Socialist Outlook

Socialist Viewpoint, International, Socialist Outlook and their supplements, 1984–2009

Bad enough in the pub

· Socialist Outlook no. 16, June 1989 · pp 8-9 · 1,938 words

Trade unions Britain

enough there is no proposed legislation which would give similar rights to a worker denied a job because they were members of a union.

The Green Paper also proposes removing further legal protection from secondary dis putes where the other employer is supplying goods to the boss who is in dispute with the original strikers. Workers on strike who call on others to take sympathetic action and embargo goods destined for their employer will face legal penalties.

If the recent proposals had been on the statute book in 1988, then the threat of the Ford workers to take industrial action over the "single union deal at Dundee would have been in defiance of the law, and therefore subject to legal penaltiex. The proposals also recommend giving more powers to the so-called Commis sioner for the Rights of Union Members, as well as extending strike balloting laws to cover people working under "contracts for service" which would affect many people like freelance writers.

Along with the present Employment Bill. due to go on the statute book in the autumn of this year, the Green Paper, which becomes law in 1990 will be the seventh piece of anti-trade union legislation since the Tories were elected in 1979. Unlike Labour's In Place of Strife, or Heath's 1971 Industrial Relations Act, this ad- ministration has not tried to curb union rights in one fell swoop. It has, instead, at two yearly intervals, consistently emded the rightsof trade union members by the device of unending the existing laws which operate in the industrial tribunals and the civil courts.

Unions can be sued by employers, their own members, and by third parties who have suf- fered damages arising from what they define as unlawful action. Most secondary action is un- lawful, and if Removing the Barriers to Emplayment becomes law, will be even more so. Political strikes are in breach of the law. Employers have been granted greater freedom

Page 6

to dismiss strikers. Unions are not al- lowed to discipline members wht refuse to abide by a strike vote, even though the ballot has boen carried out under the government's stringent ballot rules.

If unions do dis- cipline their mem- bers for scabbing. then the strike-

who the

breaker 1s ennuca Removing the barriers to union-busting: Thatcher's seventh to compensation. anti-union package is coming - with no TUC opposition in sight All these measures which are designed to make sure that workers find it more and more difficult to either call a strike, or win one, are further reinforced by legislation that forbids picketing by strikers anywhere but at their own place of work.

As recent disputes have shown, sequestra- tion of union funds is a powerful weapon in the hands of both the state and the employers. Unions can be bankrupted and often the threat of scquestration is enough to make the timid bureaucrats who lead most of Britain's unions run for cover.

Unions can not now reimburse members' legal expenses for offences allegedly com- mitted during a strike. However, workers who want to take action in the courts against their union are given a heiping hand. A Central Of- fice of Information leaflet explains how the Commissioner for the Rights of Trade Union Members can probably help them. In says that even if the litigant loses the case in the courts, provided it "was brought with the Commissioner's assistance the Commissioner will hear the costs awarded against you.

But state generosity does not extend to those workers victimised, or discriminated against, who want to take their grievance to an industrial tribunal. In 1979, six months" service qualified a worker to appeal against unfair dismissal. This now stands at two years. Furthermore, it is proposed that industrial tribonals can demand that the claimant pays a deposit before their case is heard. Even if the claim is upheld, there is no right to a statutory minimum payment, which is rather a contrast to the compensation of up to E8,925 the dismissed non-unionist might pick up.

The Employment Bill is a real onslaught on

employment protection rights. Clause eight of thix Bill amends existing laws, particularly the 1961 Factory Act, so as to remove restrictions on the employment of young people between 16 and 18. As a result many of the present limits on hours of work — total daily hours, weekend work, night work and shift working times, and half-day bolidays for young persons under the 1950 Shops Act will he repealed. Women workers in firms employing five or less people. no longer have the right to return to work after maternity leave. Restrictions on women doing night work will be repealed.

Clause ten of the Bill makes amendments to the previous rights of all employees to reasonahle time off work, with pay, to carry out the duties of a union official, if that union is recognised by management. The amendments Limit paid time off for union work and time off for training to matters in which the union is recognised by the employer. This will severe- ly restrict the time lay officials can take off for their union duties and for union training schemes.

This constant attenipt by the govemment to undermine basic trade union rights and workers job conditions has attracted criticism from far beyond the British labour movement.

The Geneva-based United Nations Intema- tional Labour Organisation, has called for legislation to bring Britain into line with the minimum requirements accepted by over 100 countries throughout the world. It points out that Britain has broken international conven- tions on eight counts. It lists these as follows:

• The union han at GCHQ.

• The denial of negotiating rights 10 teachers.

• Allowing employers to blacklist union

SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 16 June 1989

PHOTO: John Harris/Fl

members.

• Restrictions on uninns' rightsin discipline memhers.

• The ban on unions paying fines on members behalf.

• The ban on sympathetic action.

• Allowing employers to split companies artificially to limit industrial action.

• Allowing employers to sack workers who

Even the Cabolic Church, hardly a body

Up against the law: dockers lobby

• Restrictions on uninns' rightsin discipline

• The ban on unions paying fines on

militancy has joined in the protests against

noting that modern technology can often main-

Thatcher's anti-union policies. A Catholic Truth Society publication A Threefold Chord.

tain production long cnough for strikers to ex- haust themselves, conclude that 100 per cent suppert of coployces and pickets is 'ahsolute- ly necessary" It therefore criticises the legista- tion that allows union membersto dely majority votes, with the apt comment...if a member of the government were to vote against govern- ment policy, that member would be shown the

ment

anwn the

IFonly the Labour Party was so forthright in its criticisms of the anti union laws! The policy

review has come up with nothing specific. It has not one word to say on the vital issue of pick- eting. Although Michael Meacher, the shadnw employment secretary, did talk on television about unions having the right in certain instan ces, to take secondary action, he in no way ar-

emplos

gued that Labour should abolish the Tories' anti-picketing legislation. Even this mild stand has brought the wrath of Kinnock and the new

realists down on his bead and the Sunday Times of 28 May reported that in October Meacher would he sacked from his job and

Mr-

replaced by a moderate who would help 1o shed Labour's image of heing dominated by the unions"

One of Labour's new ad-men, Leslie Butter- feld, who is involved in selling Kinnock to the

electors, calls the new policy stance "the new

which he reckons to be a 'highly marketable product. Speaking about the

SOCMLIST OUTLOOK no 16 June 1989

realism

who determine how a union spends its money. None of these matters should be the preroga- tive of non-elected High Court judges, who are

only loyal and responsible to the bourgcois state.

wall ming any reliance on the

tEEL. we should nevertheless demand

that many of the aspects of its Social Charter

are implemented. Particularly those covering

of work, access to decent

not of all calzens to social benefits, the right to belong to a trade union. un in wake and for a cuaranteed mini-

-ven sinse quite modest

are ast going to he handed

wilesy of a Tory government. Thatcher's present ravings against Brussels are

in no small part attributable to the Social

that

Retreating before the law: Ron Todd People at Work, Butterfield commented: "I's not saying we will repeal every bit of industrial relations legislation since 1979. A Bill of Rights for the workforce offers a lot, and doesn't give carte blanche for secondary pick- cting."

Now as Peter Mandelson. Labour' spublicity supremo, and his ad team are far better in- formed on policy matters than Labour's elected national exccutive. you can take what Mr But- tertield says as being from the horse's mouth. Kinnock's new realism is going to be very short

on restoring union rights. Their concern is with

assuring the bourgeoisic that Labour is fit to govem - trade union members' democratic rights come a poor second.

The struggle against Thatcher's anti-trade

union laws cannot be safely left in the hands of the "new realists". Right now a campaign must begin in the constituency parties and in the unions, which insists that a new labour govern meat will repeal all the anti-union legislation brought in since 1979.

The unions are the defensive organisations of the working class. They are the means whereby workers defend their living standards. protect health and safety at work, and defend their members against unfair dismissal and vic- timisation. It is the members alone who should decide when and where to strike. They must decide whether or not to discipline scabs who nave pur their own selfisn interests above those ten years. of the majority of the members. It must he the

rank and file and their elected representatives

and defend sal and vu who shrund

20EM Ris -

mendatin

LOWI That

Charter.

Only resolute trade union struggle will en- sure that these recommendations are achieved. And that means defying the government's anti- union laws. Because the unions failed to take the use saw. trade unionism was wiped out at GCHQ. For Thatcher, Cheltenham was just onc step along the mad to rendening the unions powerless. She and her cabinet are determined to bring in legislation that eventually will prevent all stnikes. Even if they do not see them- scives able to climinate the trade unions in the foresceable future, they do intend to render them ineffectual.

Labour by its silence over its proposals on

over its pronosas on industrial relations has spoken volumes. There

is no guarantee that Labour will win the next election. Nor is there any guarantee that if it

does do, that it will restore to the union mem-

berx their hasic rights. By all means let ux cam-

paign to commit Labour to a policy of total

repeal, but let us start the fight now to build a movement right across the unions which is

prepared to break the Tories" anti-union laws.

That is the only way to win back the democratic

rights of the working people, which the state

and its courts have stolen from them in the last

"AT • ™ I

berx their hasic rights. By all means let ux cam-

it Labour to

That is the only way to win back the democratic rights of the working people, which the state and its courts have stolen from them in the last

By Janet Knight

Page 7

← New Tory legal threat to unions · Chesterfield - third time around →

Something wrong on this page?