UPDATE
Conference flashpoints
NUCLEAR
DISARMAMENT
Graome Cookson
Ramamhor whan NIIDE chiafe Iko Rickerstaffe (riaht) backed unilateralism?
Backwards
This year's Labour Party Con- ference promises little excite- ment and even less prospect of progressive policies to arm Labour to fight the next elec- tion being adopted.
Conference's main job. 35 seen by the party managers, is to endorse the Policy Review, to give a show of unity and a stand- ing ovation to the Leader for the television cameras, and to forget about the policy-making role of the party.
Two key debates coming up at conference, and the positions taken on them by the leadership. make this clear.
First, on the new restrictions imposed on members, and the new powers assumed by the leadership in policy-making. Con- ference resolutions which conflict with the policy review will not be treated as amendments to it, not will they override it. Any conflict- ing resolutions, say the NEC, will simply be "laken into account" by the special joint NEC/PLP meet- ing after conference, which will produce a 'synthesis" of positions from the policy review and agreed resolutions:
This 'synthesis' (read stitch- up) will provide the party's cam- paigning platform between now and the next election. Whilst two leadership-friendly constituencies have tabled resolutions giving an uncritical welcome to the policy review, this centralising move is opposed by 31 CLPs in 23 resolu- tions submitted so far. They call instead for conference resolutions lo he treated as amendments to the policy review, where the two conflict. Success of these procedural resolutions is a pre- condition to the rest of the left's intervention having any quence at all.
Second - more fundamental
and even more sinister - is the be-
hind-the-scenes plotting to strip
Conference permanently of its
policy-making role. Last year's
conference agreed a consultation
process to review the fu- ture organisation and role of annual conference.
The NEC, eager to give Walworth Road officials time to line up the trusty union votes, want their report to be held over to next year. But the advo cales of this change, encouraged by the new "consensus" (mainly concentrated in Fleet Street) that the block vote, along with defence, must go, are pushing for a decisive move this year.
In a motion whuch tellingly ar- gues that "there are valuable les- sons to be leamed from the way in which other European socialist parties devclop policy, the GMB call for the 1990 report to con- sider tour important opions. These are: reform of the NEC (to marginalise and dilute the already tiny influence of the left); an ex- panded role for the NEC in for- mulating and directing policy downwards through new policy commissions National Con- ference to be restricted to amend. ing policy commission proposals; reduction of the union block vote to around 50%.
If these two slip through the net, the dangers are clear weakening of Labour's base in the organised working class, more concentration of power at the top. less say for members and less
chance of progressive policies
being adopted.
Whatever mechanism for
processing policy decisions is
used, there will be policy clashes
at this year's conference at least.
The opportunity to mobilise con-
stituency and trade union support
around clear, left policy options
must be maximised - not least be-
cause it may be a last chance
under what remains of the party's
democratic
decision-making
structures.
Defence will he the major
debate at conference, and the vote
will provide a measure of how
far, in the run-up to the next elec
tion at least, Kinnock has per-
suaded the constituencies and trade unions of his *lic-low strategy. The left is aware of the significance of the debate. 55 CLPS and one trade union (MSP) have submitted a total of 5l unilateralist resolutions. 11 CLPs and one union (USDAW) have expressed support for the switch to multilateralism. But with most of the union votes safely with Kinnock's camp (following deter- mined efforts to pull key unions into line on defence in their recent round of conterences, the prospects of victory are slim. The TGWU and MSF are 1r- major unions prepared to defend unilateralism.
The return of key utilities ‹water, electnetty and com- munications ete) to public owner- ship will also be controversial. Press repons have already indi- cated that Kinnock: is possed to shift policy control away from the NEC to the PLP in the run-up to the next clection, with a retreat on water a major aim.
Following the TUC decision to call for the phasing-out of all nuclear reactors within fifteen years, and the NEC and front- hench split on the issue, the dehale at conference will he heated and close - and offers the possibility of a left victory.
Again following the TUC's
decision, the debate er union legislation will be closely
watched. The TGWU call at TUC
and again at Labour Confcrence for legislation to protect union
immunities must he supported as
challenging
first step
Kinnock's collapse in front of the Tory laws
The Labour Campaigs. fr*
Lesbian and Gay Rights have or-
Fifteet.
(right) backed unlateralism? ganised effectively against the NEC's ditching of Labour's 1985 commitment to equalise the age of consent for gay men with that for heterosexuals. 6 resolutions submitted to this year's con- ference demand that a positive framework of lesbian and gay rights and specifically the equal age of consent he included in the pour review. The right, who have already exerted bellind the scenes pressure during the policy review process to delete any such proposals, will no doubt be keen to keep he lid on the debate at
conference to0. It doesn't look like they will get away with it,
however.
Electoral reform has attracted more resolutions than any otler issue bar defence. 28 CLP's have submitted resolutions arguing for some kind of electoral reform. with 8 specifically calling for PR. Although it is not an issue on which right and left reliably align for or against, it is certainly the
case that the right has organised, with some success, to promole this issue, trying to channel it into their framework of pro-consen- sus, pro centre and ultimately pro-pact politics.
However the left should not
allow a (nomally healthy) knee- jerk opposition to such right wing pressure to divert away from the fight for a more democratic sys- tem. The notion that PR equals pacts" is an invention of the night wing and the media: the left should clearly mobilise to oppose any composite proposals favour- ing clectoral pacts, while where possible supporting the principle of proportional representation.
Jane Wells
Page 6
SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 18, October 1989
FEATURES
South Africa
A new