Socialist Outlook

Socialist Viewpoint, International, Socialist Outlook and their supplements, 1984–2009

New man on the right line?

· Socialist Outlook no. 17, August 1989 · pp 34-35 · 948 words

Women

FEATURES Maria Barranco as Candela, Antonio Banderas as Carlos, and the telephone plays itself in a scene from the film

Is the 'new man' on the right line?

Women On the Verge of a Nervous Break- dOwn A film directed by Pedro Almodovar

Review By Alex Anderson

Women On the Verge of a Nerx- ous Breakdown can be seen simp- ly as the whimsical speculation of a male director about what happens to women when they wait for the phone call from the man of their dreams. The phone call that will draw them back from the verge, away from am- bivalence and into the arms of their hero. We as an audience can be grateful that the phone call never comes, and the film adds up to a lot more than that.

Women On the Verge opens with our main woman, Pepa, deeply submerged in a drug-in- duced sleep, oblivious to the tick- ing alarm clocks and the ringing telephone. Her unfaithful lover, Ivan, slips through her fingers, leaving a dulcet-toned message on her answering machine. She is late for a voice recording session where she has to dub Spanish dialogue onto a Joan Crawford melodrama. It is the pre-recorded voice of Ivan whom she must

play opposite. One gets the feel- ing that direct communication is going to be difficult in this film.

The film catapults itself through a plot that is both farci- cal and bizarre. It involves mis- taken identities, a long lost son, Shi'ite terrorists, numerous taxi rides with a wonderfully ec- centric taxi driver and countless changes of clothes. The answer- ing machine has a starring role.

The phone call doesn't come so in a fit of feminine pique the phone goes out of the window. The phone must be repaired to be ready for the expected call, and in walks Carlos, the long lost son of the unfaithful lover, who as a boy/man is genetically equipped to repair the telephone.

Meanwhile, a waif-like friend of Pepa's has taken refuge in Pepa's flat as she fears the police are after her for harbouring Shi'ite terrorists. It is decided that Pepa must go to a feminist lawyer to plead her friend's case.

Up to now we can see the film as a 'new man's' comic celebration of women's true grit; their passion and resilience when confronted with the failings of men, but with the introduction of the feminist lawyer, this 'new man's' politics begin to reveal

right

themselves. The feminist lawyer has no sympathy with a woman who has got herself into such a plight because of her emotions. The woman is a fool, and must go to gaol for it. The meeting ends with Pepa slapping the feminist, and, lo and behold, she finds she feels much better for having done so. Having rejected feminism, she feels refreshed and unencumbered, ready to re-enter the internecine battle with men. Give me a break.

It is here that we come to the heart of the film's message. It is the arch-woman that is being celebrated here, the feminine caricature. The woman who be- cause of her trusting and loving nature, (as played by Pepa's friend, Candela), suffers at the hands of men. Yet it all ends hap- pily as this collection of feminine caricatures, armed with a jug full of lethal gazpacho, overcome their pain and disappointment to become stronger, wiser women, ready to love again.

One of the interesting varia- tions on this theme is Carlos mother. Left by Ivan when Car- los was a baby, she has spent the greater part of the intervening twenty years in a loony bin. To be loony is a desirable state for

her because she claims that 'when you are crazy you have no memory, to be sane you have to remember'.

However, remembering seems to make her crazy. She decides she wants to shoot Ivan and commandeers a motorcycle and driver and careers her way to the airport chased by Pepa in the now familiar taxi. Pepa saves Ivan from his well-deserved fate, while Ivan's wife, having pulled the trigger, seems happy to be carted away to the safety of an asylum. A sensible option, given the circumstances, though she's treated as a big joke by the film maker.

Reactionary as the message may be, the film is about women (up to a point) and in these post- feminist times we must be grate- ful. As the plot untwists there are some wonderful comic moments and delicious coincidences. I share with the film maker his fas- cination with feminine acces- sories; high heels walking across a carpet, lipstick being applied, clothes being taken off and earings being put on. But as I leave the cinema I can't help but think thai I would be a lot hap- pier with these crumbs if a woman had baked the cake.

Page 32

SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 17, Summer 1989

Shylock's

The Merchant of Venice.

Play by William Shakespeare, produced by Peter Hall with Dustin Hoffman as Shylock

Reviewed by Judith

Arkwright

The greatest thing about Shakespeare's plays is their ability to endure through genera- tions

Peter Hail's production of The Merchant of Venice at the Phoenix Theatre till September, highlights all the issues that would interest a modern audience: racism, sexism, the heartlessness of a society ob- sessed with money are all given an airing in this most tragic of all Shakespeare's comedies.

The focal point of this produc- tion is the tragedy of Shylock, the Jewish moneylender seeking revenge on the hypocritical and racist Venetian traders with whom he is obliged to deal. The central metaphor of the play is money and the way it dominates

REVLEWS/

← True Blue Murder · Letters →

Something wrong on this page?