LETTERS
Think again on PR.
In his thorough piece on "len years in the life of the Labour Party' (SO 18), Pete Firmin maintains that in 1981/2, the Campaign for Labour Party Democracy (CLPD) was 'caught in the trap of its own policy of conference sovereignty'
It is difficult to understand why he uses the word "trap'. Conference sovereignty is the bedrock of a socialist party, and this means we cannot pick and choose which decisions we
Francois Duhamel/ Touchstone GMB-sponsored proposals outlined by Jane
will follow.
Conference sovereignty is now under its greatest ever attack as a consequence of the
Wells in her article (also in SO 18). Having a consistent record on this issue, CLPD is in a better position to campaign against these proposals.
Finally, the article by Jane Wells gave a good insight into the agenda of the Labour Party Annual Conference, and correctly pointed out that it is the right who are organis- ing for PR within the Party. Unfortunately, in Earnest scene from Dead Poets Society contradistinction to this, the last paragraph contained the usual ritualistic plea in favour of PR.
It would be helpful if Socialist Owlook would set out in detail why it is at this par- ticular moment in the class struggle - when the LCC and the right wing (eg EETPU and AEU) within the Labour Party are organising for PR; when the bourgeois press (and Mar- xism Today) have had a coordinated cam- paign for PR; when this is precisely the lifeline that Owen and the ratbags in the so- called Centre so desperately need - that at this
look should be so willing to assist them in this
enterpriy those who purport to be maxists
enterprise.
should assess institutions like PR in terms of the existing concrete social conditions, not in terms of some long term a-historical project?
For historical reasons, the class divisions in this country are clearer then elsewhere in westem capitalism, and voting patterns reflect this. There is a party for the ruling class and a party for the working class. PR would under- mine class-based voting, would massively strengthen the so-called centre parties, and would prevent a socialist party from forming a majority govemment.
Socialist Outlook should go back to the drawing-board on this one!
Pete Willsman
CLPD
to organise themselves in the Dead Poets' Society and gain strength from this. The mini- rebellion at the end has a political edge to it. The boys are standing up for justice and against injustice in their school. The sugges tion is that at this point the school has lost con- trol over them and will be unable to punish them effectively.
The actors, scenery and dialogue capture the enthusiasms and insecurities of the young men well. Dead Poets' Society recreates the cultural revolt of the beatnik era and will strike a chord with those who were also at school at that time. But I still couldn't really work out why Joln Keating chose to go back and teach in that particular school.
SOCIALIST
OUTLOOK
Teachers' unions hold the key
I've been reading Ken Jones analysis of education since the days of Radical Education in the early 70's, so it was with some interest that I turmed to the "Tory Classroom Offensive' (SO 18).
As usual, much of his analysis is to the point. But I felt that the question 'which way forward?' is not as sharply posed as it might have been.
For example, Jones is correct to argue that the national curriculum, so far, seems to have been more of a victory for best practice in the teaching profession than Tory ideology. But we cannot assume that MacGregor will be content with this. The interference with the proposals of the History Working Group is probably a sign of things to come. Nor can we rely, for a strategy, on the subversion of the various Tory 'reforms' from within. This may
turn out to be possible of course, but much will depend on other factors.
So, for example, Jones is right to suggest that trade unions are not enough to deal with the challenges that face us. But trade union or- ganisation will be the core and the key. Links with the community, with pupils and parents will be best built from a position of confidence engendered by successful union organisation.
Equally, the Labour Party at local at nation- al level should be pressured. But we shouldn't be too optimistic about the probable results. At a local level, (Richard Hatcher please note), the Labour Party, whatever the intention, are managers who will have to manage the Tory measures.
Secondly, to hope that the Labour party na- tionally will suddenly start to pay attention to questions of content and control in education, as opposed to provision, seems rather to ignore what Kinnock is up to with the policy review.
Resistance to Macgregor and change for the better can be achieved. But they will have to come from below, and through, initially, the unions. Surely one of the lasting lessons of the radical education of the 1960s and 1970s is that the system cannot really be worked with any lasting success. To defend and advance we will have to rely on the forces we ourselves can build.
Keith Flett
Tottenham
We welcome letters
up to 400 words. Write to Socialist Out-
look, PO Box 1109,
London N4 2UU
SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 18, October 1989
Page 33
for socialism
1st-3rd December
1989
Venue: Kingsway
College, Sidmouth
Street (near Kings Cross tube)
THE SOCIALIST OUTL
IOK FOR EUROPE
MAJOR FORUMS AND DEBATES
INCLUDE:
• The crisis of Stalinism in Eastern Europe and China
• A socialist approach to 1992
• Women's struggles in Europe
WITH: Ernest Mandel Zbigniew Kowalewski Oliver MacDonald John Palmer Tariq Ali Alice Mahon MP* Peter Tatchell Branka Magas Ken Livingstone MP Ai Meun Lim, Penny Kemp, Joy Hu Irene Breugel,
• Lesbian & Gay Liberation
ORGANISED BY SOCIALIST OUTLOOK Rates (whole weekend): Waged: €12; Students: 68; Unwaged s6 fi offit you register by 13 November Please delete:
I would like further information about Outlook for Socialism 89 (yes/no)
I would like to registerifor Outlook for Socialism 89 (yes/no)
I would like to register for the creche (enclose number and age of children)
I would like a subscription to Socialist Outlook (£8.50 inland)
lenclose fo. (please make cheques payable to Outlook International) Name:.
Address....
Please send this form.to PO Box 1109, London N4 2UU
and others *(invited)