F EATURES
The National Dock Labour Scheme is
under assault from the Tories, with the connivance of the employers. Here BOB PENNINGTON. who was an official of
the 'Blue Union' on the docks in
1954-55, looks at the history of the
Labour
with in- те BOB
would seriously affect the docks. For the first
time in over two decades unemployment had
virtually disappeared, and the goverment ur-
gently needed dockers. When the interests of the bourgoisie were threatened and the incf ficiency of casualisation jeopardised the waref- fort, something had to be done. Consequently, the dockers and the employers were registered, and the labour farce was given a guaranteed woekly wage.
These war-time meaxures showed that the
connivance of the employers. Here BOB
scheme and the struggles of dockers for
improved conditions.
Raname
Right until the last war and the Nation- al Dock Labour Scheme of 1947, casualisation had been a scourge on Britain's waterfronts.
Mayhew, the Victorian philanthropist, wrote of the hinng system, saying: "Then begins the scuffling and scrambling forth of count-
Nation-
1947.
a 95-3?
less hands, high in the air to catch the eye of him whose voice may give them
work.. To look into the faces of that hungry crowd in to
see a right that must ever be remembered".
It was not until the first world war that entry on the
WOrl
1945, even before the war had ended, 10,000
London dockers were on strike. Again in that
September a strike which started in Birkenhead
spread nationally, lasting six weeks. This was
over a national pay award and was bitterly op
posed by the new Labour govemment, the
Tories, the Liberals, the Communist patty and
of course every 'right thinking' trade union of-
London dockers were September a strike way... mm"d nationa.
nad strikr
posed by the new Labour govemment, the Tories, the Liberals, the Communist patty and " course every right
ficial.
The situation was
explosive. A militant alfed movies that would end casualisation per- manently. provide a guaranteed pay packet and jobs, and im- prove safety. Employers
who used the ports for importing or exporting their goods favoured measures that would
in per-
would
and
netts fr
speed up turn-round times, and cut down on
disputes. They were therefore sympathetic to measures that would provide a xtahie Ishour force, whilst being op posed to nationalisution. The union bureaucracy
docks was regulated but the 'free call" was still the way the overwhelming majority
got their jobs. How little im- provement had been made to that degrading and humiliating system can be seen by the report of the Shaw Commission in 1920 which argued: 'If men were merely spare parts in an industrial machine, this callous reck oning might he appropriate. But society will not
tolerate much longer the continuance of the
employment of human beings on these lines,
The system of casualisation must, if possibic, be tom up by the roots. It is wrong."
Casualisation had its roots in the fluctuating nature of dock work and in the employers con viction that it was the only cconomic way that demand and supply could he matched. As they were only trading for profit, they saw no reason
the
Shane
uncti
alicias
why men should not make themselves available for hire when, and only when, there were ships to load and unload. Because the unions did not challenge the profit motive, and saw their func tion simply as getting the best deal within the system, they were unable to mount an effective
Wartime measures
The arrival of the second world war saw a changed situation. Ernest Bevin, former General Secretary of the Transport and General Workers Union (TGWU), became in 1940 Min- ister of Labour in Churchill's coalition govern- ment. He, along with the rest of the goverment, was setiously wurried that labour shortages
wher
challenge to casualisation.
Wartime
Gener Wess
tsten was
did 20/ dockers
not favour
nationalisation either.
They wanted to retain a system that gave them
kept demanding better wages. - Liverp
old system was neither necessary, nor was it in- violable. However the real question washow to replace it. There was in abvious came mor nationalisation. A single employer would have been in a far better position to forecast incom- ing work and distribute labour accordingly. How, asked the advocates of nationalisation,
could a multiplicity of firms, made up of ship-
ping companies and stevedoring firms - who
never consulted with each other on such mat-
ters - plan anything so complex as the overall
allocation of labour?
power by government decree - much preferable in their eyesto having to mobilise the membership in struggle - and which provided them with privileges and perks.
outset as ne -Texts Thes
The Labour govemment saw its job from the
outset as being to reconcile these different in-
terests. They were anxious to get rid of the old
anarchic system that had plagued the docks for
years. They even wanted a better deal for the
Labour force - as long as it did not antagonise
the employers too much.
The 1947 compromise
No single section of the conflicting groups was strong enough to impose its own solution. The climate of opinion in 1947 would not have toleraled a full-biown retum to the old methods. On the other hand there was no lesdership from the unions or Labour's left, that was able, or
The post-war Labour government had no
stomach for nationalising the docks, nor did it
even have the semblance of a plan for such an undertaking. .. But it nad promised to
casualisation, and had to come up with a soln-
tion. Under pressure, the port employers reloc
tantly accepted the principle of a maintenance
payment, bur wanted to retain control of hiring
and firing and the administration of docks and
harbours. The trade unions were not at all in-
clined to give up their say in administering the
register which determined who got hired. The
even wanted to lead a campaign for nationalisa
tion. Thus the 1947 National Dock Labour Scheme was from its inception a compromise It was certainly an improvement on the past.
-als articularly cmoved ine pr
mislamon nad provided, n exteratin of their self-perceived -
eradicated". mediators between capital and lahour. • sha Pace Tone rank
sring moculel mi
but hardly represented the dockers millenium. As Lord Devlin said later: "The misconception that the scheme was a concession granted in the dockers and not the best means of snlving the industry's labour problems has to be
Inc
Nevertheless the scheme was a step forward. The worst aspects of casualination had gone.
ment of half the labour force.
The unions were also repre- sented on the various boards set
write ser
up under the scheme, and on the disciplinary boards.
Of course the class struggle
continued. The labour force kept insisting on better wages. safety improvements and an in- creased fail-back guarantee to provide a decent wage if no work was available. In the carly years of the scheme there were national unofficial dock strikes in May-June 1948, Apnil 1949.
May-July 1949, April-May 1950, Febuary-April 1951 and October-November 1954.
These were led by unofficial committee, often in alliance with the National Amal- gamated Stevedores" and Dockers" Union (in- variably dubbed the Blue Union after the colour of their membership cards), whose 7,500 mem bers were then solely based in London, and al- way against the official leadership of the TGWU. It was a time when dockers were in a
favourable position to build on and extend the tavourate position gain of the scheme, but the opportunity was not taken, The TGWU, particularly under the nitra-right wing leadership of Arthur Deakin
PHOTO: Laurle Sparham/FL
mimince,
amal
ariV
nitra-right wing leadership of Arthur Deakin and bis short-lived successor, Tiffen, preferred to collaborate with the goverment and the
.Thten
illow scope for -
militant leadership, and so the advances that could have been made did not take place. The break to the Blue Union
The Blue Union played a role in the life of the docks our of all proportion to ils size, and was a constant thorn in the side of the employets and TGWU officialdom. In 1954 thousands of dockers in Liverpool, Birkenhead, Manchester and Hull, exasperated with the Ar- thur Deakin and the refusal of the TGWU (known on the docks as the "White Union'") to fight the employers, decided to join the Blue Union. The Hull dockers sent a message to Liverponi which said: "For many years we dockers in Hull have resented the way that the TGWU has handled our disputes. Time after time we have reported our grievances to the TGWU, only to be told 'our hands are tied". We
of Hull have decided that the time has come to
do some 'untying". Thus the Blue Union came
What Birkenhead dockers* leader Billy
Jolnson was to describe as 'the biggest prison
break in history" followed. Around 15,000 to
16,000 dockers in the Norther ports joined the NASD. In Birkenhead, out of a labour force of about 2,500, only two or three stayed with the White Union. The appeal of the Blue Union in the norther ports was that it was hated by both the employers and the White Union.
lat the D.
the norther ports was that it was hated by both
The NASD was a relatively democratic
SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 15 May 1989
union. All its officials were elected every three years, and thus under the constant pressure of the members. Report-hacks invariably went to mass meetings rather than to branches. The of
ficials had to operate on a mandate from the membership, unlike the TGWU where they were controlled from above. Although the 1955 recognition strike failed, the Blue Union still retained a presence in the northem ports. In Liverpool, the successful strike of 1967 should be credited to the unofficial committee, whose chair was Jimmy Benbow, an old-time Bloc Union militant.
By the mid 1960s, following the retum of a Labour government, the employers and the port users were exerting enormous pressure for change. The age of containersation had dawned, and the technological revolution was arriving in dockland. Who beller to make sure it did, than Prime Minister Harold Wilson, who had boasted of Labour's intention to apply "the white heat of the technological revolution" to British industry, He and his Minister of Labour, Ray Gunter, appointed Lord Devlin to report on the docks. Phase one of his report completed the abolition of caruel labour, in retur for the introduction of productivity deals and the end of the piece work system. It also tightened dis cipline and attacked so-called restrictive practices'. This set the scene for a number of bitter dixputes. The unrest on the docks was denounced by Gunter as communist led': Wil-
son echoed this when he told a dinner of Lon- don wine merchants "Everyone here will en dorse his (Gunter's) words' - and not surprisingly they did!
Devlin strikes again
In 1972, under the Tories, Devlin stage two
was introduced. This accepted containerisation on the employers' terms and laid the basis for a proliferation of unregistered ports and the es tablishment of inland container bases, which would in effect be inland ports doing the job of registered dockers. Dockers began picketing the new unregistered ports; and no a re усат.
TGWU was fined by Ted Heath's National In-
dustrial Relations Court over the picketing of Heaton's Transport in St Hellens, where
dockers' work was being done by unregistered labour.
Liverpool dockers struck, and the strike
spread. Eventually five unofficial London
dockers leaders were arrested and imprisoned
in Pentonville for refusing to stop picketing
Midland Cold Storage. A wave of strikes then
hit the docks, the print, and other industries;
even the TUC threatened a national one day
stoppage. The goverment was forced to find a
face-saving formula in the face of such resis-
tance and the dockets were relcased.
After the Pentonville Five were freed, the
ive werr "recd. the
national dock strike continued, demanding the
extension of the National Dock Labour Scheme
to all unregistered ports. It was a miltant strike
with extensive picketing of the unregistered
ports. Terry Turner, a Hull docker, kept a diary
of the 1972 events and he records the condi tions on some of the unregistered wharts; During recent picketing at these places it has been seen that ships work with casual labour employed for a pittance of a wage, and that
sometimes the crews work the cargoes'. At the
same time, in Tumer's own port of Hull.
employers were insisting that there was a
mal there was
surplus of 500 dockers.
Jones sells out
When the Aldington-Jones report appeared
alked about making n...
-ontainer work into
-. that in retum ... a
ockens an the macme
life (provined thev
fundancy. the
rate and the un-
docks; but the reality was that in relum for a guarantee that existing dockers in the scheme
dustry would be split. Tumer commented Dockers see this report as a palliative. Some- thing more substantial is required about
Sherm
dockers" futures before peace can come". The Daily Mirror estimated the proposals would mean the loss of 2000 jobs by the end of the
required about or ran come. The - groposals woule - hu the end of the
ne foam the deck.
Page 7