Socialist Outlook

Socialist Viewpoint, International, Socialist Outlook and their supplements, 1984–2009

Kinnock's Review seeks bosses' approval

Socialist Outlook no. 16, June 1989 · pp 4-5 · 1,433 words

Reviews

Britain Labour Party Economy

With the publication of the Policy Review in mid-May, Neil Kin- nock now only needs the stamp of approval of Labour Party con- ference in October to complete the process of bringing the Party back into line with policies acceptable to the ruling class.

Since the demise of the Liberals as the second main bourgeois Party, the ruling class has (reluc- tantly) used the Lahour Party as their fall-back at times of Tory un. popularity, safe in the knowledge that it was also concered with the orderly running of capitalism, and could even in certain circumstan- ces, police the working class more easily than the Tories.

For a period after Thatcher came to power in 1979 this arran- gement looked like being upset. In reaction to the policies of Prime Ministers Harold Wilson and James Callaghan the Labour Party moved (at least on paper) con- siderably leftwards, introducing measures of democratic account- ability (such as the clection of the Leader and automatic reselection procedures for MPs) and some socialist policies. such ar unilateralism.

Ever since he was elected leader in 1983 it has been Kinnock's intention to reverse these changes. In this he has been pressured and encouraged hy the bourgeois media and the Alhance. Kinnock and the SDP renegades from Labour wanted the same thing to bring mainstream British politics back into safe bourgeois channels.

Despite their tactical disagree- ments over how this was best done

- the Labour right believing they could beat back the left within the Party, and the Owenites believing this was hopeless and setting themselves the task of creating a new force to replace Labour as the altemative Party of government - they assisted each other in this The support for the Alliance (en-

PHOTO: Androw Wiard/ Roport

Page 2

Balism for old: Kinnock has ditc couraged by the medial gave credence to the Kinnock line that Labour was 'unelectable' with left policies.

Throughout, Kinnock has been assixted by the refusal of the trade union bureaucracy to fight back against the Tories' onslaught on jobs and democratic rights or their programme of privatisation. Every time they have retreated or sold out a struggle they have under- mined Left policies feeding the view that there is no alternative to capitalism and little chance of stopping the Tory onslaught other than by eventually electing a Labour govemment.

Frustrated with the slow process of reversing policy by way

of conference resolutions, Kin- nock instigated the Policy Review" two years ago. It was clear from the start that this was designed to change policies wholesale, while maintaining a (very thin) veneer of being a democratic process. Having defeated the hard left, reducing them to a handful on Labour's Na- tional Executive, and confident that the remnants of the soft left' would not put up a challenge, the Kinnockites could be sure of win- ning on the NEC.

The first year of the Policy Review was used as a softening- up process for the more difficult issues, in particular defence. Last

year's phase one, with its hland

hed unilateralism talk of individual rights rather than collective action. togetlier with significant constitutional changes fone of which was used to keep Martha Osamor off the shortlist for Vauxhall), sailed through the 1988 Conference with little op position.

Phase two, to be put to this year's conference, is far more sig nificant and crucial to Kinnock's project, and recognised as such by the media. Its sections on the economy, trade unions and defence contain Kinnock's blueprint for the programme of a future Labour govemment.

the economy. the programme could not make it clearer that the 'new " Labour Party represents no threat to capitalism. Of all Thatcher's privatisations, only British Telocom and water would be taken back into state hands (and then hought back). There would be no wealth tax. with a top tax rate of only 50 per cent, perpetuating the role of Labour as the Party of high taxes

- for the working class, not the bosses. There is no threat to nationalise the banks or institute exchange controls, only to reduce consumption.

Key Tory anti-union laws, in- troduced by Thatcher to hamstring the working class during her at- tempts to restructure British capitalism, would not he repealed by Labour. The right of the courts

to intervene in union affairs

and to declare strikes illegal

would be retained, as

would secret ballots and the

banning of many sympathy

strikes.

The statement on

defence was the most

awaited, even though its

broad outline was widely

forescen. In its essentials.

Kinnock has not failed the

ruling class, rejecting

unilateralism and accepting

the myth of a Russian

threat. His refusal to answer

the question as to whether

he would actually press the

button. while the source of

much humour, is of less im-

portance,

The outcome of the

Policy Review on disarma-

ment has always been seen as the touchstone for the Left's fortunes. For many Party members a commitment to unilateralism has been one of the strengths of thie Labour Party in recent years, even if its leaders have refused to cam- paign for it. It is around this that resistance will be greatest at Labour Party conference and it is the issuc on which the soft left on the NEC might have been ex pected to put up some kind of Yel opposition to the Policy

Tel opposition to the Policy Review on the NEC was restricted to the hard left on virtually every major issue. Even on disarmament Clare Short, Robin Cook and Bryan Gould failed to support an amendment calling for the removal of nuclear weapons and bases within the lifetime of a single parliament. Short, feted by the Time to Go' campaign against the British presence in Ireland, could not even see her way to sup- porting the deletion of a commit- ment to the Anglo Inish agree- ment.

For years the soft left promised to keep Kinnock and Labour policy out of the hands of the right, while in fact retreating all the time on policies they allegedly support, and directing their attacks at the hard left for their oppositionism". Now it is clear for all to sce where their attitude isleading-complete victory for Kinnock and the right

SOCIALIST OUTLOOK

with only the hard left putting up serious resistance.

Kinnock and his cohorts are so certain of winning (especially after their "victories' against unilateralism at some union con- ferences) that they have not bothered to wait for Labour Party conference before launching the Policy Review to the media with all the razzamatazz of a Hol lywood awards ceremony

The leaders of the soft left have conceded to Kinnock's central ar- gument - that to get Labour elected it must jettison left policies. In the process they have shown, like Kinnock, that they never bad any senious commit-

ment to those policies, and demonstrated their lack of concern with what sort of Labour govem- ment all this might produce - a dis astrous re-run of Wilson and Cal- laghan trying to run capitalism at the expense of the working class.

For the present, Kinnock's strategy appears to be successful. Council and parliamentary elec- tion results show Labour gaining support, with even the possibility on the horizon of winning a general election. Yet with the economy faltering and inflation rising, and the next round of privatisation (water, clectricity) being the least popular, the Tories themselves are faltering despite

the lack of any serious counter-at- tack from Labour.

The renewed wave of strikes reflects disillusionment with the Tories and contributes to Labour's rise in the polls without the Labour Party lifting a finger in support of those fighting back. At the same time Labour gains from the fact that the 'centre" parties have col- lapsed - precisely because Kin- nock has stolen their clothes and the media no longer sees the need to prop them up.

The Left, however, cannot sit back and wait for Kinnock's policiesto be shown to be a failure. There is still an outside chance of winning on unilateralism at this

year's conference if all its sup porters can work together.

We have to link up with the struggles taking place over pay. the Poll Tax, the NHS and privatisation, not only to provide a strategy to win against the Tories and bosses, but also to win new forces to the battle against Kinnock's social democratic policies. At the same time the left hasto look seriously at the lessons of the last few years and how Kin- nock has managed to turn back the left tide.

Pete Firmin.

New

← Editorial · New bosses to carve up the NHS →

Something wrong on this page?