of political life allowing for little dissent or opposition (hegemony). His measures for that are the extent to which Thatcher's chosen methods, the free economy and the strong state of the book's title, have been implemented. His conclusion is that in its war on the working class, Thatcherism has so far only really scored a draw, but looks in strong shape and confident for the replay - although its economic prospects are not too good.
The extent to which the "strong state" has been achieved is the subject of some debate in the labour movement, and has occupied many pages of Socialist Outlook over recent months. Left Labour MP Tony Banks pitched in too, suggesting in a recent television interview that once the Government's current legislative programme is exhausted, we can be sure that they'll he knocking on our doors on a Sunday morning to make sure we've had our cold showers and aren't interfering with each other'. The debate, no doubt, will continue.
Meanwhile though, Gamble fails to answer the bigger and more urgent question; what do we do about it? Unfortunately
The Free Economy and the Strong State: The Politics of Thatcherism Andrew Gamble Macmillan, £7.95
Reviewed by Jane Wells
I FIRST VOTED in 1979. Margaret Thatcher has been Prime Minister for most of my adult life.
Making sense of a political phenomenon as profound as Thatcherism has been difficult for my generation - especially when, at the same lime, you're trying to take in the whole range of political life, with little historical experience or perspective to bring to it. Dim memories of cold nights spent Listening to the radio hy candlelight in the 1973/4 miner's overtime ban (those were the days) and Harold Wilson's resignation in 1976 is about as far back as 1 go.
But it's not only those who are new to politics who have found it a difficult assessment to make. Debate between commentators on all sides (and the same sides) of the political spectrum about the nature of the beast still rages. Because. inevitably, behind every attempt to assess political reality, lie judgements which are based on more than just the immediate situation and facts. You have to have an analytical framework to work in and a set of analytical tools that are up to the job, too.
Andrew Gambie's book provides a comprehensive account of cconomic and political developments of the last ten years. He reminds us, refreshingly, that there have been downs as well as ups in the Govemment's fortunes, which are all too casy to forget when viewed through the the impending triumphalist anniversary celebration of a decade of thumping Tory parliamentary majorities and working class defeats. But rather than just commenting on those events he offers an analysis too.
Looking at the sweeping changes wrought in the British political scene over the decade since Thatcher came to power in the context of post-war political developments. Gamble explores the success of the Thatcher project: the complete domination
Dank Doran Rafar
Thatcher: only scored a draw so far?
any serious consideration of the options for the working class is completely missing from his analysis. Even the concluding section of the book, devoted to "The future of Thatcherism' does not deal with this central issue. Instead he considers only the
rospects for Thatcherism at the
evel of 'high politics" and as : force, vying for power with alternative right-wing doctrines and currents, in the context of the economic outlook.
The working class as an active force with the potential for struggle is almost completely absent from Gamble's account, which leaves it, disappointingly.
just short of as good a marxist
so far?
phenomenon as you might hope for. This omission, it is probably fair to say, stems from the set of political judgements underpinning Gamble's approach. His writing is informed by the positions of Marxism Today, to which he is a key contributor. Nevertheless. his analysis, as far as it goes, remains a useful starting point. But without that identification of 'the way forward for the working class' (to use a well wor but still meaningful phrase) you're left minsing one essential ingredient - the opportunity to use your analytical tools to dig your way out.
Advert
Notebooks for Study and Research
Marxism and Liberation
Number 10
Theology
Michael Löwy
The Notebooks for Study and Research are sponsored by • 6 Populism in Latin America by Adolfo Gilly, Helena the International Institute for Research and Education of Hirata, Carlos M Vilas and the PRT (Argentina) introduced Amsterdam. They include three series:
by Michael 1.Jwy (documents) (40pp, £2) A 'Iccture scrien: edited transcriptions of classes given at • 7/8 Market and Plan in Postcapitalist Societies: the Ex- the Institute.
perience of the So-Called Socialist Countries by Catherine
out now!
A 'itudiex" series: systematic studies of either particular experiences in a given country or a particular theme. A 'documents and debates" serice: collections of docu ments, articles and interviews designed to update a con troversial question. • 1 The Place of Marxism in History by Emest Mandel (study) (40pp, E2)
• 2 The Chinese Revolution - 1: The Second Chinese Revolution and the Shaping of the Maoist Outlook by Pierre Rousset (study) (32pp, E2) + 3 The Chinese Revolution - II: The Manist Project Tested in the Struggle for Power by Pierre Rousset (study) (48pp, E2.50) • 4 Revolutionary Stralegy Today by Daniel Bensaid (lec- tore) (36pp, 62) • 5 Class Struggle and Technological Change in Japan Since 1945 by Muto Ichiyo (study) (48pp, £2.501
Samary (lecture) (64pp. £3) • 9 The Formative Years of the Fourth International (1933-/9,281hy Daniel Bensaid (lecture) (48pp, £2.50) * 10 Marxium and Liberation Theology by Michael Lowy (stody) (40pp, £2)
Forthcoming: + 11 The Bourgeois Revolutions by Robert Lochhead Individual orders: PO Box 705 London SW19 1HA Suhecription for 5 ksues of NSR (surface E10; 100FF; air mail add 20%). Please indicate with which issue sub- scription begins (you may include back issues). All payments to P Rousset. Preferred: French francs pay- able in a bank localed in France, postal giros to CCT Paris 11 541.97 T. (picase avoid Eurochecks).
Mail cheques and orders to:
NSR, 2 rue Richard-Lenoir, 93108 Montreuil, France.
SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 14 April 1989
Page 31
SOCIALIST
OUTLOOK
LETTERS
We welcome your views and comments.
Write to:
Socialist Outlook, PO Box 705,
London SW19 IHA
(letters over 350 words may be edited)
Three-phase Stalinism The article by Phil Hearse and Dave Packer ('The way out of a tangle on Stalinism ) which appeared in SO 12 contains a distortion of my position. F have never asserted that the Chinese, Albanian and Vietnamese states, regimes, or ruling bureaucracies, are less authoritanian and manipulative than Khruschev's, not to say Gorbachev's Russia. At the most I said that in spite of that authoritarianism, they enjoyed more mass support up to a certain period, because of the role they played in the revolution in their country (this applies to China and Vietnam, probably not to Albanias. But that is neither a question of definition nor of theoretical analysis, but just a question of facts.
1 could accept Hearse and Packer's position that a stalinist or neo-stalinist party is one which subordinates the interests of revolution (i.e: of the working class) in its country, to those of any state bureaucracy (defined as a hardened burcaucratic caste exercising state power in a workers state) — whether the Russian, Chinese, Yugoslav or Vietnamese one.
But such a definition reveals the contradictions in Hearse and Packer's assessments, not in mine. To what ruling state bureaucracy did the Yugoslav Communist Party subordinate the interests of the Yugoslav revolution in 19427 Or the Chinese CP in the 1948 Chinese revolution? Or the Vietnamese CP in the Vietnamese revolution in 1949? To the Russian bureaucracy Obviously not. To the Yugoslav, Chinese, Vietnamese state bureaucracies? But these did not exist in the
years cited!
So the correct definition involves a three phase appmach. The parties were stalinist when they had an onentation of refusing to fight for the overthrow of the bourgeois-oligarchic (in Vietnam, colonial) state following the Moscow line. Then they subordinated the interests of the revolution to those of the Soviet bureaucracy.
They broke with stalinism when they took the conscions decision to change that strategic line and to fight for the overthrow of the bourgeois state. To this end they educaled their cadres and mobilized huge masses
eaten
Page 32
November 1988: Ernest Mandel at Socialist Outlook rally on Fourth International (albeit in a manipulative way) for that revolutionary goal.
They became neo-stalinist parties when, after having destroyed the bourgeois state through their conquest of power, they started to subordinate the interests of the working class and of the revolution to those of their own emerging national bureaucratic caste.
This is a more complex assessment than that of Hearse and Packer. It might even sound awkward But we don't approach theory from the point of view of whether it is easily expressed or understood. We approach it from the point of view of whether it enables us to understand the moving reality in its totality, without losing theory's inner coherence. This, I believe, is the case with my definition of stalinism. It is not fully the case with Hearse and Packer's definition. Ernest Mandel
Yugoslavia Congratulations on Colin Meade's article, 'Yugosiana: Who Will Take Charge?'. It did at least get Milosevic's position into perspoctive, and explained the balances of power that may propel him into the Yugoslavian Communist Party leadership: or not. There are few intelligent articles written on Yugoslavia at the moment at a time when, as Colin Meade points out, we need to be entering into serious debate about Yugoslavia.
However, I find the tendency to write off Yugoslav socialism as purely "bureaucratic" disturbing, and an attempt to cover up a lack of understanding of the Yugoslav system which he admits "baffles everybody" Yugoslavia has a long socialist tradition; a strong socialist party was formed in Bosnia in 1908, and the Yugoslav Communist Party (formerly the Socialist Workers Party) is as old as the federation itself. After the second world war, Yugoslavia was the only country to he wholly liberated by its own partisans, or, more accurately, by the Communist Party. Yugoslav socialists refer to the war as the "socialist revolution", believing it to be a genuinely revolutionary struggle against a capitalist oppressor, albeit a foreign one. And the "independent mad" which Tito established following the war was arguably the most democratic and accountable system of popular socialist representation ever established even if it was also the most incomprehensible: one in seven Yugoslave holds some kind of clected political office!
Of course, the system has foundered, inevitably perhaps for any socialist country trying to 'go it alone'. But we cannot afford to write off the Yugoslav way as just "bureaucratic". It deserves, and must be given, a good deal more serious consideration and debate than that if we are ever to understand the true roots of democratic socialism.
Peter Chowney
Legacy of the WRP? 1 was somewhat perplexed by the letter in the SO 12 from Trevor Wongsam, which alleges that Phil Hearse, in his earlier article Thatcherism, the coming of the strong state'.
•...falls into the same terminological trap as the former Worker's Revolutionary Party, the legacy of which is continued in the pages of Socialist Newsletter.
This assertion is all the more surprising as Wongsam produces not a shred of evidence to justify it
Socialist Newsletter has never characterised Thatcherism as Bonapartism; nor does it perpetuate the legacy of the WRP in its pages. Socialist Newsletter was one of the few publications which, during the terminal crisis of the WRP, produced a series of analytical articles and leaflets tracing the explosion of the WRP to its sectarian roots. It made a systematic critique of the WRP's leftist and triumphalist line and characterisation of the political period, which had a contemporary expression in the position that the miners' strike did not culminate in a defeat for the working class.
Wongsam's remark that Socialist Newsletter continues the WRP's legacy rasies a broader problem, however. Are such unsubstantiated assertions consistent with the traditions of political debate among Marxists? You will find little basis in the polemics of Marx or Lenin for such throwaway sideswipes.
If Wongsam se anyone else tar Socialist Newsletter with a Healeyite brush, can he at least produce some documented evidence, please? Otherwise, he will appear as just one more sectarian substituting the politics of insult and innuendo for honest Marxist discussion.
Communist greetings.
Mike Pearse, Socialist Newsletter
SOCIALIST OUTLI
Marxists and the Labour Party Jane Kelly's review of Cliff and Gluckstein's The Labour Party a Marxist Historv (SO 12) identifies the real question today — that is, the way to formulate the relationship between Marxian socialists and the Lahour Party in terms of the interests of the working class as a whole vis-a-vis the socialist goal.
What disturbs me is the formulation Kelly seems to share with Cliff and Gluckstein that the Labour Party is something to "be removed' (Kelly). Kelly mentions the united front, but it seems to me that for the transformative vision of the Marxist left to gain influence, it is necessary to generate a real dialogue between all socialists committed to removing the Tories from office. In this task the Labour Party is an indispensible vehicle. To progress, the left needs to put its own house in order. This means applying the norms of socialist democracy to the way debates are formulated and conducted within the labour movement itself. The desire to remove' other working class parties from the scene is not only against the spirit of socialist democracy but is counter-productive in a society schooled in the benefits of hourgeois democracy. Chris Madoc
A reply on the Tamils in Sri Lanka The article 'Riding a tiger into a blind alley' in Socialist Outlook 12 did not deal with the most buming questions concerning the situntion for the Tamils in Sri Lanka.
Do we support the demand for an independent Tamil Felam? Do we support the demand for the withdrawal of the 50.000 Indian troops in Sri Lanka? And if we do. can we then give critical support to those Tamils who are fighting for a Tamil Eelam and who are involved in a war with the Indian occupation force?
Leaving aside for the time heing the question of whether the plantation Tamils in the Central and Uva provinces, and the Ceylon Tamilk in the Northern and Eastern provinces, are one people ur two different peoples, authors M. Manickar and Lal Silva seem to agree with my original article - that both have for decades faced severe repression from the Sinhalese state and community
Can we then also agree that if the Tamil people in the Nouth and East of Sri Lanka are an oppressed people we must surely support their struggle for self-determination?
We scem to agree that we as socialists should put such a struggle in a class perspective, trying to unite the Tamil and Sinhalese working class as much as possible. But it is far from clear in M. Manickum and Lal Silva's article whether they will xupport the Tamils' struggle for an independent Tamil Eelam.
They talk ahout 'intervening in the struggle for full democracy...to create conditions for a unified struggle to overthrow capitalist rule. Does that mean that the Tamils in the North and East cannot have
SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 14 April 1989
L ET TE R
STEDMENS H
BE
NUP
NUPE
1057
Use for
Hand
SAVE NHS NSF
PROFESSIONALS,
OUR
say:
OSPITALS
WHILE the government forges ahead with its White Paper on the National Health Service, apparently ready to dely doctors' professional bodies as well as public opinion, the fightback is still taking shape. Hands Off Our Hospitals' meetings and local campaigns have been developing across London and now into other towns. They can also link up with battles against cuts and closures, like this picket of St Stephen's Hospital in Fulham which, along with four other hospitals, faces the bulldozers. Further details of 'Hands Off Our Hospitals' campaigns and publicity materlal available from London Health Emergency, 335, Grays Inn Rd London WC1.
UP
The
White po
national independence until capitalism is overthrown in Sri Lanka, and that the national struggle is secondary to the class struggle?
The article doex not clearly say whether socialists should demand a withdrawal of the 50,000 Indian troops. Their position hn the Indian-Sri Lankan accord, which legalised the Indian occupation force in the North and East of Sri Lanka, scems to be: we neither support not oppose. (This also seems to he the position of the Revolutionary Marxist Party of Sri Lanka). This is not a scrious position. What possible progressive mole can the Indian troops play? None. They are only doing the dirty job that the Sinhalese state has heen unable to do. All independent sources confim that the Tamil people see the Indian troups as a repressive occupation force. And they are right!
Being unclear about an independent Tamil Eelam and the Indian troops, it is not surprising that M. Manickam and Lal Silva refuse to give critical support to the main Tamil liberation front, the Liberation Tigers of Tamil Eelam (LTTE). They describe the LTTE as a petty-bourgeois nationalist terrorist organisation without support from the Tamil masses.
If that was the case, it is difficult to explain why the fourth largest army in the world still have not been able to defeat a few thousand terrorists. We might disagree with some of the tactics of the LTTE, but that should not make us abandon the just struggle for national independence.
There are many liberation movements around the world which do not have perfoct programmes or tactics. But that does not make us tum away from doing solidarity work and having discussions with them. Finn Jensen
Motes and beams Bnan Elkington in SO 12 accuses Phil Hearse of mistakes — in fact, history and analysis*. Perhaps. But what comes to my mind is a Biblical proverb about motes and beams.
Ireland an 'advanced capitalist country" — really this will not do — either as fact. history or analysis.
An advanced capitalist country which har a part of its territory occupied, whose government must always look to the approval of the occupying imperialist power, its economy completely dominated by (un) imperialist power(s) forced to make in the longterm extremely disadvantageous "sweetheart" deals to encourage foreign investment, which has not even begun to approach separation of Church and State and where, after all, the national liberation struggle is still the central political question.
Perhaps SO should step up its irish coverage?
Penny Duggan
PS Women were paid less than men for doing the same job'...Equal pay has suddenly become a reality in Britain?
Page 33
Defend the Upington 25
The Upington 25
coverage in the South African press,
are the largest group facing the
gaflows in South
African legal history. They have
been convicted on the same basis
THIS TEN
of common 200 KEL
purpose used
against the Sharpeville 6. They
should be the
subject of the
same sort of
International
MLL
ARTHEID
TANEES
KJ
NOT
little or nothing has yet been done in
Britain. *The reasons for this
apparent indifference are not difficult to trace. The
defendants are
supporters of a
range of different
anti-apartheld
organisations. The
ANC Is not
organisationally
campaign.
The 25 were convicted of the 1985 murder of a
municipal
policeman in
Paballelo township, outside Upington, a town on the
border with Namibla. Most of the accused were convicted on the basis that they were part of a crowd
which stoned the home of the municipal policeman
before he was killed, also by a crowd of people. Most of the defendants have been in prison since April 1988 after an 18 month hearing. The accused are aged between 21 and 64. The youngest, Xollswa Dube, was 17
at the time of her arrest. She has since given birth to a
baby girl whom she has called innocentla.
All of the defendents" dependents are in dire financial need. But little support has come from the usual sources
of prisoner aid, such as the South African Council of Churches. And although the trial has received extensive
Hugo Blanco released
International solidarity action has been successful - Peruvian trotskyist Hugo Blanco (featured in SO 13) has now been released after protests in Sweden, Belgium. Switzerland, Germany. Spain, France and across Latin
America and the United States.
But Jose Ramön Garcia, kidnapped member of the
present in Paballelo.
So far it has been the
Cape Action
League which has
made the most
efforts to campaign
around the case.
There is absolutely no doubt that if the case had happened in a stronghold of the ANC, the Upington 25
would be at the very centre of the intemational
anti-apartheid movement's campaigning efforts. It is up to the small left in Anti-Apartheid in this country to
bring this case forcibly to the attention of the whole moverent. Our aim should be to drag the Upington 25 to
the centre of the Anti-Apartheld Movernent's
campalgning, in the same way as the Sharpeville 6.
became a central focus for the movernent.
Send letters of support and donations to: Upington 25, c/o The Rural Worker, SACHED, 5 Church
Street, MOWBRAY 7700 SOUTH AFRICA
t solidarity still needed
Mexican PRT. is still missing. Telegrams of protest and
demands that the Mexican state retum him allve ana
unharmed should be sent to:
Carlos Salinas de Gortiar, Presidente Constitucional Estados Unidos Mexicanos, Palacio Nacional Mexico DF.
Mexico
READ SOCIALIST OUTLOOK EVERY MONTH -
the magazine for the serious left
magazine for the
Special rates for regular individual subscribers:
1 year's subscription (ten issues) for £7.50 (inland); £10 (Europe); £15 (outside Europe) (multi-reader institutions £17 inland, £30 overseas
Name.
Address.
Subscription
o stant
ue number.
(Return to Socialist Outlook, PO Box 705, London SW19 1HA, England