Socialist Outlook

Socialist Viewpoint, International, Socialist Outlook and their supplements, 1984–2009

Letters

Socialist Outlook no. 16, June 1989 · pp 35-36 · 1,344 words

Letters

Trotsky Asia Lesbian and gay Russia and the USSR

SOCIALIST

OUTLOOK

LETTERS

We welcome your views and comments.

Write to:

Socialist Outlook, PO Box 705,

London SW19 1HA

Reactionary separatism in India The call for the establishement of a Sikh nation (Khalistan) in the Punjab is a totally reactionary and sectarian demand Jonathan Jones (Socialist Outlook 14) is wrong to equate this reactionary movement in the Punjah with national feeling in Kashmir.

The agitation today in Punjab is not for a Punjabi state hut for Khalistan. In any case Punjab is divided between India and Pakistan - a division which took place at the tinie of independence and which inveilved the most brutal inter-community conflicts.

This brutal communalism is mirrored today in the pro-Khalistan movement in the Punjah and in communalist purties in other states. An well as systematically murdering socialists and other political opponents, the Khalistanis regularly slaughter ordinary Hindus. In this way they hope to drive non-Sikhs out of Punjab and to have Sikhs driven out of other parts of India.

Despite the fact that the Khalistanis are in

a small minority even among Sikhs, they have had a degree of success in this aim. The Khalistan movement is not one of an oppressed nationality, but of religious fundamentalists reflecting the interests of well-off farmers and petit bourgcois sections. and supported only by reactionary forces in Pakistan and their friends in the CIA.

Thus any success for the Khalistan movement would strengthen reactionary communalist and sectarian forces in other Indian states. Far from strengthening the hand of the Indian masses, it would be an enormous blow, opening up further divisions that would take years to heal.

The I.C.S. (Inquilabi Communist Sangathan - which is the Indian Section of the Fourth Internationi) is implacably opposed to the Khalistan movement as are other socialists in India.

An unrelenting struggle against the Khalistanis, both in Britain and India, should not detract from our oppostion to other communalist currents, nor to the increasing concessions which the ruling Congress Party makes to such developments. Indeed in many places it has heen sections of the Congress Party who are themselves responsible for fomenting communalism and who have played their part in creating the basis for the rise of the pro-Khalistan movement. Ollver New, West London

Once again, lesbians made invisible I am writing to reavsure readers that despite the blatant omission of any mention of lesbians from the write-up of the Women for Socialism Conference in Socialist Outlook No 14, Women for Socialism is committed to

building a socialist feminist movement that is for all women, including lesbians.

This was demonstrated by the fact that we had a speaker from the Socialist Lesbian Group on the platform in the opening plenary of the Conference, a workshop on "Lesbians and Socialism" which was one of the best attended of the day and discussed a wide range of issues rarely on conference agendas. and that the 'structure, aims and objectives which were adopted, specifically state that Women for Socialism is anti-heterosexist and that the steering group would include the post of lesbian liaison officer (which was filled).

I certainly feel that this is a great step forward for a socialist-ferinist tradition that has largely failed to take up lesbian issues, greatly to its detriment. Unfortunatcly this appears to be a view not universally held.

Yours wondering what it takes sometimes, Rebecca Flemming

The stuff that dreams are made of? John Lister (Socialist Oullook No 14) says "thoughts are material things. They are not. Matter is that which exists independently of thoughts. There is no other definition. If thoughts are matter, how can matter exist independently of them? To say that thought is material is no better than saying matter is "mental", and turns materialism into a nonsense, Both say 'matter and thoughts are the same stuff Cliff Slaughter, Leeds

PS I must correct Mike Pearse's letter on the WRP. The WRP's crisis of 1985 was not "terminal.

st correct Mike Pearse * letter The WRP's crisis of 985 wi

ties, in which he argues that it was Trotsky who misunderstood the dialectic, and that his interpreta- tion of history was flawed.

With Harry Wicks, Reg Groves, Henry Sara and others, James played a prominent part in the Trotsky Defence Committee which was set up to counter the avalanche of falschoods which came out of the Moscow Trials. Al- though he continued to play a role in Trotskyist cireles, he increasing- ly concentrated on rescarch and writing.

His novel abour West Indian barrack-yard life, Minty Alley was published in 1936, and he was working on what was to be his magnum opus, his study of the San Domingo revolt, the first success ful slave rising in history. The Black Jacobins is now acknow- ledged as the classical study of that epoch-making event, and showed James mastery of the theory of permanent revolution.

In 1938 he published A History of Negro Revolt. After the unifica-

tion of most of the Trotskyist grouplets in 1938, James was one of the delegates to the Founding Conference of the Fourth Intema- tional, and was elected onto the In- temational Executive Committee.

In 1938, James left Britain for the United States and immediately plunged himself into the work of the Socialist Workers Party (SWP), particularly concentrating on issues affecting black people.

He spent some weeks with Trotsky in Mexico, where they dis- cussed the question of an autonomous black movement. Within the SWP he fought for a tum toward black people as an in- legral part of the revolutionary movement in the USA

The outbreak of World War Two and the crisis which arose within the SWP over its position on the Soviet Union gave James the opportunity to develop his dif- ferences with Trotsky, For James, the signing of the Stalin Hitler Pact was the culminating evidence that the USSR was no longer a

SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 16 June 1989

workers state which had to be defended.

In collaboration with Raya Dunyevskaya he formed the Johnson- Forrest Tendency, which developed theoretical positions which took them further and fur- ther away from the traditional posi- tions of Trotsky and the Fourth In- temational. They argued that the Stalinist parties outside the USSR were not the 'tools of the Kremlin". but were an organic product of the mode of capitalism at this stage". The Soviet Union was not a deformed workers' state in which the bureaucracy had usurped state power, but state capitalist. His break with Trotskyism was now absolute,

James also played an active role in support of the growing revolt against colonial rule, especially in Africa. Kwame Nkrumah was a protegé of his, and he was hopeful that Nkrumah would lead the fight for a free and socialist Africa. But he did not hesitate to break from Nkrumah when he saw where he

was going.

In his latter years CLR - as he was universally called - almost be- came a living legend. His room in Brixton became a place of pilgrimage

for black revolutionaries from all over the world, His interests were widespread and cosmopolitan. A passionate love for Shakespeare and Beethoven vied with his devo- tion to cricket and his continued in- terest in revolutionary politics.

He remained an optimist all his life. On his 80th birthday he told a young audience in Chicago '1 will live to sec the South African revolution. I don't think I will live to sce the American revolution, but when you make your revolution I will find some way of coming here to join you.

That revolutionary optimism. that unquestionable belief in the future of humanity was the charac-1 teristic wich best sums up CLR James -thinker, writer, revolution- ary.

Page 33

As we head towards a summer of struggle ...

18 7

EVERY MONTH

the magazine for the class

struggle left

Special rates for regular individual subscribers:

1 year's subscription (ten issues) for £8.50 (inland); £10 (Europe); £15 (outside Europe) (multi-reader institutions E17 inland, £30 overseas

Name.. Address.

Subscription to start from issue number (Return to Socialist Outlook, PO Box 705, London SW19 1HA, England.

← Obituaries · Italian left regroups →

Something wrong on this page?