopes banning them would
have the same effect as the outlawing of the
ANC and PAC after the Shurpeville massacre
Vaal's Lekoa
including
Fisau struggle.
col- prisonment and death.
Butha was rebuffed even hy the uncle Toms. On a visit to the township in June, where he was offered the 'frecdom of six townships Sharpeville. he invited the Mayor Mahalarsi and other councillors to sit on his nacional council Mahalatsi and his Teagues have been living behind barbed wire
in a specially-constructed and heavily muard-
of 1960 — a period of relative political calm and apathy. But there is no possibility of this scenario being repcated The people in the townships and, especially the youth have been highly politicised in the last two years of
emergency they have become inured to in-
much part of their daily lives thar no repres- sium, however severe, will be able to put a
recugnition.
al
strength Living in u perpenual state of confrontation
It has become so
workers got their jobs back and union
Despite its victory at the all- white polls, the regime does not fedl irself strung enough to take on the organised
the workers in open
While the trade unich movement, as sucb. is not the ideal vehirle for political leadership — involved as it of necesity is, with the day? to-day struggles fur better working conde
SOCIALIST OUTLOOK to 2 July/Auguis 1987
la tr Si
UTHAFRI
Africa today and the founding of the British
tons and wages — its organised strength and close ties with the liberation muvement can act as a shekd for the polinical wing if ir 1s driven underground. The close bond which hus been esrablished between the unions and the community townslups and berween the unions and the students will also prove disciplining the spreading revolt and guiding it into more fruitful channels.
The birth of an indeperilent working class party would. undoubrediy, be a big step for ward but the emergence of such a party with a muss base is not likely in the immediate future. CONTU's proclaimed political plat form, with its firm commitment to socialism, provides the framework within which such a party can take shape. It is toward this end
Labour Party at the turn of the century. The trade union Icaders in Britain took the in- itiative to lorm a political party mainly as a defensive response to legislation which threatened the very cxistence of the unions,
their own programme — socialism - con scious of the fact that this programme is the only guarantor of victory. It is by striving to
gramme that the working class exercises its leadership. All other interpretations of the "leading role of the working class" are com
It is significant that at is founding con-
containing the minimum political demands that reflect the view of the majority of metal workers" vision of a free and democratic non- discriminatory South Africa it underlined
that the demands of the Freedom Charter
organisations
important
thar revolutionary socialists must work, in side the unions and inside the mass organisa- finns. There are no short cuts. Parties which
the
in
win the others in the alliance to this pro-
pletely meaningless.
ference at the end of May, the new COSATU afliliate, the National Union of Metalworkers of South clearly spelled out its commitment to socialist society where workers' control of government and industry was enforced While it adopted the Freedom Charter as
containing the minimum political demands
that reflect the view of the majority of metal
especially the Taff Vale judgement.
Ir was not till 1918, in the wake of the Russian revolution, that the word 'socialism' tade its appearance in the platform of the British Labour Party. The British Labour
Party was burn in a period of relative
cronomic growth and political stability when
4242214630-9115115 from the ruling clas engthen the ficht for
Africa (NUMSA),
Artille
¡harter
ding political activity to the industrial muscle threaten the power and structure of the state, or the social order
Its purpuse IF tor reto.
Ar no time did it
of the working class.
can give efferive leadership to the working
class cannor he created by proclamation.
unions cannor be a
substitute for the political party of the work-
ing class, neither can this role be fulfilled by the populist maks organisations, the UIs.
While the trade
The scenarn in South Alrica is vastly dif- lerent. There the unions have come into ex- Istence and grown strong in an era of un- precedented turbulence. COSATU'S very ex- Istence and the close links it has crablished
TOOTECH
could only be realised in the lives of the
working-class masses "through the practical
marlaration
dallii WOrAIDK » ale umitatione olar
•demandın tat *
.... with
wOrker
charter' a demand originally raised by the
imprisoned Moscs Mayekiso, unanimously clected as general secretary of
In South Africa, the conditions are par
the new union.
he thin who was
Ticularly lavourable to the emergence of a working class party with a policy which will
safeguard the interests of all sections of the
oppressed while remaining firmly committed
to socialism. This is because the overwhelm-
ing majority of black people in South Africa,
that is, the overwhelming majority of the population, are bound with indisoluble links
la....
to the working class.
sectIon
cconomically active men and women in
South Africa are urban or rural workers.
The students, who have often been in the forefront of the barries in the townships, and
the sons and daughters of workers. In chis
wroughi, working -Jass
political programme, which has for its objec
tive the overthrow of the capitalist-apartheid
state, is also the programme which embraces
all the demands of the people as a whole —
an end to racial discrimination, equality in
with CHHCIHSTY youth and women 's
organisations, make it qualitatively different
to the union which formed the British
Labour Party, Its programme is uncom-
promisingly political and recognises that the
strugele for immediate coonomic demands is
not enough. The declared aim OFCOSATL is
an end to racisi capitalism. le sees the battle
to end apartieid and the overthrow of the
social order as a single struggle. Whar it has
nor yet done is to forge the political instru-
ment which can electively lead this struggle
class
The middle classes form only a small
v.ICK pln
be said, that by far the biggest section of the
www.menen
news
the AZAPO or, tor thar matter, the ANC.
Although all these
"leading role of the working class?, they are very this. It makes gond reading in amricles and
any struggle organisations.
Organisations never umit to genuflect in the direction of the
vague about the specific meaning of
The are
toretront situation,
"Dan or.т mn. nyve não.
calling on the workers to bear the brunt of
initiated by the miss
This has led, in the past, to friction bet- ween the trade unions and the populist
The most glaring example of this was the stay-away in Porr Flizabeth and Eas London in March, 1985, an arrion
- an independent party of the working
polt...a. ad thi
au ine acmands an end to racia law. education
working
organisations.
which was decided upon by community. youth and political organisations, withour first cunsulting the trade unions. It was the workers who suffered loss of pay; it was the workers who provided the picker lines. this is not what we mean when we talk about the leading role of the working class
and civil socicty: the
3l the wealth in the coulry...
dovernment of the class the same
A WORKERS PARTY, by itself, no matter how well led, cannot achieve victory. 1t
and; with
fre
vel Witn all se ple fighting the racist regime
been tensified
sow which
feature
HISII has
necessary alliances, the working class does
not subordinate its own programme to ac- But i anoth
defcats of the popular and people's fronts in
But, in these
The
AJE
DELILAN
For socialists world-wide the task is to in- tensify the mobilisation of solidarity with the
The heady
A workers' party, even if initiated and launched by the trade unions — which is the most likely variant — would not be an ex- clusively trade unionist party confining itself to trade union politics. There is no com- parison between the situation. in
France and Spain in the 1930s are tragic reminders of the msuit of such compromises.
leading role of the working class
repression. "up: news may keep South Africa out of the media headlines and off the tv screens. Rut
is going оп, remorselessly. It cannor be halted. Victory is
The mie
nicatis that. with
total
defear the main South
the fighring resolutely for the united objective to
Brie while
the struggie
enemy.
fist tran
the EliminatION
wwnships. iscqunnce Suppression of
Bur inevitably.
11
SOCIALIST