Socialist Outlook

Socialist Viewpoint, International, Socialist Outlook and their supplements, 1984–2009

Mississippi Burning

· Socialist Outlook no. 16, June 1989 · p 33 · 819 words

Burning is based on the true story of the killing of three young Civil Rights workers, Goodman, Chaney and Schwerner - two white and one black - in Mississippi in 1964 during the Civil Rights campaign in the South of the linited States.

The film starts with the murder - one barely has time to get involved in the fate of the young men - and concentrates on the efforts of the FBI to track down and prosecute the murderers,

The two main characters are FBI men, one a northerner and

one from Mississippi, where he

had been a sheriff before going north to join the PBI. Making the FBI the heroes makes for an odd feeling, to say the least. knowing that the reality is that they fully back the racist system and indulge in all kinds of nefarious practices which damage civil rights

That sard, the film is interesting and worth seeing. It brings different things to different people. I went to see it with three other people, one of them black. For me, it brought hack the horror which I had felt at the time of the murders. Bad as all the other violence and murders during the Civil Rights campaign had been, these seemed particularly horrific because of the way in which the roung men had been set up and solated for the purpose of murder, because of the way in which it was not allowed that they be buried together in Mississippi and, most of all. because of the way in which Chancy, the black man, had heen mutilated as well as killed.

Unlikely heroes: Hackman and Dafoe as FBI men

The film shows the black community as simply passive

inevitable gloss given by the production.

The youngest of the party, in her late twenties, was not sure whether these particular murders were fictional, extrapolated from the general history of the period, or factual. She, along with about half the audience, was black, and had had some doubts about going to see the film - much along the same lines as women might have about going to see The Accused - but, having seen it, felt that it had been worth the pain. The audience as a whole were obviously moved - the silence was palpable as we left the cinema.

The film was in the liberal tradition - clearly against racism und higotry, but without any real analysis of their causes. The nearest it came to such an analysis was when the Mississippian FBi man told his colleague a story about his father killing the mule of a neighbouring black farmer who was doing better than his father. He ended the story by saying. *If he was no better than a

Negro, he was nothing.

However, it does raise a number of interesting questions. The Northem FBI man clearly sees the Southemers as somehow weird and himself as coming South to solve the problems there. The black community is largely passive and frightened, though elements of resistance do come through - as, for example, in some of the church services, in the scene where the black farmer takes his

un out to try to fight off the

Clan invaders and in the scene where the young black boy tells the FBI man to ask the sheriff

his questions, and responds to

the latter's question, aren't you trightened? by saying. 'Why aren't you!

The attitude of white Southemers who are not Klan memhers is also raised, though not fully explored. For example, in one scene, the camera cuts straight from the beating up of a young black boy to a television interview with a woman in the crowd watching the drazging of the swamp for the bodics. She is asked how she thinks black people are treated in Mississippi

and responds along the lines that they are generally treated well and it's only the Northern student rabble who have stirred up trouble. The turing point in the film comes when the wite of the deputy sherlf gives the FBI the inforiation which leads to their being able to set up and calch the criminals. When she is severely beaten up as a result of this, the feeling of the PBI mcn changes from one of professional determination to one of emotional involvement. For the audience, too, this scene leads to audible gasps. Do we still feel more about violence against a white person? Or was this because she was a woman? Or hecause of the realisation that the Kian would attack anyone, regardless of colour?

However, though the

questions are raised, answers are not explored and the glossines of the treatment of the FBI is unrealistic and disturbing. In spite of these reservations, the rilm is worth making at effort to see. Like Cry Freedom, it is a lot better than might have been expected, though it is worse than one would have liked.

← Real Lives? · Obituaries →

Something wrong on this page?