Protest and Stark turns the tables. The green-house effect submerge come together to defeat a scattered round the globe people's jobs? What are the most of Bangladesh in forty promoted with cardboard Ben Elton (Sphere survive conspiracy (generally waste at sea? Will the go to bed together. Books, £3.50) Reviewed by Steve Potter with each other. Stark
SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 15 May 1989 Subscription for 5 Issues of NSR (surface E10; 100FF; air mail add 20%). Please indicate with which issue able in a bank located in France, postal giros to CCP Paris • 6 Populism in Latin America by Adolfo Gilly, Helena • 7/8 Market and Plan in Postcapitalist Societies, the Ex- perience of the So-Called Socialist Countries by • 9 The Formative Yearsofthe Fourth International (1933- • 10 Marrism and Liberation Theology by Michael Itwy All payments to P Rousset. Preferred: French Francs pay- Hirata, Carlos M Vilas and the PRT (Argentina) intro- NSB, 2 rue Richard-Lenoir, 93108 Montreuil, France. Individual orders: PO Box 705 London SW19 1HA + 11 The Bourgeois Revolations by Robert Lochhead Marxism and Liberation subscription begins (you may include back issues). duced by Michael 1öwy (documents) (40pp, £2) 1938) by Daniel Bennald (lecture) (48pp, €2.50) Notebooks for Study and Research 11 54197 T, (please avoid Eurochecks). Catherine Samary (lecture) (64pp, £3) Michael Löwy Theology Mail cheques and orders to: (study) (40pp, £2) The Notebooks for Study and Research are sponsored by the A "lecture" series: edited transcriptions of classes given at * 1 The Place of Marnism in History by Emest Mandel • 2 The Chinese Revolution - I; The Second Chinese Revolution and the Shaping of the Maoint Outlook by + 3 The Chinese Revolution -IT: The Maoist ProjectTested in the Struggle for Power by Pierre Rousset (study) • 4 Revolutionary Strategy Today by Daniel Bensaid (lec- + 5 Class Struggle and Technological Change in /apan series: collections of docu- International Institute for Research and Education of A 'studien" serics: systematic studies of either particularen- ments, articles and interviews designed to update a con- periences in a given country or a particular theme. Since 1945 by Muto Ichiyo (study) (48pp, £2.50) Number 10 Amsterdam. They include three series: out now! Pierre Rousset (study) (32pp, £2) A documents and debales' troversial question. (study) (40pp, 52) ture) (36pp. E2) and to leave a safer world for our Margaret Thatcher7 No, it comes working class issue: the response competition at the moment. Read Porritt? Margaret Thatcher? Neil selling themselves, the polluters, Which is good, for the radical his: After all, it's up to all of us attitude to Stark. But that's their to fight the problem of pollution of much of the British far left is No doubt some will fake this seriously tried to claim ecology to sniff suspiciously around the ecological issue, declaring it to marketing capitalists are now Lots of people will buy it and ecologist movement has stiff Kinnock trying to sound like as saviours of a future world. be too soft to merit scrious children and grandchildren.* Only Arthur Scargill has Who said that? Jonathan problem, not Ben Elton's, on the back of'a packet of for what it is — a central Through a miracle of Peaudouce nappies. attention. Page 32 read it.
have been to demand procisely that the Soviet workers and peasants and commit itself to the at the time of the intervention in 1979 by the the two PDPA factions). Despite this, should the Marxist response have been to join in the ousting of the Khalq Faction and the murder the independent mobilisations of the Afghan of Amin and the installation in power of the imperialist orchestrated chorus and demand Parcham Faction (the more conservative of burcaucracy sovietise Afghanistan? That is demand that the burcaucracy base itself on - or should it expropriation of the ruling classes and the In relation to the Soviet invasion of establishment of a workers' state. That Soviet troops withdraw slaughter of large sections of the Afghanistan Revolutionary socialists formulate strategy removal of Soviet Armed Forces is genocidal not through abstract models of development ERS sanghter and the enforcing of a visciously reactionary fundamentalist regime, Their remaining provides elementary physical but day to day reality: the reality of the favouring the Soviet withdrawal from insubstantial matter of the consequent There is something of a problems with Afghanistan (SO 13). It is the not population by the Mujahedin. ETT Afghanistan SOCIALIST OUTLOOK We welcome your views and comments. Soclalist Outlook, PO Box 705, LETTERS Write to:
Page 33 Finland but correct to have called for a Sovier was maintained by Trotsky, If John and other pacify the hig landlords and other forces who counter-revolutionary war. The Afghan crisis who were the most vociferous on the Marxist Socialist Outlook can in no way be compared today's exception becoming tomorrow's rule. line of Socialist Organiser on Afghanistan is comrades claim to hold a Trotskyist position then the onus is on them to show why it was got into deeper and deeper water throughout defending a marxist position on the workers" to the social chauvinist cretinism of Socialist the 1980s but this must be seen as a product of the rightist oricntation of the bureaucracy under the proletarian dictatorship, whilst the positions on the Maivinas, Palestine, Ireland maintained by Schachtman whilst the latter Menshevist-Stalinist, bourgeois-democratic It is no accident that Socialist Organiser. correct to oppose a Soviet withdrawal from establishment of a workers' state the Soviet and also encouraged the Mujahedin in their demobilised sections of the Afghan masses It is obvious that the Soviet burcaucracy any claim to be a Marxist-Leninist party at resulting in the dismantling of many of the had an interest in overthrowing the regime. Afghanistan at the time of the intervention, states and explicitly defend the position of Schachtman against those of Trotsky. The exception that proves the rule. A failure to This culminated in the PDPA abandoning left in favour of a Sovict withdrawad from Finland in 1940, the former position was imperialist pressure as expressed in their Organiser, Afghanistan stands out as the confirms Trotsky's theory of Permanent correct this wrong position may result in national liberation can only be achieved gains of the 1978 revolution in order to underdeveloped and oppressed nations. and the Parcham Faction of the PDPA, have today abandoned any pretence at hureaucracy and the Parcham Faction part of their consistent capitulation to Whilst the international politics of By setting themselves against the Revolution, Namely that in the withdrawal from Afghanistan. line leads to defeat. the end of 1988. Patrick Scott The PDPA Stalinists instituted a number of that now they are withdrawing this represents oppressed.. can pave the way for socialism." of the Mujahedin. While the SAF were there It is with uncharacteristic disregard for the financed by reaction and fuelled by religious The editorial is quite correct to assert that movement: can we favour the proconditions degeneration of the SWP(UK). As such they Of course it is true, as John states, that the statement on Afghanistan (SO 13) attempt a who are about to be lacerated by the bullets significant reforms: abolishing bride prices, Whatever the possibilities of cither in the Mujahedin. Its rule will mean mass murder, establishing schools, and various important Tand reforms. Its replacement by those who advocate in their refuge camps the stoning lives of thousands that SO can countenance position somewhere between a defencist (ie influence. This line was clearly emphasised of women adulterers, who are in the pay of troop withdrawal all along we are also told But this is not immediately useful to those programme beat left behind in the seventh over the next year is a sickening prospect. are full of contradictions. We are told that they at least mitigated their worst affects, miscry and barbarism. To watch it unfold John Lister's uticle and also the editorial Khomeni's counter-revolution was an backwardness. A political solution and a whilst we should have favoured a Soviet Marxist current await to be brought into enormous setback for the revolutionary sovietising Afghanistan but was merely: Soviet hureaucracy had no intention of Bonapartist regime within its sphere of Marxist) position and the 'third camp' interested in securing the rule of a left the regime of Hehmalyar i Islamic — US imperialism and have a political for the creation of a similar state in abandonment of the country to the only the 'sclf organisation of the short term, they are hindered by a defeat for the working class! century, would be disastrous. being in Afghanistan. Afghanistan 2 Simon Kennedy theories, as all good Trotskyists should know, All this is a far cry from the scenario of the • The elections were sponsored hy a wing of them may richly deserve, but that is beside that the process of political revolution will be so much to defend democracy in the working limited, is irreversible and was initiated from however now clearly hold out the possibility centred around a leading figure in the CPSU class movement, were to be left in a political Stalinism by the Trotskyist movement in all seemed possible in the 1930s, when Trotsky revolution. At the very least we can now sec I believe this view deserves debate, of the Gorbachev and Political Revolution different and more complex than previously the Stalinists against its walls. (A fate some With Kruschev and now Gorbachev, it is of a much greater degree of self-reform and The recent elections in the Soviet Union clear that the Soviet bureaucracy is capable would be tragic if Trotskyism, having done masses storming the Kremlin and shooting Political Revolution. Acording to this, as I kind Socialist Outlook so well provides. It but one respect — Trotsky's theory of the SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 15 May 1989 usurped political power from the working ® The democratisation process, oven if democratic revolution when it was taking of a relatively peaceful process of refor revolution from below, in a more or less Tarig Ali says, an element of revolution backwater because it did not recognise a The important points to note here are: envisuged by Trotskyists. It involves, as class, would never willingly concede it. Glastnost has vindicated the critique of • The process of reform is currently understand it, the hurcaucracy, having was formulating the theory of political When history settics a question only of the bureaucracy led by Gorbachev: political reform of Soviet society than sectarian dogmatists cling to obsolete Hence the need for a working class Icading to full socialist democracy, within the bureaucracy itself; - Boris Yeltsin. violent process. Alan Radford Bristol
MERS WIVES GROUp a summer of struggle ... As we head towards
READ SOCIALIST OUTLOOK EVERY MONTH (multi-reader institutions £17 inland, £30 overseas £8.50 (inland); £10 (Europe); £15 (outside Europe) Special rates for regular individual subscribers: 1 year's subscription (ten issues) for (Return to Socialist Outlook, PO Box 705, London SW19 1HA, England. Subscription to start from issue number... Address.. Name...