FEATURES
Media recognises collapse of
Despite Nigel Lawson's ef- forts at Blackpool, the Tories' economic policies are on the rocks. With the
mortgage rate at 14%, infla-
tion (excluding the cost of housing) at over 7 percent, and the balance of payments heading for a £23 billion deficit for the year, the government's 'economic miracle' has become an Alice in Wonderland tale.
Even Lawson's strongest supporters in the national press are losing confidence as rifts widen between Law- son and Thatcher's main economic adviser, Alan Wal- ters.
It is useful to look back at the situation in 1988, the high point in Lawson's chancellorship.
Output in the manufacturing sector appeared to be increasing sharply, and the Tories found themselves sitting on a "budget surplus' (more money was com- ing into the exchequer than was being spent) - as a result of mas sive revenues from privatisation and higher than expected in- come from North Sea oil. Un- employment was beginning to fall slowly, resulting in an increase in tax receipts for the Treasury. Declaring that their economic strategy had been a resounding success, Law- son and Thatcher took the brakes off their austerity policy and in the context of relative- ly low interest rates, cut income tax by 2p in the pound and slashed the tax bill of the rich. This was in line with their longer term plans for expanding the economy through 'market' or 'consumer-led' mechanisms.
So what has gone wrong for Lawson? Certainly the decision by West Germany to increase interest rates in early October didn't help. The most recent rise here came in response to this, but since the 'Lawson boom' started there has been a total rise in in- terest rates of 40%.
Lawson has been faced with similar con- tradictions and long term problems as other chancellors. British capitalism's weak
manufacturing base means that levels of in-
creased consumer spending - or 'demand-led
growth' as the Keynesians call it - have not
been matched by the increases in output that
Page 8
The weakness of the British manufacturing sector in relation to other capitalist economies has long been recognised by most marxists, although their analysis of why has often differed. They have pointed variously to the strength of the working class, to the backwardness of the British ruling class in its obsession with financial capital at the expense of manufacturing capital, and the ex- istence of an archaic social struc- ture. This is not to deny the im- portance and influence of general and international developments in capitalism - but rather to acknow- ledge that within the generalised crisis affecting the capitalist world there are certain par- ticularities about the British economy.
Labour governments have at- tempted 'corporatist" solutions to modernise industrial production. They have set up wage-cutting in- comes policies and huge govern- ment planning agencies, seeking
B/.2•00/2222
baasaca
SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 19, November 1989
ment planning agencies, seeking
"planning agreements' with big
business, but not tackling the
power of financial capital or the
stranglehold on industry exer-
cised by the 'high pound'
demanded by the City. This same Wall Street - more influential than Lawson's rhetoric
reformist approach has tradition-
ally dominated the thinking of the Labour left, although proponents of the Alter- native Economic Strategy of the 70's did debate the merits of exchange control and protectionist import duties to safeguard 'British' industries against 'foreign' competi- tion.
The Tories have had a quite different ap proach to dealing with the "supply side" problem of British capitalism. In the early 1980s they deliberately crashed the economy - under the banner of monetarism - to create a "shake out' much of the excess capacity in the traditional sectors of manufacturing. They also set out through use of unemployment and anti-union laws to impose a dramatic reduction in labour costs.
At the same time they have promoted the 'enterprise culture' in the most profitable sec- tors - such as electronics and fast foods, and encouraged Japanese-style labour discipline. They have continued to give the City a free hand, and indeed promoted it. They have openly attacked demands to join the European Monetary System - where the
Keynesian theory assumes. In short, the British economy 'overheats' very quickly and at comparatively low levels of activity.
The post war years saw 'overheating' take place against a background of relatively full employment. Governments deflated and pushed up unemployment, but to levels that rarely exceeded half a million. The Lawson 'economic miracle' took place against an un- employment rate that was only slightly below two million and contained huge regional variations. The result of 'overheating' has been a significant increase in inflation and the mounting trade deficit, as consumers armed with credit cards buy foreign goods at the expense of more costly British ones.
In trying to bring about a 'soft landing". Lawson has had gradually to increase interest rates. However, his handling of the economy has resulted in loss of confidence by interna- tional finance and the cashing of sterling deposits in favour of other currencies. To at- tract back these speculators, Lawson has had to offer them the recent increases in interest rates - to support the pound.