Socialist Outlook

Socialist Viewpoint, International, Socialist Outlook and their supplements, 1984–2009

Chess: Your move, Judit

· Socialist Outlook no. 12, February 1989 · pp 34-36 · 2,294 words

Marxism Britain Ireland Stalinism

chess, and accused Judit

of having a monstrous competitiveness, killer eyes

and that her favourite English word was 'crusbed" (how

would he have done giving interview in a foreign

launguage at the age of 127).

Where is all this leading? Surely we must have the first

woman grandmaster soon. Beyond that, who knows?

Gary Kasparov may yet roceive his come-uppance for

acting as a judge on Miss World"

Campbell MacGregor

Page 32

Marxism and Individualism

Whilst agreeing with most of what Theresa Conway has to say about the Labour leadership's conference Policy Review document (S.O. October 1988), I scent danger in her unqualified criticism of its incessant references to the rights of individuals.

Marx wrote that the aim of the communist revolution was the creation of a society in which the free development of cach is the condition for the free development of all' and

Socialist Organiser

Mick Woods and Pete Firmin are in danger of creating a mythology in their article on Socialist Organiser (S.O. 10). They claim that it was Socialist Organiser's "lurch to the right" which led to the split in 1984 and that those who set up Socialist Viewpoint opposed this rightward drift. Neither of these claims are true.

In fact the political positions of Socialist Organiser in 1984 werc almost identical to those of Socialist Outlook today. It was only after the split that the politics of Socialist Organiser changed dramatically on Ireland. on Palestine and now on the USSR and

Easter Europe. The

reason for this has been the increased political influence and dominance of Sean Matgamna. It is probahly true that Matgamna deliberately and bureaucratically provoked a split among the paper's supporters in order to gain this dominance.

Those who formed Socialist Viewpoint were either unceremoniously booted out, or organised to opposed the lack of proper discussion and democracy. Others were totally demoralised and left. The classic

where the administration of people would give way to the administration of things - both statements which make the human individual the end of emancipatory politics.

Furthermore the marxist critique of capitalism ruthlessly exposes the phoney nature of the freedom promised to the individual who subordinates him or herself to the nceds of capital.

The truth of these insights can be seen for example in the sphere of education, where the free

markeleers attempt to limit and control access to knowledge, whilst socialist strive to make it available to whoever wants it.

Both the capitalist and the bureaucratic ideologies rest on a spurious counterposition of the individual to society - but starting at opposite ends. Every politically active woman must be aware how often references on the left to the interests of society ar a whole conceal an abusive attitude to the majority part of that whole!

Colin Meade

bureaucratic methods of Sean Matgamna meant the end of an era in which Socialist Organiser had attempted with some success to apply the methods of the Transitional Programme creatively to the class struggle of the day. After bureaucratic wayshad been used and swallowed, the path was open for the creation of a sect based on the developing thoughts of Chainnan Matgamna.

The best traditions of Socialist Organiser were continued in Socialist Viewpoint and now in Socialist Outlook: 1sm certainly not ashamed of having been a supporter of Socialist Organiser and its predecessors from the start in 1967 to a principled break in 1984.

The break from their traditions on the part of today's Socialist Organiser can be seen in their drastic changes of line. On Ireland, for example, Socialist Organiser and it. predecessors Worker's

Action and Worker's

Fight maintained throughout the 1970s and early 1980s a proud solidarity with the IRA

when many lell groups capitulated to bourgeous pressure.

On Eastern Europe, we fought tooth and nail

inside the International

Socialists/Socialist Worker's Party for a "deformist position against the majority Cliffite 'state capitalist" Line. In fusion with Worker's Power which held 'state capitalist' views in 1975, we embarked on a programme of education which heightened understanding within a traditional Trotskyist framework.

At all times we maintained three principles: for political revolution against Stalinist bureaucracy: for defence of the nationalized economy against imperialist attack; where there was any conflict between the first two, we argued for support for the self-activity of the working class.

This constant discussion on Stalinism led Socialist Organiser to be one of the first left groups to support Solidamose in Poland and to call for Soviet withdrawal from

Afghanistan. It is extraordinary that at a time when many Trotskyist groups are criticising their own past softness on Stalinism Socialist Organiser

should abandon positions

which are basically correct.

Dave Spencer

SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 12 February 1989

Sectarianism

I am writing becanse of my concem over the sectarian approach of Socialist Outlook.

The cover of S.0. 10 carries the heading A socialist response to the Green challenge'. You should be presenting a socialist response to the ecological crisis, rather than the green movement. An articic on this subject should admit frankly that marxists have done very little on the issue, call for a greater commitment from

the left, and learn from the experience of those who have already been involved for many years, to discover what role marxists should play.

Instead the article explains that once again marxists have all the right answers and those who have been active in the green movement for years have got it wrong. 1 would not like to try and sell that issue of Socialist Outlook to my friends in Greenpeace and Friends of the Earth!

Then there is the article on Socialist

Bonapartism 1

Phil Hearse s article on Thatcher's supposed Bonapartism (S.O.

No. 11) gave too much away in the direction of the Communist Party's document New Times" which he criticised in an earlier issue.

Hearse believes that the Tories are counter-revolutionary. This implies that Britain was a workers state, or at least in a pre-revolutionary situation, in 1979. As a former editor of Socialist Challenge, Hearse will surely have noticed a degree of continuity (as well as a break) between the policies of Callaghan and Thatcher. Even the poll tax is, in part. another in the senies of attacks launched by Labour on local

In fact Hearse's conception of a bonapartist government leads him to the idea that Thatcher is centrally concered with the attacks on democratic rights, whereas she is centrally concerned with restoring the profitability of British capitalism. Fortunately the residual strength of the working class has prevented the bosses from restoring their world position through wage cuts etc.

Thus by counselling despair almost of the

Marxism Today' type rather than optimism about the balance of class forces, Hearse hegins to seck a broad democratic alliance with wet Tories, ete. The fruits of such ideas were evident when BBC journalists cancelled a strike against the "terrorist" reporting ban, in favnur of a joint approach with management.

Geoff Collier

Hull SWP

Bonapartism 2

The article "Thatcherism. the coming of the strong state" by Phil Hearse (S.O. 11), whilst pointing out some of the unprocedented excesses of Thatcherism compared with any other British post-war govemment, still contains more dangers than virtues.

Hearse falls into the same terminological trap as the former Workers Revolutionary Party, the legacy of which is continued in the pages of Socialist Newsletter.

The first feature to be grasped in defining bonapartism (semi or ofberwise) is, as Trotsky explained most clearly in his article "Bonapartism and fascism' (1934) - the same articie referred to by Hearse, that forms of bonapartism arise when deep class polarixation renders parliamentary rule impotent

SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 12 February 1989

Organiser. What is the point of it - yet another vitriolic aftack by one miniscule organisation on another? All the organisations (from the Communist Party leftwards) have some senious, committed militants. Attacking these organisations does not help your supporters to work with people who hold views different to yours.

This is not to say political differences should be ignored If your publication carrics an article on, say,

As soon as the irreconcilable camps have taken up their fighting positions at the poles of capitalist society, it wasn't long before it became clear that the adding machine of purliamentarianism lost all importance. It is true that the Doomergue Govemment, like the Brunening-Schleicher Governments in their day. appearat first glance to govern with the assent of parliament. But it is a parliament that has abdicated, a parliament that knows that in case of resistance the govemment would dispense with it Thanks to the relative equilibrium between the camp of counter revolution which attacks and the camp of revolution which defends itself. Thanks to their temporary mutual neutralisation, the axis of powers has been raised ahove the classes and ahove their parliamentary representation. It is necessary to seek a head of the government outside parliament and "outside the parties" The government does not appear as an exccutive organ of the parliumentary majority. but as a judge-arbiter between two camps in struggle ... a goverment of the sabre as the judge arbiter of the nation - that is just what bonapartism is.

Socialist Organiser, a supporter of that organisation should be able to read it and feel at the end of it that their views have been fairly presented in a respecful way and that the basic differences between you have heen clarified. It is not necessary or helpful to denounce it in the way you have done - talking about a "lurch to the right, 'decline and degeneration", 'throwing the movement back to Kautskyism ' etc etc.

Britain desperately needs an

Hearse's contention that the left assumes bonapartism arises only on the massive defeats of the working class is again incorrect. On the contrary, bonapartism anises when the parliamentary system is unable to contain the struggie of contending classes.

Trevor Wongsam

Bonapartism 3

In The Coming of the Strong State', Phil Hearse makes mistakes in fact, history and analysis. A complete and comprehensive correction would require an anlysis of bonapartism, the theory of the state, the structure and changes in society and the economy. the successes of Thatcher and the failure and ineptitude of the opposition (why do you need Bonaparte when you have Kinnock?).

In the first place the analysis is anglo-centric. Many restrictions in democratic rights are also to be found in other advanced capitalist countries: the illegality of abortion and homosexuality in Ireland, as well as the press bans on the republican movement: the Federal Republic of Germany has the Berufsverbot, banning radicals from employment in the public services - from teachers

organisation/publication that can rise above all this, that does not start from the premise that it has all the answers, that is open to other ideas, will discuss differing ideas in a respecful way. Only in this way will you win over the broadest possible alliance to tackle the huge problems facing us. Nobody is going to listen to you if you listen to nobody. It is high time for a chalige!

Richard Owens

to train drivers; in the USA there are vicious anti-union laws and union busting by both professional firms and near fascist gangs; and the French TV channel ORTF was the Govemment station for many years after De Gaulle, although legally independent.

Any trawl of the advanced capitalist countries would ding up similar examples. Do they prove that these couniries are or have been bonapartist? It is also important to remicmber that many democratic rights have been won very recently. Just to go back 25 years, abortion was illegal. so was homosexuality. Women were paid less than men for doing the same job and were hiatantly and legally refused equal treatment in many areas of life. Was that a bonapartist system?

"Thatcherism' is a collection of the trends, facts and features that Phil Hearse notes, made into a coherent theory of an authoritarian. anti democratic strong state beyond parliamentary democracy, preciscly to justify the strategy of the Popular Front in the 1980's, and not to analyse a real phenomenon in society.

Brian Elkington

Page 33

Every issue of the month

Socialist O

We promise: ... No Wine Colu mn ... No inter

No rave

articles by Eric Hobshawm

SOCIALIST

OUTLOOK

BECERDARIIAN

... No sectarian posturing ... No passive propagandism ... No long-winded

'new realist' defeatism ...

A subscription to the monthly Socialist Outlook brings you

breat!

FRESH AIR,

not HOT AIR!

• A magazine that speaks its mind on the issues of the day, fighting the lurch to the right in the unions and wider labour movement, offering analysis, comment and a fighting way forward in the struggles of the oppressed. • An internationalist magazine, with many overseas contacts, fighting British imperialism at home and anti-working class regimes across the world, defending the rights of both Solidarnosc and the Sandinistas. Socialist Outlook combats Stalinism and all forms of bureaucracy in the international workers' movement, as well as fighting racism and sexism that weaken and divide the working class. I A marxist magazine, committed to the class struggle, actively involved in the key battles, not criticising from the sidelines, and not afraid to attack abstention and empty ultra-left sloganising. • A thinking person's magazine, carrying film and book reviews, articles on history and basic marxism; a readable magazine, avoiding the pretentious jargon of armchair i defeatism and the hectoring demands of purely propagandist groupings.

Your time is precious WHY PUT UP WITH WINDBAGS?

READ SOCIALIST OUTLOOK EVERY MONTH -

the magazine for the serious left

Special rates for regular individual subscribers:

1 year's subscription (ten issues) for £8.50 (inland); £13 (Europe); E18 (outside Europe) (multi-reader institutions £17 inland, £30 overseas

Name...

Address..

Subscription to start from issue number...

Return to Socialist Outlook, PO Box 705, London SW19 1HA, England.

← Poem: Epilogue · Women in the NUR →

Something wrong on this page?