Socialist Outlook

Socialist Viewpoint, International, Socialist Outlook and their supplements, 1984–2009

Dialectical materialism

Socialist Outlook no. 14, April 1989 · pp 28-29 · 1,536 words

Marxism Trade unions Miners

materialism is essential.

The term "dialectical" is used by Marx in a way not explained in most dictionarics, It refers to the movement of mattier through internal contradiction and conflict. Ax Lenin pur it: *The condition for the knowledge of all proces- ses in the world in their "self movement", in their spontaneous development, in their real life, is the knowledge of them as a unity of op posites. Development is the "struggle" of opposites'. (On the Question of Dialectics, CW Vol 381

This approach in the very opposite of the su- perficial, empirical view taught to us as bour- geois "common sense': dialcctical materialism understands that things are not simple as they seem, and are in a continual process of change. As Trotsky argued against American marxists who had abandoned dialectical materialsm: *The fundamental flaw of vulgar thought lies in the fact that it wishes to content itself with mo- tionless imprints of a reality which consists of eternal motion. Dialectical thinking gives to concepts, by means of closet approximations. corrections, concretisations, a richness of con- tent and flexibility; I would even say a suc- culence which to a certain extent brings them close to living phenomena. Not capitalion in general, but a given capitalism at a given stage of development. Not a workers' state in general, but a given workers state in a hackward country in an imperialist encirclement, ctc.

"Dialectical thinking is related to vulgar thinking in the same way that a motion picture is related to a still photograph. The motion pic- ture dnes not outlaw the still photograph, but combinesa series of them according to the laws of motion'. (In Defence of Marxism, pp50 I).

For those who believe that any such discus-

SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 14 April 1989

B A C K A I cs

sion of philosophical method is abstract mumbo-jumbo, it is useful to remember that Trotaky was writing to develop his analys of the degenerated Russian workers' state; and Lenin's turn to philosophical writing laid the basis for the ahrupt tactical tum he fought for in the April Thanas af 101

that the new sinua- tion or quality that emerges contains elements of the old. but represents a negation of the COL 8.57 previous stage, and will never rotum to it. Though the Ayatollah success- fully contained any anti-capitalist dynamic in the Iranian revolution. there is no prospect

Later, lesser figures may have tried to tum dialectical materialism into a semi-mystical creed or state orthodoxy Tha miners' strike: in a constant. complex nrocess of channe

with which to bludgeon opponents, bur for the great revolutionaries it was seen as a practical tool for analysis and a guide to intervention.

What are the key factors in dialectical analyms? The first is the conflict between form and content: each phenomenon must be seen as the product of a unity and conflict of opposites

- opposites which are themselves in a process of development, change and interconnection.

Thus, for example, the single outward reality of the 1984-5 miners strike concealed a con- tinual, complex intemal process of change in the balance of forces - within the NUM itself in the uneven, fluctuating morale of the rank and file, the divisions within its leadership, and the inter-relation between them; between the NUM as a union in struggle and the TUC (itself divided between the forces of new realism and those still prepared to offer some support to the NUM): between the official labour movement as a whole and the rank and file of the working class; and between the working class and the ruling class (championed and led as it was by coal boss lan MacGregor and the Thatcher govemment)

Outwardly, the situation of the strike ap- peared not to change for weeks on end, then to change from hour to hour. To offer adequate, consistent and principled leadership and solidarity in that situation required a constant process of dialectical analysis capable of detect- ing and assessing each change.

The contradiction between form and content also appears at the level of the individual. That is why opinion polls are so inadequate as a guide to Labour policy: all they offer is an iso- lated snapshot of cach single punter's view at one moment, in the absence of any political in- tervention or leadership. In fact each worker is her/himself a conflict of opposites - reflecting not only the existing balance of class forces fin cluding the setbacks under ten years of Thatcherism) but also the objective need and potential of the working class to fight back. This is the element which can be built upon under conditions of mass, participatory democracy - and why Tones and the Labour right wing preferisolating individual postal ballots to mass meetings.

The recognition of the labour movement as a unity of opposites is a starting point for any marxist analysis and programme. The unity also contains conflict, and thus the seeds of change. In the unions, in particular there is s clear con- tradiction between the pressures felt by the rank and file membership in the workplaces - under direct management pressure - and the relative- ly privileged life-style of their full-time offi cials. Among the rank and file themselves, however there are also differentiations between the more secure, better-paid sectors and the more downtrodden layers: each is subject to dis- tinct pressures and makes different demands. Analysing this complex dialectical picture can reveal the contradictions that may at times open the door to major struggles.

The unions represent the unity but also the interpenetration of opposites. Racism, the cyni- cal exploitation of the family unit to divide, and the use of mass scabbing can all divide worker from worker, turning some into agents of bour- geois ideology or policy. Sections of the union bureaucracy also play this role.

In this regard, dialectical analysis is par- ticularly important in the assessment of the point at which quantity is transformed into quality: an ever larger number of small, quan- titative changes can produce at a given point a qualitative change. This occurs all the time in the natural world - rising temperature in a ket- tle produces a qualitative leap from water to steam at boiling point; nine months of smaller changes in pregnancy gives rise to a qualitative. ly new development when the baby is born. The same can be true in politics: years of right wing class collaboration by the Electricians union (EETPU) led during the Wapping dispute to the qualitative change to union-busting, scab-herd- ing. and the eventual break from the TUC to form a US-style "business union'.

Such transformations may be relatively routine and predictable (ar with the kettle), or take the form of an abrupt "leap" in development (as when a nuclear reactor melts down, or a series of quantitative mass demonstrations and army defections produces the sudden collapse of a repressive regime— as in Iran ten years ago).

The common factor in such developments is

SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 14 April 1989

of a restoration of the old regime of the Shah. The miners' strike of 1984-5 was entircly different from that of 1973

74, and will never be

repeated in the same form.

This is a real problem, since we all go for- ward into the future equipped with ideas and methods learned in the past. The only way to update and develop these ideas is through a struggle to change the world, and to learn from it how to fight more effectively. Of course refor- mists like today's TUC and Labour leadership do not want to change the basic framework of society, so they see the process as one of dis- carding anything that might lead to conflict.

Marxists, who recognixe the need to mobiline the working class to overthrow the capitalists and smash their state machinery, recognise that this cannot be done simply by issuing propagan- da for socialism. A programme and policy must be developed on the basis of the material needs and demands of the working class, and popularised as an alternative lo the defeatism of the official labour movement.

The kerel of dialectical materialism is that contradiction may be uncomfortable for defenders of 'common sense', but it is not ac cidental or undesirable: it is the very essence of life, of change.

The marxist method demands that analysis should begin from and return to the practical ex- perience of the class struggle, developing a theoretical analysis of the interactions between its component parts in their processes of change. This analysis should lead to elaborat- ing agitational demands, slogans and tactics for the fight, which must then be tested out

A marxist organisation will check the cor- rectness and effectiveness of its slogans by a democratic process which analyses the ex- perience of carrying them out in the class strug gle. This should also deepen its understanding of the overall xituation, improve and advance its tactice, and strengthen its links with the forces in struggle.

Dialectical materialism therefore may sound like an academic discussion topic, but it is an active, interventionist method of analyxis, flat- ly counterposed to the idealist methods of sec- tarian propagandism.

Ignore or ridicule it at your peril!

John Lister

Page 27

← Science of the class struggle · Beyond Perestroika? →

Something wrong on this page?