Socialist Outlook

Socialist Viewpoint, International, Socialist Outlook and their supplements, 1984–2009

'Business-style' Polys

· Socialist Outlook no. 18, October 1989 · pp 18-21 · 2,493 words

Education Labour Party

whether it is research, called for 'the lightening There can be organised in lo trans- hnics and guest lectures outside the of sanctions, ballots on conjunction with students.

aram sanctinne and local who will anvhow be or-

Determined 10 trans- form Polytechnics and Institutes of Higher Education from places of education into profit

Thatcherite making. enterprises: the

Polytechnic and Col-

leges Employers Forum have offered lecturers a miserahic pay increase of 5.75% from April

*88 - '89, tied to the ac- ceptance of the new- style contract.

Talk of "competing in the «narket for

undergraduates

and

more

than university staff are just pie in the sky. What the deal is really about is a

massive worsening of con-

ditions for lecturers (and

as a result for all who work in this sector). A 38 week year will extended to 46, a 30 hour altendance 1 week will become at least 37 hours': and all work,

undergraduates pavıng secturer Inar universitv

whether it is research. guest lectures outside the home institution, writing books, will have to be agreed with the "manager"

-an all-out attack on academic freedoms. fourth term will almost certainly he introduced so that "revenue generation' can take place - fleecing rich American students by running courses on "Culture"

This delightful offer was rejected at the begin- ning of September by the lecturers union NATFHE and no new talks are planned. At the same time talks with local authorities have also broken down.

with the employers refus ing to improve an offer of 5.3% for lecturers in Fur- ther Education also linked

• Rexible working A

strike ballot is being held

for this group to take ac-

tion of October 17.

Unfortunately

NATI-HE has so far only

of sanctions, ballots on exam sanctions and local action" in Higher Educa- tion. There is some dis- quiet among recture: about the exam sanctions which was the tactic used by the AUT (Association of University Teachers) in their fight for better pay. In the event there was a rapid resolution between the AUT and the Univer sity authoritics befor exams started, and the lec- turers didn't get a lot more than the original offer.

But there are mure problems with it than its past history, for it hits stu- dents at their most vul- nerable time. In most cases it will affect students in their last year when they

In -

are at their least militant and when collective action is least likely.

What is much more likely to be a successful tactic is a series of national one and two day strikes.

ganising acuon agaunst

loans this year.

NATFHE will probab ly argue that they will be taken to court for secon dary action if they call na tional stoppages in Higher Education as cach anstitu- tion is now a 'plc". But the question is - bow can we win? Confining action ln the localities immediately affected - like Kingston Polytochnic where new- style contracts have been issued to new staff this

summer - will only isolate

separate institutions. We hava to arone that

whatever the legal status

of Polytechnics and In-

stitutes of Higher Educa tion, this is a national dis- pute over conditions with

negotiating body: National action is

the way this will be won.

national

s will he won

OOK

It is around Local Management of Schoois (LMS) that there will be

schools and the development of ai- liances with local community groups. schools to greater influence by the

mosT opportuniry to can popular models of the local control of

at I.MS

'user of the education service must be exposed. Kenneth Baker's state- ment about there being "winners and losers" under LMS is clearly correct The losers will be schools with large- ly working class pupils, progressive Labour authorities, and the school workforce.

Teachers retumed to work this new academic year with vacancy levels at their highest ever, workloads on the up and up and having seen their NALGO colleagues win a 'no strings agreement well above the miserly 5.9% imposed on teachers in April. Action by teachers with other school workers could he a catalyst for a campaign against the Tories in which the ERA is challenged The fight will he a long one.

Martin Allen

SUPPLEMENT

valu

teachers

Local Management of

Schools (LMS)

- an issue for the labour movement

Education is by far the largest sector of local government. It ac- counts for a half or more of local council spending.

Local authorities have had the power to make use of that money to implement distinctive local priorities. The ability to implement policies, particularly on race" und gender, that Tellected differen: clun alicmal priorities from those of the Tory goverment was one of the most im- portant gas of the left Labour authorities of the last decade.

That period is now over. Not simply hecause of the political defear of 'municipal socialism", but because the Tories have now completely changed the mules of the game. Start- ing next April control of 90% of the education budget (increasing to 93% by 1996) is being taken away from Loc Education Authoritice and placed in the hands of the governing bodies of all but some of the smallest primary schools. (It's a year later in Inner London).

LMS gives school governors

schous

SOCIALIST OUTLOOK ne

power in two important respocts. Firstly, it gives them the power to decide what the schools's educational prionties and policies are to be. They have to operate within the framework

of the national curriculum and nation- al testing, of course, but that still leaves seway for the govemons to decide if the school is going to be a

Magship of Thatchente education ur in allemnt ax lar as poxsihle to adhere to more radical and egalitarian prin- ciples, Secondiy, LMS gives gover-

nors the power to decide how the

school budget is spent. By far the

largest item of expenditure is the

salaries of teachers (about two thirds

of the total budget) and non teaching

staff: cleaners, secretaries, caretakers.

school meals workers

money is tight the obvious way to

balance the books is to reduce labour

thie

costs.

At stake then under LMS are two

vital issues for the working class in

education: one is what is taught and

how it's laught. The other is the jobs and conditions of school workers.

Battles that bave heen fought at local

Council level on sace asses often have to ne rough. «gan school.

Unde- a progresove Lanour government, with a different national

policy framework and a substantial increase in educational expenditure, LMS could represent a real step for- ward lor mopular democrauv in education. Under the Tories, it repre- senix something very different. Their intention is that LMS will decimate the powers of Labour LEAs and the

strength of the unions in education by strength of tl.

creating an education markel-place in creating at co which schools will compele against

pele against each other like private husinesses for

pupils and hence funding.

school is to be run by a chief execu-

tive, the head, now armed with the tive ne... latest in business management icchni- ques, and a board of directors, the governor. The expression of a col lective alternative will be impossiblc: LEAs will be powerless to impose their policies on the schools, and the unions will be atomised by the laws on sccondary industrial action into 28,000 separate: workplaces. The

Women for

Socialism

Dayschool:

Women and

Education'

(speakers

Caroline Benn

and Martha

Osamor)

October 7,

10am-4pm, Wesley House, 4, Wild Court, London WC2. Cost E5/E3/E2

Page 17

SUPPLEMENT

Tories' gamble is that school gover- "The Labour nors including those tens of

thousands who are Labour supporters Party will be compelled by the irresistible leadership

combination of national education should be

policies and the laws of the education

market to act as the transmission organising a

agents, however reluctant, of national

Torics' educational aims.

The spearhead of the LMS offen- campaign now

sive is the threat that governors will to arm its

try to solve their financial dilemmas supporters in

at the expense of jobs and conditions.

Already one teacher union is talking the schools

of 30,000 teaching jobs at risk, result- with the

ing in larger classes. How many of arguments and

these will be redundancies and how the tactics to

many natural wastage remains to be

seen. In addition, conditions of ser- resist the Tory

vice will worsen: temporary contracts offensive in

will become the norm, workloads will education. Of

increase, equal opportunities will be

undermined. course it will

But LMS is a gamble. The Tories do no such

can undoubtedly base themscives on thing"

a certain popular dissatisfaction with

education, and try to claim the banner

of parental power against town hall

bureaucracy and teacher dominance.

Essentially this is the legacy of the

Tast thirty years of social-democratic

educational reformism, and a key task

for the left is to develop a convincing

radian alternative to that tradition.

But it is also true that there is real

popular support for many of the gains

of progressive primary and

prehensive education, and certainly a

belief that the Tories are not spending

enough on the schools. The question

is, can that potential opposition be

tumed into an effoctive alliance for

resistance:

LMS wille gravely weakening

the ahility of the labour movement to

oppose Tory policies at the LEA

level, paradoxically opens the door to

grassroots action at school level. For

the unions, defending their members

wit entai stronger and more

autonomous workplace organisation,

with a consequent undermining of the

hold of their new realist leaderships.

The increased powers of school

grvertors means more power to

parents to community activists tas

coopted govemors) and to Labour

Party supporters, of whom there must

be at least a hundred thousand, mayhe

Iwice or three times that number, on

governing bodies, not just as Labour

Party nominees. If they can unite with

teachers and other school workers

around common objoctives, they can

make of LMS a Trojan horse for the

Tories

The Labour Party leadership

should be organising a national cam-

Page 18

"Every Labour LEA should be setting up a Governors Support Unit to provide not just initial training but ongoing coordination, briefing and back-up on a socialist basis"

policie:

paign now to arm its supporters it. the schools with the arguments and the tactics to resist the Tory offensive in education. Of course it will do no such thing. It is symptomatic that the motion from the Socialist Education Association to thin vear's Party cron ference, which is invariably passed, is concerned only with education policy after a Labour govemment is elected. and makes no mention of the need for resistance now to the most reactionary onslaught on education for sixty ycars.

Fortunately we don't have to wait for the Labour leadership. Local Labour Party branches can begin now to get organised for LMS. Up till now, though being a school governor is probably the largest single area of involvement by labour movement representatives in the state apparatus, it has hardly featured on the agenda of the left. Being a school governor is seen as something worthy but peripheral to the mainstream of

Labour Party politice The Tones have changed that. Every CLP, every

branch, has school governors in it.

whether as Party nominees, or parents, or teachers, or coopred mem-

bers. The first step is to identify them.

and then to bring them together on a constituency and a city-wide hasis.

Governons" support groups can over

come isolation and help give ordinary

working peaple on governing bodies

the arguments and the confidence to

stand up to Tory sympathisers and

mampulative heads. Without that

Labour governors will end up rubber-

stamping the Tory agenda, and af

worst sacking trade unionists to

balance the Torics" books.

The only way govemors can begin

to resist Tory policies is by basing

themselves on the colloctive strength

of teachers and other school workers

on the one hand, and parents and the

community on the other. Thix is the

strategic alhance that will have to be

built in the bitter local struggles that

will occur at school level as LMS is

introduced and the national cur-

riculum and national testing get under

way. The alternative is teachers and

parents trying to solve their problems

at cach others' expense. The bottom

line of such alliances has to be sup-

port by parents - and school students

- for industrial action by school staff.

but that can't be taken for granted:

teachers have to reach out beyond

their sectoral interests and actively

seek to construct common under

standings and objectives.

Governors are well placed to play

a key role in huilding that coalition of

interests, but their ability to do so depends upon the stance they take

over cuts in jobs and conditions and wer curs cducational altacks. It is impossible to build an alliance with people if you

are at the same time cutting their jobs

or overriding their coucational con-

cems. Instead of being the reluctant

agents of Tory attacks, Labour gover-

nors should be aiming to build a

coalition of support for their refusing

There are

to implement

analogics here with the position of

Labour councillors. In particular.

Labour governors must refuse to at-

and conditions of teachers and other school workers. That means running the school into the rod and campaigning for more money from the LEA and the govem- ment It means demanding that Labour councillors then refuse te carry out their legal obligaton to step in and take over the management

of the school from the governors in

order to make the cuts needed to balance the school budget.

Finally, there still remain two im- portant political roles for Labour

councils after LMS. First, they still have the rexponsibility of allocating the education hudget. We need to. demand that no school suffers a cut in its budget as a result of LMS; that maximum advantage is taken of tlie 25% of the delegaled budget thal is not decided simply by pupil numbers to discriminate as much as possible in

favour of working class schools, and

that insofar as possible essential ser-

vices are retained centrally and not

a nose.

with the

Secondly, they have to recognise the new situation, and realise that Labour councils have to respond to the shift of power to governors by putting hig resources into politically and lechnically supporting them. Every Labour LEA should be setting up a Govemors Support Unit to provide not just initial training bor ongoing coordination, briefing and back-up on a socialist basis. district Labour Party should be set- ting up procedures for coordination hetween Labour governors

Labour governors Labour councillors on the Education

Labour Committee.

coordination

and

the Fuscation

cumpaigns

workers and local can be built. LMS

the sort of direct involvement in the ation that nas neen al. absent for the pas

Richard Hatcher

OOK no 18. October 1989.

SUPPLEMENT

← Fighting the Education Reform Act in schools · Tories give students the third degree →

Something wrong on this page?