U IP D
terests
national
ZIRCON RAID
THE SECURITY SERVICES Bill (SSB) and Official Secrets Bill (OSB), currently going through parliament, represent further entrenchments of the powers of the state and erosions of civil liberties.
The failure of the 'broad anti- Thatcher alliance' to creale any kind of political crisis out of the passing of the bills holds many les sons in itself. Widespread criticism of s.2(1) of the old Secrets Act, the government's defeats over Spycatcher, Ponting and other controversies led this al liance to develop illusions that the new bills may lead to a liberalisa- tion, albeit against the tide, on the question of state security.
In fact the govemment never had any intention of addressing this criticism. The sole function of the new acts will be to make more efficient the implementation of policy dangerously riddled by debacles in recent years. Hence two of the main demands raised by this lobby in the Spycatcher and Ponting affairs - the need for "public interest" and prior publi- cation' defences against prosecu- tion for disclosing information -
have been omniited from the OSB.
A jury was able to let off Clive = Ponting even though he was: technically gailry. because of the complete arbitrari- ness and lack of 3 credibility of the old Secrets Act.
Now there will be an indefinite and blanket ban on the
The new laws disclosure of any
easier and mo information in specific areas: defence, MIS, inter- national relations and national security. Under these terms it is likely that Ponting would not have got off: Spycatcher would have remained banned; and John Stalker would now be inside with the Guildford 4.
The OSB's real acupe is only clear when taken with the SSB (setting out the ambit of M15) and a definition of the type of informa- tion and activity subject to non- disclosure. This is to include protecting the state from actions intended to overthrow or under- mine parliamentary democracy hy
Advert
International
VIEWPOINT
A fortnightly review of news and analysis published under the auspices of the United Secretariat of the Fourth International
Subscribe now!
Payment: French francs preferred. Cheques to PEC, CCP No 2322 42T Paris. Bank transfers to PEC, BNP Robespierre, Account 230179/90. Important: All bank or postal transfers must also be notified by letter. Subscription and correspondence to:
International Viewpoint,
2 rue Richard Lenoir, 93108 Montreuil, France
Subscription rates:
Surface Mail: 1 year 200FF(E18; 6 months 120FF/E9.50
tir Mail: 1 vear 245FF(E21: 6 months 135FF/E13
TODAY
TOMORROL
and publications 1 or publish.
e raids on journalists i nation illegal to obtain . industrial or Varen: implementation wi en- ither beans are spilled on ght and MIS's infamous : and burgling acrosr It also could be used tr ence on actions: incrud- I ones) taken against lefl ck, trade union .. Insn ions. ith the media ban ar n xympathisers - the sim mply to keep "Britain"s at bay. The bill's effect ntimidatory: smothering blic debate, particularly lia and by public figures.
The weakness t Labour's opposition is hat it has always defended the concept of "national interest" and "national security" that the bills are based on Before 1889 there was no legislation against spying or information leaking Its appearance and usage coincided exactly with the zenith and decline of British imperatisi hegemony and (ironical- ly) the developing need to protect itself against its imperialist rivals - not those opposed to bour- geois democracy. Thus the 1911 Act now heing replaced was passed in response to upprehension
political. means*. In sure no furt Peter Wrig "bugging London'. Il ensure siles ing illegal wing, blact organisations.
As witl republican is not sim enemies' a will be int broad publ in the medi
nalysis United
T Paris. tant: All
regarding German activities in the run up to the 1914-18 war.
Thus in defending this national interest Labour's hands were tied in attempting to argue that the denial of trade union rights al GCHO should not he over-ridden on grunds of national scurity. Similarly with the new OSB: how can Labour convincingly argue for a public interest" defence in favour of disclosure that will somehow get around a national interest argument against it? Eitherthe public interest" and'na- tional interest are the same or they are not. If there is such a gap be- tween the 'people" and the 'nation' are not other policics based on na- tional socurity, NATO member- ship for one, also likely to be ques lioned?
United action with all who op pose the existing and proposed restrictions on freedom of infor- mation and the lack of account- ability of state bodies, must be sought. Unfortunately this is un- likely to hite, without greater clarity over what exactly such al- liances are for and against. Socialists, at least, must be clear that such rights will never be at- tained so long as they are tied to the interests of the capitalist state. We have much to contribute to that discussion.
Piers Mostyn
Page 6
SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 13 March 1989