Socialist Outlook

Socialist Viewpoint, International, Socialist Outlook and their supplements, 1984–2009

The SWP and women

Socialist Outlook no. 14, April 1989 · p 23 · 910 words

The left Women

women's oppression in very different ways, and pursue strategies which are quite opposed to one another."

He goes on to illustrate this with a series of highly selective historical pastiches. It is this counterposition of feminism and socialism that forms the basic thesis of the book and it is the bedrock of the Socialist Workers' Party's (SWP) political view of women and women's liberation. At the heart of this is the idea that women have no common interests or experien ces, even that: "Women are not a separate group". The other side of this coin is a flat denial that men as a social group benefit in any way from the institutionalised oppression of women under capitalism. The problem is further con- founded by the tendency of SWP analysis to consistently conflate class society with capitalism and to use the words capitalism and class as synonomous.

The internal contradictions of this position make the thread of the argument in the book al- most impossible to unravel. If, as even Mr.Cliff agrees, all women are oppressed, as women. under capitalism, then it clearly follows that all women have some common interests in ending that oppression. The common cause of women should not be overstated, as it sometimes is by radical feminists with dreams of universal sisterhood, because women are divided by class, race, sexuality and ahility, and the power relations intrinsic to capitalism are reflected in the women's movement. But to deny any com- monality is to fly in the face of reality.

The right to choose

Two examples suffice to show the problem. The right of a woman, any woman, to have con- trol over her own body, to determine whether, when and how to have children, the right to con- traception and abortion, unites women. It's true that the wealthy bourgcois woman can always pay to ger an abortion while working class women have to depend on the vagaries of the NHS, but abortion campaigns have always had support From a wide range of women. Similar- ly the position of women, all women, in the family is a subordinate one. Ax Engels pointed out, the mole of the bourgeois woman was little different from that of the prostitute and in the working class family: 'the man is the bourgeois and the woman is the proletarian

The SWP position seems in he that it is not

SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 14 April 1989

in the interests of the bour- geois woman to fight for gendet equality because it will necessarily lead to the overthrow of the capitalist system, clearly not in their class interests: in such a conflict, class interests will always prevail. This rather

appealingly simple solution

number of e/Retles

masks problems. First of all, are we not in favour of exploitingto B the full the contradictions

inherent within capitalism? Andron

Secondly, it ignores the class position of the petty bourgeoisic, squeezed, as

Murx points out. between Women workers: discriminated against because of

the two great classes - the their gender as well as their class working class and the bour- geoisie. People in this class have eventually to decide which xide they are on. Are we not in favour of winning them to the side of the work- ing class? People radicalise on all sorts of dif- ferent issues: the oppression of women is, for women, one of the more likely issues on which to win them over.

Do men benefit?

Society is divided not only by class but also

KEEP IT SAFE

Tessa Howland/if

The women's movement has consis

tently organised on abortion rights

by sex, race, sexuality and ability. Capitalism has interwoven these divisions into a complex mossic of domination and subordination. They cannot be unravelled by class reductionism.

Then there is the seemingly endless con- troversy over whether men benefit from the op pression of women. The SWP's answer to this is: "an emphatic no!...it is a situation from which only the ruling class benefits.* As Tony Cliff says: "The working man is as dehumanised as the woman.' Moreover, he denies any importance to the fact that men, not women, even from the ruling class, are: "rapists, porographers, wifebeaters, eto,' as 'these are the actions of individuals and are small com- pared to the way the capilalist system structures and perpetuates women's oppression through its institutions...the blame should be placed squarely on class society, not on its individual agents This raises a numberof points, not least of which is the inadequacy of blaming the system" and leaving it at that. Are we not in favour of organising now against rape, woman- beating and so on? If the SWP had their way the "rule of thumb' (the nineteenth century right of a husband to beat his wife with a stick not larger than his thumb!) would still be with us.

What is meant exactly by the question do men benefit from women's oppression?' Answers to this will differ depending on whether it is being asked in an abstract way or concretely in the here and now. Unfortunately the SWP seem to have confused the two. From the point of view of the struggle for socialism - the only way all forms of oppression will be overcome - men have no interest in the oppres- sion of women. But socialist "man" does not cxist today. "he will be crealed through the struggle itself. As revolutionary socialists we can say that working class men have no inter-

Page 21

← The class struggles, and then the women get liberated · Car Wars →

Something wrong on this page?